Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How am I supposed to teach these covid zombies?

304 replies

tapdancingaardvark · 09/10/2023 21:46

Please don't send your children to school with covid. Three times today I've had to speak to normally intelligent, engaged children to find out why they are sitting there apparently stunned into stupor, unable to follow a lesson or even keep their eyes open. Each has told me they have been off with covid but have "recovered" now.

No they have not recovered.

It isn't a badge of honour to send your child in after the mandatory 3 days and say everything is normal if it isn't. These kids need a proper recovery time, relaxing at home until really better, not staggering around in school wasting everyone's time and infecting other people. They can't learn in this state. They won't get better as fast either.

Last week was bad enough, this week I've sent 3 children back home already, and it is only Monday

YABU - its only covid, its only a cold, they can sit there and suffer and get some work done
YANBU - unwell children need to be looked after at home

OP posts:
tapdancingaardvark · 10/10/2023 21:36

EvilElsa · 10/10/2023 08:31

My sons secondary push the attendance message so hard -weekly emails, threats about missing proms/trips/court. When DS (who has 100% attendance) had covid I called to clarify as their policy was clear as mud -was told to send him in and that the three days on their own website didn't apply. If your child is off you have to provide a detailed explanation of why with symptoms and expected return date with a fit note after three days. I can see exactly how parents would send their "covid zombie" kids in.
To be honest I can't wait for DS to finish school now (he is in year 11).

no you don't "HAVE TO". Just ignore!

OP posts:
tapdancingaardvark · 10/10/2023 21:32

Lastchancechica · 10/10/2023 08:13

But what is the point???????
You can catch it literally ANYWHERE!
So providing testing is a total waste of money and plastic, as you won’t stop it spreading or even slow it down 🙄🙄

I thought people would have understood this by now!!!

Edited

The point is a lot of people have to test and know if they have it, they might need immediate treatment, they might need to postpone hospital treatment, they might be in contact with vulnerable people, a lot of people still have to test, I had it last month and had to go onto immediate anti virals, within a couple of hours of starting to feel ill. Lots of people are in my situation, so still have to test

OP posts:
neverbeenskiing · 10/10/2023 21:18

gemma19846 · 10/10/2023 20:27

Ahhh teachers acting like they are the parents of their students...again!! Not your kids! Do your job and teach. MAYBE their parents have to work or dont want school moaning about their attendance!

In the last 2 weeks alone I have fed several children whose parents failed to give them breakfast before school, taken a child to a CAMHS appointment because their Mum was too hungover, found an NHS dentist for 3 children from the same family, arranged repairs to a child's bike so they can get to school, bought school shoes for a child, washed a child's clothes, booked an eye test for a child, and looked after several upset children who were sent into school very obviously unwell until their parents were able to collect them (one took 3 hours!). My colleagues who teach Reception are increasingly having to toilet train children, teach them how to dress themselves and how to use cutlery (and I'm not talking about children with SEND) so believe me, we would dearly love to do our jobs and leave parenting the parents. Unfortunately, some parents can't be trusted to parent.

Tinybrother · 10/10/2023 21:02

neverbeenskiing · 10/10/2023 20:57

I completely understand those saying that they feel their school are giving mixed messages by sending out attendance letters. But it's not that simple. I can assure you that school staff, including SLT, absolutely do not want to be dealing with obviously sick children on top of all the shit that we are currently dealing with. Schools are under a lot of pressure from the Department of Education, Ofsted and the Local Authority to improve attendance.

We had an Ofsted inspection fairly recently and there was a significant focus on attendance. The Head got an absolute grilling about it, even though our whole school attendance is higher than the national average.

I'm a Safeguarding Lead and Attendance is considered a safeguarding issue, so I have to have regular meetings with an Attendance Officer from the Local Authority where they interrogate us about our attendance policy and procedures, go through our attendance data with a fine tooth comb and question us about individual children and demand to see evidence of what we are doing to tackle persistent absence. In the last meeting they were very critical of us not offering rewards for 100% attendance. We refuse to do this and were clear about the reasons why (because it's ableist) but they wouldn't let it go. We were also berated for refusing to fine parents. Although it wasn't stated explicitly there was a suggestion that we may no longer recieve support from the Education Welfare Caseworker assigned to us if we aren't willing to refer parents for prosecution.

A lot of people don't realise that School's Attendance policies are largely dictated to them by these organisations, we can't just go rogue and do our own thing.

Well except that if you have pushed back and not given attendance awards and not gone down the fining route then it is possible to stand by those principles.

people do realise the bind that schools are in. What they are objecting to from the OP is fhe accusation that parents are thick/lacking in common sense if they don’t want to spend hours unpicking each email from school to decide which one school stands by and which one is just a box-ticking exercise. I live with a teacher so I leave those mind games to him to figure out.

neverbeenskiing · 10/10/2023 20:57

I completely understand those saying that they feel their school are giving mixed messages by sending out attendance letters. But it's not that simple. I can assure you that school staff, including SLT, absolutely do not want to be dealing with obviously sick children on top of all the shit that we are currently dealing with. Schools are under a lot of pressure from the Department of Education, Ofsted and the Local Authority to improve attendance.

We had an Ofsted inspection fairly recently and there was a significant focus on attendance. The Head got an absolute grilling about it, even though our whole school attendance is higher than the national average.

I'm a Safeguarding Lead and Attendance is considered a safeguarding issue, so I have to have regular meetings with an Attendance Officer from the Local Authority where they interrogate us about our attendance policy and procedures, go through our attendance data with a fine tooth comb and question us about individual children and demand to see evidence of what we are doing to tackle persistent absence. In the last meeting they were very critical of us not offering rewards for 100% attendance. We refuse to do this and were clear about the reasons why (because it's ableist) but they wouldn't let it go. We were also berated for refusing to fine parents. Although it wasn't stated explicitly there was a suggestion that we may no longer recieve support from the Education Welfare Caseworker assigned to us if we aren't willing to refer parents for prosecution.

A lot of people don't realise that School's Attendance policies are largely dictated to them by these organisations, we can't just go rogue and do our own thing.

gemma19846 · 10/10/2023 20:27

Ahhh teachers acting like they are the parents of their students...again!! Not your kids! Do your job and teach. MAYBE their parents have to work or dont want school moaning about their attendance!

Sophie89j · 10/10/2023 20:23

I agree with you however, our secondary school recently sent a google form out for interested pupils for a school trip, due to the amount of interest they’ve actually chosen to pupils based on attendance and ATL scores which I think is absolute bull shit. I only keep my son home if actually unwell he has been more unwell in the past 12 months than in previous years so he has been placed on the reserve list, I think this is unacceptable when his ATL scores are above average, not going to lie to say perfect 😂

On the matter of why people test, I tested about a month ago and was positive, I work with vulnerable individuals within the community and my grandfather is severely unwell which means I wouldn’t visit him or go into work potentially subjecting other people in work to it then potentially subjecting their clients to it.

Covid is still an extremely severe illness, two weeks ago my mother, who until then was healthy couldn’t breathe, I had to phone an ambulance and my 53 year old mother nearly died. Luckily we were already in the hospital by the time her horrendously scary turn happened, her mouth turned blue, there were 20 odd doctors and nurses around her within 2 minutes with a crash cart. The covid had caused pneumonia and a chest infection which has now caused long term lung damage. A previously healthy 53 year old with no health concerns.

Yet I am also aware that nurses in the ICU and maternity wards by me are being told not to test!!!! It’s as if the government are trying to kill us off!!!!

CaliMom23 · 10/10/2023 20:14

That happened in my kid's class. And then 10 more kids got Covid. 10 families got Covid. And now one of the mums has Long Covid and unable to work. All that suffering because one selfish parent didn't keep an unwell kid at home!

Luckyducky10 · 10/10/2023 19:39

All schools bang on about is keep on sending kids to school regardless, here they expect them to go to school and take there antibiotics with them!!! It’s disgusting.

Givemepeas · 10/10/2023 19:30

‘Are we supposed to cherry pick the information from school whether or not to ignore it or act upon it? ‘

Exactly!

Believeitornot · 10/10/2023 19:29

The DfE’s own statistics show that a big part of the problem with absence is illness. Then we are gaslit into the idea that it’s just soft parents keeping them home for a sniffle.

FFS.

Believeitornot · 10/10/2023 19:28

YANBU OP.

But on the other hand we’ve got a government and NH fucking S pretending Covid isn’t a thing, a failure to have air filters which would make a massive difference (the House of Commons has them!!!!) and the DfE issuing diktats about attending school.

Rudderneck · 10/10/2023 17:27

TrashedSofa · 10/10/2023 11:43

Interesting points.

It's a fact that we as a society can't do without the labour of people who have school aged DC too young to be left. Naturally, policy has been made accordingly.

Oh, I don't know about that. I think we probably could. But it wouldn't be good for those at the top of the food chain.

IncomingTraffic · 10/10/2023 17:15

LadyPenelope68 · 10/10/2023 15:26

And teachers aren’t a babysitting service for your ill child either 😡😡 don’t be so utterly selfish and idiotic

Edited

Maybe teachers DO need to accept that part of their role is childcare. They are in charge of children without their parents present for defined periods of time because they work in a school.

The idea that ‘childcare’ is somehow beneath teachers is actually pretty offensive.

