Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not too early for retirement or aibu?

209 replies

Orangeriessmellparadise · 10/10/2023 02:09

Anyone has retired at age 48?
Frugal lifestyle and financially OK. Deciding to retire this year and hope with no regrets, actually cant wait! but friends think I'm too young for this even if I'm able to do it.

What do you do if you are in a similar position? How do you spend your days?
How do you come across people that see you as too young for not being in the workforce? Also health is not the best at the moment and my child is already a young adult so less and less responsibilities in general.
Is it too early or shall I go for it?

Sorry if it sounds like a bit silly question but is a genuine curiosity for your opinions. Thanks!

OP posts:
WrongSwanson · 11/10/2023 19:12

Orangeriessmellparadise · 11/10/2023 18:40

I didn't expect so many comments and all interesting things to read. Food for thought and very helpful indeed, so thanks AGAIN.

For more perspective, when I say living frugally it doesn't mean miserable. I do enjoy many things that only money can buy but also a lot that cost very little or nothing. I'm good balancing those things.
Also health issues myself and seeing illness in my parents at a young age have been a great eye opening and incentive to finally decide is time to enjoy and relax.
I agree it feels I'm too young for the word retirement. This is stop working and then a few years later will be fine to say retired.

I have private sources of income and inheritance to rely on in the long term. I pay national insurance voluntary too and savings already sorted for kids University.
Although is not a million or two, I think is possible and doable.

Aibu or a million or more is not necessarily/compulsory to retire early? Maybe I'm missing something? This country is very expensive I know! Thx

I'd go and see a financial advisor and make sure you 've planned this properly

BlueSky2023 · 11/10/2023 18:57

Is there a hereditary illness that your parents had at a relatively young age that you think you might get and is it life limiting or mentally decapitating, if the answer is yes to any of these I would go for it,
Retiring whilst living frugally Dosen’t sound like much fun to me though, I envisage myself as a lady who lunches and goes on long cruises in my retirement but I think unfortunately the reality will be far different from that😊……should have started saving earlier

TizerorFizz · 11/10/2023 18:54

Helping DC with houses? That’s a huge cost. I think £1m at your age is vital. How much capital are you using? How much income do the investments bring in? Will that last and what about IHT planning.

We all know this country has an epidemic of retiring early. Of course not everyone does but it’s not helping with recruitment and labour shortages in many skilled areas. Sadly it’s a fact and holds the country back as it limits growth. With 40 year student loans there’s even more incentive to not work!

Orangeriessmellparadise · 11/10/2023 18:40

I didn't expect so many comments and all interesting things to read. Food for thought and very helpful indeed, so thanks AGAIN.

For more perspective, when I say living frugally it doesn't mean miserable. I do enjoy many things that only money can buy but also a lot that cost very little or nothing. I'm good balancing those things.
Also health issues myself and seeing illness in my parents at a young age have been a great eye opening and incentive to finally decide is time to enjoy and relax.
I agree it feels I'm too young for the word retirement. This is stop working and then a few years later will be fine to say retired.

I have private sources of income and inheritance to rely on in the long term. I pay national insurance voluntary too and savings already sorted for kids University.
Although is not a million or two, I think is possible and doable.

Aibu or a million or more is not necessarily/compulsory to retire early? Maybe I'm missing something? This country is very expensive I know! Thx

OP posts:
OhamIreally · 11/10/2023 18:40

TizerorFizz · 11/10/2023 12:26

There’s also something to be said for making sure you really do have enough money. Many have found they don’t. We are a nation that doesn’t like work though. My DH still works at 70. On his terms but it keeps his mind active and fully engaged.

From my observations, I don’t think people wholly change character. If you are a bit unpleasant, mean, fearful, racist, just plain difficult in the first place your worst traits get worse. The nicer traits recede. People who are just pleasant stay that way!

I think it's a bit unfair to tar a whole nation as not liking work, implying everyone is workshy. Especially when you say you stopped work at 40 and rely on your high earning husband's income.

There's plenty of hard working, diligent people in this country, paying mortgages and taxes and hoping for a pleasant, if modest, retirement.

Crowing about your millions whilst casting aspersions on others comes across as a little crass.

Davidscreen · 11/10/2023 16:57

I saw this a bit in lockdown. People not mixing and their views becoming entrenched… unchallenged and increasingly odd, in one particular older relative and her spouse.

I hadn’t thought about the not mixing element of retirement before this thread. A woman I know still helps out at Brownies to keep her active. I’d love to be volunteering in my retirement, but I’m too busy working at the moment.

The most frightening part must be actually spending the money you have so carefully saved up!

