Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make homemade gifts for Christmas this year?

89 replies

elm26 · 09/10/2023 20:14

First Christmas with DD, we are also moving house in January and need to buy a bigger car.

We have told all of the adults in the family to not buy us anything, if they would like to buy something for our little one that would be really kind but also don't feel they have to, she'll be 7 months and won't understand it anyway! I've made it clear I don't want lots of toys etc she's too young and we just don't have the room for it right now.

I would like to gift something to our parents/DD's grandparents and aunts and uncles so I was thinking of doing homemade Christmas tree shaped shortbread in a nice tin for each couple plus something made by DD, have seen the little canvas's people do with their footprints being reindeer antlers then paint the face and I'll write "DD's first Christmas" on it or something similar to this? Is this really naff or would you appreciate these?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AnneButNotHathaway · 11/10/2023 10:33

Handmade gifts are nice, but I wouldn't do the footprint thing, as others said, it's something that matters to you, not others. You can make a printable family calendar or use a Christmas collage maker and print out and frame photo collages that would include photos of your DD, but something that comes from her wouldn't be a great idea.

elm26 · 10/10/2023 21:16

My kitchen is most definitely clean, I'm actually diagnosed OCD and clean obsessively which isn't good for me but good for other people when it comes to things like this!

OP posts:
Iamanisland · 10/10/2023 18:23

BluebellsForest · 10/10/2023 12:02

You're in AIBU, OP. Plenty of posters come here to be undermining and upsetting. Posting in Christmas might be a happier experience.

Or just honest like you can't be in real life? I binned stuff like that from when my own children were little and I'd definitely bin it from someone else's or if I got homemade food. I'd never tell anyone in real life but I can be honest here.

Steev · 10/10/2023 18:12

Big no to the handprint but shortbread would be okay if I know your kitchen is clean Wink

HIC2020 · 10/10/2023 15:21

I am making handmade gifts this year for Christmas (blankets and hot water bottle covers) 😊 I am trying to make things they would find useful.

I really like the biscuits idea, especially if you get some nice tins to put them in (who doesn't love a good tin). As an aunt I can't say I would appreciate the footprint canvas. DD first Christmas is a big thing for you but not so much everyone else. I do love the cards and pictures my neices and nephews give me now they are a bit older. Maybe something for the grandparents though.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 10/10/2023 14:47

I think that's lovely
I also think DGP's would be pleased with the handprints or you could send a nice photo of her perhaps

ThinWomansBrain · 10/10/2023 14:24

why not use a photo of DC as your christmas card?

I often gift jars of cranberry sauce at christmas time - super easy to make, I normally find the packs in supermarket make way too much, even for me (it's amazing on porridge) and rarely have any freezer space.

SunsetsAndSandwiches · 10/10/2023 14:16

Opinion seems split on the handprint/footprint idea! My cousin made all of the family Christmas cards with her babys footprints on one year (I think she added reindeer or snowmen facial features?) and I thought that was a nice idea - the more sentimental members of the family kept the cards, others could just appreciate the cuteness over Christmas but then didn't feel obliged to keep it on display afterwards.

Agree with the poster who suggested recycling glass jars to put your shortbread in (or fudge!) Rather than spending on tins

FuzzyPuffling · 10/10/2023 14:15

MrsDanversChickenSandwich · 10/10/2023 14:01

People like to show how tough and unsentimental they are on aibu!

You know your parents/in laws and are best placed to judge whether they’d like the little footprint. Sounds like your daughter’s grandparents would love it!

I’d love the shortbread, if it was someone I knew was a good baker, and someone I knew had a nice clean house that didn’t have five cats lounging about on the kitchen worktops.

Yeah, you're right, I'm tough and unsentimental. (Did you read my response?)

But I really love my five cats!

lost78300 · 10/10/2023 14:10

How about a candle with a hand print on it and tell them to use it and think of DD.

Buy cheap candles from IKEA and use acrylic paint.

MrsDanversChickenSandwich · 10/10/2023 14:01

elm26 · 10/10/2023 11:56

This seems quite upsetting to me, I can't imagine any of my family putting anything to do with DD in the bin let alone her grandparents, she only has to giggle at them and they get all teary. Each to their own though!

People like to show how tough and unsentimental they are on aibu!

You know your parents/in laws and are best placed to judge whether they’d like the little footprint. Sounds like your daughter’s grandparents would love it!

I’d love the shortbread, if it was someone I knew was a good baker, and someone I knew had a nice clean house that didn’t have five cats lounging about on the kitchen worktops.

PostItInABook · 10/10/2023 13:55

Homemade stuff is fine if it’s actually useful and something the recipient would actually like and use…….otherwise it just becomes another piece of thoughtless tat.

