Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make homemade gifts for Christmas this year?

89 replies

elm26 · 09/10/2023 20:14

First Christmas with DD, we are also moving house in January and need to buy a bigger car.

We have told all of the adults in the family to not buy us anything, if they would like to buy something for our little one that would be really kind but also don't feel they have to, she'll be 7 months and won't understand it anyway! I've made it clear I don't want lots of toys etc she's too young and we just don't have the room for it right now.

I would like to gift something to our parents/DD's grandparents and aunts and uncles so I was thinking of doing homemade Christmas tree shaped shortbread in a nice tin for each couple plus something made by DD, have seen the little canvas's people do with their footprints being reindeer antlers then paint the face and I'll write "DD's first Christmas" on it or something similar to this? Is this really naff or would you appreciate these?

OP posts:
BluebellsForest · 10/10/2023 10:44

This horrible MN lore that children are only of genuine interest to their parents is so untrue and nasty. I have cards of my nephews footprints that I loved receiving and have kept it for years. Ignore the miserable posts, OP. You know your family.

caringcarer · 10/10/2023 10:38

I think the Grand Parents will love the hand print gift from your DC. I've kept the ones my DGC did for me and I cherish them. Shortbread in a tin sounds lovely too.

elm26 · 10/10/2023 10:25

Thank you everyone for your opinions and ideas!

I'm going to make sloe gin, some flavoured vodka, some jam and some shortbread. I've ordered some little bottles and jam jars from Amazon and it'll give me something fun to do whilst baby sleeps! Going to just put some Christmas ribbon around them and hopefully everyone will enjoy.

Regarding present from DD, going to make homemade Christmas cards instead like a few suggestions here, then nobody feels they have to have them on display all year.

OP posts:
anyolddinosaur · 10/10/2023 09:17

Food gifts that dont need to be eaten immediately - fine. Other food may go in the bin. Kids hand/footprints are only for very doting grandparents, not for all of them and definitely not other relatives unless they have shown they are mad about the baby by e.g. regular babysitting for nothing. A small picture of the baby is acceptable, I still have some pictures of relatives babies.

Luckydog7 · 10/10/2023 09:04

I made hampers (well actually boxes) to go to each group of the family over covid which were well received. I put in homemade chutney/plum jam, Candied almonds, one shortbread chocolate sandwich thing (two biscuits with choc in the middle), hot chocolate truffles that could be melted into hot milk.

I made a small amount per person but lots of variety so everything will get eaten by someone and its exciting to open and see whats inside.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/10/2023 09:00

A BiL makes gorgeous fudge, which I’d be happy to receive any time. A niece has made peppermint creams, also v nice.

The only homemade thing I’ve given was a tin of my very very cheesy cheese straws, but only because I knew the recipient really liked them, and they’d be opened/eaten up within a few days.

I once also made bottles of rum punch, with a ‘lethal’ warning label on the side!

LaurieStrode · 10/10/2023 08:54

Just a cute photo of the baby, in a pretty card with a heartfelt greeting written by hand, and the date, would be plenty for me.

twostraws · 10/10/2023 08:26

Being honest, I hate cutesy child gifts. They’re not my children. We might be related, but that doesn’t mean I want to display their footprints etc in my home!

Homemade gifts are only good where the giver has an actual talent. Something edible made by someone I know well who I know can bake would be well-received.

If you don’t know how to knit or paint though, now is not the time to learn! Stick to the biscuits.

Sparrow7 · 10/10/2023 08:21

I think do the handprint/foot print thing as a card not a gift, then they can pop in a frame if they want to keep but there is no pressure to keep if they don't want to. I love handmade food gifts, chutneys, chilli sauce etc particularly.

ZenNudist · 10/10/2023 08:18

Oh not for auntie and uncles. Just grandparents.

ZenNudist · 10/10/2023 08:18

BittIeLastard · 09/10/2023 20:22

I'd have said no to the shortbread and yes to the footprints. They are her grandparents, aunts and uncles they are likely to treasure them.

This! My in law's and parents used to love getting personalised things.

mondaytosunday · 10/10/2023 08:15

I'd love homemade biscuits/jam/chutney! Far better than a scented bath set or book (no one knows my taste) or picture frame.
But agree with everyone above - something 'made' by your child or commemorates that child - no. Your parents might like a framed photo of them and the baby (or you, partner and baby) if they display pictures but to be honest if my sister gave my the kind of hand print type thing it would be a waste of her time and money.

CandleWick4 · 10/10/2023 08:06

@bettynutkins.Without wanting to sound mean (and I really don’t want to sound mean), did they love them or do they feel they have to have them on the tree or you’d be offended/upset?
my friend got me a personalised something for Christmas once. I don’t like it. It’s not my taste or style but I put it up every year or she’d ask.
these things are ok for grandparents but no one else wants them.

