Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want some flex from family on childcare

260 replies

poppyseeds99 · 10/10/2023 08:27

We agreed with a relative that she would do pickups for my toddler at a new nursery one day a week. We had been using that evening to do a sports class each week. Relative announced 2 weeks ago that she would only pick up one day a fortnight (instead of each week) with very little notice or warning. This left me scrambling looking for cover with 12 hours notice last week. This week, I have a late work meeting that day so I've booked a sports class that's a bit later and asked if we could do a handover at 9pm (exceptionally). Relative went ballistic saying she is only doing pickup at 5 and then we have to come straight home from work. End result, we've cancelled the class and we're doing pickup. The thing is, relative insists they have to do the pickup anyway because they want time with our daughter - but only on their terms. AIBU to think about booking a babysitter who can just cover the hours we need?

OP posts:
CanINapNow · 11/10/2023 20:18

I am honestly shocked at these replies OP! The idea that we should never leave our children for an hour is just ridiculous! I personally ENJOY having time away from my DC and don’t think that makes me an awful person! Mumsnet posters always seem angry when parents use childcare for anything other than work/appointments and I just cannot see why. Happy parents = happy children. If you can afford it/family offers it, then grab the help with both hands! Having children is not supposed to be some sort of prison !! How lovely for you and partner to go to a fitness class together! Good for you. And DC gets to spend time with family member too, win win. So many people seem to have missed that the 9pm was a one off. Can’t see it being a big issue, DC is young and won’t struggle at school the next day etc. obviously your relative has the right to say no to the 9pm though but my mum or dad wouldn’t mind doing that for me occasionally. Your relative also has the right to change to a fortnightly arrangement but I’d be really annoyed if they didn’t give me a couple of weeks notice! You’re allowed time away from your children. Ignore the angry replies and enjoy your class. Hope you find a good babysitter for the alternate weeks xx

MistyMooPup · 11/10/2023 20:08

@Guccigirl123 PS no one who has to work or ask for help is less of a mum! Just don’t have the privilege.

MistyMooPup · 11/10/2023 20:07

@Guccigirl123 few people have the luxury of being a full time mum. You are blessed.

thecatsthecats · 11/10/2023 19:40

Spaghettinetti · 11/10/2023 00:33

Perhaps it’s the only time OP and her DH get together. Perhaps they suffer from mental health issues and the exercise helps to keep those issues in check? Perhaps both are overweight and have been advised to exercise by their doctor? There could be a whole host of reasons why they need to do their exercise class and why they need to do it together (perhaps they have a rubbish leisure centre that only do exercise classes on a Wednesday night for example).

I don’t think that OP is being unreasonable. I think that families are supposed to help each other out. That’s what they do in most places around the world. It’s just here everyone seems to be out for themselves.

Perhaps, perhaps, perhaps...

Yes, all those perhaps's are valid. Of course the OP is absolutely fine to ask about that arrangement.

But she was unreasonable to accept a no when it was given to her.

Guccigirl123 · 11/10/2023 19:17

People rely too much nowadays on relatives to help with childcare. I was a full time mum to triplets and never expected any help from family members I was always there to pick them up from school etc. your choice to have kids!

Sundownmemories · 11/10/2023 19:06

MyMiniMetro · 11/10/2023 18:49

Oh definitely this. It won't be popular but it's true. I'm a runner (a common-garden 9 minute mile park-run type ) but purchased a treadmill because I can't take children with me either on a run or to the gym - plus I actually like my family and want to be around them. Now I fit in short runs where I can find the time. Keeps my end in, as they say. We do lots of other exercise together, so anyone using the 'it's valid time away because it's exercise ' excuse is kidding themselves.

There are a few people I know who like to brag about their marathon and ultra-marathon achievements over the year. I'm there thinking HOW? How do you get the training in, with family and job? Something has to be being neglected, well to my way of thinking. And you are right, they are so rigid about it, expecting everyone to make allowances for their running schedule as if it was a disability or serious illness. They are not Tigst Assefa, looking to break world records, win medals and make money from running. Getting a PB sub-3hr time in a 'small town' marathon, doesn't actually matter a jot, not really, not enough to justify making entitled demands, dumping on people and missing out on family life.

Nice to hear from someone who is a runner but also knows it’s not the end of the world to not exercise.
Agree about something getting neglected. How do you tell your child you chose not to see them that day because you wanted to go to a gym class? How can you even be happy missing them? And knowing how difficult toddlers can be at bedtime how can you allow someone to go through all that hassle so you can exercise. Go when the child is in bed. Go separately so you don’t need childcare.
Also, if my husband told me he was going straight to the gym from work and would miss bedtime I’d be saying absolutely not. Yeah ok, I’ll struggle while you’re on the treadmill enjoying yourself 😂 shut up 🤦‍♀️😂

MyMiniMetro · 11/10/2023 18:49

Sundownmemories · 11/10/2023 15:59

Just wanted to say that I do agree with most comments about it being incredibly cheeky for parents to expect people to look after their children so they can exercise.
Not to start a war, but I find a lot of parents who exercise regularly feel it’s a total necessity and something they MUST do. It’s really not! It’s just a hobby, most parents give up their hobbies when their kids are young because any extra childcare or time away from their kids just isn’t feasible.
I also wonder why anyone would want to be at an exercise class/ gym at 9pm at night instead of getting home to their child that they haven’t seen all day.

Oh definitely this. It won't be popular but it's true. I'm a runner (a common-garden 9 minute mile park-run type ) but purchased a treadmill because I can't take children with me either on a run or to the gym - plus I actually like my family and want to be around them. Now I fit in short runs where I can find the time. Keeps my end in, as they say. We do lots of other exercise together, so anyone using the 'it's valid time away because it's exercise ' excuse is kidding themselves.

There are a few people I know who like to brag about their marathon and ultra-marathon achievements over the year. I'm there thinking HOW? How do you get the training in, with family and job? Something has to be being neglected, well to my way of thinking. And you are right, they are so rigid about it, expecting everyone to make allowances for their running schedule as if it was a disability or serious illness. They are not Tigst Assefa, looking to break world records, win medals and make money from running. Getting a PB sub-3hr time in a 'small town' marathon, doesn't actually matter a jot, not really, not enough to justify making entitled demands, dumping on people and missing out on family life.

vapesareforsnakes · 11/10/2023 18:30

Angryappendix · 11/10/2023 16:56

@Sundownmemories

Without taking the OPS thread into account, that is the most ridiculous comment I’ve read on here about exercise.

My DP runs and goes to the gym, I do jogging and walking, if we didn’t we’d be miserable, overweight and unfit. (I still am those things but I’m working on it with the limited time we have as working parents).

Exercise isn’t a hobby, just like eating well and taking care of yourself isn’t a hobby.
Exercise makes us better parents and sets a good example to our child.

Actually offended by your comment.

Don't be ridiculous. It's a hobby. I am sure loads of parents would love a member of family to let them go do their non essential hobby at 9pm at night but they keep free childcare for you know work and emergencies etc, if you are paying someone to mind your kids while you go do your hobby...that is a different kettle of fish.

404usernotfound · 11/10/2023 18:24

Nanaof1 · 11/10/2023 09:25

Must be another difference between the US and UK. It seems many look at it as a chore or KMA moment for watching a child relative.

I watched my DGC for any reason. Any time. It was covered. I made sure I was there for DGC meals, loved giving her a bath, loved reading, crawling around, playing "Go this way", singing DGC to sleep.

When DD and her NVDH split, I got to be with DGD during the day, or take her home with us for night or even two. As she got older, I was there every a.m. bright and early to help her get ready and take her to school. Then the reverse in the p.m. I was the luckiest person on earth.

It was always a privilege and never a chore. I was blessed beyond measure. And the time is fleeting. Blink and they're grown.

Every single one of my friends did the same as often and as much as they could. Some still do since they have multiple young DGC.

So no, I don't "get" the relative at all and see no reason why OP should do what said relative dictates as to what times and when. OP--Hire a sitter, a lot more stable and you can go to sport class every week, if you choose, without worry. Win-win.

I don’t think that’s a US vs UK thing. I think that a retirement vs employment thing.

Sundownmemories · 11/10/2023 17:42

Angryappendix · 11/10/2023 16:56

@Sundownmemories

Without taking the OPS thread into account, that is the most ridiculous comment I’ve read on here about exercise.

My DP runs and goes to the gym, I do jogging and walking, if we didn’t we’d be miserable, overweight and unfit. (I still am those things but I’m working on it with the limited time we have as working parents).

Exercise isn’t a hobby, just like eating well and taking care of yourself isn’t a hobby.
Exercise makes us better parents and sets a good example to our child.

Actually offended by your comment.

It is a hobby though. If you didn’t have anyone to enable you to exercise away from your child you would survive. If you don’t have a job, you can’t pay your bills or provide for your family. It’s not a necessity.

It may be important to you, something you enjoy that makes you feel better. The world would not stop turning if you didn’t exercise and you would survive without it.

You are also proving my point that those who exercise regularly think it’s a necessity. Also, I’m sure your child wouldn’t care if you didn’t exercise.

MyMiniMetro · 11/10/2023 17:27

.

Angryappendix · 11/10/2023 16:56

@Sundownmemories

Without taking the OPS thread into account, that is the most ridiculous comment I’ve read on here about exercise.

My DP runs and goes to the gym, I do jogging and walking, if we didn’t we’d be miserable, overweight and unfit. (I still am those things but I’m working on it with the limited time we have as working parents).

Exercise isn’t a hobby, just like eating well and taking care of yourself isn’t a hobby.
Exercise makes us better parents and sets a good example to our child.

Actually offended by your comment.

Sundownmemories · 11/10/2023 15:59

Just wanted to say that I do agree with most comments about it being incredibly cheeky for parents to expect people to look after their children so they can exercise.
Not to start a war, but I find a lot of parents who exercise regularly feel it’s a total necessity and something they MUST do. It’s really not! It’s just a hobby, most parents give up their hobbies when their kids are young because any extra childcare or time away from their kids just isn’t feasible.
I also wonder why anyone would want to be at an exercise class/ gym at 9pm at night instead of getting home to their child that they haven’t seen all day.

