Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can someone explain how a parent could not invite their child on holiday?

567 replies

Tunisbaby · 09/10/2023 22:16

I just don't get it. How could any parent invite one of their biological children, not the other? How does that thought process go? 'What about... DS1... nah'
I could never ever imagine forgetting to invite my child or thinking about booking one child place and not even giving a second thought to enquiring with the other parent.
I get kid free holidays completely. But choosing to only be a parent to one child for the week when you have a seven year old at home is just bizarre.
Can any parents explain why this is ever thought to be ok?

OP posts:
ChristmasCrumpet · 11/10/2023 08:12

PreetyinPurple · 11/10/2023 08:08

A few people have asked. I imagine the child is pre-school and they are going term time and that’s why she isn’t saying how old it is.

Oh!

I didn't realise she hadn't answered that. I presumed she was making all this fuss because it was in the school holidays, and they'd literally just not invited him.

If they're taking a toddler whilst an elder child is supposed to be with mum and having to attend school, then she's just being a pain in the ass and knows perfectly well why the school age child wasn't "invited"...

90sfilm · 11/10/2023 08:09

@aSofaNearYou i'm still waiting fpr ypu to give me one. Not after pages and pages. Just one...

PreetyinPurple · 11/10/2023 08:08

A few people have asked. I imagine the child is pre-school and they are going term time and that’s why she isn’t saying how old it is.

90sfilm · 11/10/2023 08:07

@ChristmasCrumpet nothing you have said answers or justifies why it is ok for a dad to not invite one of his children on holiday. Plenty of fathers and stepmothers do as you can see from this thread. It is seen as an understandably cruel act to exclude a child when they want to go. A supposedly loving and supportive partner or wife of a father with another child should not put any barriers down which would make the fatger feel awkward about inviting his child from a previous relationship. If you can't empathise with someone elses child being excluded then you would only ever realise if it happened to ypur own child. Maybe then you'd finally see why it's deemed so cruel and inexcusable as you'd have to watch the rejection and suffering on your own child's face.

Plaplablah · 11/10/2023 08:03

Can this child even go though? We don't know that OPs DS is free to go. What about school? Unless I've missed it somewhere OP hasn't said that she'd be happy for her son to miss school for a week to go to CPs.

She has said herself that she doesn't want to give specifics which I imagine most likely means her ex and new partners child is not school aged which is why they are going in the middle of school term and she wants them to go in the school holidays when her son can go.

There is nothing in OPs post that has said her son is free to go. He's more than likely not given he'd be in school!

ChristmasCrumpet · 11/10/2023 08:02

Plaplablah · 11/10/2023 07:18

I don't think the question is that your kids should miss out on a holiday. I think the question that often comes up is whether the Dad, who's a parent to all of them, should go. I've been on quite a few holidays with our joint DC, one to Disneyland too. Couldn't afford to take DSC as well so they didn't come. But, importantly, neither did DH. I went with family instead. My children aren't missing out on a holiday same as DSC go with their mum, but my husband felt he couldn't come and be fair to his older children which I understand and respect.

So you don't go on holiday with both your husband and children? And your children will never get to holiday with their father?

Have the SC ever been on holiday with their father?

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 08:02

90sfilm · 11/10/2023 07:57

@aSofaNearYou where is the successful explanation of why a father would exclude one of his children from a holiday if they are free and want to go?There isn't one as it's unjustifiable to exclude one of your children and would cause that child (having spoken to friends who experienced this as a child)

In your opinion. There are pages and pages of explanations about why people do this, and how it doesn't cause any issues. The fact that you don't agree with them doesn't mean you can just say the explanations aren't there. They are successful to me, they are clearly successful to many others.

90sfilm · 11/10/2023 07:57

@aSofaNearYou where is the successful explanation of why a father would exclude one of his children from a holiday if they are free and want to go?There isn't one as it's unjustifiable to exclude one of your children and would cause that child (having spoken to friends who experienced this as a child)

SoupDragon · 11/10/2023 07:56

I'm sure that on threads posted from the POV of the step mother who wants to go away as a family without the step children, most posters say it's perfectly reasonable and that the SC don't need to be included in everything, they get holidays with their mother etc etc.

Subforsupper · 11/10/2023 07:21

Binkyj89 · 11/10/2023 06:18

OP has 1 child and dad has the other child. Both the dads children but he's taking one away she really should of given more information

Yeah I just meant, it’s not unusual to go on holiday without your kids, we do it once or twice a year.

Plaplablah · 11/10/2023 07:18

LittleMousewithcloggson · 10/10/2023 23:25

I really think many people don’t see the big picture and cost implications.
DHs ex left him. They sold up and she had enough to pay for a house outright - which is fair enough as he should provide a home for his kids. She has no mortgage, a great job and maintenance. Kids wear designer clothes and have a lot of holidays with her.
DH starts again. We buy a small house together and have a mortgage. We have 2 children. DH is paying bills and maintenance and has very little excess income. I can afford to pay for 4 of us to go on holiday but only the 4 of us. My parents help out so we can go abroad.
why on Earth would I say to DH to invite his other children? I can’t afford it
And why on Earth would I expect my kids to miss out on holidays - especially if their step siblings are having them

Edited

I don't think the question is that your kids should miss out on a holiday. I think the question that often comes up is whether the Dad, who's a parent to all of them, should go. I've been on quite a few holidays with our joint DC, one to Disneyland too. Couldn't afford to take DSC as well so they didn't come. But, importantly, neither did DH. I went with family instead. My children aren't missing out on a holiday same as DSC go with their mum, but my husband felt he couldn't come and be fair to his older children which I understand and respect.

Coffeaddict · 11/10/2023 06:56

DP takes DSS away without our other children. He's been away 3 times this year for 2-3 nights at a time. Is that as equally horrendous?

also we went camping for 4 days without DSS over the summer but I'm sure that makes me some evil stepmum.

So to be clear gor us there is a 8 and 10 year gap between DSS and his brothers. The trips with dad are so they can more robust activities that the younger ones are not able for. Ditto the trip in the summer with just the younger boys was spent at places like parks and soft plays which DSS has outgrown.
I also know many families where both parents are together but only 1 goes due to interest, age of kids ect. So my question is was a trip with his other child balances with trips and quality time with his older child? If so pick your battles. If not then have a discussion with him

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 06:48

A child might not be able to spend christmas day with both parents at the same house but a child must be invited to his or her dad's house every year whether the child chooses to go or not. It's about it being an open house for the child and unhindered access to their father.

What is with all this "must"? Do people really think there is a finite set of rules about this? They do not have to be invited every year and choose themselves whether to go, plans can be made on their behalf and those plans might be to alternate years. They are young children, it is absolutely not obligatory or universally done to allow them to choose, or to be obliged to refrain from making alternate plans on the years it has not been arranged that they will come.

My DSS is not invited to "dad's house" and welcome to choose for himself on the years we don't have him to Christmas because frankly we will be elsewhere with my family. He will be with his mum. Children do not always get to choose everything.

In fact the more I think about it the more nuts this quote seems to me. Children do not have to have "unhindered access to their parent", no child does, whether step child or not. There are times when all children's access to their parent is "hindered", when they have to go to work for example. Parents can make plans and sometimes they will not be available, that is perfectly normal.

