Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(THREAD 2) To ask if we can please try to have Palestine and Israel thread where we acknowledge how awful it is for everyone, but try not to throw shit at each other?

190 replies

Poudretteite · 09/10/2023 19:51

Not OP just created another thread as the first one was full

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Pollyputhekettleon · 09/10/2023 21:50

Takoneko · 09/10/2023 21:37

I’d also like to make it very clear that I am not pro-Palestine, anti-Israeli.

Yeah sorry I didn't mean that as a description of your position, it was clumsily phrased but you got what I was asking.

LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 21:46

@Pollyputhekettleon

I've discussed it many times with pro-Palestine, anti-Israel people and without exception they turn out to hold antisemitic views once you really engage them on the topic.

They want a one state solution, with Israel to not exist.

JuvenileEmu · 09/10/2023 21:38

DisquietintheRanks · 09/10/2023 21:14

@BMW6 then I guess the answer is to work out a 2 (or even 3) state solution that is palatable to both sides.

What do you think the alternative would be?

But how can this happen when Hamas won't make any kind of compromise whatsoever? They have made it quite clear that anything short of the destruction of Israel is unacceptable to them.

Takoneko · 09/10/2023 21:37

I’d also like to make it very clear that I am not pro-Palestine, anti-Israeli.

Takoneko · 09/10/2023 21:36

Pollyputhekettleon · 09/10/2023 21:18

Fair enough. Do you know why none of the other pro-Palestine, anti-Israel, whatever you call them, posters on here are answering this? I mean, is there a good answer out there?

Honestly, I think people are conditioned to like stories with “good guys” and “bad guys”. They see a situation like this and want there to be a “good side” and a “bad side”. The messy reality that both sides have done awful things and that it’s a story of abject failure by the international community to take responsibility for a situation that they were instrumental in creating doesn’t give people the same satisfaction as it being a simple story of good vs evil where they can pick the right “side” to be on.

There are bad actors on both sides and good actors on both sides but there is not a good side and a bad side. I think people find that psychologically unsatisfying and all a bit too complicated.

Takoneko · 09/10/2023 21:29

Poudretteite · 09/10/2023 21:19

The point is Palestine has said they will only be happy with 100%. They do not support the existence of Israel. This is why they cannot come to agreement.

Hamas is only happy with 100%. Hamas are not Palestine. They are in power in Gaza but not in the West Bank and they are not in charge of the PNA, which is the internationally recognised representative of the Palestinian people. The PNA is in favour of a two state solution, and has been pretty consistently since the Oslo Accords.

Poudretteite · 09/10/2023 21:19

DisquietintheRanks · 09/10/2023 21:14

@BMW6 then I guess the answer is to work out a 2 (or even 3) state solution that is palatable to both sides.

What do you think the alternative would be?

The point is Palestine has said they will only be happy with 100%. They do not support the existence of Israel. This is why they cannot come to agreement.

OP posts:
Pollyputhekettleon · 09/10/2023 21:18

Takoneko · 09/10/2023 20:11

I’m not saying I agree with their arguments. I think I’ve made it clear that I think that the international community should have stepped in to enforce the partition plan whether the Arab Palestinians liked it or not. It was a fair balance between the competing claims and I support Israel’s right to exist.

And yes, I’m aware that were issues before World War Two. I believe I was the one who pointed out that the British limiting of visas was a response to the 1936-39 Arab Uprising. Jewish people were moving out of Europe in the 1930s after the Nazis took power. It didn’t begin in 1945. The Arab Uprising was triggered by the increased Jewish migration after 1933. It’s worth noting that Britain was only willing to waive visa requirements for unaccompanied children on their own soil in 1938.

Fair enough. Do you know why none of the other pro-Palestine, anti-Israel, whatever you call them, posters on here are answering this? I mean, is there a good answer out there?

DisquietintheRanks · 09/10/2023 21:14

@BMW6 then I guess the answer is to work out a 2 (or even 3) state solution that is palatable to both sides.

What do you think the alternative would be?

BMW6 · 09/10/2023 21:02

DisquietintheRanks · 09/10/2023 20:51

What Israel should do is offer a (sensible) two state solution. Hamas may want to destroy the state of Israel totally (its a slogan that plays wonderfully with its electorate) but I'm pretty sure the vast majority of Palestinians would settle for that. And even Hamas once said it would.

What's more interesting is what Israel would give away to win peace. In recent years they seem to be doing pretty well with their slow land grab so why would they want to change?

The 2 State solution has been offered to Israel and Palestine 5 times.

Every single time Israel has agreed, Palestine said No.

5 times.

Look it up.

DisquietintheRanks · 09/10/2023 21:01

Poudretteite · 09/10/2023 20:56

The two state solution was wrecked when Israel gave up Gaza as a good faith gesture and Palestine immediately started using it to attack Israel. Palestine would use what they were given to try and take more as their motive is to destroy Israel and eliminate the Jews.

I don't think anyone could argue that what Israel does with and to Gaza is done in good faith. Not without fearing a lighting strike.

BMW6 · 09/10/2023 20:59

Sippingmytea · 09/10/2023 20:49

But by the same logic that suggests that all British people are Tories and we support everything our government does?

People are not their governments. People can also support freedom for Palestinians and equally be disgusted by the actions of Hamas.

It is a real shame that people on this thread are so closed minded.

FFS.

Someone wearing a Palestinian flag in the light if the last 24 hours is doing nothing less than celebrating Hamas actions in Israel.

