Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grown adults screaming when excited... just WHY?

168 replies

peakyblenders · 09/10/2023 12:37

Inspired by last night's Big Brother - granted, people who go on Big Brother aren't exactly representative of the average person, but I'm noticing this in real life too and it bugs me no end.

I lost count of the number of times in last night's episode housemates randomly went 'AAAAAH!' for no reason whatsoever other than (presumably) being excited. Granted I'm an introvert, but I just can't understand why an adult would express excitement by screaming. Exclaiming loudly, yes, that's pretty standard. But that wordless 'AAAAAH!'? It truly baffles me.

This has been in the back of my mind lately because I feel I'm noticing it more in day-to-day life. I'm not talking young things in nightclubs, I'm seeing it in how people interact generally when excited. Example: I passed a woman on the street a few weeks ago who seemed to have spotted someone she knew and, as far as I could gather, hadn't seen in a while. She was clearly excited to see the other person, but instead of using actual words to express that she stood on the spot, assumed a position like she was laying an egg, and literally just went ‘AAAAAAAAAH!’ Then a very shrieky, huggy greeting as you'd maybe expect in the circumstances, but that initial ‘AAAAAAAAAH!’ totally bemused me. As does adults screaming in excitement generally. It just wouldn't occur to me to scream because I was excited.

AIBU to not get why grown adults do this?

OP posts:
WetBandits · 09/10/2023 15:41

AvengedQuince · 09/10/2023 15:31

It's not faux concern, I am autistic. If another autistic person genuinely can't help it, as in they would do it at a funeral, then fair enough!

This thread is about squealing when you are happy and excited. Do you often find funerals exciting?

newamsterdam · 09/10/2023 15:35

She does it because she chooses to.

AvengedQuince · 09/10/2023 15:31

WetBandits · 09/10/2023 15:00

Or, as she has said many times, she is autistic which has fuck all to do with maturity.

Also, it seems that many posters here are very performative with their faux concern for how screaming might affect ND people yet fail to consider that some ND people may scream/stim when they are excited.

It's not faux concern, I am autistic. If another autistic person genuinely can't help it, as in they would do it at a funeral, then fair enough!

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 09/10/2023 15:20

ProudMummyOfFour · 09/10/2023 12:47

Let people express excitement in the way they want to, mind your own business.

No. It is my business.

Passepartoute · 09/10/2023 15:20

Surely everyone let’s out a little scream (even a teeny, tiny eek) when something amazing has happened?
If not what do they do?

If you were to just get some amazing news like winning the lottery, winning a once in a lifetime opportunity holiday or finding out you’re pregnant after years of infertility, what would you do?

I'm actually more likely to be dumbstruck by something like that. At most I gasp a bit or say something like "Wow!". Definitely no shouting or screaming.

Passepartoute · 09/10/2023 15:18

Because they see it on TV and think it's normal.

1month · 09/10/2023 15:16

willWillSmithsmith · 09/10/2023 14:54

@1month I’m going to guess you are either a teenager or early twenties. Screaming at meeting a friend or other ‘excitable’ things that don’t really merit a scream don’t tend to be done by more mature adults. That’s not because they’re humourless or uptight, you just grow out of it, like any behaviour that is predominately the domain of children. It’s just a natural progression. I can get very excited about things but it doesn’t translate into screaming.

A squeal of delight isn’t the same as a performative scream.

I didn’t read you’re autistic until just now. Maybe that is why you have a different take on screaming when meeting a friend. People around you aren’t going to know so they’ll just feel the irritation of what seems like performative screaming/screeching.

Edited

But I’ve never said I’m loud with it, so what’s the harm?

You could be in the same shop as me and not even notice because I’m shouting my lungs out.

The posters who have said they scream have all said they don’t do it loudly, so who are we hurting?

Surely everyone let’s out a little scream (even a teeny, tiny eek) when something amazing has happened?
If not what do they do?

If you were to just get some amazing news like winning the lottery, winning a once in a lifetime opportunity holiday or finding out you’re pregnant after years of infertility, what would you do?

Most people would probably cry initially but then let out a scream, even if it’s a tiny one.

ChillysWaterBottle · 09/10/2023 15:12

ProudMummyOfFour · 09/10/2023 12:47

Let people express excitement in the way they want to, mind your own business.

