Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can someone explain how a parent could not invite their child on holiday?

567 replies

Tunisbaby · 09/10/2023 22:16

I just don't get it. How could any parent invite one of their biological children, not the other? How does that thought process go? 'What about... DS1... nah'
I could never ever imagine forgetting to invite my child or thinking about booking one child place and not even giving a second thought to enquiring with the other parent.
I get kid free holidays completely. But choosing to only be a parent to one child for the week when you have a seven year old at home is just bizarre.
Can any parents explain why this is ever thought to be ok?

OP posts:
PreetyinPurple · 10/10/2023 14:00

Sorry I didn’t quote the person saying the boy wouldn’t make a difference to the accommodation/cost.

Plaplablah · 10/10/2023 14:00

Christmas and the amount of money spent is also a silly idea. I wouldn't even expect equal amounts in a nuclear family when you have children of differing ages.

My DSC got a phone last year that cost upwards of £600. Should I have spent £600 on our 3 year old? Or should we have said no you can't have a phone DSC because we only spent £80 on your sibling so that's all you're getting too.

Older children tend to be more expensive that small ones. I imagine that's the same scenario for tonnes of families up and down the country with an age gap.

Then you have the situations in a blended family like, for example, my parents who may get our child a more expensive gift than DSC. I don't think there's anything wrong with that, DSC have grandparents themselves who spoil them just as much as my parents do our child.

Again, it's not all going to be equal.

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 10/10/2023 14:00

My parents want to send gifts/money for my DC. They definitely don’t need to do the same for a child unrelated to them.

PreetyinPurple · 10/10/2023 13:59

Everyone has to have a bed though. You don’t pay for a lodge and put as many people as you like in it. That was in the 80s. It has to be the right size for the number of guests, under 1s are free I think.

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 10/10/2023 13:58

And no, they don’t need to be invited if it’s not suitable. Eg term time.

However wouldn’t want to actively make any child feel bad.

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 10/10/2023 13:56

Just on the point of presents - no doesn’t have to be an identical amount.

I am happy to have gotten DSD a new iPad. She is older.

I am happy that my own younger DC has second hand toys from vinted. It doesn’t matter. He is getting enjoyment out of it.

90sfilm · 10/10/2023 13:52

@yogasaurus when posters are talking about children being treated equally we are not referring to them leading identical lives. More, they both get the same amount of money spent on them at birthdays and christmasses. If you're going to shell out money on one child and treat them to a holiday, other children from previous relationships also need to be at least invited. It goes without saying that they're not going tp have identical lives. The op has outlined a situation where her child is being actively discriminated against and i know from being friends with and being the partner of such more or less forgottem children that it impacts them. No matter how kuch new wives and dads try to convince themselves that surely it's implausible that both children get treated equally. You can sense the attitude on here towards children from previous relationships when expressions like 'cart around' get used. Children are very much aware that this is how they are seen.

yogasaurus · 10/10/2023 13:50

If you're kicking off with your child's other parent because he took his "new" children to the aquarium when yours were with you for the weekend for example, you're going to make it seem to your child like it's a problem when really it isn't.

This underlies so many of these threads, alongside how the new wife doesn’t ‘deserve’ the experience she wants and should live a life of servitude.

Plaplablah · 10/10/2023 13:45

LolaSmiles · 10/10/2023 13:39

This is the problem though with trying to jam a blended family into the mould of a nuclear one.
This is the crux of the issue.

A blended family isn't going to be the same as a nuclear one. They're just not the same and the adults all have different circumstances.

Each child has two parents and if they split up then the family circumstances will change. The parents have a responsibility to be fair and equitable towards their children, that doesn't mean all children across two blended families need to be treated identically.

If one of the parents is being obviously unfair in life (like playing happy families with new partner, new baby and new partner's children whilst ignoring their own children) then they're being a shitty parent. The holidays are irrelevant.

Exactly. I think sometimes the "everything must be identical/ equal all of the time" brigade make things 10x worse.

If you're kicking off with your child's other parent because he took his "new" children to the aquarium when yours were with you for the weekend for example, you're going to make it seem to your child like it's a problem when really it isn't.

LolaSmiles · 10/10/2023 13:39

This is the problem though with trying to jam a blended family into the mould of a nuclear one.
This is the crux of the issue.