MarieRoseH · 11/10/2023 14:44

Don't give into yo her. It's not access on her terms only. Is she wants to see your child she can when it suits you. Don't be dictated to

Nanaof1 · 11/10/2023 13:22

poppyseeds99 · 11/10/2023 09:06

Thanks for the further replies, I appreciated the constructive ones. All sorted now x

I saw that after I replied, so sorry! I forgot to refresh the page, so the last several pages didn't load until after I posted my first one and then I just didn't notice.

Again, sorry! 🤐😳😉

Beautiful3 · 11/10/2023 10:23

You and your husband could alternative going. Might be an idea. We have no help from relatives, and my husband ànd I take turns to go out so the other can babysit.

NameChange30 · 11/10/2023 09:46

Is there a gym with a crèche near you?
DH and I tend to exercise separately (so one has the kids while the other does a run/swim/class) but a gym with crèche can be very handy.

Is there a reason why your relative only wants to see your child in the evenings and not at the weekend for example?

I wonder if it's your MIL...

Ellie1015 · 11/10/2023 09:44

Are you still going to faciliate some time for child and relative if they were both upset at missing out? If not that feels like a punishment to relative for doing the 9pm or weekly cover.

LuckySantangelo35 · 11/10/2023 09:32

LadyBird1973 · 11/10/2023 09:15

No child was harmed by having a late night once a fortnight or by being put to bed by their loving gran or aunty!
Parents are allowed to do some things for themselves.
And then are allowed to sometimes change a routine to accommodate it - maybe OP's child is totally fine with the occasional change. Not all kids need strict routine, some families are more 'go with the flow' types.

THIS!!

Who could possibly argue with this?!

whatsappdoc · 11/10/2023 09:30

But it's the drama and no need for it. Dh does the normal exercise class while relative does their normal shift with baby then dh returns home to take over baby routine while op works late and does the late exercise class. What 99% of parents would have done. Instead we have non-flexible parents wanting a joint late exercise class and an unsurprisingly reluctant relative.

Nanaof1 · 11/10/2023 09:25

YourNameGoesHere · 10/10/2023 18:37

I don't think lots of replies have been extreme at all. Yes of course many parents get help from relatives but I don't know any that would do so simply so they could go to an excise class together. People generally use family childcare for work and attending appointments not so they can both have 3 hours off once a fortnight to go to a class they could easily take turns attending.

Must be another difference between the US and UK. It seems many look at it as a chore or KMA moment for watching a child relative.

I watched my DGC for any reason. Any time. It was covered. I made sure I was there for DGC meals, loved giving her a bath, loved reading, crawling around, playing "Go this way", singing DGC to sleep.

When DD and her NVDH split, I got to be with DGD during the day, or take her home with us for night or even two. As she got older, I was there every a.m. bright and early to help her get ready and take her to school. Then the reverse in the p.m. I was the luckiest person on earth.

It was always a privilege and never a chore. I was blessed beyond measure. And the time is fleeting. Blink and they're grown.

Every single one of my friends did the same as often and as much as they could. Some still do since they have multiple young DGC.

So no, I don't "get" the relative at all and see no reason why OP should do what said relative dictates as to what times and when. OP--Hire a sitter, a lot more stable and you can go to sport class every week, if you choose, without worry. Win-win.

LadyBird1973 · 11/10/2023 09:15

No child was harmed by having a late night once a fortnight or by being put to bed by their loving gran or aunty!
Parents are allowed to do some things for themselves.
And then are allowed to sometimes change a routine to accommodate it - maybe OP's child is totally fine with the occasional change. Not all kids need strict routine, some families are more 'go with the flow' types.

jannier · 11/10/2023 09:09

M4J4 · 11/10/2023 08:54

Because OP and her DH may have plans with their dc themselves or the DC may have activities.

If the relatives wants to be inflexible on week nights then why should OP be flexible on weekends?

OP needs to do what’s best for her dc not relative.

I'm not sure what's best for DC is the ops priority

jannier · 11/10/2023 09:07

Codlingmoths · 11/10/2023 02:49

How? They have childcare full time and are happy to pay for a babysitter, so they will be sorted once they get that in place. this family member who apparently desperately wants to see their child, at specific times, and as long as they can cancel with short notice is the one here who has cut off their nose to spite their face.

Very odd view ....mum can you pick X up from school until 6pm once a week.....great love to special time child loves it and looks forward to it, mum it's getting too much can I do it once a fortnight? ....mum I've booked the gym so you must stay to 9 and do homework bedtime ...mum I can't it's too much for me .....we'll take a hike then mum and child can miss out and be upset because I want mum to suffer ....op actually said her child was upset because she had cancelled the normal 3 hours because mum refused the extra hours op demanded so she wasn't letting her do the normal....the mum didn't cancel what she had agreed to just the demanded extra late night hours....ie mum would do what was agreed for work but couldn't do the social evening bit.

poppyseeds99 · 11/10/2023 09:06

Thanks for the further replies, I appreciated the constructive ones. All sorted now x

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread