Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How am I supposed to teach these covid zombies?

304 replies

tapdancingaardvark · 09/10/2023 21:46

Please don't send your children to school with covid. Three times today I've had to speak to normally intelligent, engaged children to find out why they are sitting there apparently stunned into stupor, unable to follow a lesson or even keep their eyes open. Each has told me they have been off with covid but have "recovered" now.

No they have not recovered.

It isn't a badge of honour to send your child in after the mandatory 3 days and say everything is normal if it isn't. These kids need a proper recovery time, relaxing at home until really better, not staggering around in school wasting everyone's time and infecting other people. They can't learn in this state. They won't get better as fast either.

Last week was bad enough, this week I've sent 3 children back home already, and it is only Monday

YABU - its only covid, its only a cold, they can sit there and suffer and get some work done
YANBU - unwell children need to be looked after at home

OP posts:
HelpMeUnpickThis · 10/10/2023 11:40

HappierTimesAhead · 09/10/2023 22:08

Why would we ignore letters from the school? How do we know which to ignore and which to take seriously?! YABU and ridiculous for seeming to expect we all know what you happen to know.

@tapdancingaardvark you are being ridiculous.

@HappierTimesAhead thank you for speaking sense.

IncomingTraffic · 10/10/2023 11:39

Grimchmas · 10/10/2023 11:22

Totally agree with everyone who is saying this.

We all know school isn't supposed to be childcare.

We also all know that we live in a society where the reality is that there's no alternative for a lot of families.

I’m not convinced that the statement ‘school isn’t supposed to be childcare’ is true or that it has ever been true.

One of the drivers for the institution of the school existing at all as a means of providing education is that is serves the purpose of freeing parents up from childcare duties to some degree so that they are more able to undertake paid work.

It has never been able to fulfil this part of the function because of a range of other fudges that limit the length of the school day and produced the expectation of a long period of non-school in the summer (which has its roots in freeing up child labourers for agriculture).

i suspect the phrase ‘school is education not childcare’ emerged as a means of putting and keeping parents in their place. But it’s both disingenuous in both practical terms and in relation to the intentions behind schools.

Almostwelsh · 10/10/2023 11:34

School absolutely is childcare according to the DWP when telling single parents to get back into work.

WeWereInParis · 10/10/2023 11:23

My DD's school says to send them in with cold symptoms, and also "insists" on a Dr's note if they're off for more than 3 days.

I will happily ignore both of these rules if I feel DD is too ill to attend but not ill enough to take up a Dr's appointment (for example the only time she was ever off nursery for more than 3 days was chickenpox which did not need a dr, and had she been at school rather than nursery, I'd have ignored that rule). But there is a lot of pressure.

Grimchmas · 10/10/2023 11:22

TrashedSofa · 10/10/2023 10:49

There is more truth to this than many people are willing to admit. We have a system where school functions as necessary childcare. Lockdown and to a much lesser extent the short notice bank holiday for the queen's funeral last year both spelled that out very clearly.

Which isn't to say this is a good thing, but telling people they should access emergency babysitting services that definitely exist, are affordable and can meet all demand is just stupid.

Totally agree with everyone who is saying this.

We all know school isn't supposed to be childcare.

We also all know that we live in a society where the reality is that there's no alternative for a lot of families.

EvilElsa · 10/10/2023 11:16

Laiste · 10/10/2023 11:02

How are you supposed to prove they've thrown up? A photo?

The policy has been changed from 24 to 48 hours off school from the last up chuck. Fair enough.

So my DD throws up at school at wed lunch time and the school sends her home. She's fine by Thursday morning, but not allowed back till Monday. This happened twice last year. That's me following THEIR policy.

I then get 2 stinking emails off the school about attendance. One last July at the end of year, and another as they started this September warning me about her terrible attendance last year 😳

Now we have had a letter wanting them all off to Dorset for a week this time next year during term time. The strong implication is that if we don't send them and cough up the 500 quid then the child is going to be damaged by missing this wonderful time away from school 😳

Fucking no. Sorry. We can't afford it anyway.

I had this a couple of years ago with DS. School sent him home mid afternoon as he was sick. Following THEIR written policy I kept him off the next day and the day after (he was still being sick the next morning and I informed them of this before 8.40am). I got a really shitty, patronising email about absence with lots of scaremongering bullshit about failing exams and all sorts. I'll try and find it to post here. When I pointed out that I'd followed their policy and reported the absence correctly each day I had no reply and no apology. This is for a kid with at least 98% attendance, usually 100% each term. We get weekly pie charts and lecture emails with lots of "scare facts" (which I'm sure are just made up piffle) about what happens if kids miss a few days or go on a term time holiday. You'd think from some of it that a week off means that basically you've ruined your education forever and there's no point carrying on. Then people wonder why kids are sent in sick.

Grimchmas · 10/10/2023 11:11

picturethispatsy · 10/10/2023 06:15

Controlling much?!
What a shit way to deal with young people 😞

And horribly, horribly ableist.

I'd want to get together with other parents and throw a gigantic end of term party for EVERYBODY on the same night as the prom and encourage all the kids to come to that.

MrsSkylerWhite · 10/10/2023 11:09

Understand

MrsSkylerWhite · 10/10/2023 11:09

I can completely u destined why they are going in. They’ve missed far, far too much in recent years.

IncomingTraffic · 10/10/2023 11:07

If having children who are not fighting fit in school is causing problems for teachers and impacting on teaching… maybe the answer is for schools to find better ways of managing children who are unwell but not unwell enough to be off school.

Maybe the DfE could look into how it is going to support this.

Blaming parents for any of it is not the answer.

IsleofDen · 10/10/2023 11:05

I think YABU to aim this at parents.

My daughter’s school insists on a drs note for sickness of more than 3 days or it goes down as unauthorised absence and you have to fight with them (and eventually the LEA) over it.

Frankly, if schools insist on having policies to the detriment of children, this sort of thing will happen. Don’t lecture parents, speak to your SLT and get them to write sensible policies that put children, not attendance, at the heart.

Saharafordessert · 10/10/2023 11:03

Crikey, parents really can’t win can they!
Are we supposed to cherry pick the information from school whether or not to ignore it or act upon it?
School is indeed childcare as well as for the obvious educational purposes. Parents know their kids are in school and muddle through if they are off sick.

Laiste · 10/10/2023 11:02

How are you supposed to prove they've thrown up? A photo?

The policy has been changed from 24 to 48 hours off school from the last up chuck. Fair enough.

So my DD throws up at school at wed lunch time and the school sends her home. She's fine by Thursday morning, but not allowed back till Monday. This happened twice last year. That's me following THEIR policy.

I then get 2 stinking emails off the school about attendance. One last July at the end of year, and another as they started this September warning me about her terrible attendance last year 😳

Now we have had a letter wanting them all off to Dorset for a week this time next year during term time. The strong implication is that if we don't send them and cough up the 500 quid then the child is going to be damaged by missing this wonderful time away from school 😳

Fucking no. Sorry. We can't afford it anyway.

Handsnotwands · 10/10/2023 11:00

we had a talk last night, ostensibly about work experience, but the first half was about the importance of attendance, with crude and inaccurate pie charts an everything

i mean if kids are still missing too much school because they're terrible vectors of disease, why not take some simple and achievable steps, like putting some basic outline of the missed lesson on teams for them to look through from their sick beds?

IncomingTraffic · 10/10/2023 10:54

It’s an inevitable consequence of over a century of education policy centred around attending school.

Of course parents will organise their lives and any other childcare around their child’s school attendance. Of course childcare providers will organise their provision around the fact that children attend school. Of course employers will operate in ways that respond to the fact that parents of children of school age are more available during the hours the children are in school.

The statement ‘school is education not childcare’ is simply not true.

Givemepeas · 10/10/2023 10:51

We are told NOT to keep or kids off school. Any time off for medical appts or a dental appt has to be backed up by written evidence or a copy of the appt text notification.
We’re told that even missing a day or two learning could be catastrophic and kids might never catch up and teachers don’t have time to catch up.
We’re told that absences disrupt everyone.
We aren’t given permission for any time off at all for any reason.
Our kids attendance is measured and highlighted on everything, every report, in the SIM that the school uses.

We’re threatened with fines under ASBO rules for letting or kids miss school.

on top of that we’re told COvID is now like any other virus, and to be treated like colds- so get on with it…

if we kept kids off for every sniffle the schools would be empty… and as we aren’t testing for Covid anyway, is it not just a cold??

Sorry, but you’ll just have to cope with children having seasonal viruses.