Tinybrother · 10/10/2023 16:25

What’s funny is that the workplace that puts significant amounts of pressure on for staff not to take time off to look after ill children is my husband’s school. You would think that given schools are supposedly faking the emphasis on attendance and really don’t want ill children coming in, they would support their own teaching staff who are trying to avoid that happening in their children’s school.

or maybe the OP is exaggerating about how much fakery there is going on in their school, who knows

LlynTegid · 10/10/2023 15:58

Sympathy for you, as mentioned the attendance policies schools are forced to adopt contribute, and no doubt employers wanting people in the office who can work from home does not help.

Denial by government that Covid is still about does not help either.

Wrongsideofpennines · 10/10/2023 15:53

LadyPenelope68 · 10/10/2023 15:26

And teachers aren’t a babysitting service for your ill child either 😡😡 don’t be so utterly selfish and idiotic

Edited

Wow, that was unnecessarily rude. I don't even have children in school, I was merely demonstrating what a parent's thought process might be.

You may think it selfish of a parent to do this but there are many parents who feel they have no choice if they want to keep a job and a stable home for their child. Blame workplace policies.

Softnatural · 10/10/2023 15:32

LadyPenelope68 · 10/10/2023 15:26

And teachers aren’t a babysitting service for your ill child either 😡😡 don’t be so utterly selfish and idiotic

Edited

So what you you do? You're working all hours to make ends meet, you have a child who is unwell but just about able to function, not going to work means losing pay, at best, if it's something you've had to do often, losing your job and you can only just pay the bills anyway. What would you do?

Come on, list all the options available to that parent?

LadyPenelope68 · 10/10/2023 15:26

Wrongsideofpennines · 10/10/2023 08:35

There are no babysitting services for sick kids. They don't exist. And no childcare setting is going to take a sick child either. So if parents have already used their pitiful 5 days carer's leave or whatever some jobs offer then they don't really have an option to send their kids to school.

And teachers aren’t a babysitting service for your ill child either 😡😡 don’t be so utterly selfish and idiotic

hellohellothere · 10/10/2023 12:41

Perhaps you should change careers if you have no empathy for parents or children? You need to be angry with Ofsted not the families.

IncomingTraffic · 10/10/2023 12:01

TrashedSofa · 10/10/2023 11:57

Well of course. There's no way to trot out the school is not childcare line without sounding like a twat. Especially not after the last 3 years.

And yet… here we are. 🤦🏻‍♀️

TrashedSofa · 10/10/2023 11:57

IncomingTraffic · 10/10/2023 11:55

Yes.

But we should not be perpetuating the lie that school is not childcare.

We should be starting from open acknowledgement that is absolutely is childcare. School is a form of childcare that also provides education.

Childcare is not somehow lesser to education - which is the sentiment that underlies a lot of the ‘school is not childcare’ rhetoric.

Well of course. There's no way to trot out the school is not childcare line without sounding like a twat. Especially not after the last 3 years.

IncomingTraffic · 10/10/2023 11:55

TrashedSofa · 10/10/2023 11:43

Interesting points.

It's a fact that we as a society can't do without the labour of people who have school aged DC too young to be left. Naturally, policy has been made accordingly.

Yes.

But we should not be perpetuating the lie that school is not childcare.

We should be starting from open acknowledgement that is absolutely is childcare. School is a form of childcare that also provides education.

Childcare is not somehow lesser to education - which is the sentiment that underlies a lot of the ‘school is not childcare’ rhetoric.

TrashedSofa · 10/10/2023 11:43

IncomingTraffic · 10/10/2023 11:39

I’m not convinced that the statement ‘school isn’t supposed to be childcare’ is true or that it has ever been true.

One of the drivers for the institution of the school existing at all as a means of providing education is that is serves the purpose of freeing parents up from childcare duties to some degree so that they are more able to undertake paid work.

It has never been able to fulfil this part of the function because of a range of other fudges that limit the length of the school day and produced the expectation of a long period of non-school in the summer (which has its roots in freeing up child labourers for agriculture).

i suspect the phrase ‘school is education not childcare’ emerged as a means of putting and keeping parents in their place. But it’s both disingenuous in both practical terms and in relation to the intentions behind schools.

Interesting points.

It's a fact that we as a society can't do without the labour of people who have school aged DC too young to be left. Naturally, policy has been made accordingly.

IncomingTraffic · 10/10/2023 11:40

Almostwelsh · 10/10/2023 11:34

School absolutely is childcare according to the DWP when telling single parents to get back into work.

Yes.

welfare policy is very clearly based on the assumption that school is childcare.

Let’s stop pretending otherwise. Or blaming parents for needing to use it as such.