Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(THREAD 2) To ask if we can please try to have Palestine and Israel thread where we acknowledge how awful it is for everyone, but try not to throw shit at each other?

190 replies

Poudretteite · 09/10/2023 19:51

Not OP just created another thread as the first one was full

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
1dayatatime · 10/10/2023 12:28

@Glitterdavies

Parkingt111
@LemonyTicket
What I would LIKE to happen is for the international community to step in. To use any force necessary to force Israel to go back to the 1967 borders

I agree with the above
But where would you propose the Jewish settlers who have settled beyond the borders move to?

Back to Israel

+++

Firstly no country is going to be willing to offer its forces to make Israel go back to its 1967 borders.

And even if Israel voluntarily went back to the 1967 borders then you are naive if you think this will stop the conflict. Hamas which are supported by more than50% of the population in Gaza want nothing less than the wholesale destruction of Israel.

I do agree with you though that illegal Israeli settlers on the West Bank should move back to Israel. Not only is it illegal but it only serves to piss off the Palestinian Authorities who are the reasonable ones in this cluster fuck.

DisquietintheRanks · 10/10/2023 12:20

How odd. That's certainly not what you said.

Angrycat2768 · 10/10/2023 12:18

AhNowTed · 10/10/2023 11:54

Let's just be clear.

The Palestinians in Gaza are controlled by Hamas. Population 2.3m

The Palestinians in the West Bank (State of Palestine) are controlled by the Palestinian Authority, who's president is Mahmoud Abbas. Population 2.7m

There's another 1.6m who live in Israel.

They are not all the same.

That was exactly my point!

Givemepeas · 10/10/2023 12:14

‘And London was founded by the Romans - hopefully no modern day Italians will be claiming ownership’ 😅

no. I don’t have much time for any religion claiming rights in modern times because of something their holy book claims happens thousands of years ago.
there’s respect for peoples beliefs, and there’s common sense.

My friend’s mum ( Israeli born but married and moved to London 50 years ago) is of the opinion that Jewish people are gods chosen people and god gave them the land that is now Israel and everyone else needs to shift somewhere else. She’d happily see every single Palestinian dead. They’re less than human in her eyes.

religious extremists are all bloody mad, regardless of their persuasion.

DisquietintheRanks · 10/10/2023 12:09

Palestine voted In Hamas

If that's what you really think @SizzlestheSausageDog then please read more and comment less

Efacsen · 10/10/2023 12:05

OneLittleFinger · 10/10/2023 11:44

Jerusalem was founded by the Canaanites, the ancestors of Jews and Arabs, and was conquered by King David. From what I can tell, anyway.

And London was founded by the Romans - hopefully no modern day Italians will be claiming ownership

AhNowTed · 10/10/2023 11:54

Angrycat2768 · 10/10/2023 11:28

But yes I do think that many left-wing/liberal Western supporters of the Palestinian cause assume that they yearn for the same kind of society that they themselves live in, for a liberal democracy

Totally. It's a kind of projection. I honestly don't know who Palestinians would vote for but they are probably pretty openly indoctrinated to think the current way is the right way, so it's not hard for me to believe they'd keep Hamas.But yes I do think that many left-wing/liberal Western supporters of the Palestinian cause assume that they yearn for the same kind of society that they themselves live in, for a liberal democracy

Totally. It's a kind of projection. I honestly don't know who Palestinians would vote for but they are probably pretty openly indoctrinated to think the current way is the right way, so it's not hard for me to believe they'd keep Hamas.

I think a lot of it is a kind of naive reverse racism. They think all brown people are the same, and if only the Western Imperialists disappeared, all those Brown people would realise how much they had in common and all get along, when they are different peoples, with nothing in common with each other in many cases and huge variations in history and background.

Let's just be clear.

The Palestinians in Gaza are controlled by Hamas. Population 2.3m

The Palestinians in the West Bank (State of Palestine) are controlled by the Palestinian Authority, who's president is Mahmoud Abbas. Population 2.7m

There's another 1.6m who live in Israel.

They are not all the same.

OneLittleFinger · 10/10/2023 11:44

BMW6 · 10/10/2023 11:29

But it IS their homeland!

Clue - who founded the city of Jerusalem?