Binkyj89 · 11/10/2023 06:18

OP has 1 child and dad has the other child. Both the dads children but he's taking one away she really should of given more information

Subforsupper · 11/10/2023 05:25

We often go on short breaks without the kids. We leave them with a grandparent. Usually a weekend. It’s just nice to have a bit of ‘us time’ and recharge

ChristmasCrumpet · 11/10/2023 05:19

90sfilm · 10/10/2023 22:11

So the evidence you have that suggests op thinks that the father should love her child more than his others is that she described the first child that he had as 'his first child'? However, you don't question why the father hasn't invited his own child on a family holiday because these things 'naturally occur'

I think op is emphasising that their child is first born as the father is acting like his subsequent children have replaced his first child as he is not invited on a family holiday with his dad. From OP's post it's clear she wants her son to go and isn't stopping him. I don't think OP's son not being invited on a holiday 'naturally occured'. It was a conscious decision to exclude child by his own father and new wife. I know of childhood friends who were always invited on holiday by their father and stepmum. No matter how much OP will tell her child that her dad loves him equally the child will feel excluded by this action. Friends and dp who weren't invited by fathers when they went on a family holiday with their wife and subsequent children always report similar feelings - exclusion, unworthiness, replaced. I think that a child not being invited on a family holiday when the child's mum is not putting up any resistance and thebchild is free to go is certainly not 'logistics' and everyone knows it.

A child might not be able to spend christmas day with both parents at the same house but a child must be invited to his or her dad's house every year whether the child chooses to go or not. It's about it being an open house for the child and unhindered access to their father.

There's a difference in just stating, "oh John, he's my first, Amelia is my second" etc, and "John should be prioritised, he's my first". OPs posts lean towards the latter.

A child might not be able to spend christmas day with both parents at the same house but a child must be invited to his or her dad's house every year whether the child chooses to go or not. It's about it being an open house for the child and unhindered access to their father.

At 7, the child isn't choosing anything. It's down to the parents. I don't understand this "as long as mum says it's ok, he should be going" either? It's not her call, she's not the sole decision maker.

There are two households. Two rents, two sets of alllll the bills, all the to-ing and fro-ing between the two. The child benefits from two households (for arguments sake) 50% each. The other children benefit from one household 100%.

The households are not identical. That's what happens when parents split up. That's life. Caused by the decisions of the parents. Maybe the child's mother provides 50% of a high level lifestyle and dad is skint and his 50% is of a lower level. If there are children 100% resident in mum's home, they will receive 100% of her higher level, and should not be penalised simply because that's their only household, and another child has two households.

Also, if mum's/dad's household is significantly higher level, not due to them, but their partner, then it's not either biological parent's place to start making comments about their child not receiving the same treatment, because the "benefit" comes from a person who is neither of the child's parents. And yes, the child that is that partner's child does, and should, receive the benefits, and no, the non biological child isn't entitled (no matter how much the parents seem to think they are!) and if the partner chooses to share those additional benefits with a non biological child, that's obviously great, but it's their choice, and their choice alone.

Amanda2727 · 11/10/2023 03:16

@Decemberstartsonsunday i totally agree. My kids dad went on to have another child. He now barely sees . The few times there’ve been at his house and his partners . His partner finds reasons to not be around and made no attempt to get to know them. They have a half sister they haven’t seen for 7 years.

J578 · 11/10/2023 00:05

I don’t see how people are finding this fair?!
my step daughter has always always come on holiday with us! (Me and husband have 2 children).
shes 21 now and still gets invited albeit pays for herself but still wouldn’t dream of not inviting her!

Dramatic · 10/10/2023 23:28

LittleMousewithcloggson · 10/10/2023 23:25

I really think many people don’t see the big picture and cost implications.
DHs ex left him. They sold up and she had enough to pay for a house outright - which is fair enough as he should provide a home for his kids. She has no mortgage, a great job and maintenance. Kids wear designer clothes and have a lot of holidays with her.
DH starts again. We buy a small house together and have a mortgage. We have 2 children. DH is paying bills and maintenance and has very little excess income. I can afford to pay for 4 of us to go on holiday but only the 4 of us. My parents help out so we can go abroad.
why on Earth would I say to DH to invite his other children? I can’t afford it
And why on Earth would I expect my kids to miss out on holidays - especially if their step siblings are having them

Edited

Taking 4 extra (much older) kids to Lapland (who have also spent 3 weeks in the Carribbean) is very different from taking one 7yo to center parcs.

