Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(THREAD 2) To ask if we can please try to have Palestine and Israel thread where we acknowledge how awful it is for everyone, but try not to throw shit at each other?

190 replies

Poudretteite · 09/10/2023 19:51

Not OP just created another thread as the first one was full

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
DownNative · 09/10/2023 23:37

ticketstickets · 09/10/2023 22:44

So I am sure you are aware, being Irish, that the grandfather of the current Israeli President, Isaac Herzog, was the first Chief Rabbi of the Republic of Ireland, and was known as the Sinn Fein Rabbi.

Its not incompatible to be a Zionist and and an Irish patriot. :)

Chaim Herzog. An article:

https://m.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/life/features/israeli-politician-isaac-herzog-on-singing-dups-praises-in-ni-and-why-a-blue-plaque-to-his-late-father-should-be-returned-to-his-former-belfast-home/37435340.html

As you can see, Isaac found it wasn't that straightforward. His father's blue circle was vandalised by anti-Israel elements - tends to be Republicans. And he wasn't best pleased with Provisional Sinn Féin’s comments about Israel. But he felt the DUP understood Israel.

Israeli politician Isaac Herzog on singing DUP's praises in NI and why a blue plaque to his late father should be returned to his former Belfast home

One of Israel's most influential public figures has paid tribute to the DUP during his first visit to Belfast to see the birthplace of his father Chaim Herzog, who was the President of his country in the 1980s.

https://m.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/life/features/israeli-politician-isaac-herzog-on-singing-dups-praises-in-ni-and-why-a-blue-plaque-to-his-late-father-should-be-returned-to-his-former-belfast-home/37435340.html

SomeCatFromJapan · 09/10/2023 23:37

@LemonyTicket we lived in Doha for a bit and the pay scales for government jobs were literally linked to nationality - with Brits, Americans, Canadians and Western Europeans obviously getting the best pay. They still had the kafala system while we were there although I know there's been reform now.

And yes you had to really watch what you said on social media.
Don't get me wrong I didn't complain, and I still don't really join in the critisism, as I accept it's just a completely different culture and we chose to be there.

But yes I do think that many left-wing/liberal Western supporters of the Palestinian cause assume that they yearn for the same kind of society that they themselves live in, for a liberal democracy. Hence the large crossover of LGBT/Queer groups with Palestine flags in their bios etc whereas they would presumably get extremely short shrift in Gaza if they were openly gay or trans.

I think you said you were no Netanyahu/Likud fan and I agree with you there, I asked you yesterday about the differences between Gaza and the West Bank and you kindly gave me a very detailed answer, am I right in thinking there are ongoing tensions and unpleasantness in the West Bank? Is it true that Palestinians get removed from their houses to accommodate settlers or is there also more of a back story there?

LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 23:18

What's absolutely mad to me is that you're still going on about it! @quiteoldad

Look back to "holding Israel to completely different standards!"

quiteoldad · 09/10/2023 23:15

By "in tact" do you mean they should leave behind their property? Why? It belongs to them!

Jesus wept, we're trying to sort out 75 years of violent, mutual animosity and you're quibbling about whether or not you take the light bulbs and door handles with you.

LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 23:10

@Floppyelf

We are able to live in a multicultural society in Britain because it is enshrined with human rights. It's not legal to reduce someone to a worse status or ban them from living somewhere or doing certain jobs because they're a minority. They have a full set of human rights which protect them from that.

That would not be the case in an Arab led Israel. The human rights we have here, are almost unheard of in the Arab world. Dubai is a good example of a Muslim country that embraces other cultures. But I lived there for 6 years. It only does so on paper. In reality, an Arab has far more rights than an Indian. A woman has far less rights that a man. You can't be homosexual. There are no elections.

It is also an anomaly because it's a ridiculously rich country, so people have good lives and want to keep it that way. But it still operates on a caste system with locals at the top, western "expats" in the middle (but with no actual rights!) and then the lower cast such as Indians treated like absolute dirt and paid slave wages.

ticketstickets · 09/10/2023 23:07

theDudesmummy · 09/10/2023 22:55

@ticketstickets that is interesting about Hertzog's grandfather. I live in Ireland but am not (yet) Irish, but am English. I had not realised until reading various news outlets here today how pro-Palestinian Ireland appears to be. I see they were one of the 4 countries in the EU who vetoed the stopping of aid to Palestine today.

FWIW I myself don't know what to think. My father was born in Palestine (he is British though, his father was doing business there) and growing up I was always taught to be pro-Palestinian (my parents would say "next year in Jerusalem" as a toast). But I went to a school which was predominantly Jewish. So I always realised there were two ways of looking at this region.

Now I just feel desperately sorry for all the poor civilians, on both side, and I would not take to the streets with either flag because I don't support either army.

almost twins. :)

Also British, live in Ireland, and my father was born in Palestine. (to Jewish refugees from Europe).

LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 23:05

@quiteoldad

I'd be happy with that, but this time, as they depart, they leave the West bank settlements in tact

My "in tact" do you mean they should leave behind their property? Why? It belongs to them!

Floppyelf · 09/10/2023 23:00

LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 20:25

Yes @Takoneko

It would be a completely different story if the people of Gaza had elected a more moderate government with much more liberal / western ideas so they could live side by side with shared values - but as is - they need different places to live because they have completely different ideas on how to live.

What would be very nice, is if Arabs who wanted to choose to come and live in Israel under a moderate / Western style way of life were given the right to do that. Eg: right of abode - similar to what we get in British overseas territories.

However, I feel this might be a fantasy of mine. I think one of the things groups like Hamas or countries like Iran or Syria fear most is that some Muslims might see the way of life under a liberal democracy and decide that sounds better!

However, I feel this might be a fantasy of mine. I think one of the things groups like Hamas or countries like Iran or Syria fear most is that some Muslims might see the way of life under a liberal democracy and decide that sounds better!

that is the case here in the UK unless you live in a blindspot area where its just one culture of 1st/2nd/3rd generation immigrants.

The fact that that hardcore islamist states like saudi arabia/uae/qatar have embraced some western values means that through lifting people out of poverty it brings in some rational thinking or atleast introduces it.

quiteoldad · 09/10/2023 23:00

@LemonyTicket
What I would LIKE to happen is for the international community to step in. To use any force necessary to force Israel to go back to the 1967 borders and to force Gaza to hold free and fair democratic elections. Then I would like them to sign a deal, on the lines of the last one and for everyone to get on with living their lives. I would like to see extremist, terrorist leaders out of Gaza. But that is not something I can make happen even if there were elections held. But once that is done, those people can turn that place into a wonderful, safe and prosperous state.

I'd be happy with that, but this time, as they depart, they leave the West bank settlements in tact.

theDudesmummy · 09/10/2023 22:55

@ticketstickets that is interesting about Hertzog's grandfather. I live in Ireland but am not (yet) Irish, but am English. I had not realised until reading various news outlets here today how pro-Palestinian Ireland appears to be. I see they were one of the 4 countries in the EU who vetoed the stopping of aid to Palestine today.

FWIW I myself don't know what to think. My father was born in Palestine (he is British though, his father was doing business there) and growing up I was always taught to be pro-Palestinian (my parents would say "next year in Jerusalem" as a toast). But I went to a school which was predominantly Jewish. So I always realised there were two ways of looking at this region.

Now I just feel desperately sorry for all the poor civilians, on both side, and I would not take to the streets with either flag because I don't support either army.

LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 22:53

@quiteoldad

If it isn't bigotry, what is it?

It can be bigotry. For example not wanting to hire someone because they are Jewish. But antisemitism is much more common in the form I have explained above: holding general beliefs about Jews (or zionists, or israel) which link into hundreds years of tropes about power / conspiracies/ looking after their own and generally being treated differently.

It doesn't usually present in the obvious - hit you in the face way that afrophobia or islamophobia do, and Jews (certainly in Britain) are unlikely to face discrimination on almost any level. It becomes something else, deeply held beliefs which tie in to all the same ideas which sent us into diaspora for thousands of years.

LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 22:49

@SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs

do you think that long term, the situation will ever be resolved and that Israel and Palestine will ever see peace? If so, what do you think would need to happen to make that a reality?

Let me answer first with what I would like to happen.

What I would LIKE to happen is for the international community to step in. To use any force necessary to force Israel to go back to the 1967 borders and to force Gaza to hold free and fair democratic elections. Then I would like them to sign a deal, on the lines of the last one and for everyone to get on with living their lives. I would like to see extremist, terrorist leaders out of Gaza. But that is not something I can make happen even if there were elections held. But once that is done, those people can turn that place into a wonderful, safe and prosperous state.

What I actually think will happen is that they will fight a while longer and Israel will blow Hamas off the planet and likely a lot of innocent people will suffer and die. After which they will probably fight with Iran and Syria.

It's shit.

But then so is the situations in Iran and Syria. People put so much focus on this but the situations in some of those countries is absolutely horrifying.

ticketstickets · 09/10/2023 22:44

Pollyputhekettleon · 09/10/2023 21:55

I wonder if a lot of them are actually unaware of really basic stuff, like that there were any Jews in Israel before WW2 though? I would have always been pro-Palestinian pretty much by default, being Irish. I suspect, actually I know, that the vast majority of Irish people are as clueless as I was. But the people you're debating with are presumably more activist, politically motivated leftists/Muslims, which is probably a different ballgame.

So I am sure you are aware, being Irish, that the grandfather of the current Israeli President, Isaac Herzog, was the first Chief Rabbi of the Republic of Ireland, and was known as the Sinn Fein Rabbi.

Its not incompatible to be a Zionist and and an Irish patriot. :)

LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 22:41

A few very good examples of absolutely prolific left-wing antisemitism amongst pro-Palestinians are:

  • Denying the right of Jews in the State of Israel to exist and flourish, collectively and individually, as Jews, in accordance with the principle of equality. I will talk more about this at the bottom of the post, but many left-wing people defend the right of Palestinian nationalism whilst simultaneously denying the same right of Jews. And they see absolutely no problem with this. When it comes to Palestinians it's "their land" but when it comes to Jews "oh they can live anywhere!"
  • Requiring people, because they are Jewish, publicly to condemn Israel or Zionism (for example, at a political meeting). This has happened to me endlessly. They have decided "zionism" is racism for their moronic reasons and will then get quite adversarial with Jews demanding that they denounce the concept of Jewish nationalism or else face shame.
  • Assuming that non-Israeli Jews, simply because they are Jews, are necessarily more loyal to Israel than to their own countries. I have come across this a lot. If I have even remotely offered a balanced view on Israel that doesn't fit the "Palestine are downtrodden" narrative, then I have been outright accused of being a paid lobbyist! (I have never even BEEN to Israel!)
  • Engaging in really, really classic antisemitism but believing it's okay because they change the words they use to say Jews. So for example they will engage in the most obvious tropes and racist conspiracy theories, ideas where “the Jews” possess hidden power that they use to promote their own collective agenda at the expense of other people. A fantasy that “the Jews” control governments with a “hidden hand,” that they own the banks, control the media, act as “a state within a state,” and all these kinds of things. They outright do that, and you can see it all day every day on Twitter - but they think it's not antisemitism because they say "zionist" or "Israel" instead of Jews.

So I am not talking about "Bigotry" in the sense that most left-wing people would identify it, but all of the above is recognised on the Jerusalem declaration as antisemitism because that's what it is. It is holding Jews to strange standards linked with the age old, pernicious idea that we are crafty, powerful, up to no good and wielding power over some powerless weakling.

Going back to the anti zionism thing, I think this has become the badge of honour for the Pro Palestine brigade, but to me this is a concerning position because it denies the Jewish people alone a right to self-determination; It equates Zionism with racism when really it is a response to the racism of others, it focuses obsessively on the world’s sole Jewish state and holds it to standards to which no other country is subjected.

This idea of an “international Zionist” conspiracy came from soviet propaganda. It draws upon, mimicks and replicates antisemitic myths which stretch back hundreds of years. But because it comes wrapped up in an anti-imperialist package, many on the left can't see it for what it is.

In reality, supporting Hamas or condoning their behavior or even wishing for them to rule over people with their disdain for human rights, women, gays or justice should appal the left. In real terms, if you have left wing values, you must be pro-Israel, pro-Palestine and pro-peace.

For some people, and I spotted a few on this thread, they are using the Palestine issue as a vehicle for disproportionate, ferocious criticism of the Jewish state and dehumanisation of the Israeli people. Of course this state should be held accountable for all it's faults and wrongdoing, but should not be held to standards not expected or demanded of other democratic states.

The cry of "Give them their land back" is not reasoned thinking. Anyone who genuinely considers all people equal might advocate for a negotiated two-state solution to realise the legitimate aspirations of both the Jewish and Palestinian peoples to self-determination and to guarantee Israel’s most precious characteristic: its democratic and Jewish nature. Ignoring that because you don't like Israel shows a deep prejudice.

When people jump on the bandwagon, like one did on the thread last night calling Zionism "evil" and denouncing it in these awful terms, Jews are generally well aware that the denunciation points the finger at them. And ultimately this term has taken the shape of a monster for many lefties - to mean racism, colonialism, western power, money, conspiracy. When really all it actually means is that Jews do have a right to their state. Just like Palestinians.

MMBaranova · 09/10/2023 22:35

@SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs

I think that's a good question. I have no optimism there and I don't think it is entirely due to my being upset over the current horrors. I can identify four general zones along a continuum: 1 a solution that is accepted by the various parties < > 2 a modus vivendi while the former is worked on and the next is avoided < >3 tit for tat animosity, violence and unfairness < > 4 war / intifada / escalated horror and misery.

Recently the situation has been at my stage 3 and has now dropped to 4. There have been more hopeful times where there has been stage 2 and Nobel Prizes all round. Can a stage 1 be found? I don't see one at the moment.

quiteoldad · 09/10/2023 22:26

Without being rude to you, antisemitism generally isn't bigotry, and people who don't understand it often can't see it.

If it isn't bigotry, what is it ? I've just had a look and it says

"in particular prejudice against a person or people on the basis of their membership of a particular group"
On the Venn diagram, I would place anti-semitism as being a subset of Bigotry.

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 09/10/2023 22:22

@LemonyTicket do you think that long term, the situation will ever be resolved and that Israel and Palestine will ever see peace? If so, what do you think would need to happen to make that a reality?

LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 22:10

@quiteoldad

I too have discussed the topic many times with pro-Palestine, anti-Israel people and I've found that by far the greater majority of them are not anti-semites

Without being rude to you, antisemitism generally isn't bigotry, and people who don't understand it often can't see it.

quiteoldad · 09/10/2023 22:08

@ POLLY
We rarely taked about Jews in middle easten countries. I used to mention about how the situation for Jews in the middle east centuries ago was preferable to how it is now . Though I might modify that after having done a bit more reading and having been "filled in" by L. Again, earlier proposals of solutions didn't come up.
Main discussions are about how to sort the mess out today. Part of the problem is parties laying historical claim to........ or bringing up atrocities wreaked by the other party. Look bloody forward to getting a settlement..... don't pick at old sores.

LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 22:06

There's another thread going along the lines of "I don't understand Israel Palestine" and I read the first couple of pages and felt ill. Most people are on there giving very strong opinions without the slightest fucking clue what they are talking about.

I don't expect people to understand this issue very well. I am Jewish. I am Arab. I have lived at least half my life in the Middle East. I have a degree in Theology and a Masters in Middle Eastern studies. It's been my life's work to study the ancient land of Israel and it's modern formation.

What annoys me is that people are so arrogant that they wade in with all the confidence in the world and misrepresent the facts in a way that distorts the problem. Many people on these threads have raised Northern Ireland and Ukraine. I have never commented. Why? Because I don't know enough about those topics to comment.

This thread was great because people largely didn't wade in with nonsense. They discussed, asked questions and it was a serious conversation. But the Western world has a habit of arrogance. Not just in assuming they know everything, but in assuming everyone is like them - when actually different cultures can have very different values around the world.

I have said before, this issue became very trendy for people this last couple of years. The marches and the "free Palestine" slogans and the flags on your profile. Like being gluten intolerant or having the right trainers. It's quite a cringe "comfortable westerner" virtue signal that you're down with current affairs and a Palestinian supporter.

Ultimately they genuinely have almost no fucking clue of what they are supporting. They trot out punch lines which are off the shelf propaganda and have no understanding of the meaning or context. I reckon if you took 100 of these people and asked them 10 basic questions on this issue they constantly ramble on about - perhaps 1 of them might be able to answer!

So largely I think people have absolutely no idea what they are talking about, but they want to feel part of things so they basically pick the "side" that fits their persona. And right now, it's cool to be Pro-Palestine. Down with the imperialist, colonial, blood sucking Israel! That's basically it.

I also think antisemitism is a massive problem on the left of politics. I am left wing and had to more or less stop using twitter because people I liked would be immensely antisemitic and then angrily deny it if you pointed it out - even politely. I was made to feel uncomfortable a LOT because these people have such massive anti Jewish bias which they can't admit to. They can't accept that they - a left wing, highly tolerate, committed antiracist might well be trotting out all the same tired old tropes about Jewish Power and conspiracies that Hitler did. But that is what they are doing.

So the problem is, the left wing of politics are traditionally leaned on to police things like racism, bias, prejudice etc. But they are so invested in the penniless Muslim as the underdog that they can't see that they are actually being immensely biased and holding up the two sides to completely different standards. They also can't see their general philosophy is actually seriously offensive.

I read a fantastic book on this a while ago by a professor in Sheffield, on basically how antisemitism is the one form of prejudice the left can't see and I completely agree with that. I had to stay off Twitter completely in the wake of this because all these socialists who I used to identify with are more or less backing Hamas in this.

Crazy. But I guess antisemitism is such a subtle art form, so deeply ingrained into people's prejudices and because it's not "punching down" at someone necessarily poorer, weaker or generally not white - that some people are completely unable to clock it. Certainly me and my grown children have been pretty deeply distressed by it though.

Rinoachicken · 09/10/2023 22:03

As someone who didnt really have a clear understanding of the history, I have found this short explanation a good place to start.

I don’t know if it’s 100% accurate but it has helped give me a better idea of the situation and how it has come about so I can now go and do further reading.

History of Israel-Palestine Conflict

This video presents the History of Israel-Palestine conflict that rooted a few thousand years ago. Chapter:00:00 Introduction00:42 Early History of Israeli-P...

https://youtu.be/m19F4IHTVGc?si=vM8Hc1QYxUhO8WTP

Pollyputhekettleon · 09/10/2023 22:01

quiteoldad · 09/10/2023 21:58

I've discussed it many times with pro-Palestine, anti-Israel people and without exception they turn out to hold antisemitic views once you really engage them on the topic.

I too have discussed the topic many times with pro-Palestine, anti-Israel people and I've found that by far the greater majority of them are not anti-semites.

You must obviously debate the topic with a lot of anti-semites. I tend to avoid those kind of people because there is little point in debating with bigots.

In your experience how do they explain why the Arabs objected to the two-state solution in the beginning? And what do they say about the whole dhimmitude business?

MMBaranova · 09/10/2023 22:00

The Ukraine war thread is now at: Ukraine Invasion: Part 45

I'd link it but my Mumsnet Foo is in a bad state after the last thread froze as I was replying and it froze.

quiteoldad · 09/10/2023 21:58

I've discussed it many times with pro-Palestine, anti-Israel people and without exception they turn out to hold antisemitic views once you really engage them on the topic.

I too have discussed the topic many times with pro-Palestine, anti-Israel people and I've found that by far the greater majority of them are not anti-semites.

You must obviously debate the topic with a lot of anti-semites. I tend to avoid those kind of people because there is little point in debating with bigots.

Pollyputhekettleon · 09/10/2023 21:55

LemonyTicket · 09/10/2023 21:46

@Pollyputhekettleon

I've discussed it many times with pro-Palestine, anti-Israel people and without exception they turn out to hold antisemitic views once you really engage them on the topic.

They want a one state solution, with Israel to not exist.

I wonder if a lot of them are actually unaware of really basic stuff, like that there were any Jews in Israel before WW2 though? I would have always been pro-Palestinian pretty much by default, being Irish. I suspect, actually I know, that the vast majority of Irish people are as clueless as I was. But the people you're debating with are presumably more activist, politically motivated leftists/Muslims, which is probably a different ballgame.