Jerusalem was founded by the Canaanites, the ancestors of Jews and Arabs, and was conquered by King David. From what I can tell, anyway.

SizzlestheSausageDog · 10/10/2023 11:34

I think we are on the same wavelength @Angrycat2768 . Palestine voted in Hamas, if the Jewish population were removed from the equation I don't think they would suddenly become a liberal democracy.

BMW6 · 10/10/2023 11:29

Glitterdavies · 10/10/2023 11:20

Would you give up your home in Europe because someone from another country said its their birth right.

And when you fought back and was put in an even worse place was told that you deserved it? Should've moved when you had the chance?

I don't think you would.

But it IS their homeland!

Clue - who founded the city of Jerusalem?

Angrycat2768 · 10/10/2023 11:28

But yes I do think that many left-wing/liberal Western supporters of the Palestinian cause assume that they yearn for the same kind of society that they themselves live in, for a liberal democracy

Totally. It's a kind of projection. I honestly don't know who Palestinians would vote for but they are probably pretty openly indoctrinated to think the current way is the right way, so it's not hard for me to believe they'd keep Hamas.But yes I do think that many left-wing/liberal Western supporters of the Palestinian cause assume that they yearn for the same kind of society that they themselves live in, for a liberal democracy

Totally. It's a kind of projection. I honestly don't know who Palestinians would vote for but they are probably pretty openly indoctrinated to think the current way is the right way, so it's not hard for me to believe they'd keep Hamas.

I think a lot of it is a kind of naive reverse racism. They think all brown people are the same, and if only the Western Imperialists disappeared, all those Brown people would realise how much they had in common and all get along, when they are different peoples, with nothing in common with each other in many cases and huge variations in history and background.

Lonesomefetter · 10/10/2023 11:22

It all seems so futile and depressing. I heard the point that no powers seem to be speaking about peace, rather taking sides. It's impossible to credibly take a side though unless you know the complicated history of that area and I certainly don't (and if I'm really honest, don't care enough to learn) obviously I'm very sorry for anyone losing their lives in seemingly endless conflict.

Glitterdavies · 10/10/2023 11:20

Would you give up your home in Europe because someone from another country said its their birth right.

And when you fought back and was put in an even worse place was told that you deserved it? Should've moved when you had the chance?

I don't think you would.

Poudretteite · 10/10/2023 11:18

Parkingt111 · 10/10/2023 10:46

@LemonyTicket
What I would LIKE to happen is for the international community to step in. To use any force necessary to force Israel to go back to the 1967 borders

I agree with the above
But where would you propose the Jewish settlers who have settled beyond the borders move to?

Also, the reason Israel went beyond the borders was that Palestine refused to accept them, waged war, and then lost. It was their gamble.

OP posts:
Glitterdavies · 10/10/2023 11:15

Parkingt111 · 10/10/2023 10:46

@LemonyTicket
What I would LIKE to happen is for the international community to step in. To use any force necessary to force Israel to go back to the 1967 borders

I agree with the above
But where would you propose the Jewish settlers who have settled beyond the borders move to?

Back to Israel

SizzlestheSausageDog · 10/10/2023 11:09

I find it a bit bizarre how people can simultaneously condemn what happens in Afghanistan and Iran etc with hard-line Islamic governance and the lack of human rights for the population, and also say let's give all of Israel back to Hamas. How will that end well? It will surely just end up as another Afghan/Iran situation with no rights for women or other minorities?

Parkingt111 · 10/10/2023 10:46

@LemonyTicket
What I would LIKE to happen is for the international community to step in. To use any force necessary to force Israel to go back to the 1967 borders

I agree with the above
But where would you propose the Jewish settlers who have settled beyond the borders move to?

BMW6 · 10/10/2023 10:37

Does anyone think this conflict can end without Hamas being entirely destroyed?

And how can that be achieved - won't more radicalised and enraged men (and women) flock to their cause as Hamas members are killed?

For any chance of peace, surely the first step must be the dropping of the wish to eradicate Israel? Both sides have to recognise and acknowledge the right of the other to exist?