A blended family isn't going to be the same as a nuclear one. They're just not the same and the adults all have different circumstances.

Each child has two parents and if they split up then the family circumstances will change. The parents have a responsibility to be fair and equitable towards their children, that doesn't mean all children across two blended families need to be treated identically.

If one of the parents is being obviously unfair in life (like playing happy families with new partner, new baby and new partner's children whilst ignoring their own children) then they're being a shitty parent. The holidays are irrelevant.

yogasaurus · 10/10/2023 13:37

It’s naive in the extreme to think that two siblings with different mothers or fathers will live equal and identical lives at all times.

That’s just not how it works. There will be things you do with your DC only, but for some reason it’s an issue when the DF
does the same.

They don’t live in suspended animation when the DC is with the other parent.

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 10/10/2023 13:34

I do sympathise with the children who have two separated parents and two households (or more?!)

All the adults should try to be kind and considerate of them.

But their experiences cannot be identical with all the step/half siblings in different households.

You also wouldn’t expect your step parent to pay for your holiday / school fees / inheritance / maintenance. Only your bio parents have this obligation.

aSofaNearYou · 10/10/2023 13:26

It just seems some posters think that the new woman is entitled to have the same experience as a couple who have had one baby together and don’t have previous children. She isn’t, she’s chosen to be somebody who has a child already and like I said their baby has had an older sibling from the beginning, her partner has two kids he needs to treat equally, there are implications for finances etc because he now has two children he is responsible for.

My DP cannot treat his DP equally, because he lives with 2 and not the other. There will be many differences that there would not be if he lived with them all. It's up to the individual to decide which differences they are comfortable with, and which they aren't. For some, that will include going on holidays during the time they are not with them, in the same way they do many other things in the time they aren't with them, and for others it won't. There is no one size fits all or existing set of rules.

My life would be very different if my DP didn't have a child, in many ways. That does not mean it is written in law that we can never go away anywhere without him.

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 10/10/2023 13:26

@clappyjay
DH/we would take both children to the same places if both children lived with us full time.

As DSD does not, that is not possible.

I care for DSD and treat her well when she is under my care, but no, I do not need to account for her as my own child in every respect.

@crumblingschools
Agree, the father should make an effort with all his children.

Plaplablah · 10/10/2023 13:24

clappyjay · 10/10/2023 13:17

It just seems some posters think that the new woman is entitled to have the same experience as a couple who have had one baby together and don’t have previous children. She isn’t, she’s chosen to be somebody who has a child already and like I said their baby has had an older sibling from the beginning, her partner has two kids he needs to treat equally, there are implications for finances etc because he now has two children he is responsible for.

I don't disagree. I just think our idea of the consequences of that decision may be a little different.

I chose to be with a man with older children. I don't think that means I can never take my/our child away without DSC. I do think it means my husband may choose not to join us though and I accept that.

I don't think it's at all the same as saying would I leave one of my bio kids behind because they were in school and the other wasn't as a PP presented to me. Of course its not the same because I don't have two bio DCs. My husband does, so he's the one who can either come or not come, his choice. But I'm not going to base every decision I make personally on what I'd do if I had two kids when I don't. The consequence of being with a man with other DC is that I accept he may need to make decisions that have an affect on me (I.e. not coming away with DSC), but I'm not going to let that stop me from doing it every time either.

I also don't think it means I should consider myself jointly financially responsible for husbands older DC. I do think it means I need to accept my husband may not have as much disposable income as I do because he has more children.

And so on..

crumblingschools · 10/10/2023 13:21

For the posters who say they have different configurations of who goes on holiday depending on the type of holiday, have they missed the fact that this dad seems to do nothing with his first DC, but seems an active dad with his second child. This holiday probably just highlights the difference in treatment, and is shit

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 10/10/2023 13:19

Hi @clappyjay

Yes, same dad.
DSD lives with her mother primarily. We have her for most of school holidays and do fun outings with her when we have her.

DH does not take DSD on separate holidays 1:1.

We have been overseas a couple of times with only our DC (young) and not taken DSD as she was at school.
No issues.
However we do not mention our trips away in front of her as we would never want to make her feel left out (even though we do trips without her).

If we go somewhere like Disneyland then we would take both the children.

clappyjay · 10/10/2023 13:17

Plaplablah · 10/10/2023 13:08

This is the problem though with trying to jam a blended family into the mould of a nuclear one. My husband has more children than I do so no I don't plan out my finances based on the amount of children he has.

Sure there are some considerations to be made, can my husband afford his half of the childcare bill etc.. but I don't think I have to consider his older DC every time I make a financial decision though when I'm talking about my own money.

We have separate finances though so probably a lot easier to do that. I know that's like a deadly sin on here though but frankly I will never completely combine finances with anyone. Works fine for us.

It just seems some posters think that the new woman is entitled to have the same experience as a couple who have had one baby together and don’t have previous children. She isn’t, she’s chosen to be somebody who has a child already and like I said their baby has had an older sibling from the beginning, her partner has two kids he needs to treat equally, there are implications for finances etc because he now has two children he is responsible for.

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 10/10/2023 13:13

@Plaplablah
agree with you!

clappyjay · 10/10/2023 13:12

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 10/10/2023 13:06

Hi @clappyjay

Its different when it’s 2 children with the same parents, or when the children have different mothers (and different primary residences).

So I would take our DC away during term time, and not expect to account for older DSC. Older DSC have their own mother, social activities, friends.

However in the future, I would obviously only take all children away in term time, if my own DC were school aged. As, my own DC do not have another mother they usually live with.

im assuming that they all share the same dad.. does he do anything with his other kids to ‘make up for’ a holiday they haven’t been included in. The issue with the OP is a dad with two children being treated differently.

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 10/10/2023 13:11

There is no such thing as being treated exactly equally. Not between siblings in a nuclear family, and especially not when there are different mums/dads involved.

Someone will have a more/less expensive hobby/present.
Parents will have more/less time/money at different points in time.

Plaplablah · 10/10/2023 13:08

clappyjay · 10/10/2023 12:44

it simply isn’t possible for one child to be included in everything two families do. For a start finances often don’t stretch to it

But aren’t finances a consideration when you plan for subsequent children? When I planned for a second child it was taken into account we would now have 2 children and all the expenses that entails.

OPs ex and his new partner would have needed to consider that their baby already had a built-in sibling from the off, so future plans holidays trips houses etc etc would all need to be considered with a family of 4 in mind. Just as any other family planning another child would have to.

This is the problem though with trying to jam a blended family into the mould of a nuclear one. My husband has more children than I do so no I don't plan out my finances based on the amount of children he has.

Sure there are some considerations to be made, can my husband afford his half of the childcare bill etc.. but I don't think I have to consider his older DC every time I make a financial decision though when I'm talking about my own money.

We have separate finances though so probably a lot easier to do that. I know that's like a deadly sin on here though but frankly I will never completely combine finances with anyone. Works fine for us.

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 10/10/2023 13:06

Hi @clappyjay

Its different when it’s 2 children with the same parents, or when the children have different mothers (and different primary residences).

So I would take our DC away during term time, and not expect to account for older DSC. Older DSC have their own mother, social activities, friends.

However in the future, I would obviously only take all children away in term time, if my own DC were school aged. As, my own DC do not have another mother they usually live with.

Onceuponaheartache · 10/10/2023 13:04

I have 2 step kids from a previous relationship and my Fiancé has a son.

Ex and I had 1 main family holiday a year with all 3 kids (his 2 our 1). We would have occasional weekends away with just dd. When there is a large age gap it isn't possible to include all kids in all things.

My step kids had several expensive holidays with their mum a year that dd will never have as I cannot afford it.

You seem to have a very peculiar outlook on this and seemintent that your ds is being intentionally isolated but at 7 he isn't old enough for 90% of the rides at alton towers which leads me to think you are massively projecting.

I suggest you find a way to deal with your issues rather than making them your sons in the future.

90sfilm · 10/10/2023 13:03

@clappyjay True. Children being treated equally should be the overriding concern. If you can't handle that as a steparent then you should get with someone without children. To take one child on holiday but not the half sibling from a previous relationship sends a damaging message of being less worthy, less worth the cost. It is just as bizarre as a family where the mum and dad are together who only take one sibling and leave the other with grandparents as they can only afford to take one. Treating a child differently is emotional abuse whether they share a mum or not. The impact is the same on the child: very damaging.