CandleWick4 · 10/10/2023 07:58

This question gets asked every year and it’s always a tricky one. I think homemade gifts are ok if they’re done right and they have the recipient in mind.
For example my MIL crochets and often does homemade gifts. She will ask what we’d like, what colours we like etc and makes individual gifts.
I think people can also be a bit funny about eating things other people have made?
Me I wouldn’t be overly joyed about short bread or a foot print. Honestly by the time youve bought paint and canvas’ and ingredients you could do a small gift. I’d rather have a bottle of £5 aldi Prosecco. But that’s me - you know you’re family

SherbetLemonn · 10/10/2023 07:54

You are absolutely not unreasonable to do this and I am quite sure your parents would appreciate pretty much anything at all that you and their granddaughter gave them. I was thinking you could do the sweet footprint as a Christmas card, that way they can keep it if they choose, and frame it for example for other years, but don’t feel obliged if that makes sense?
My sister, a couple of years back, made homemade fudge for everyone, put it in lovely glass jars, you know the ones with the clip on type lids, and put a pretty bit of ribbon on them etc. I absolutely loved it, fudge was delicious but the jar was very handy too! It could also be made ahead of time much more easily than biscuits etc.

Warum · 10/10/2023 07:54

Just doing no gifts would be an option too. I'm sure folk will understand.

bettynutkins · 10/10/2023 07:52

I bought flat round baubles and put my son's footprint on and made it into a reindeer. With something like
"Merry Christmas, love from xx 2023" on the back.
They are on the trees every year, all the family loved them.

Snowonthebeachx · 10/10/2023 07:48

Things that have gone down well with my parents and in laws are photobooks of the grandkids from photobox or bonus print.

Homemade food wise have you thought about sloe gin or another type of home made liquor if they are drinkers?

Mummumgem · 10/10/2023 07:43

My son and DIL were in a similar position last year, we told them not to buy us presents but we wanted to buy for them.

i was really surprised Christmas morning when they gave us a family photo, a friend had taken it for them, he had printed it at work (better printer) and popped it in an inexpensive frame. The girls had made a card and even the one year old had signed with a thumb print. Needles to say I will keep it forever

In the end we bought them curtains for their new house 😂😂, it’s what they needed and money was tight. The children we bought new coats and I might have just added a craft box they do love to colour etc 😁.

Mistressanne · 10/10/2023 07:28

I like to get photos of my dgc.
Tbh when the dc are hard up at Christmas I don’t mind what we do or don’t get. As a parent I wouldn’t want dc to be worrying over spending on us at Christmas. Mostly I like to see the dc, that is the best gift.

My ddil usually hunts out secondhand books for me or buys me my favourite eyebrow pencil which is a £5. Ds will get dh something football related.
Dd does personal stuff so dh and I get a family photo.
I’m not keen on food gifts unless the person making them is good at baking.
However I’m the baker in our family so they wouldn’t do this for me.

AuntieMarys · 10/10/2023 07:27

DilemmaDelilah · 10/10/2023 07:18

As a grandmother and aunt - I would definitely NOT appreciate a canvas, hand/foot print etc. from the baby. Maybe I am a miserable grinch but I have finally got to the stage in life where I have my home decorated the way I like and I do not have a load of photos etc. around the place and certainly nothing cute like hand/foot prints. I do have some particularly nice individual photos of close family members in nice frames, but very few. When I have been given such cute gifts in the past I'm afraid they have gone straight in a drawer - I keep the latest ones for a little while in case of visits, when I would find somewhere temporary to put them, but they all get thrown out in the end except photos, which go in a box without their frames.

I would, however, appreciate a foodie handmade gift. I like food - especially the kind of things I don't buy on a regular basis - and I would appreciate the effort.

Yes I'm the same....dh has grandchildren and we would hate twee sentimental gifts. Luckily his dd wouldn't do anything like that for us...she doesn't do it for herself!
A good chutney or jam is always welcome, but nothing sweet.
I agree with someone else...you've said no gifts, yet you're giving them.

DilemmaDelilah · 10/10/2023 07:18

As a grandmother and aunt - I would definitely NOT appreciate a canvas, hand/foot print etc. from the baby. Maybe I am a miserable grinch but I have finally got to the stage in life where I have my home decorated the way I like and I do not have a load of photos etc. around the place and certainly nothing cute like hand/foot prints. I do have some particularly nice individual photos of close family members in nice frames, but very few. When I have been given such cute gifts in the past I'm afraid they have gone straight in a drawer - I keep the latest ones for a little while in case of visits, when I would find somewhere temporary to put them, but they all get thrown out in the end except photos, which go in a box without their frames.

I would, however, appreciate a foodie handmade gift. I like food - especially the kind of things I don't buy on a regular basis - and I would appreciate the effort.

SageMist · 09/10/2023 23:07

Some people like homemade gifts, some don't. Some like mementos of grandchildren/nephews/nieces and some don't. I love home made gifts because I like that someone actually put some effort in. I don't really appreciate baby foot prints or mugs labeled best mum/Nan/auntie. So you need to decide what each individual would like to receive rather than what you would like to give.

AutumnAuntie · 09/10/2023 23:05

I wouldn’t want any homemade food gifts. If someone is struggling with money I’d genuinely prefer they didn’t buy or make anything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread