Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(THREAD 2) To ask if we can please try to have Palestine and Israel thread where we acknowledge how awful it is for everyone, but try not to throw shit at each other?

190 replies

Poudretteite · 09/10/2023 19:51

Not OP just created another thread as the first one was full

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
theDudesmummy · 13/10/2023 07:27

The queen of Jordan is Palestinian.

emilysquest · 13/10/2023 07:21

Can I ask something which I have not seen any answer to on the many discussions I have read? Jordan is Israel's much larger neighbour to the east and has a very long border with them, presumably not completely defended by Israel. What is their stance/role? Do they have any diplomatic influence/military intent which would have effects one way or another and how or when would they use them? Who are their main friends/allies?

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 00:55

piddocktrumperiness · 11/10/2023 08:37

I'd like to ask and would love for someone to help me understand:

  • Why does Netanyahu's govt still allow settlement expansion in the west bank?
  • What is the general consensus or feeling from Israelis on the settlements in the West Bank?
I'm wondering if the govt stops facilitating the expansion of these settlements, and even, withdraw those settlements from the West Bank, that we are more likely to see progress in this situation?

He is right wing and wants dominance. During the departure from Gaza in 2005, he was a very loud opponent to it. He said he Israel had to keep the territories occupied and under military control as a security buffer to the outside world. He felt them being Palestinian was a security risk. So it was clear what his priorities are. He is not interested, I do not think, in peaceful resolutions so much as defending Israel at all costs.

Sharon said at the time that it was the right thing to do to leave Gaza, and being in Gaza was oppressing the Palestinians. He was right of course. So it's not like all Israeli people share Netenyahu's ideas - he is a right wing man. Just like here you will have people who agree with Suella Braverman putting people on planes to Rwanda while everyone else thinks it's horrific.

Hopefully he goes in the next election.

SureWhyNotThen · 11/10/2023 22:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

DownNative · 11/10/2023 22:31

Dolphin1111111111111111111111111 · 11/10/2023 22:20

@DownNative where in that video does it show them being mistreated? Have you seen the video showing translation and they are saying to her that they will not hurt them?

Strawman Argument as I said they ARE Hamas terrorists who are taking them hostage. Disingenuous for anyone to claim otherwise!

Hamas are using them along with 100 other hostages as human shields. I've no doubt Hamas will have already mistreated them in various ways which they've form for.

I repeat, Hamas are NOT protecting them in the video. Elsewhere I've explained terrorist propaganda of themselves as being "defenders" for multiple reasons and audiences. It is not what you think.

And, yes, I've seen that video. It's from Middle East Eye. Likewise I said, it's Hamas propaganda.

Dolphin1111111111111111111111111 · 11/10/2023 22:20

@DownNative where in that video does it show them being mistreated? Have you seen the video showing translation and they are saying to her that they will not hurt them?

1dayatatime · 11/10/2023 21:47

@DownNative

Good post - there really does seem to be a lot of new MN accounts posting on this topic

NotTerfNorCis · 11/10/2023 21:45

There's been concerted disinformation on both sides from the word go, DownNative.

DownNative · 11/10/2023 21:31

Just to give people an indication of the misrepresentations, lies and pro-Hamas content some accounts are posting on Mumsnet.

This morning a user called UhohFibonacci posted this YouTube video clip from the Middle East Eye in a thread called "To Be Sickened By Hamas" in AIBU:

https://youtube.com/shorts/vrRe97wGFHA?si=N2FZT15bAD444UGb

They claimed this showed Palestinians protecting the woman and child in the video. But when you click on the link, the title states they're "Palestinian fighters".

When I challenged UhohFibonacci on why they left that detail out, they tried to claim the men in the video were Palestinian civilians not associated with Hamas who were protecting them.

Furthermore, they boasted I'll never be able to definitively prove the men in the clip were Hamas members.

Funnily enough, it has now been proven those men ARE Hamas terrorists and the woman in the clip is Shiri Silberman-Bibas and her children. They're hostages and definitely not being protected.

www.nbcnews.com/video/video-shows-hamas-gunmen-kidnap-shiri-silberman-bibas-and-her-children-194724933949

Always, Always be prepared to critically interrogate whatever anyone says or the videos they post.

Try NOT to be led by your emotions as propaganda is designed to work on you that way.

(THREAD 2) To ask if we can please try to have Palestine and Israel thread where we acknowledge how awful it is for everyone, but try not to throw shit at each other?
(THREAD 2) To ask if we can please try to have Palestine and Israel thread where we acknowledge how awful it is for everyone, but try not to throw shit at each other?
(THREAD 2) To ask if we can please try to have Palestine and Israel thread where we acknowledge how awful it is for everyone, but try not to throw shit at each other?
1dayatatime · 11/10/2023 21:16

A Palestinian explains Hamas:

ketchup07070 · 11/10/2023 20:55

cakeorwine · 11/10/2023 20:43

On previous threads, people have pointed out that Israel has in the past warned people when they were going to bomb somewhere.

It was mentioned by someone on Radio 4 today that this was no longer happening - which given the amount of bombing and missile activity, you can see why. There is a lot of bombing and artillery going on.

I don't know if anyone has any up to date information if this is still happening?

I don't know, but C4 news has just suggested Israel is using white phosphorous. The footage of bleeding babies and children in Gaza is terrible. We must all call for a ceasefire, we should not just watch.

DownNative · 11/10/2023 20:49

Takoneko · 11/10/2023 20:39

Transient conquest is different to settlement and annexation.

In 2019 Mike Pompeo announced that the US no longer considered Israeli settlements to be illegal under international law. The UN reasserted that they are illegal and the UN position on this had not changed.

That’s pretty recent. The principle underlying the UN position is that it is illegal to settle and/or annex territory gained in a war.

And what has the United Nations done about it?

Exactly. The UN's punitive measures are so insignificant States can ignore them.

Personally, I think the international community is gradually moving back to its earlier view that conquest is not illegal under International Law.

cakeorwine · 11/10/2023 20:43

On previous threads, people have pointed out that Israel has in the past warned people when they were going to bomb somewhere.

It was mentioned by someone on Radio 4 today that this was no longer happening - which given the amount of bombing and missile activity, you can see why. There is a lot of bombing and artillery going on.

I don't know if anyone has any up to date information if this is still happening?

Miri13 · 11/10/2023 20:43

All I know is that it’s a horrific situation and I’m not taking sides. My heart is breaking for all the innocent people on both sides that now have to suffer. It’s heartbreaking and unfortunately, I fear it will get worse :(

Takoneko · 11/10/2023 20:39

DownNative · 11/10/2023 20:16

It is the international community response that tends to inform international law, not the other way round.

But my point is that international law states this specific prohibition yet the punitive aspect is so insignificant that States can easily ignore it. In his paper entitled "The Re-Emergence of Conquest: International Law and the Legitimate Use of Force" published in the 2020 Liverpool Law Review, Michael Mulligan "speculates on the possibility that the re-emergence of conquest is further evidence that international society is reverting to a previous incarnation whereby Great Power politics is assuming its former pre-eminence, at the expense of the rules-based system which emerged after the Second World War."

Territorial Conquest hasn't always been regarded as illegal under International law, so the law itself can change at any point. This is the Realpolitik. It is not set in stone permanently.

The kind of territorial acquisition Israel, USA and UK have done in the last two decades is known as transient conquest in addition to pseudo-conquest. All three have demonstrated they are willing to hold territory temporarily, but willing to exchange it for something else at some point. For the USA and UK plus Allies as well as Israel, it was in exchange for dismantling of terrorist networks and developing a democratic society in those places.

Transient conquest is different to settlement and annexation.

In 2019 Mike Pompeo announced that the US no longer considered Israeli settlements to be illegal under international law. The UN reasserted that they are illegal and the UN position on this had not changed.

That’s pretty recent. The principle underlying the UN position is that it is illegal to settle and/or annex territory gained in a war.

Dolphin1111111111111111111111111 · 11/10/2023 20:38

.

(THREAD 2) To ask if we can please try to have Palestine and Israel thread where we acknowledge how awful it is for everyone, but try not to throw shit at each other?
DownNative · 11/10/2023 20:16

Takoneko · 11/10/2023 19:03

International response is a poor measure of legality or illegality. Realpolitik means that the world accepts all sorts of things that are illegal under international law.

You only have to look at the total lack of international response to the annexation of Crimea in 2014 to see that.

It is the international community response that tends to inform international law, not the other way round.

But my point is that international law states this specific prohibition yet the punitive aspect is so insignificant that States can easily ignore it. In his paper entitled "The Re-Emergence of Conquest: International Law and the Legitimate Use of Force" published in the 2020 Liverpool Law Review, Michael Mulligan "speculates on the possibility that the re-emergence of conquest is further evidence that international society is reverting to a previous incarnation whereby Great Power politics is assuming its former pre-eminence, at the expense of the rules-based system which emerged after the Second World War."

Territorial Conquest hasn't always been regarded as illegal under International law, so the law itself can change at any point. This is the Realpolitik. It is not set in stone permanently.

The kind of territorial acquisition Israel, USA and UK have done in the last two decades is known as transient conquest in addition to pseudo-conquest. All three have demonstrated they are willing to hold territory temporarily, but willing to exchange it for something else at some point. For the USA and UK plus Allies as well as Israel, it was in exchange for dismantling of terrorist networks and developing a democratic society in those places.

Takoneko · 11/10/2023 19:03

DownNative · 11/10/2023 18:19

In regards to international law and conquest of territory, Eugene Kontorovich of the Northwestern University School of Law did an interesting study in 2009 entitled "International Responses to Territorial Conquest" on this issue.

Main takeaways:

"While territorial conquest has been relatively infrequent in the post-World War II period, most conquests have not been condemned by the international community. Indeed, acceptance is as common as condemnation."

And:

"International condemnation is found in only a few cases. Other conquests have won overwhelming international acceptance; these interestingly include both conquests of entire nations. The majority of conquests receive no clear international response."

So, the response is not really clear irrespective of what the UN Charter says. In a punitive sense, its insignificant.

Edited

International response is a poor measure of legality or illegality. Realpolitik means that the world accepts all sorts of things that are illegal under international law.

You only have to look at the total lack of international response to the annexation of Crimea in 2014 to see that.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 11/10/2023 18:59

I'm wondering if the govt stops facilitating the expansion of these settlements, and even, withdraw those settlements from the West Bank, that we are more likely to see progress in this situation?

While Hamas exist I believe that's very unlikely

Any real difference may have to wait until they've been destroyed, and given that Israel honoured their commitment to withdraw from Gaza I see no reason to believe that movement on the dreadful settlements wouldn't also be possible ... but it'll have to be a negotiated agreement and Hamas clearly have no interest at all in these

Puzzledandpissedoff · 11/10/2023 18:53

JuvenileEmu · 09/10/2023 21:38

But how can this happen when Hamas won't make any kind of compromise whatsoever? They have made it quite clear that anything short of the destruction of Israel is unacceptable to them.

It can't, which is why the only viable answer is to get rid of Hamas and replace them with an administration willing to negotiate rather than just destroy and kill

And speaking of destruction it's been reported that Gaza's only power plant has now run out of fuel, so now the lights will be going off too

shellyleppard · 11/10/2023 18:40

Someone was selling a leaf.....from Tenerife..... for a £1,000!!!! I couldn't stop laughing

DownNative · 11/10/2023 18:19

Takoneko · 11/10/2023 17:29

I really can’t agree with this. “They” didn’t go to war and lose. Civilians don’t go to war, governments do… that’s why international law says you can’t “win” territory in a war. In 1948 Jordan, Egypt, Iraq, Syria and Lebanon went to war and lost, not the Palestinian people who had no say in the matter. Egypt and Jordan then kept the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza under occupation by their militaries for the best part of two decades.

In regards to international law and conquest of territory, Eugene Kontorovich of the Northwestern University School of Law did an interesting study in 2009 entitled "International Responses to Territorial Conquest" on this issue.

Main takeaways:

"While territorial conquest has been relatively infrequent in the post-World War II period, most conquests have not been condemned by the international community. Indeed, acceptance is as common as condemnation."

And:

"International condemnation is found in only a few cases. Other conquests have won overwhelming international acceptance; these interestingly include both conquests of entire nations. The majority of conquests receive no clear international response."

So, the response is not really clear irrespective of what the UN Charter says. In a punitive sense, its insignificant.

Takoneko · 11/10/2023 17:29

Poudretteite · 11/10/2023 08:12

OK, so it's justified that they went to war. (Although they are not 'from another country,' they were originally exiled, and were persecuted and genocided globally in other people's countries, that's the whole point)

They did go to war, and they lost. That's why they ended up with less than the original agreement. That's kind of how it works?

I really can’t agree with this. “They” didn’t go to war and lose. Civilians don’t go to war, governments do… that’s why international law says you can’t “win” territory in a war. In 1948 Jordan, Egypt, Iraq, Syria and Lebanon went to war and lost, not the Palestinian people who had no say in the matter. Egypt and Jordan then kept the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza under occupation by their militaries for the best part of two decades.

etmoietmoietmoi · 11/10/2023 09:26

piddocktrumperiness · 11/10/2023 08:37

I'd like to ask and would love for someone to help me understand:

  • Why does Netanyahu's govt still allow settlement expansion in the west bank?
  • What is the general consensus or feeling from Israelis on the settlements in the West Bank?
I'm wondering if the govt stops facilitating the expansion of these settlements, and even, withdraw those settlements from the West Bank, that we are more likely to see progress in this situation?

To answer your first question - because Netanyahu is a racist supremacist. I can't answer your second question because, despite being ethnically Jewish, I don't know people who live in the West Bank and have little to no connection with Israel. However a poster on another thread is demanding people like me should be making more of an effort to publicly denounce Israel.

I'm wondering if the govt stops facilitating the expansion of these settlements, and even, withdraw those settlements from the West Bank, that we are more likely to see progress in this situation?

Agreed.