LittleMousewithcloggson · 10/10/2023 23:25

I really think many people don’t see the big picture and cost implications.
DHs ex left him. They sold up and she had enough to pay for a house outright - which is fair enough as he should provide a home for his kids. She has no mortgage, a great job and maintenance. Kids wear designer clothes and have a lot of holidays with her.
DH starts again. We buy a small house together and have a mortgage. We have 2 children. DH is paying bills and maintenance and has very little excess income. I can afford to pay for 4 of us to go on holiday but only the 4 of us. My parents help out so we can go abroad.
why on Earth would I say to DH to invite his other children? I can’t afford it
And why on Earth would I expect my kids to miss out on holidays - especially if their step siblings are having them

Dramatic · 10/10/2023 23:20

ChristmasCrumpet · 10/10/2023 21:31

Completely disagree.

Throughout the thread, it's her "first born" "first child" "he was a dad first" and those "new kids".

OP seems disgruntled that her DS is only the centre of her universe, as he has to share that spot with other siblings at his father's.

She and the father caused the split household. It's not the child's fault. Situations like this naturally occur when a child has to live across two homes. No, you can't really spend Christmas Day at one house with both parents, for example. It's down to the mother/father to ensure they explain carefully and factually why this is the case.

It's normal for a non resident child to be absent from activities in the home they spend far less time in. Both parents should be reassuring the child that this is literally down to logistics and nothing else.

Sharing the spot of being "centre of the world" to his father means sharing the holiday surely? Rather than being left out of it completely

Decemberstartsonsunday · 10/10/2023 23:17

YANBU Op,
I don't understand how he can leave his 7-year-old out; a child that age would love that holiday. I don't understand why people get into relationships with people who already have children, only to later expect them to be forgotten and left out, or why people, men mainly, forget about their other child when they have a new family.

Fairospop22 · 10/10/2023 23:02

Is the new partner paying or your ex?

LittleMousewithcloggson · 10/10/2023 23:00

I’m a step mum to 4
i have 2
There is 8 years difference between my eldest and the youngest stepchild
When mine were tiny we went to butlins and center parcs during term time. Never occurred to us to take the older ones - they wouldn’t have wanted to spend time singing along with Bob the Builder!
When mine were 5 and 6 we took them on a 5 days holiday to Lapland to see Father Christmas. DHs ex was furious as her children had never done that but my parents and I financed the trip. We could never have paid for an extra 4 children and mine shouldn’t have to miss out - I worked 2 jobs to pay for it
My stepchildren went to the Caribbean for 3 weeks with their mother and partner.
They got £500/600 spent on them each every Christmas by their mother, mine got much less than that
They live in different homes, they have different lifestyles
You can’t expect stepchildren to be included in everything with the new family. It’s a nice idea but it’s just not possible

uneffingbelievable · 10/10/2023 22:56

fattytums - you are quite unnecessarily offensive.

It is a difficult subject - at the end of the day the DF needs to treat his children equitably. If he takes one on holiday then he should take the others on holiday too.

If it is none of the EXs business what goes on in the DFs new household, then the argument well the other DC goes on holiday with his DM so it is fair.

It is about one parent treating all their children equitably and if that means he can not afford to take them all on holiday, then they can not all go - it should not be a case of pick and choose.

My EX coudl ahve afforded to take his new DP and her 2DCs and his 2 DCS to Spain but could not afford to take them all business class and 5 str hotel to Barbados. So 2 got left behind. The hurt that caused can not be underestimated. When they had a joint child my DCS half sibling - he has taken joint DC on holiday every year for the past 7 years - he has taken his first DCs away once with their joint sibling. There is nothing equitable or fair about that and they know it.