Newmama67 · 10/10/2023 13:47

Totally get where you’re coming from about not wanting loads of toys for various reasons (no storage, them not being spoilt, the environment).

Firstly, everyone loves a biccy so that’s lovely.

If you really want to keep the foot print idea, I wouldn’t do a reindeer theme as it makes it a Christmas decoration I would argue. Your little one will bring plenty of stuff like that home over the years in school. 😁 My mum is a super stylish granny with an eye for gorgeous interior design. I can’t imagine her displaying it all year round (I’d be stunned!), although she adores my little one and is sentimental. If you’re only doing two (I’d avoid aunts and uncles!), I would do just one footprint in black on a textured handmade paper in cream. Etsy has some lovely ones. Then I’d frame it in a thick white mount and thin silver frame. It’ll cost little (paint, paper and two smallish square frames with mounts in already from Amazon or TKMaxx is great for reasonable and quality frames) but look like you’ve got it from Not on The High Street or something. Then they can decide whether to display or keep as a keepsake in a drawer as it won’t be too big as it’s just one footprint, not two.

Have a lovely first Christmas!

FuzzyPuffling · 10/10/2023 13:33

elm26 · 10/10/2023 11:56

This seems quite upsetting to me, I can't imagine any of my family putting anything to do with DD in the bin let alone her grandparents, she only has to giggle at them and they get all teary. Each to their own though!

What matters to me is in my heart.

Torganer · 10/10/2023 12:30

elm26 · 10/10/2023 11:56

This seems quite upsetting to me, I can't imagine any of my family putting anything to do with DD in the bin let alone her grandparents, she only has to giggle at them and they get all teary. Each to their own though!

Honestly we get sent home so much homemade crap from nursery - you can’t keep it all! My mother hates tat with a passion, but she absolutely adores her grandchild. Always cries with joy at some point, and the tears of sadness when we leave. Keeping material homemade stuff has no bearing on love!

Fifthtimelucky · 10/10/2023 12:21

I think things like hand and foot prints depend on grandparents' preferences but also on how many grandchildren they have. Between them, my father and stepmother had 20 grandchildren and his wife had 7. They loved having photos of their grandchildren on display but tended to replace them as new ones arrived.

Personally I like homemade food gifts. I have made people lemon curd and/or mint jelly in recent Christmases because they are so much better than the bought versions.

applepearorangebear · 10/10/2023 12:03

Footprint Christmas cards are a lovely idea: easy to store, no pressure to have on display if people are short on space / precious about decor etc. I still have lots that friends and relations have sent over the years and I'm not even a doting grandparent!
Love the edible ideas too. One further suggestions: we got given a big jar of tiny round cheese nibbles one year, which were great with drinks. Might be an idea, instead of / as well as sweet things?

BluebellsForest · 10/10/2023 12:02

You're in AIBU, OP. Plenty of posters come here to be undermining and upsetting. Posting in Christmas might be a happier experience.

elm26 · 10/10/2023 11:56

FuzzyPuffling · 10/10/2023 11:12

Yes to the shortbread, huge no to the footprints. ( And that's as a grandparent). It'd be straight in the bin.

This seems quite upsetting to me, I can't imagine any of my family putting anything to do with DD in the bin let alone her grandparents, she only has to giggle at them and they get all teary. Each to their own though!

OP posts:
KezzabellaB · 10/10/2023 11:41

I think your ideas are lovely and, as a proud Nana, would love the hand and foot print gift too.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 10/10/2023 11:40

The hand prints on xmas card is a great idea as they obviously dont have to keep them, however I have certain xmas cards that I keep in with the decorations and they come out every year. Thats a really nice reminder of times gone by. (Particularly kids as they grow!!)

NoWinterYear · 10/10/2023 11:33

The short bread is a lovely idea. I think foot or hand prints for grand parents is ok but no one else would probably appreciate it much. My parents and in-laws love our kids to pieces and would treasure a bunch of fallen out hair as a gift if it came from their precious grand kids but I do think they would appreciate more something slightly more tangible like a photo of their grand child. For aunts and uncles I wouldn't do anything from the baby. When she's older she can make stuff for them and they will probably like that but I can't imagine me or my siblings appreciating prints much or even any other token sentimental gift on behalf of the baby

FuzzyPuffling · 10/10/2023 11:12

Yes to the shortbread, huge no to the footprints. ( And that's as a grandparent). It'd be straight in the bin.

beetr00 · 10/10/2023 11:07

I see you're organised @elm26 so just fyi, I've ordered from this shop previously, their items are so personal and very good quality too.

https://www.etsy.com/uk/shop/ByBeautifulgiftshop?section_id=38360075

Torganer · 10/10/2023 10:56

I would do the handprint as a Christmas card instead. That way, there is no expectation to keep or display it after Christmas.