Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(THREAD 2) To ask if we can please try to have Palestine and Israel thread where we acknowledge how awful it is for everyone, but try not to throw shit at each other?

190 replies

Poudretteite · 09/10/2023 19:51

Not OP just created another thread as the first one was full

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
piddocktrumperiness · 11/10/2023 08:41

I wanted to add, that from what I am reading it seems like the settlers; their behaviour towards other Palestinians (note the spitting on Christians) , the protection they require from the military and the access to resources they get over the access to Palestinians in the area, in addition to the expansion of settlements are what is really fuelling the fire in the region.

Happy to be corrected

piddocktrumperiness · 11/10/2023 08:37

I'd like to ask and would love for someone to help me understand:

  • Why does Netanyahu's govt still allow settlement expansion in the west bank?
  • What is the general consensus or feeling from Israelis on the settlements in the West Bank?
I'm wondering if the govt stops facilitating the expansion of these settlements, and even, withdraw those settlements from the West Bank, that we are more likely to see progress in this situation?
Poudretteite · 11/10/2023 08:12

Glitterdavies · 10/10/2023 11:20

Would you give up your home in Europe because someone from another country said its their birth right.

And when you fought back and was put in an even worse place was told that you deserved it? Should've moved when you had the chance?

I don't think you would.

OK, so it's justified that they went to war. (Although they are not 'from another country,' they were originally exiled, and were persecuted and genocided globally in other people's countries, that's the whole point)

They did go to war, and they lost. That's why they ended up with less than the original agreement. That's kind of how it works?

OP posts:
SequentialAnalyst · 10/10/2023 22:54

Did the Crusaders rape and pillage? You bet they did.

SequentialAnalyst · 10/10/2023 22:51

Man's inhumanity to man.

Inhabitants of York, England burn all their Jewish population to death, in Clifford Tower, where they had sought refuge.
BBC - Religions - Judaism: York pogrom, 1190

Not too long after, Christianity got the idea that having a Holy War to reclaim Jerusalem for the Christians was a Good Thing. Hence the waste of human life that was the Crusades, only they were waged against Muslims, who fought much more fairly than the Christians did.

BMW6 · 10/10/2023 22:37

LemonyTicket · 10/10/2023 20:36

And London was founded by the Romans - hopefully no modern day Italians will be claiming ownership

Yes, I am sure that Jews being granted a right to their own state in the place they came from after 3000 years of endless discrimination and genocides in almost every place on the planet is very similar to and Italian coming to Bromley with a suitcase.

FGS.

Thanks, that made me laugh so much 😂

SequentialAnalyst · 10/10/2023 22:21

Who was it on the previous thread who claimed soldiers were killing machinesAngry?

Tell that to all the men who served in WW2 on the British side, of whom my DF was one.

AUIU, in the Second WW, many British were poor at aiming at the enemy, IYGWIM. No such choice in the First WW, which had ended only 21 years before the Second one began.

My DF once sat in the back of a lorry, in the Western Desert, in his early 20s, holding a pistol, and supervising some German POWs. Everyone in the lorry was shit scared.

Conflict involves many individuals, each of whom is living their own individual and unique life, and praying not to die.

LemonyTicket · 10/10/2023 20:36

And London was founded by the Romans - hopefully no modern day Italians will be claiming ownership

Yes, I am sure that Jews being granted a right to their own state in the place they came from after 3000 years of endless discrimination and genocides in almost every place on the planet is very similar to and Italian coming to Bromley with a suitcase.

FGS.

Givemepeas · 10/10/2023 19:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

echinaceadreams · 10/10/2023 18:51

It's awful.

Pollyputhekettleon · 10/10/2023 18:50

BMW6 · 10/10/2023 10:37

Does anyone think this conflict can end without Hamas being entirely destroyed?

And how can that be achieved - won't more radicalised and enraged men (and women) flock to their cause as Hamas members are killed?

For any chance of peace, surely the first step must be the dropping of the wish to eradicate Israel? Both sides have to recognise and acknowledge the right of the other to exist?

But how would you convince everyone on the Arab side to agree to let the Jews have their own state? Doesn't seem possible to me, the opposition to it clearly has very deep roots.

DownNative · 10/10/2023 15:07

AhNowTed · 10/10/2023 13:55

@DownNative

Thanks. Also led me onto interesting sites and commentators I hadn't come across.

No problem! 👍

AhNowTed · 10/10/2023 13:55

@DownNative

Thanks. Also led me onto interesting sites and commentators I hadn't come across.

Auvergne63 · 10/10/2023 13:51

Poudretteite · 10/10/2023 13:28

Just to be clear, this is you justifying the destruction of London Jewish shops?

Absolutely not. Targeting Jewish shops is wrong but this is not Kristallnacht.
My point was that the Israeli government is now doing to the civilians in Gaza what was done to the Jews in Warsaw: no food, no water, no electricity and no medication. Current international humanitarian law (IHL) — the law of armed conflict — makes clear that the deliberate starvation of the civilian population as a tactic of war is prohibited and a prosecutable war crime.
I hope this is clear enough.

DownNative · 10/10/2023 13:30

AhNowTed · 10/10/2023 13:14

I thought this was interesting, as it may go some way to explaining why Abbas as lost support.

For years, Netanyahu propped up Hamas. Now it’s blown up in our faces

The premier’s policy of treating the terror group as a partner, at the expense of Abbas and Palestinian statehood, has resulted in wounds that will take Israel years to heal from

For years, the various governments led by Benjamin Netanyahu took an approach that divided power between the Gaza Strip and the West Bank — bringing Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas to his knees while making moves that propped up the Hamas terror group.

The idea was to prevent Abbas — or anyone else in the Palestinian Authority’s West Bank government — from advancing toward the establishment of a Palestinian state.

Thus, amid this bid to impair Abbas, Hamas was upgraded from a mere terror group to an organization with which Israel held indirect negotiations via Egypt, and one that was allowed to receive infusions of cash from abroad.

Link to full article in The Times of Israel...

https://www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/

Other perspectives:

https://ecfr.eu/article/cancellation-costs-abbas-and-palestinian-democracy/?amp=

https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/2023-04-13/ty-article-opinion/.premium/president-mahmoud-abbas-has-destroyed-the-palestinian-national-movement/00000187-7a26-dc6c-a5ff-7f77277e0000

https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/02/06/palestinian-authority-israel-west-bank-security-cooperation-suspended-mahmoud-abbas/

Cancellation costs: Abbas and Palestinian democracy

By cancelling Palestine’s first elections in 15 years, President Mahmoud Abbas has relinquished Palestinian democracy and national reunification, and is setting the stage for future turmoil.

https://ecfr.eu/article/cancellation-costs-abbas-and-palestinian-democracy?amp=

Poudretteite · 10/10/2023 13:28

Auvergne63 · 10/10/2023 13:01

Warsaw ghetto.

Just to be clear, this is you justifying the destruction of London Jewish shops?

OP posts:
AhNowTed · 10/10/2023 13:14

DownNative · 10/10/2023 13:05

You're missing quite a few important facts and detail there.

President Abbas has lost control over a northern swath of the West Bank, especially after he called off an election. Polls indicated Fatah would suffer another humiliating defeat to Hamas. Around two-thirds of Palestinians opposed his decision to call off the vote.

On top of that, there is considerable support in the West Bank for terrorist groups who reject the authority of the Palestinian Authority. Palestinian pollster Khalil Shikaki and his Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research (PCPSR) found that 72% of Palestinians support forming more armed groups in West Bank. 65% of Palestinians in West Bank support the concept of armed groups taking NO orders from the Palestinian Authority. Numbers were higher in Gaza, where 84% of respondents backed the concept.

A minority of Gazans do NOT support Hamas.

Even Abbas' Fatah party has an armed wing. Around 14% of Palestinians supported them in 2021. Hamas has more support.

True that Palestinians are not a monolithic group.

True also that a majority of Palestinians support Hamas and a majority in the West Bank support armed groups taking NO orders from the Palestinian Authority.

The worst thing for all Palestinians is for them to completely reject the Palestinian Authority. Palestinians believe the Palestinian Authority is weak since they're willing to work with the Israeli Government. Hamas fully exploits that issue to great effect.

I thought this was interesting, as it may go some way to explaining why Abbas as lost support.

For years, Netanyahu propped up Hamas. Now it’s blown up in our faces

The premier’s policy of treating the terror group as a partner, at the expense of Abbas and Palestinian statehood, has resulted in wounds that will take Israel years to heal from

For years, the various governments led by Benjamin Netanyahu took an approach that divided power between the Gaza Strip and the West Bank — bringing Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas to his knees while making moves that propped up the Hamas terror group.

The idea was to prevent Abbas — or anyone else in the Palestinian Authority’s West Bank government — from advancing toward the establishment of a Palestinian state.

Thus, amid this bid to impair Abbas, Hamas was upgraded from a mere terror group to an organization with which Israel held indirect negotiations via Egypt, and one that was allowed to receive infusions of cash from abroad.

Link to full article in The Times of Israel...

https://www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/

For years, Netanyahu propped up Hamas. Now it’s blown up in our faces

The premier's policy of treating the terror group as a partner, at the expense of Abbas and Palestinian statehood, has resulted in wounds that will take Israel years to heal from

https://www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces

Auvergne63 · 10/10/2023 13:11

Sippingmytea · 09/10/2023 20:49

But by the same logic that suggests that all British people are Tories and we support everything our government does?

People are not their governments. People can also support freedom for Palestinians and equally be disgusted by the actions of Hamas.

It is a real shame that people on this thread are so closed minded.

Totally agree with you. What Hamas did was abhorrent as much as what the Israeli government is doing now is. Stopping food, water, medication and electricity to nearly 3 millions people is beyond belief. Let's not mention the constant bombing. These people have nowhere to go. Thank you lucky star that you were born here and not there.

DownNative · 10/10/2023 13:05

AhNowTed · 10/10/2023 11:54

Let's just be clear.

The Palestinians in Gaza are controlled by Hamas. Population 2.3m

The Palestinians in the West Bank (State of Palestine) are controlled by the Palestinian Authority, who's president is Mahmoud Abbas. Population 2.7m

There's another 1.6m who live in Israel.

They are not all the same.

You're missing quite a few important facts and detail there.

President Abbas has lost control over a northern swath of the West Bank, especially after he called off an election. Polls indicated Fatah would suffer another humiliating defeat to Hamas. Around two-thirds of Palestinians opposed his decision to call off the vote.

On top of that, there is considerable support in the West Bank for terrorist groups who reject the authority of the Palestinian Authority. Palestinian pollster Khalil Shikaki and his Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research (PCPSR) found that 72% of Palestinians support forming more armed groups in West Bank. 65% of Palestinians in West Bank support the concept of armed groups taking NO orders from the Palestinian Authority. Numbers were higher in Gaza, where 84% of respondents backed the concept.

A minority of Gazans do NOT support Hamas.

Even Abbas' Fatah party has an armed wing. Around 14% of Palestinians supported them in 2021. Hamas has more support.

True that Palestinians are not a monolithic group.

True also that a majority of Palestinians support Hamas and a majority in the West Bank support armed groups taking NO orders from the Palestinian Authority.

The worst thing for all Palestinians is for them to completely reject the Palestinian Authority. Palestinians believe the Palestinian Authority is weak since they're willing to work with the Israeli Government. Hamas fully exploits that issue to great effect.

LemonyTicket · 10/10/2023 13:02

@Angrycat2768

I think a lot of it is a kind of naive reverse racism. They think all brown people are the same, and if only the Western Imperialists disappeared, all those Brown people would realise how much they had in common and all get along, when they are different peoples, with nothing in common with each other in many cases and huge variations in history and background

Completely. It's so patronising! I think this is how they excuse stuff like terrorism and medieval brutality. Its a bit like ",oh the poor savages don't know any better". It grates me.

Countries like Iran and surrounding parts of Persia were historically the roots of the most sophisticated thinking and civilisations. They were busy inventing the windmill 500 years before the birth of Christ.

Where they've gone has more to do with the domination of traditional Islamic secular rule, and that led to a lack of a framework of education, democracy and all the fertile grounds of development.

Auvergne63 · 10/10/2023 13:01

Poudretteite · 09/10/2023 20:37

I have also hears from Jewish colleagues today that shops in their North London community have had windows smashed by those ‘celebrating’ the acts of Hamas.

Kristallnacht

Warsaw ghetto.

piddocktrumperiness · 10/10/2023 12:55

@SizzlestheSausageDog Can we please stop lumping Hamas with the rest of Palestine?

They are ONLY IN GAZA- NOT THE WEST BANK. Many, many Palestinians live in the West Bank and East Jerusalem- have nothing, absolutely nothing to do with Hamas. Hamas has not authority over them either.

Palestine did not, vote them in. Please refrain from using absolutes

The conflation of Hamas and all Palestinians is very unfair.

LetsResearch · 10/10/2023 12:43

I think it's disgusting that many people are cheering on the Palestine terrorist group for murdering, raping and kidnapping people at an Israeli music festival. The vile people say that Israelis deserved it for being on land that doesn't belong to them... Even though the land has belonged to the Jews for millennia. Judaism is a lot older than Islam. I feel for innocent civilians on either side who want peace, not war.

History of Israel-Palestine Conflict

This video presents the History of Israel-Palestine conflict that rooted a few thousand years ago. Chapter:00:00 Introduction00:42 Early History of Israeli-P...

https://youtu.be/m19F4IHTVGc?si=3-5sFbHPhjEeDe92

SizzlestheSausageDog · 10/10/2023 12:37

@DisquietintheRanks that's what the Wikipedia article on Gaza says, if it is wrong please point me to a relevant resource. I believe they do a level of fact checking, especially on such a contentious area.

Angrycat2768 · 10/10/2023 12:29

DisquietintheRanks · 10/10/2023 12:20

How odd. That's certainly not what you said.

I replied to this
But yes I do think that many left-wing/liberal Western supporters of the Palestinian cause assume that they yearn for the same kind of society that they themselves live in, for a liberal democracy

with

I think a lot of it is a kind of naive reverse racism. They think all brown people are the same, and if only the Western Imperialists disappeared, all those Brown people would realise how much they had in common and all get along, when they are different peoples, with nothing in common with each other in many cases and huge variations in history and background.