Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can someone explain how a parent could not invite their child on holiday?

567 replies

Tunisbaby · 09/10/2023 22:16

I just don't get it. How could any parent invite one of their biological children, not the other? How does that thought process go? 'What about... DS1... nah'
I could never ever imagine forgetting to invite my child or thinking about booking one child place and not even giving a second thought to enquiring with the other parent.
I get kid free holidays completely. But choosing to only be a parent to one child for the week when you have a seven year old at home is just bizarre.
Can any parents explain why this is ever thought to be ok?

OP posts:
ChristmasCrumpet · 11/10/2023 17:20

90sfilm · 11/10/2023 16:24

@ChristmasCrumpet you've just come up with lots of scenarios again that are unrelated to ops post and my posts. Another user has speculated that the reason the op's son has not been invited to the holiday is because it's during his term time. Where does the op say or suggest this? Also, i don t know why you are talking about a child not having 100 percent access to a parent who has split up from the mother. Nobody has said this.

It's getting a bit exhausting now but just to clarify again. The specific situation is a father going on to have children with a new partner and taking actions that make the child feel left out or replaced. If a child doesn't feel replaced then great. But an example i have is my dh who was not invited to any family holidays with his dad once he had a child with another woman. Nothing to do with going away during term time as he can only afford that. The thought process was 'well why does he need a holiday with me now. He goes away with his mum'. DH feels rejected by this. Oof course his mum didn't play on this as she couldn't stomach looking upset so she would not play on it and take him on her own adventures. However, dh still feels like he was replaced. Like his father had a new child now who he could be a proper dad to and dh barely got the scraps. The specific scenario i am outlining is one that it is evident that a lot of posters can relate to. Not a scenario where a child has a stepmum but they make an effort to treat the child equally. if the child doesn't feel rejected then there is no issue.

you've just come up with lots of scenarios again that are unrelated to ops post and my posts.

They're pretty common examples, and given OP won't give any information, it's not unreasonable that these examples would apply

Another user has speculated that the reason the op's son has not been invited to the holiday is because it's during his term time. Where does the op say or suggest this?

Again, OP hasn't said anything. But it would make exact sense that the break includes term time days, as the resident child is younger than primary aged OPs child, and all Center Parcs breaks tend to involve at least one weekday. It's the most likely scenario.

Also, i don t know why you are talking about a child not having 100 percent access to a parent who has split up from the mother. Nobody has said this.

Someone has literally said exactly this. Hence several posters have responded to it.

90sfilm · 11/10/2023 17:07

Teder · 11/10/2023 16:05

You don’t come across as opening to listening either. You’re focused on your own point of view and your perspective. It helps to put yourself in the child’s shoes, it doesn’t necessarily mean you will change your behaviour but perhaps act more empathetically.

@Teder I do agree and can see that some posters/step mums are not putting themselves in the child's shoes. There are stepmums out there who do put themselves in the child's shoes. So there is obviously another and more empathetic way of doing things where the child doesn't feel so rejected. Nobody is asking stepmums to love the child as fervently as they love their own child. The important thing is that the child doesn't feel replaced, especially when there are half siblings.The frustrating thing is that the same step mums i'm thinking of would never let a guy in a subsequent relationship push their child out of the picture or make them feel awkward about involving them in family holidays. I wonder how some of these posters would feel if they were tp get in a subsequent relationship and have a child and the guy say they could go on holiday with their child but the child they have now cannot come. I bet they couldn't envision that and would say no way.

90sfilm · 11/10/2023 16:24

ChristmasCrumpet · 11/10/2023 15:34

Because people thinks it's utterly ridiculous, doesn't mean it's "touched a nerve". It means they think it's utterly ridiculous.

Not having access to a parent 100% of the time shouldn't default to feeling rejected. And if a child does feel that way, it's because a parent has made them think it's unfair, because it's not an unreasonable thing at all.

Similarly, a child should understand that if they spent 100% of their time in one household, they would do (pretty much) 100% of things in that household. And if they spend, say, 70% of their time, then 30% of their time over two households, that (pretty much) they would do 70% and 30% of the things in those respective households. And this shouldn't cause a child to feel rejected, that's what happens when their parents don't live together. And it's on the parents to make the child understand this.