Notamum12345577 · 11/10/2023 16:54

Testina · 10/10/2023 23:39

@Notamum12345577 are you sure you can take a private pension at 50? When you are only now 40? I have done a lot of reading around pensions and I have never seen this for a DC private pension. Specific NHS schemes like Mental Health officer or possibly military… but not a standard private pension. I’d love to know what your info is, as I’m older than you and have to wait until 57. So I’d love to be wrong!

I can, but it changed to 55 for new people not that many months after I joined. It’s a DB pension though if that makes a difference in that respect….also a work place one.

Notamum12345577 · 11/10/2023 16:53

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

TizerorFizz · 11/10/2023 15:55

@GnomeDePlume We have a friend a bit like this. At 72 he now has signs of dementia (we think) . Not filtering what you say or do is definitely a slippery slope. Our friend appears largely incapable of thinking about anyone bar himself snd expects to be waited on. Refuses to engage with household jobs, drive, or do anything to help his wife who was working in a demanding job until recently (she’s younger) and he has actually been like this for several decades now. We have tried encouraging, chivvying, suggesting things etc but it’s impossible now. We’ve somewhat backed away from association after a joint holiday as we were appalled. We do support his wife but we don’t know how she sticks it.

GnomeDePlume · 11/10/2023 14:05

I think the problem I saw with DM retiring early (56) was that she associated in the main with people far older than herself. She took on their attitudes and mannerisms.

DB1 retired even younger at about 50 and socialises exclusively with DM. They are now reinforcing and amplifying each other's views.

At 60 DB1 is still out in the world even if only going to shops and bank. He has lost interest in filtering his comments (he doesn't need to with DM) so causes a lot of offence. But he doesn't care because there is no consequence. He will still get his pension.

KeepTheTempo · 11/10/2023 13:09

Wrapunzel · 11/10/2023 12:32

Only skim read the thread but have a look at Mr Money Mustache, OP. He retired at 31 but still dabbles in self employment as and when.
Regarding taking pensions at 50, I'm 44 and the earliest I can access my civil service pension is 50. My private sector one is 57.

He 'retired' at 31, except for the relatively lucrative job he then made out of telling everyone about his retirement. Which therefore wasn't a retirement.

It's a bit like Tim Ferriss and the '4 hour work week'. That man works long hours, he's just reframed it in his own head and for a legion of followers.

Still good examples of alternative career paths and income streams, but not really guides to an easy life.

Wrapunzel · 11/10/2023 12:32

Only skim read the thread but have a look at Mr Money Mustache, OP. He retired at 31 but still dabbles in self employment as and when.
Regarding taking pensions at 50, I'm 44 and the earliest I can access my civil service pension is 50. My private sector one is 57.

TizerorFizz · 11/10/2023 12:26

There’s also something to be said for making sure you really do have enough money. Many have found they don’t. We are a nation that doesn’t like work though. My DH still works at 70. On his terms but it keeps his mind active and fully engaged.

From my observations, I don’t think people wholly change character. If you are a bit unpleasant, mean, fearful, racist, just plain difficult in the first place your worst traits get worse. The nicer traits recede. People who are just pleasant stay that way!

Readingundertheoaktree · 11/10/2023 11:19

GnomeDePlume · 11/10/2023 10:35

Fair enough but what I have seen with my relatives is that they have become more fearful, reactionary, right wing, racist, intolerant on retirement. DB1 is the worst as he has no outside interests other than minding DM and worrying what his neighbours are doing.

They don't have connection with a younger generation which they would have had if they had stayed working.

They must have been all those things before retirement. No-one becomes racist etc because they retired.

GnomeDePlume · 11/10/2023 10:35

KimberleyClark · 11/10/2023 09:09

I retired at 58 four years ago and have not “become old”. I go to the gym every other day to keep myself strong and fit. I’m still really keen to travel and see as much of the world as I can before my health gives out. We are childless but don’t feel our lives are any worse for not having grandchildren.

Fair enough but what I have seen with my relatives is that they have become more fearful, reactionary, right wing, racist, intolerant on retirement. DB1 is the worst as he has no outside interests other than minding DM and worrying what his neighbours are doing.

They don't have connection with a younger generation which they would have had if they had stayed working.

TizerorFizz · 11/10/2023 10:09

@thecatsthecats I’m not travelling overland to get to Poland. I’m still busy and travelling actually isn’t cheap for older people who don’t have time. We have commitments to others so need our holidays to mean a something to us. So we don’t want ad hoc cheap arrangements and it doesn’t save you much over a flight! They are pretty cheap to Poland. Far less cheap to Japan and Argentina.

