Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can someone explain how a parent could not invite their child on holiday?

567 replies

Tunisbaby · 09/10/2023 22:16

I just don't get it. How could any parent invite one of their biological children, not the other? How does that thought process go? 'What about... DS1... nah'
I could never ever imagine forgetting to invite my child or thinking about booking one child place and not even giving a second thought to enquiring with the other parent.
I get kid free holidays completely. But choosing to only be a parent to one child for the week when you have a seven year old at home is just bizarre.
Can any parents explain why this is ever thought to be ok?

OP posts:
JustAMinutePleass · 10/10/2023 16:52

Mylovelygreendress · 10/10/2023 10:57

My exh’s next wife had a DD and they went on to have 2 more DC . They all went to Disney Florida and didn’t include our DC . I offered to contribute to the cost but was told it was a “ family “ holiday .
He did send a postcard ( it was a long time ago!) and showed our DC their holiday photos .
One of the many reasons I hate the bastard .
Our DC are adults and have virtually no contact with him .

What scum. People like that shouldn’t be able to have children. It makes me so angry. I’m glad your dc have nothing to do with them.

Beezknees · 10/10/2023 16:49

Thisismynewusername1 · 10/10/2023 16:46

I can afford to take both my kids on holiday. It doesn’t stretch to two more children.

his ex takes them on holiday with her new husband.

all the children get a holiday.

So why does “equal” seem to mean two children getting two holidays and two getting one? Or even two getting a holiday and two getting none, because taking four away is too expensive?

And does your husband pay for half of their holidays?

You might have two kids. Your husband has 4.

Thisismynewusername1 · 10/10/2023 16:46

Beezknees · 10/10/2023 16:24

If I couldn't afford to take both my children on holiday I wouldn't go. Don't have more kids if you can't afford it.

I can afford to take both my kids on holiday. It doesn’t stretch to two more children.

his ex takes them on holiday with her new husband.

all the children get a holiday.

So why does “equal” seem to mean two children getting two holidays and two getting one? Or even two getting a holiday and two getting none, because taking four away is too expensive?

Flyingcarpetintraining · 10/10/2023 16:43

Plaplablah · 10/10/2023 14:00

Christmas and the amount of money spent is also a silly idea. I wouldn't even expect equal amounts in a nuclear family when you have children of differing ages.

My DSC got a phone last year that cost upwards of £600. Should I have spent £600 on our 3 year old? Or should we have said no you can't have a phone DSC because we only spent £80 on your sibling so that's all you're getting too.

Older children tend to be more expensive that small ones. I imagine that's the same scenario for tonnes of families up and down the country with an age gap.

Then you have the situations in a blended family like, for example, my parents who may get our child a more expensive gift than DSC. I don't think there's anything wrong with that, DSC have grandparents themselves who spoil them just as much as my parents do our child.

Again, it's not all going to be equal.

But your grandparents aren’t directly related to your DSC and didn’t make a choice to be involved in their life (like you have done, by being in a relationship with their father). Your grandparents treating your DSC differently to your DC is therefore completely different to if their Dad were treating them differently to your shared children.

LolaSmiles · 10/10/2023 16:40

My thoughts exactly! The amount of people defending this is both shocking & depressing.
It is not ok to write-off you kids from first family cos you have a new one
Can cause major self esteem issues in the child

Of course writing off kids from a first family is wrong. Has anyone said otherwise?If someone is writing off their children then it isn't a holiday problem. It's a shit parenting one.

If someone is a shit parent and doesn't bother with their children from a previous relationship then ticking the box of "took them to center parcs once a year to make sure that we pretend we're treating the children the same" isn't going to fix it. How many kids say 'dad was a crap parent, dropped us the second he got a new missus, focused on playing Disney dad to her kids and their new baby, but it's alright because when they went to Spain for a week we also got to go so he's actually a decent dad, no harm done"?

In healthy co-parenting relationships and blended families the adults should be able to have discussions that doesn't resort to "treat every child identically or else you're writing them off".