"You have to go to school, remember" shouldn't cause feelings of deep rejection. "Mum/Dad will be away this weekend, but they can't wait to see you next weekend" as a one off, shouldn't cause feelings of deep rejection. "It's a week of doing baby things, and you'd be bored stiff" shouldn't cause feelings of deep rejection. Maybe the non resident parent can only afford a term time break. A child may be naturally disappointed, but it can be handled two ways. A simple explanation as to why they aren't going (predominantly the fact they're in full time education) so they understand that they couldn't go. Or, you could tell the child "well, I would let you have the time off school, so there's nothing stopping you going" which is fueling the child to think the only good reason they aren't there, is because they aren't wanted. It all depends on how the parents present this to the child.

@ChristmasCrumpet you've just come up with lots of scenarios again that are unrelated to ops post and my posts. Another user has speculated that the reason the op's son has not been invited to the holiday is because it's during his term time. Where does the op say or suggest this? Also, i don t know why you are talking about a child not having 100 percent access to a parent who has split up from the mother. Nobody has said this.

It's getting a bit exhausting now but just to clarify again. The specific situation is a father going on to have children with a new partner and taking actions that make the child feel left out or replaced. If a child doesn't feel replaced then great. But an example i have is my dh who was not invited to any family holidays with his dad once he had a child with another woman. Nothing to do with going away during term time as he can only afford that. The thought process was 'well why does he need a holiday with me now. He goes away with his mum'. DH feels rejected by this. Oof course his mum didn't play on this as she couldn't stomach looking upset so she would not play on it and take him on her own adventures. However, dh still feels like he was replaced. Like his father had a new child now who he could be a proper dad to and dh barely got the scraps. The specific scenario i am outlining is one that it is evident that a lot of posters can relate to. Not a scenario where a child has a stepmum but they make an effort to treat the child equally. if the child doesn't feel rejected then there is no issue.

Teder · 11/10/2023 16:05

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 14:28

Jesus, what have you got to be resentful about? You got involved with someone that has previous children, if you thought you may resent those children for existing then you should have walked away for everyone's sake.

I really cannot be bothered to go back to absolute basics and explain to you all the many things that can prove difficult about being a step parent and lead a person to struggle with it, do some reading around the subject if you're interested, but I suspect you are not open to listening, really.

You don’t come across as opening to listening either. You’re focused on your own point of view and your perspective. It helps to put yourself in the child’s shoes, it doesn’t necessarily mean you will change your behaviour but perhaps act more empathetically.

sandyhappypeople · 11/10/2023 15:55

Thisismynewusername1 · 11/10/2023 15:26

Out of interest, is it ok for grandparents to take one child and their family/children away, but not another?

for example, going to Disney (and paying) with their daughter, sil and children, but not inviting their son, dil and children.

I’m not sure if strangers can answer that without knowing the ins and outs?

But on the surface of it I’d question why you were taking one and not the other?

ChristmasCrumpet · 11/10/2023 15:34

90sfilm · 11/10/2023 10:23

@aSofaNearYou we're not talking about these times. We're talking about a father not inviting one of his children on holiday. A holiday that the child would love to go on and is free to go on. The unhindered access as i've said before is the same access that he'd get with his mother. Shouldnt be half arsed dad just because he's split up from the mum. And yes, only taking the children from your new relationship on holiday is half arsed parent to your excluded child. But too much focusing on parents. The emphasis should be on how it makes the child feel. I'm not coming at this from the perspective of someone who has a child who this is happening to. I'm coming from it from the perspective of someone who knows of people who have been the excluded child in this situation and have felt a trauma from being excluded from a family holiday. They've grown up now amd vowed to never exclude a child from a holiday with his own dad. My partner would never put up with a partner who wanted to just spend some quality time with him and their children at the expense of our child's feelings. This has clearly tpuched a nerve with a lot of step mothers eho do this which is why they find it so 'ridiculous' that it's seen as cruel to not invite one of the fatehr's children on a family holiday. For every one there is a stepparent eho does find it cruel. Take heed!

Edited

Because people thinks it's utterly ridiculous, doesn't mean it's "touched a nerve". It means they think it's utterly ridiculous.

Not having access to a parent 100% of the time shouldn't default to feeling rejected. And if a child does feel that way, it's because a parent has made them think it's unfair, because it's not an unreasonable thing at all.

Similarly, a child should understand that if they spent 100% of their time in one household, they would do (pretty much) 100% of things in that household. And if they spend, say, 70% of their time, then 30% of their time over two households, that (pretty much) they would do 70% and 30% of the things in those respective households. And this shouldn't cause a child to feel rejected, that's what happens when their parents don't live together. And it's on the parents to make the child understand this.