Behave yourself. There is no other reasonable interpretation.

LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 20:58

@DisquietintheRanks

What Israel should do is offer a (sensible) two state solution. Hamas may want to destroy the state of Israel totally (its a slogan that plays wonderfully with its electorate) but I'm pretty sure the vast majority of Palestinians would settle for that. And even Hamas once said it would

Are you saying the last 5 deals including the one negotiated over years at the camp david summits weren't sensible offers? how so? the feedback from that was they they wouldn't say yes to anything.

What's more interesting is what Israel would give away to win peace. In recent years they seem to be doing pretty well with their slow land grab so why would they want to change?

I am not sure how that is a good thing really. They have to spend a lot of money on defence and weapons and there's little more costly than perpetual war. It damaged their reputation internationally. As well as trade. Peace would undoubtedly be better for Israel.

For Hamas though, it would mean the gravy train of foreign aid currently being used for the leaders to live in luxury and siphon funds offshore would be over. What would they do then? They have no industry? No agriculture? No educated population really? Terrorism isn't a career.

I think it's glaringly obvious who is better served by peace and who is better served by perpetual fighting.

Poudretteite · 09/10/2023 20:56

DisquietintheRanks · 09/10/2023 20:51

What Israel should do is offer a (sensible) two state solution. Hamas may want to destroy the state of Israel totally (its a slogan that plays wonderfully with its electorate) but I'm pretty sure the vast majority of Palestinians would settle for that. And even Hamas once said it would.

What's more interesting is what Israel would give away to win peace. In recent years they seem to be doing pretty well with their slow land grab so why would they want to change?

The two state solution was wrecked when Israel gave up Gaza as a good faith gesture and Palestine immediately started using it to attack Israel. Palestine would use what they were given to try and take more as their motive is to destroy Israel and eliminate the Jews.

OP posts:
DisquietintheRanks · 09/10/2023 20:51

Poudretteite · 09/10/2023 20:03

@mrsmara Kindly point out where I say 'Hamas is justified in wanting to destroy Israel and the Jews?

You said it wasn't any surprise in response to Hamas saying they will not accept the existence of Israel at all. So what is Israel supposed to do?

What Israel should do is offer a (sensible) two state solution. Hamas may want to destroy the state of Israel totally (its a slogan that plays wonderfully with its electorate) but I'm pretty sure the vast majority of Palestinians would settle for that. And even Hamas once said it would.

What's more interesting is what Israel would give away to win peace. In recent years they seem to be doing pretty well with their slow land grab so why would they want to change?

MrsSchadenfreude · 09/10/2023 20:49

I used to live in Israel. Finally heard from my friend who had moved out of Tel Aviv to Ashdod that she is OK. A few days ago she posted a photo of the view from her balcony over the sea, and said she loved living there as it was so peaceful. 🙁

Sippingmytea · 09/10/2023 20:49

But by the same logic that suggests that all British people are Tories and we support everything our government does?

People are not their governments. People can also support freedom for Palestinians and equally be disgusted by the actions of Hamas.

It is a real shame that people on this thread are so closed minded.

Poudretteite · 09/10/2023 20:45

Sippingmytea · 09/10/2023 20:42

Why?

If someone wore a Russian flag as a cape after Russia's invasion, would it be hysterical to believe it was a gesture of support, as you can't say that Putin=Russia?

Your post is the stupidest thing I've read throughout this whole event...

OP posts:
Sippingmytea · 09/10/2023 20:42

Why?

LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 20:41

@Sippingmytea

He was wearing a Palestinian flag. Did he tell you he supports Hamas or did you just jump to the hysterical assumption that Palestine = Hamas?

Oh seriously get in the bin.

WarmWinterSun · 09/10/2023 20:40

I put two and two together with that one

Sippingmytea · 09/10/2023 20:39

He was wearing a Palestinian flag. Did he tell you he supports Hamas or did you just jump to the hysterical assumption that Palestine = Hamas?

Poudretteite · 09/10/2023 20:37

I have also hears from Jewish colleagues today that shops in their North London community have had windows smashed by those ‘celebrating’ the acts of Hamas.

Kristallnacht

OP posts:
LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 20:32

@WarmWinterSun

I was also upset to have a man walk past me in London this evening wearing a Palestinian flag as a cape, as if he was proud of the attack. It made me feel ill

Oh that would have disgusted me! How completely insensitive. I am a leftie, but I despair at how ignorant the British left are. Their hatred for Israel is so consuming that they can't even stand up against the worst form of terrorism imaginable. I think in the future they will be bloody ashamed.

A few of the left wing people I chat to on Twitter were completely unable to stop "both sides" or Whataboutery" or even stopping to say Israel brought it on themselves. It's just gross.

I have also hears from Jewish colleagues today that shops in their North London community have had windows smashed by those ‘celebrating’ the acts of Hamas. This is completely unacceptable

This is devastating :(

WarmWinterSun · 09/10/2023 20:28

I don’t understand all of it either, but what is clear to me is that terrorism is never acceptable and must always be condemned. There is no justification for the murder, rape and kidnapping of women and children and the acts committed by Hamas are beyond abhorrent.

I was also upset to have a man walk past me in London this evening wearing a Palestinian flag as a cape, as if he was proud of the attack. It made me feel ill. I have also hears from Jewish colleagues today that shops in their North London community have had windows smashed by those ‘celebrating’ the acts of Hamas. This is completely unacceptable.