Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can someone explain how a parent could not invite their child on holiday?

567 replies

Tunisbaby · 09/10/2023 22:16

I just don't get it. How could any parent invite one of their biological children, not the other? How does that thought process go? 'What about... DS1... nah'
I could never ever imagine forgetting to invite my child or thinking about booking one child place and not even giving a second thought to enquiring with the other parent.
I get kid free holidays completely. But choosing to only be a parent to one child for the week when you have a seven year old at home is just bizarre.
Can any parents explain why this is ever thought to be ok?

OP posts:
QueenofallIsee · 10/10/2023 13:03

There are loads of circumstances that have a bearing on whether this is acceptable or not. I was a step child who didn’t see their other parent and was not taken to Disney when my half sibling went with my primary parent. That hurt at age 14 but makes more sense as an adult as it was in school term, my brother was 4 and I had been aged 12 with my grandparents so actually not as unfair as aged 14 me thought it was. I am now a step mum that has been away with just my bio, just my step, every single one of us and just me and my husband. I don’t think every child needs to be included in every single thing, it’s just not practical.

Thisismynewusername1 · 10/10/2023 12:57

clappyjay · 10/10/2023 12:44

it simply isn’t possible for one child to be included in everything two families do. For a start finances often don’t stretch to it

But aren’t finances a consideration when you plan for subsequent children? When I planned for a second child it was taken into account we would now have 2 children and all the expenses that entails.

OPs ex and his new partner would have needed to consider that their baby already had a built-in sibling from the off, so future plans holidays trips houses etc etc would all need to be considered with a family of 4 in mind. Just as any other family planning another child would have to.

I am the higher earner. Before I had children I made sure I was in a position where I could afford to have them.

dh contributes equally to all his children. he does not have much disposable income once child maintenance is paid.

I pay for our holidays, but I can’t stretch to two more children, it effectively doubles the cost.

dh takes his two away with his parents once a year. We go away with our two roughly every 2-3 years.

i am not not having a holiday because we can’t afford to include his kids who have 3 holidays a year anyway (one with dh, their mum takes them abroad x2)

Catza · 10/10/2023 12:54

I think there shouldn't be a blanket obligation to take everyone on holiday at the same time every time. Sometimes we go away with my step daughter, sometimes we also take her younger sister who is not even related to my partner. Sometimes my step kid is with us while her mum goes on holidays with the rest of the kids and her new husband, sometimes they all go with mum, sometimes kids go with their respective dads, sometimes my partner and I go away together without kids. It's all very fluid and amicable and I can honestly say nobody's ever been upset over who goes where and when.

Feralgremlin · 10/10/2023 12:54

I guess I’m just confused at this weird belief that if you are a family, everything has to be done with everyone or not at all.

My parents are still together, we didn’t always holiday as a family of 4! They took me to Lanzarote, and took my brother to the Lake District. Then my mum, grandad, aunt, and brother went to America for two weeks, and me and my dad had a couple of trips to museums and musicals in London, because (and I know this will blow your minds) we have different interests and don’t always want to do the same thing!

Similarly, I have been on holiday with just my mum and my DS, my DH and my DS, my DH, DS and two DSDs, and just my DH! We regularly have days out as a 5, but sometimes DH will have a day out with just DSDs so they can have quality time, but equally we will have days out with just me, DH and DS.

It’s not a “blended family” thing, it’s a “everyone is an individual with different interests and needs at any given time, which are constantly changing and need to be nurtured differently” thing.

Tomatoketchupred · 10/10/2023 12:54

This explains it perfectly and are our reasons for taking our young babies away and not my older step child.

clappyjay · 10/10/2023 12:53

If someone posted a thread on here saying they wanted a 2nd baby but wouldn’t be able to afford to take two on holidays etc. lots of people would advise them to stick with one child. If it’s financial OPs ex really shouldn’t have chosen to have another child.

KT1112 · 10/10/2023 12:50

fattytum · 09/10/2023 22:40

but this is the step mothers holiday, yes? She doesn't want to take your child, obviously. She want to take her partner. She doesn't want to take your child. Why would she want to take your child on her holiday?

It seems perfectly reasonable to me.

You go away with your child and partner

She goes away with her child and partner

You are being very entitled to think they should be babysitting for you in their holiday.

Why don't you want to be with your child during this time?

Babysitting? Its his child

Babydaddysuck · 10/10/2023 12:45

My eldest dad took his new kids to disney land missing my childs birthday. Never understood how he could do that

clappyjay · 10/10/2023 12:44

it simply isn’t possible for one child to be included in everything two families do. For a start finances often don’t stretch to it

But aren’t finances a consideration when you plan for subsequent children? When I planned for a second child it was taken into account we would now have 2 children and all the expenses that entails.

OPs ex and his new partner would have needed to consider that their baby already had a built-in sibling from the off, so future plans holidays trips houses etc etc would all need to be considered with a family of 4 in mind. Just as any other family planning another child would have to.

clappyjay · 10/10/2023 12:40

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 10/10/2023 09:57

Hi OP,

This happens because

  • The stepmum might be the one organising/paying for holidays
  • The stepmum may not assume your child to be going, especially if your child primarily lives with you.
  • Their child is younger than school-age and so they prefer to travel during term time (saves a lot of money)
  • They want time away as a couple, but their young children have to go with them (as no other parents) whereas your child does not. It may be hard to have privacy or relax with an older child who belongs to a different parent present.
  • They might be visiting her extended family

All reasonable, yet it wouldn’t be nice to make it obvious to your DC that they are going somewhere fun without him.

i have one child who is school age and one who is not, I can’t just choose to take the younger one on term-time holidays but not the other. They have chosen to have a child knowing there is an older sibling with this sort of age gap which rules out term time holidays, similar to the rest of us who have slightly larger gaps between siblings.

The older child ‘belongs’ to both parents.

Everyone supporting this seems to have been the underlying idea that the older child just doesn’t really ‘count’.

Plaplablah · 10/10/2023 12:40

unless its a scenario where all children live in the same home I.e. one parent isn't involved anymore. There will always be inequalities and frictions imo

I agree with this tbh. I do think it's easier to treat DSC like your own when the other parent isn't on the scene.

And I think in the other scenarios where children are splitting time between two active parents, it doesn't do anyone any good to act like there should never ever be any differences and that everything should be entirely equal all of the time. It's never going to be in that situation. Not when a group of children have different parents who are all involved and have different views, different priorities, different finances etc..

My child (sorry OUR child, don't want to confuse PP) is always going to have a slightly different upbringing that DSC. Because they have different mothers. There are things I agree with that perhaps DSC mum doesn't, there are things perhaps she'll prioritise that I won't and so on. Their dads may be the same but they do have different mums and therefore there will always be some differences. It's stupid to suggest there never will be or shouldn't be.

Thisismynewusername1 · 10/10/2023 12:39

If you want your child to be included in everything his dad does with his wife and child, you need to hand over residency and allow the child to live with them.

it simply isn’t possible for one child to be included in everything two families do. For a start finances often don’t stretch to it, secondly it’s unreasonable to expect people to only plan activities for when the child is with them, and sit at home not doing anything when they aren’t.

throw in uncertainties like wanting a holiday, but not being possession of the child’s passport, and knowing the other parent could easily decide the day of travel that she’s not handing it over. Or the child deciding not to come. It’s very different to a residential child.

54isanopendoor · 10/10/2023 12:38

I agree. It's horrible for the child.

Newmumatlast · 10/10/2023 12:38

Thats a really reasonable and practical response

Newmumatlast · 10/10/2023 12:37

I agree with you in terms of my own personal feelings. I also have small kids but adult SC and feel sad for them having different opportunities but thats just the fact of them having grown up in different circumstances when their Dad had less but actually mainly because their mum was very different from me in terms of minimum wage part time work with no qualifications whereas I am what people would call a career woman and had kids later so most of our improved financial situation is due to me. If my SC was small I wouldn't exclude them from things like holidays - we actually took her when she was small pre our kids. But unevitably there will be differences because just as her mum isn't responsible for my kids, I am not actually responsible for her so it makes sense that I make provisions for my own children that she is not included in (like savings for future) just as her mum can for her (she has a house my kids obviously won't inherit).

Eliza25 · 10/10/2023 12:36

I've never been close to my partners son, we've been together 12 years, for various reasons distance being one of them. His girlfriend is now having a baby in labour as I write and I can't feel excited. I don't feel part of it. How can I support my partner and fake feelings?

ThirdDressStress · 10/10/2023 12:31

I think each family needs to weigh up their own circumstances regarding holidays.

For example, my EXH has never taken our shared DC on holiday, but he goes with his wife and step kids. I am fine with this because I take our DC away so they get a holiday. If he had to take our children along with him it would become unaffordable so therefore no one in that family gets a holiday. Why should those DC miss out on any holiday at all because they can't afford to include my two DC who already had a holiday.

If I wasn't in a position to take them I would probably feel differently but as long as everyone is getting a nice break I am not fussed.

Newmumatlast · 10/10/2023 12:26

The problem is though that its complex. If you went away you wouldn't take the sibling with you. Now I get that you will say its different as the sibling isn't your child but both kids are his... but then your child isn't the new partner's child are they? So on that basis it makes sense that they might have a holiday just them in the same way you could have a holiday just you. It also depends who is paying. If she works and it's her money then she shouldn't have to pay for your child to go aswell. It would be nice if she did but she doesnt have to.

ultimately I think if they're only going because she can afford it, not him, then your child can't be expected to go. If it is his money then he shouldn't be funding a holiday for only one child and not the other - unless he already has (I.e. they can expect a holiday alone like you could but then he should probably also fund one together or give the same money to your child to go on the one with you).

This is why really blended families do not work unless its a scenario where all children live in the same home I.e. one parent isn't involved anymore. There will always be inequalities and frictions imo.

Plaplablah · 10/10/2023 12:23

crumblingschools · 10/10/2023 12:21

@Plaplablah interesting how you use 'my' and 'own' child, as if nothing to do with DH

This one always comes up on these threads. My child is also my husbands child. What difference does it make what term I use. Its not interesting it's just a fact. Our, mine, his blah blah why does it matter? Unless of course you're trying to paint me in some sort of light... hmm.

OP calls her child her son throughout. How terrible of her not to constantly refer to him as THEIR son.

Don't be so ridiculous.

crumblingschools · 10/10/2023 12:21

@Plaplablah interesting how you use 'my' and 'own' child, as if nothing to do with DH

Plaplablah · 10/10/2023 12:21

And I'm not to blame if my husband turned around and said "actually ill come with you this time". I'd assume, given he is DSCs dad, that he'd considered them and made a decision based on what he thought best. If it turned out DSC were hurt that his dad joined me and DC on a holiday, it would be his fault, not mine. He's a big boy who can make decisions by himself.

Plaplablah · 10/10/2023 12:19

crumblingschools · 10/10/2023 12:15

@Plaplablah so if you had 2 children, one school age and one not, would you be happy to leave the school age one at home to make the most of cheap holidays

The point is I don't have two children one in school and one not. I have one child who is not in school so yes I take them outside of school holidays whilst I can.

My husband, the one who does have two children one in school and one not, can choose whether to come or not. He often doesn't and that's fine by me.

I know people will say "well you chose a man with older DC" and my response to that is well yes, that's why I don't have a problem with DH not joining us, nor do I pressure him to. It doesn't mean I have to never do anything completely normal with my own child though, like taking them on holiday in term time if I can.

aSofaNearYou · 10/10/2023 12:18

crumblingschools · 10/10/2023 12:15

@Plaplablah so if you had 2 children, one school age and one not, would you be happy to leave the school age one at home to make the most of cheap holidays

That's not what she said, is it. She said it's not her job to feel guilty if he chooses to.

And like it or not, there is an obvious practical difference between leaving behind a child that doesn't live with you and does many things separately to you, as opposed to one who does live with you, for whom you'd need to find childcare, and who is used to doing everything with you.

Mylovelygreendress · 10/10/2023 12:18

Kaill · 10/10/2023 12:07

Sorry but I think you’re being unreasonable. Expecting your ex to have no family time with his new wife and DC because he always has to cart your DC along. That’s not fair on his wife or child, they should be allowed to have time with him. Your DC doesn’t have to be included in everything, as long as they get a reasonable amount of time with their dad. And you’re extremely unreasonable to expect the new wife’s parents to treat your totally unrelated DC the same as their own flesh and blood grandchild.

I think I saw something mentioned about it being a term time holiday? Presumably his younger DC isn’t at school yet and yours is. In which case how do you expect your DC to be able to go when they’re at school?

I may be wrong but I would guess you are a SM with pesky stepchildren??
You sound like my exh’s next wife !

crumblingschools · 10/10/2023 12:15

@Plaplablah so if you had 2 children, one school age and one not, would you be happy to leave the school age one at home to make the most of cheap holidays