2chocolateoranges · 11/10/2023 09:48

I know a few people who retired at 50 (social worker, firefighter, police service, local civil service) all bar one lasted a year and have got themselves part time jobs eg chauffeur, taxi driver, gardener.

they said that he fact none of their family or friends were at home made the days really long so got themselves a part time job to keep them busy.

thecatsthecats · 11/10/2023 09:47

The thing about travel though is that it can cost wildly less if you have more time to do it, or at the very least you can do it more interestingly if you have more time.

My parents would happily take 3 weeks getting to Krakow by random transport over taking a flight, and we take minibuses, ferries etc - but there's only so much you can do with most holiday allowances. Plus when you're there you can spend time seeing places nearby without taking big chunks out of your schedule.

We've never taken them, but there are also loads of last minute deals for a month half board in January in Turkey etc that would probably break even against cold weather and food prices.

Travel is almost certainly less expensive per day if you're retired!

determinedtomakethiswork · 11/10/2023 09:42

You're not retiring, you're just stopping work. Make sure you keep up with your national insurance contributions.

LumiB · 11/10/2023 09:38

TizerorFizz · 11/10/2023 09:25

It’s interesting how many retired people want to travel. I’ve had great holidays for decades and intend to continue. I’m older than most posting! However it’s not a cheap hobby unless you want to backpack! Flights have gone up a lot. If you expect to spend from 50-80 travelling you better have deep pockets. If you live frugally, as the OP, I doubt the horizons include extensive travel. That’s the biggest issue: what are you gojng to do? Travel makes me tick. Most of what makes me tick costs money! It’s no point retiring early and being destitute at 70 because your calculations are wrong.

Most people I know who fully enjoy retirement have big gold plated pensions and/or large inheritances. Or have sold their business. All have substantial funds and aren’t living frugally.

This is why I won't be fully retiring once my mortgage is done. I'll work part time or contract just to fund holidays. This means I don't have to a full time wage slave and can enjoy more of my life without living too frugally either.

Yocal · 11/10/2023 09:34

Sometimes fulltime workers dream of early retirement, but what they really need is to work part time in a good workplace in a role they enjoy. 👍

I'd check that isn't the case so you don't have to be so frugal in your early retirement. You might find it a better balance.

TizerorFizz · 11/10/2023 09:25

It’s interesting how many retired people want to travel. I’ve had great holidays for decades and intend to continue. I’m older than most posting! However it’s not a cheap hobby unless you want to backpack! Flights have gone up a lot. If you expect to spend from 50-80 travelling you better have deep pockets. If you live frugally, as the OP, I doubt the horizons include extensive travel. That’s the biggest issue: what are you gojng to do? Travel makes me tick. Most of what makes me tick costs money! It’s no point retiring early and being destitute at 70 because your calculations are wrong.

Most people I know who fully enjoy retirement have big gold plated pensions and/or large inheritances. Or have sold their business. All have substantial funds and aren’t living frugally.

Pinkyhairclip · 11/10/2023 09:21

The people I know who retired young are not bored. Quite the opposite! They seem to having a great time and are always busy.

It's also a bit depressing to think that work is the only way we can prevent boredom and find meaning to our lives. There's so much more to do in life than just work!

If you love your job then fair enough. But this live to work mentality isn't always healthy. Majority of us could be replaced by our employers in a heartbeat and probably will be as AI develops.

Pinkdelight3 · 11/10/2023 09:17

It's said that most people need to 'do something of value everyday' to not get bored, depressed etc. What is considered something of value is very much down to the individual. It may be work or caring or picking up litter or an infinite number of things. Some people definitely 'get old' when they retire and don't find those other things to give them purpose/balance/perspective and then minor things do create inordinate fear and inertia. But others find a new routine that suits them better than work and still do their things of value. Guess we're just lacking context in what the OP intends to do and I wouldn't rush into retirement without some sense of that. Better to take a break or downshift if possible, ease into it.

KimberleyClark · 11/10/2023 09:09

GnomeDePlume · 11/10/2023 07:00

Something I would be concerned about with living frugally is what does that entail? Growing your own vegetables? Is is sustainable forever? We have an allotment and know how much works it takes.

DM retired at 56 when DF became seriously ill then died. Both my DBs have retired at the same sort of age.

What I noticed with all 3 is how 'old' they became on retirement. Their lives narrowed right down immediately. DM (now 84) & older DB (now 60) spend a lot of time together and feed each other's fears. They both fret about neighbours, see threat everywhere. Lockdown has made this paranoia worse.

It may be significant but DM & DBs are all single. Neither DB are going to have GCs to be involved with. DM has GCs (my DCs) but is not close to them for lots of reasons.

I retired at 58 four years ago and have not “become old”. I go to the gym every other day to keep myself strong and fit. I’m still really keen to travel and see as much of the world as I can before my health gives out. We are childless but don’t feel our lives are any worse for not having grandchildren.