"You have to go to school, remember" shouldn't cause feelings of deep rejection. "Mum/Dad will be away this weekend, but they can't wait to see you next weekend" as a one off, shouldn't cause feelings of deep rejection. "It's a week of doing baby things, and you'd be bored stiff" shouldn't cause feelings of deep rejection. Maybe the non resident parent can only afford a term time break. A child may be naturally disappointed, but it can be handled two ways. A simple explanation as to why they aren't going (predominantly the fact they're in full time education) so they understand that they couldn't go. Or, you could tell the child "well, I would let you have the time off school, so there's nothing stopping you going" which is fueling the child to think the only good reason they aren't there, is because they aren't wanted. It all depends on how the parents present this to the child.

Thisismynewusername1 · 11/10/2023 15:26

Out of interest, is it ok for grandparents to take one child and their family/children away, but not another?

for example, going to Disney (and paying) with their daughter, sil and children, but not inviting their son, dil and children.

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 14:46

@sandyhappypeople I don't feel resentful personally, frustrated is a better word. But resentful would probably be the appropriate term if I had a partner who couldn't understand and respect that I don't feel the same way about time with his child as he does.

sandyhappypeople · 11/10/2023 14:42

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 14:28

Jesus, what have you got to be resentful about? You got involved with someone that has previous children, if you thought you may resent those children for existing then you should have walked away for everyone's sake.

I really cannot be bothered to go back to absolute basics and explain to you all the many things that can prove difficult about being a step parent and lead a person to struggle with it, do some reading around the subject if you're interested, but I suspect you are not open to listening, really.

I'm open to listening, and honestly, you don't have to tell me, the struggle is real, I've experienced it from both sides, but do you think resentful is really the right word to use?

I wouldn't have had an issue with that if you'd have said 'frustrated', that's understandable, but resentful is quite an extreme emotion when talking about SC IMO, if you really feel that way then my previous post still stands and I think you may have been better off avoiding someone with children altogether.

resentful
/rɪˈzɛntf(ʊ)l/

adjective

  1. feeling or expressing bitterness or indignation at having been treated unfairly.
aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 14:28

Jesus, what have you got to be resentful about? You got involved with someone that has previous children, if you thought you may resent those children for existing then you should have walked away for everyone's sake.

I really cannot be bothered to go back to absolute basics and explain to you all the many things that can prove difficult about being a step parent and lead a person to struggle with it, do some reading around the subject if you're interested, but I suspect you are not open to listening, really.

SemperIdem · 11/10/2023 14:10

@sandyhappypeople

It’s rare that the children are the cause of resentment, but having an interfering ex forever involved in one’s life, not even your own ex, does get wearing.

Every step mother knows what the deal is re the children. Not all of them have the same deal when it comes to the mothers of said children however.

sandyhappypeople · 11/10/2023 14:04

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 12:20

I'm not sure what you mean by not telling the child. What they don't know doedn't hurt them? Do you mean the father going away with his children from currebt relationship and everyone keeping this a secret from his other child? I personally don't know why a parent would only take a child away from their current relationship but not take another child of theirs away. Again as others on here have pointed out, it's about wanting to make all your children feel equal and no favouritism going on

The reason they would go on a trip without their child is that they recognise that they have formed a relationship with somebody who is not that child's parents and as a result, that person might not enjoy trips with their child in the same way they would, or may actively not enjoy it. They would be a happier, more contented step parent less likely to end up feeling resentful if they were able to have that breathing space and enjoyable experience alongside all the time they no doubt dedicate to their DPs child for their sake. And yes, sure, a decent parent couldn't sanction going along with that at the expense of their child's feelings. But when the child doesn't even know? Why not? To me, there is maturity in accepting that you've made your family set up complicated by having children with more than one person and it may require compromise on your part from your ideal image of a nuclear family to keep everybody happy. As long is things are handled in a way where everyone feels their needs can be fulfilled without anybody being told something that would hurt them, then all is well.

You have to remember that a lot of the time in these cases, we're talking about pre school aged children and on older step child. So the child that goes on the holiday is a baby or toddler, not exactly known for their eloquent descriptions of what they've been up to. I've never had to warn my DD not to mention things to my DSS, she just doesn't, because she is young and that isn't something she would say.

They would be a happier, more contented step parent less likely to end up feeling resentful if they were able to have that breathing space and enjoyable experience alongside all the time they no doubt dedicate to their DPs child for their sake.

Jesus, what have you got to be resentful about? You got involved with someone that has previous children, if you thought you may resent those children for existing then you should have walked away for everyone's sake.

Teder · 11/10/2023 13:16

My dad did this with his new family. He was an average father who saw us at a weekend and plonked us in front of the telly. He paid maintenance so reckoned he was awesome. He’s not a bad person but he wasn’t a caring, loving father. Some of these posters remind me of my step mum, she’s not a bad person either but she lacks empathy and insight. She thought she had it right and wouldn’t listen. They seem surprised we aren’t close as adults especially now they want to see the grandchildren.

I married a man who was a father. One of the reasons I loved him was because he was an excellent father. He doesn’t make every excuse in the book like some of the men who’ve been described here. Do we always get it right? Nope but we try.

I would never have married an “every other weekend” type dad who chose cheap holidays over trying to create a cohesive family unit.

Nina1013 · 11/10/2023 12:32

If it’s next week, your child is at school. Even if they’re going on a weekend, that’s Friday and Monday all day that you are able to use the facilities and it’s not a cheap break so I can understand them wanting to! With a school aged child, it’s a 2 night/2 day break while paying for a 3 night/4 day break because you have to wait until they finish school on the Friday and have them back for school on the Monday.

sandyhappypeople · 11/10/2023 12:29

IvorTheEngineDriver · 11/10/2023 12:12

We do it. DD comes on holiday with us and is quite happy with the arrangement. DS (elder brother) would sooner crawl over broken glass. There's no "one size fits all" answer to this. It all depends on circumstances.

Edited

Your situation (and many other people on this thread giving ‘examples’) is really quite different to what the OP is describing though, of course it’s fine to go on holidays separately if everyone is happy with that.

In your case It would only be comparable if the elder brother in your description really wanted to go but wasn’t actually invited.

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 11/10/2023 12:25

This has surely answered OP’s question!

Agree 100%
P

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 12:20

I'm not sure what you mean by not telling the child. What they don't know doedn't hurt them? Do you mean the father going away with his children from currebt relationship and everyone keeping this a secret from his other child? I personally don't know why a parent would only take a child away from their current relationship but not take another child of theirs away. Again as others on here have pointed out, it's about wanting to make all your children feel equal and no favouritism going on

The reason they would go on a trip without their child is that they recognise that they have formed a relationship with somebody who is not that child's parents and as a result, that person might not enjoy trips with their child in the same way they would, or may actively not enjoy it. They would be a happier, more contented step parent less likely to end up feeling resentful if they were able to have that breathing space and enjoyable experience alongside all the time they no doubt dedicate to their DPs child for their sake. And yes, sure, a decent parent couldn't sanction going along with that at the expense of their child's feelings. But when the child doesn't even know? Why not? To me, there is maturity in accepting that you've made your family set up complicated by having children with more than one person and it may require compromise on your part from your ideal image of a nuclear family to keep everybody happy. As long is things are handled in a way where everyone feels their needs can be fulfilled without anybody being told something that would hurt them, then all is well.

You have to remember that a lot of the time in these cases, we're talking about pre school aged children and on older step child. So the child that goes on the holiday is a baby or toddler, not exactly known for their eloquent descriptions of what they've been up to. I've never had to warn my DD not to mention things to my DSS, she just doesn't, because she is young and that isn't something she would say.

IvorTheEngineDriver · 11/10/2023 12:12

We do it. DD comes on holiday with us and is quite happy with the arrangement. DS (elder brother) would sooner crawl over broken glass. There's no "one size fits all" answer to this. It all depends on circumstances.

Baconisdelicious · 11/10/2023 12:08

clappyjay · 11/10/2023 10:51

I think if it were role reversed and a woman was doing this she wouldn’t get the same support.

EG someone comes on to AIBU and says:

Hi, I have 2 daughters aged 4 and 7. My 7-year-old has her arranged time with her dad (we are separated) next week. Me and my husband are going to take our 4-year-old on holiday to centre parcs during this time. Older DD would have loved this but tbh my husband deserves the time for us to just be a little family unit of 3 without somebody else’s child there. And in all honesty it’s much cheaper to not include older DD and my husband is the one who is funding this trip with his work bonus. AIBU?

Exactly. Anyone saying that would be wiped off the map!

Bra · 11/10/2023 11:50

Out of order - I'm going on holiday next week and we are taking my daughter who is two and my stepdaughter who is 16. Wouldn't dream of leaving SD out, or at least asking if she wanted to come.

90sfilm · 11/10/2023 11:30

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 11:11

I can't remember if OP said her child actually knew about the trip or not, just that he would enjoy it in theory, which is not the same thing as knowing and wanting to go.

But either way, like I said, there are also situations where the child isn't invited but doesn't know about the trip. Not just ones they know about and are upset about.

@aSofaNearYou The op mentioned that the son's father said i wont see you next week as we're goign away. By we he means new wife and the child/children he shares with her. She's made apoint of saying that she gets child free holidays. As i do. if they wanted to go away on their own and all of their children were old enough to stay with grandparents then that is fine as the children are being treated equally. The issue is that a father is treating the child from a previous relationship differently as he has not invited the child on a holiday.

I'm not sure what you mean by not telling the child. What they don't know doedn't hurt them? Do you mean the father going away with his children from currebt relationship and everyone keeping this a secret from his other child? I personally don't know why a parent would only take a child away from their current relationship but not take another child of theirs away. Again as others on here have pointed out, it's about wanting to make all your children feel equal and no favouritism going on. Wanting to spend time with them (of course as long as they themselves want to go on the holiday). Personally, I would be upset if i found out my dad had been away with my step sister and paid fprnit all but hadn't invited me. If she had been told to keep quiet about it also and i happened to find out then i'd also feel that that wpuld jeopardise our relationship too. This may not be the situation ypu are putlining though.

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 11:11

90sfilm · 11/10/2023 11:08

@aSofaNearYou I'm considering the emotive situations as this is the one the op has put forward. Her child hasn't been invited and he'd love to go. If a child is invited but doesn't want to go, of course it's a completely different situation. I'm specifically talkign about a situation where the child is not invited. Sorry i thought that was obvious.

Also yes my expression was confusing when i said 'unhindered access' but i've now explained what i meant. i think father's house should feel like the child's home as much as mother's house.

I can't remember if OP said her child actually knew about the trip or not, just that he would enjoy it in theory, which is not the same thing as knowing and wanting to go.

But either way, like I said, there are also situations where the child isn't invited but doesn't know about the trip. Not just ones they know about and are upset about.

90sfilm · 11/10/2023 11:08

@aSofaNearYou I'm considering the emotive situations as this is the one the op has put forward. Her child hasn't been invited and he'd love to go. If a child is invited but doesn't want to go, of course it's a completely different situation. I'm specifically talkign about a situation where the child is not invited. Sorry i thought that was obvious.

Also yes my expression was confusing when i said 'unhindered access' but i've now explained what i meant. i think father's house should feel like the child's home as much as mother's house.

90sfilm · 11/10/2023 11:02

notlucreziaborgia · 11/10/2023 10:51

You’ve said that no one answered the question. They did, just not to your liking.

Okay 🤷🏻‍♀️ I know some that were fine with it and others that weren’t. I’m in the former group myself. I’m not sure you’d bother to acknowledge the views of any you know that didn’t have an issue with it tbh.

@notlucreziaborgia i said noone successfully answered the question. So if a stepmother replies that her step child was not taken on holiday because the fsther could obly afford tp take one child on holiday (just so happens to be the child that they share) then that is not successful explanantion as in lots odlf situations the other child will feel excluded and rejected. Successful in my opinion would be a scenario where a child would not be deprived of a holiday theuvwould love to g o on and to spend some quality time with their father and half sibling. No child feeling upset or rejected. This is my opinion of course. You don't need to tell me this. I get it.

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 11:00

90sfilm · 11/10/2023 10:52

@aSofaNearYou i don't thibk yoy know what i mean by unhindered access though. Youbkeep going back to that point but i ve tried to explain that i don't mean that a parent should be at their child's beck and call 24/7. I mean that the child should not be made to feel like a guest in their father's home just because he has a new family. A child should not be made to feel like an inconvenience and be sent home early to his mum's because thebdad and step mum want a chinese take away (as op suggested).

I remember when my parents split up when i was a teenager i had a key to my mum's to let myslef in if i had gone out with friends. Wheb i let myself in my dad's house i got told off by my dad's gf at the time for not knocking. My step dad never did this though. As it was my home. I didn't need to knock. Do you see what i mean by saying unhindered access?

Also i wasn't quoting you saying 'ridiculous'. Another poster had said it. I still don't understand what is ridiculous to not invite one of yohr own children on hokiday if theyvreally want to go.

No I didn't know that's what you meant because it's not what you said. You said the child should have unhindered access to their parent whether they choose to use it or not, using Christmas as an example. I'm pointing out how silly and unrealistic that suggestion is. Maybe you meant something else but that is what you said. "Hindered access" is not the same thing as "made to feel like a guest".

You also only seem to be considering scenarios where the child "really wants to go". What about situations where they can't because they are at school, or they just don't even know it's happening? You are only considering the most emotive scenario.