PuddlesPityParty · 10/10/2023 16:39

Why haven’t you said how old your DC is?

Beezknees · 10/10/2023 16:24

1sttimemum1602 · 10/10/2023 15:44

As someone who has a partner with two children from a previous relationship, this clearly needs more information. Did you offer to contribute to the cost of your shared child going on said holiday? Why should one parent have to pay for the full holiday for your child, should offer to pay 50/50 of the e cost for child of you really wanted him to go.

Your child will do things with you that his sibling will not do, so why should his half sibling have to share every moment with their parents? It’s important to recognise that child too, and not just your own in the situation.

Also, I presume the other child is a fair bit younger so they may not even need to pay for that child to go to centre parcel and it won’t be so expensive to keep a young child entertained there without adding costs for extra activities. A 7 year old would be much more expensive to take than under 3, so if their child is under 3 consider that.

If I couldn't afford to take both my children on holiday I wouldn't go. Don't have more kids if you can't afford it.

PhantomUnicorn · 10/10/2023 16:21

Flyingcarpetintraining · 10/10/2023 16:01

I think if you asked children with separated parents whether they’d rather have extra holidays and two Christmases or have their parents together the vast majority would choose the latter. I think two Christmases is a pretty poor consolation prize (and I say this as a divorced parent), particularly with the attitude of some step parents and non-resident parents on here and in real life- who treat DSC as second class citizens and less important than their ‘new family’

Well.. not always. As i said, my kids don't want to spend time with their dad outside of their 2 days a month and every other xmas.

my step daughter doesn't speak to him now she's an adult either, but she does still see me and my kids.

Don't make assumptions about other peoples situations.

Beezknees · 10/10/2023 16:18

YANBU OP. So many men do this. If they can't afford to take both kids, maybe they shouldn't have had more kids then. And if their wife doesn't like it, shouldn't have married someone who already has kids.

AlliWantIsARoomSomewheeeere · 10/10/2023 16:13

Imjusttootired · 09/10/2023 23:19

This thread is 😞
why People think this is acceptable is beyond me and why people get in to different relationships and have children with someone who wouldn’t include their previous DC is ridiculous and the many people who defend the behaviour is just as bad !

My thoughts exactly! The amount of people defending this is both shocking & depressing.
It is not ok to write-off you kids from first family cos you have a new one
Can cause major self esteem issues in the child

And you are considering being a step parent thinking its ok. Please go find someone else with no kids.

BetterWithPockets · 10/10/2023 16:09

@LolaSmiles puts it perfectly: Fair doesn't always mean equal, and dare I say it if someone is a shit parent following a split then the holidays aren't the big issue. Their shit parenting is.

ToadOnTheHill · 10/10/2023 16:05

It really depends doesnt it.

I wouldnt want my child going on a week long holiday with a new step sibling if they hadnt spent much time together. And by time, I mean full weekends and sleepovers.

As kids, me and my sibling were separated and we had a mix of holidays, sometimes we both went with dad, sometimes we both went with mum, sometimes we just went with the resident parent.

You need to make sure you dont make this into a problem for your child if it hasnt registered.

BetterWithPockets · 10/10/2023 16:05

I don’t think it’s quite so clear cut, OP. My DH & his ex have an agreement, for example, that he takes his DSs (my DSSs) on a winter holiday; their mum takes them on a summer holiday. So DH, our DD & I have a summer holiday that doesn’t include my DSSs. Likewise, my DD doesn’t normally go on the winter holiday with my DH and my DSSs — so DH & DSSs have quality time together then. (I take my DD away then, just the two of us, so WE have quality time together too.) If we go away at other times, we’d normally go away all of us together but it’s not black & white. My DH has sometimes taken all the kids away and I’ve not gone if I’ve been working.

Biscuitmonster2318 · 10/10/2023 16:02

Heronwatcher · 10/10/2023 11:15

OK so OP you’re obviously not taking the views of people who disagree with you on board. So looking at it pragmatically your view must be that your ex DH is an utter callous bastard who hates his own kids or, at best, can’t be arsed with them. So what now? Unless you think it’s genuinely better for your DS to stop contact with your ex completely are you still not better trying to help your DS negotiate this by at least trying to see it from another perspective, like one of the ones mentioned on this thread, rather than wallowing in the injustice of it all? Or even better speaking to your ex and finding out his own perspective and trying to get him to understand how all of his behaviour might hurt your DS?

You have ‘misunderstood’ OP it’s the Stepmother who is a callous person
As it seems to me that the OP are ‘hinting’ at a terrible stepmom.

As usual the man is a weak willow, wisp of a man.
Evil stepmom in the background. 😂

Flyingcarpetintraining · 10/10/2023 16:01

PhantomUnicorn · 10/10/2023 09:44

Has never been an issue here, my kids never wanted to go on holiday with their dad since we separated and have made that quite clear, it's their idea of hell.

When we were still married, his older daughter used to come on some holidays with us, and not others.

She went on holiday with her mum and step dad too... so got twice as many holidays as any of her half siblings from either parent.

She also got twice as many christmases, birthdays, presents.. so in all, yes it wasn't nice shuttling between two families, but there was also some reward in it.

I think if you asked children with separated parents whether they’d rather have extra holidays and two Christmases or have their parents together the vast majority would choose the latter. I think two Christmases is a pretty poor consolation prize (and I say this as a divorced parent), particularly with the attitude of some step parents and non-resident parents on here and in real life- who treat DSC as second class citizens and less important than their ‘new family’

LolaSmiles · 10/10/2023 15:51

Exactly. I think sometimes the "everything must be identical/ equal all of the time" brigade make things 10x worse.

If you're kicking off with your child's other parent because he took his "new" children to the aquarium when yours were with you for the weekend for example, you're going to make it seem to your child like it's a problem when really it isn't
I agree with you.

Picture the situation

Two parents have a child called Sophie.

They split up.

Mum and step dad have a new child called Mark.

Dad and step mum have a new child called Freya.

Sophie has to be included in every trip or holiday that Mark and Freya get, even though step mum and step dad might have different situations.

Step mum and step dad might have children from previous relationships, so now not only does Sophie have to be treated identically to Mark and Freya, but her experiences are also dictated by what step mum & step dad's ex partners do with their children as well, because Mum and Dad aren't allowed to do anything with Sophie's half siblings unless the step siblings from their previous relationships are also invited.

Fair doesn't always mean equal, and dare I say it if someone is a shit parent following a split then the holidays aren't the big issue. Their shit parenting is.

1sttimemum1602 · 10/10/2023 15:44

As someone who has a partner with two children from a previous relationship, this clearly needs more information. Did you offer to contribute to the cost of your shared child going on said holiday? Why should one parent have to pay for the full holiday for your child, should offer to pay 50/50 of the e cost for child of you really wanted him to go.

Your child will do things with you that his sibling will not do, so why should his half sibling have to share every moment with their parents? It’s important to recognise that child too, and not just your own in the situation.

Also, I presume the other child is a fair bit younger so they may not even need to pay for that child to go to centre parcel and it won’t be so expensive to keep a young child entertained there without adding costs for extra activities. A 7 year old would be much more expensive to take than under 3, so if their child is under 3 consider that.

Biscuitmonster2318 · 10/10/2023 15:43

It is because on those times my remaining children would go to their dads.

I have been in this situation also. From that of a parent whose children’s father would go away with his new wife and her children and not with ours at the same time.
why shouldn’t a stepmother have the same opportunity to go away on holiday with her husband and children. They would see their dad 3 out of 4 weekends, we also split the holiday’s. I hated it and missed them but court ordered.

wh she met him the arrangement had been in place for years. Why should another mother be expected to meet her husband and because of our children- she no longer has the same freedom as before.

Yhr stepmom is a just that a stepmom to your children and a mother to her own. She is entitled to have her own chance at creating a little family unit too.

i loved when he went away as I was able to plan/surprised with extra time to be with my children.
I absolutely respected her for the time she was expected to just quietly change her life. She had her own child, was a nurse and worked 4 nights a week to see her child. It’s ridiculous and utterly selfish of me to then expect her to have no time to relax
yet I did and her dad did. Ive also been the stepmother as well.
I think the ‘scorned past’ springs to mind through this thread. As though the OP just wants to make it seem as though her poor child has just been abandoned.
the post was misleading to start- the child lives with her and goes on a weekend. So change them around as I assume if she was going away she would not accommodate the other parent. She gets an extra weekend period with her child. The child wouldn’t have probably have noticed unless Dramatic Overtones have been playing out around the child.
The OH post, reads just as she probably tells people, As though a mix and match new family of mum, dad and stepkids etc who live together 24/7 as a nuclear family have said to her child. You aren’t coming.
Ridiculous.

This post just seems to a way to vilify a step mum who wants her holiday too.

Always putting on the step mum.
at the end of the day it’s the ex husband only who has an obligation to do a damn think. Just as the mother.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 10/10/2023 15:04

This is why really blended families do not work unless its a scenario where all children live in the same home I.e. one parent isn't involved anymore. There will always be inequalities and frictions imo.

This ^

I think too many men seem happy to leave their first family behind and move onto a new one without giving a shit. And too many women are keen to get involved with them and have children with them without giving any thought to how it will pan out. And quite often neither party seems to give a shit about how those first children will feel.

PhantomUnicorn · 10/10/2023 14:56

if you aren't the resident parent, you have every right to expect a nuclear family experience with you, your partner and your children.

Your lives can't revolve around a child who does not live with you, and it isn't fair on your child to not do anything with them unless the stepchild is invited.

Yes, you marry someone with kids, there is the expectation that when visitation is happening that the child be included in your plans, but that is as far as it should go.

If my ex decided to move in with his current GF and her kids, i'd be pretty pissed off if my weekends were being constantly disrupted by him taking them out every time his GF wanted to take her kids somewhere.

CherryMaDeara · 10/10/2023 14:51

icallitasplodge · 10/10/2023 14:50

Take on the man, take on the children. Anything else is a disservice.

Very telling that you don't say 'take on the man OR woman'.

The man needs to take on his own his own children, not palm them off to new wife.

icallitasplodge · 10/10/2023 14:50

Take on the man, take on the children. Anything else is a disservice.

90sfilm · 10/10/2023 14:41

@Plaplablah I think it's obviously understandable if a toddler year gets less money spent on them then a 16 year old but i'm referring to situations where there is only a few years difference between a sibling but the child from the previous relationship gets treated like an afterthought. Some real examples, child from new relationship gets multiple presents for Christmas and an expensive new camera. Child from previous relationship gets some guitar strings. Child from new relationship gets given money to go travelling, 'afterthought' child gets nothing. 'New' child gets lots of help to buy first car. 'afterthought' child doesn't even get a lift to view the car. The list goes on and on. Nothing like a parent desperately trying to spend 600 pounds on their toddler to match the older siblong's phone or whatever. Got nothing to do with the unfairness the OP is raising and others here.

YireosDodeAver · 10/10/2023 14:05

Each child should have the same amount spent on them by their father. However, if the holiday is being paid for by the new partner or if the new baby is young enough for a "babies go free" deal but the older child isn't then the amount being spent by the father on the younger child is zero.

Heronwatcher · 10/10/2023 14:02

@yogasaurus yes it’s like the new family should be punished because the ex is being a bit nicer to them than he was to the ex wife and kids- which I don’t think is fair at all.

I think everyone basically agrees that there should be an effort to achieve fairness to all the kids, but I think where people disagree is whether that means that the children from the first partner have to be involved in every activity in all cases. Personally I think it’s not, and there are other ways to achieve being fair (just as there are in non blended families) and it’s down to all of the adults to achieve that, the best way they can, with the resources they’ve got. It sounds like the dad might not be doing that here very well, but that’s an issue for him not his new partner.

Swipe left for the next trending thread