DownNative · 10/10/2023 08:39

AhNowTed · 10/10/2023 08:06

For anyone interested, there's a fabulous series still available on iPlayer about the troubles in NI, how it began, through the terrible middle and finally an uneasy peace. It's the most unbiased thing on this subject I've seen, with equal voices from both sides of the conflict. It's called

Once upon a time in Northern Ireland

It's truly remarkable.

A lot of context and information is left out in that series.

But Northern Ireland was not anything like the Israeli-Palestinian conflict which is also far, far more complicated than ours was.

Of course, PIRA was connected to Hamas as part of an international terrorist network where they trained together in Libya, collaborated with dictatorship regimes and helped each other in various ways, e.g. PIRA training FARC in Colombia. Colonel Gaddafi supplied PIRA with significant weapons and semtex. Additionally, Gaddafi's Libya supported Palestinian group Hamas, and developed a close relationship with its leader, Khaled Mashal.

This terrorist network included ANC's terrorist wing, MK aka Spear Of The Nation which had Nelson Mandela as one its founders.

It is important for people to be aware of the extent of international terrorist networks because chances are they oppose one or more of them. So supporting any particular one, for example Hamas, would be contradictory and unsustainable under close scrutiny.

AhNowTed · 10/10/2023 08:06

For anyone interested, there's a fabulous series still available on iPlayer about the troubles in NI, how it began, through the terrible middle and finally an uneasy peace. It's the most unbiased thing on this subject I've seen, with equal voices from both sides of the conflict. It's called

Once upon a time in Northern Ireland

It's truly remarkable.

AhNowTed · 10/10/2023 07:54

I should have added, Trump's dog's breakfast of a plan in 2020 was rejected by everyone!

WaitingfortheTardis · 10/10/2023 07:33

I'm naiive I know, but for me the only thing that matters is that innocent children are caught in the middle of all this. It's so sad. I wish as humans we had evolved beyond all this.

AhNowTed · 10/10/2023 07:27

quiteoldad · 09/10/2023 23:00

@LemonyTicket
What I would LIKE to happen is for the international community to step in. To use any force necessary to force Israel to go back to the 1967 borders and to force Gaza to hold free and fair democratic elections. Then I would like them to sign a deal, on the lines of the last one and for everyone to get on with living their lives. I would like to see extremist, terrorist leaders out of Gaza. But that is not something I can make happen even if there were elections held. But once that is done, those people can turn that place into a wonderful, safe and prosperous state.

I'd be happy with that, but this time, as they depart, they leave the West bank settlements in tact.

I would be happy with that.

In 2011 Obama called for negotiations along the 1967 lines with mutually agreed swaps.

This was roundly rejected by Netanyahu.

LemonyTicket · 10/10/2023 00:19

@SomeCatFromJapan

Awesome! Been to Daha a few times! But yes, then, you get it. It is a completely different world where as an expat you get treated very nicely but you are a guest and that much is clear. The way some people are treated is not very fair or right at all. But culturally there is not a principle of equality.

But yes I do think that many left-wing/liberal Western supporters of the Palestinian cause assume that they yearn for the same kind of society that they themselves live in, for a liberal democracy

Totally. It's a kind of projection. I honestly don't know who Palestinians would vote for but they are probably pretty openly indoctrinated to think the current way is the right way, so it's not hard for me to believe they'd keep Hamas.

Hence the large crossover of LGBT/Queer groups with Palestine flags in their bios etc whereas they would presumably get extremely short shrift in Gaza if they were openly gay or trans

This one always leave me open mouthed. I saw one yesterday with a banner: "Queers for Gaza". They'd have a bloody shock fast enough!

I think you said you were no Netanyahu/Likud fan and I agree with you there

We despise him. He has caused so much damage.

Am I right in thinking there are ongoing tensions and unpleasantness in the West Bank? Is it true that Palestinians get removed from their houses to accommodate settlers or is there also more of a back story there?

Sadly yes, that's accurate. And they are escalating. There are forced evictions, handled in ways I personally find bordering on sick. They do quite cruel things like interfere with or even demolish infrastructure or facilities that communities need to live.

This behavior goes against all my values, and basic measures of right and wrong - but the international community isn't doing anything. They can do something, but they're not. They keep denouncing it, but doing nothing. It would be a lot better for everyone if they did.