TrashedSofa · 10/10/2023 10:49

IncomingTraffic · 10/10/2023 10:42

I am really loving the utterly bonkers idea that there is some form of emergency childcare parents can call upon to ensure their continued employment when their children are ill.

Do the people who suggest this stuff actually live in the real world?

For all practical purposes, school IS a babysitting service for parents that also provides education. Accepting that is the case is important to running schools effectively. It’s disingenuous and hugely elitist to pretend otherwise.

There is more truth to this than many people are willing to admit. We have a system where school functions as necessary childcare. Lockdown and to a much lesser extent the short notice bank holiday for the queen's funeral last year both spelled that out very clearly.

Which isn't to say this is a good thing, but telling people they should access emergency babysitting services that definitely exist, are affordable and can meet all demand is just stupid.

Yerroblemom1923 · 10/10/2023 10:46

My dd's school won't send them home! Even when genuinely ill! Which then makes parents think twice about sending them in in the first place.

dogsinthesky · 10/10/2023 10:43

This thread has been super helpful. Just got the dreaded threatening letter. Unfortunately DD has been off for recovering from a serious medical procedure and also a nasty illness (that the teachers saw when they sent her home again on two occasions poorly) all evidenced and noted to the reception. Getting the "letter" felt like a slap in the face particuarly as we had no choice about the absences. I sent a strongly worded email to the head teacher as I felt it was super out of order.

IncomingTraffic · 10/10/2023 10:42

I am really loving the utterly bonkers idea that there is some form of emergency childcare parents can call upon to ensure their continued employment when their children are ill.

Do the people who suggest this stuff actually live in the real world?

For all practical purposes, school IS a babysitting service for parents that also provides education. Accepting that is the case is important to running schools effectively. It’s disingenuous and hugely elitist to pretend otherwise.

IncomingTraffic · 10/10/2023 10:37

anyolddinosaur · 10/10/2023 08:55

Covid damages the brain. https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/long-covid-even-mild-covid-linked-damage-brain-months-infection-rcna18959 and the more reinfections you have the more chance other organs will be damaged. Anyone pretending this is "just a cold" has probably suffered that brain damage already.

Unwell children should be home and not making other children sick.

I'm well aware this is a message most people dont wish to hear - but you should try to reduce your risk of infection/ reinfection when you can reasonably do so.

Covid scaremongering is NOT helpful here.

People need to be able to get on with their lives.

x2boys · 10/10/2023 10:35

Passepartoute · 10/10/2023 09:17

You do know that different people react to the infection in different ways, don't you? Surely you can't have grown up without realising that there are different levels of seriousness of any type of infection?

And do you realise that schools expect children in Covid or no covid?
As long as they are well.enough
Also many work places expect their employees in ,they don't care whether they have Covid or not
Bsck.in thecreal.World people have food to.buy and bills to pay its extremely selfish to.expect them to stay at home .

NDfamily · 10/10/2023 10:31

The problem with schools is that they don't just direct their resources to the 30% of children most in need (which would be appropriate), they direct their entire service or purpose to those 30% and make it compulsory for everyone.

For a small minority of families being absent from school is a risk for any number of reasons: they don't have enough food to eat, lack of rich home learning environment so they are missing lots of the only education they get, children covering that they're actually caring for their parent 50 hours a week, genuine safeguarding issues etc. It's exactly the same with the other draconian policies. Homework and reading diaries for 7 year olds? Hits the group who never get read to at home. Lunchbox policies? Monitors the content of food provided for the group who only ever get fed junk food.

The problem is, we really need a discussion about the ethics of applying strict, uniform, non flexible and compulsory policies to all families regardless of the need. In my opinion it's become so controlling and schools have vastly overstepped the remit of providing a safe, solid education. Also, by trying to do everything for everyone they have stretched themselves so thin that everybody receives a barely adequate service.

Softnatural · 10/10/2023 10:30

Surely pretty much everything schools do is "just" because Ofsted requires it. Do we ignore it all?

Shadyboots23 · 10/10/2023 10:30

PinkRoses1245 · 10/10/2023 09:24

YABU. You know most parents have to work? Kids need to learn resilience and everyone need to stop testing for Covid. It’s irrelevant

No, not everyone needs to stop
It's not irrelevant for me when I need anti virals if I get covid
I don't want people with covid visiting me
I don't want to go to my appointment in a place full of people with cancer if I've got covid
I also need to increase a certain medication if I have covid and take advice from my consultant