Thank god someone said it early on.

Wtf is wrong with people on here.

FoleyHuck · 09/10/2023 15:10

stayathomer · 09/10/2023 12:39

I live so far away from my friends and family that if I saw someone I hadn’t seen in a while I’d scream too. It just comes out of some people- we can’t help it!!(sorry!🙈)

Agree with this. A while back on a casual night at the pub two of our friendship group who no longer live in the same country casually walked in, having arranged to come and surprise the rest of us for a weekend. Screaming ensued.

I wouldn't scream at someone I'm expecting to see, or am likely to see (ie: we live in the same place and I just bump into them).

katseyes7 · 09/10/2023 15:07

Grassy82 I agree with you 100%. I work in a supermarket, and the number of children who scream relentlessly is unbelievable.
I totally understand that some children have sensory issues/SEND. But I don't think it can possibly be every one of these screechers.
There appears to be a direct correlation between a lot of the screamers and the parents who either ignore them, and/or are glued to their phones.
I've talked to my sister in law (who teaches reception class) and she says this is an issue too. Reckons a lot of it's attention seeking. She tells them they can scream, but they should do it with their mouth shut "because there's a fly, and it might fly into your mouth if you keep it open."

MrsMarzetti · 09/10/2023 15:07

Always done by an attention seeking moron with the mental age of 3.

Pandor · 09/10/2023 15:04

I dislike it, but I guess the way we “perform” emotion in public is very culturally driven.

it makes me think of grief, and how in some cultures it wouldn’t be remarked upon for someone to scream and cry out, whereas in a typical English funeral people tend to keep it inside. I don’t think it means one person is grieving more than the other, but their cultures have guided them to demonstrate that grief in different ways.

The same is try (to an extent) with squealing. In some social circles it is not just tolerated but almost encouraged - if you don’t perform your excitement loudly enough people might start to question whether you are enjoying yourself. From there it is a small step to being the outsider, not part of the gang. So you mirror their performative screaming to stay included, to demonstrate your belonging (and emphasis the difference between the loud fun in-group and the dull staid out-group of bystanders).

lilyblue5 · 09/10/2023 15:04

gillywee · 09/10/2023 13:36

They do if it's the Sistene Chapel.

GrinGrinGrin

Only joined this thread to say this 🤣🤣🤣

WetBandits · 09/10/2023 15:00

willWillSmithsmith · 09/10/2023 14:54

@1month I’m going to guess you are either a teenager or early twenties. Screaming at meeting a friend or other ‘excitable’ things that don’t really merit a scream don’t tend to be done by more mature adults. That’s not because they’re humourless or uptight, you just grow out of it, like any behaviour that is predominately the domain of children. It’s just a natural progression. I can get very excited about things but it doesn’t translate into screaming.

A squeal of delight isn’t the same as a performative scream.

I didn’t read you’re autistic until just now. Maybe that is why you have a different take on screaming when meeting a friend. People around you aren’t going to know so they’ll just feel the irritation of what seems like performative screaming/screeching.

Edited

Or, as she has said many times, she is autistic which has fuck all to do with maturity.

Also, it seems that many posters here are very performative with their faux concern for how screaming might affect ND people yet fail to consider that some ND people may scream/stim when they are excited.

InvisibleDuck · 09/10/2023 14:57

I hate this. It's so childish and I've never felt the need to do it. I'm also sensitive to noise (autistic!) and if someone unexpectedly screams near me it makes me jump and is very unpleasant for me. To me, screaming is something you do if you're very frightened or in a lot of pain.

As a teenager I was incredibly embarrassed because a band visited our school and other girls followed them around screaming wordlessly. It reminded me of a pack of animals and made no sense at all. I'd much rather have exchanged a few words with one of the band members - it wasn't a performance, they were just walking around - but couldn't get anywhere close because of the screamy mob.

I don't think it's something everyone does! I once received some extremely good news via email - I gasped in surprise and was very smiley for a while. Screaming would have been a bizarre reaction. I do the flappy hands stim thing when I'm very happy too but only in private - and silently! - because I know others would find it odd.

Katypp · 09/10/2023 14:57

IncompleteSenten · 09/10/2023 12:50

I assume in that situation it's an affectation. A performance.

See also wide open mouth with hand in front of it, in the way you only used to see in cartoons.

Millybob · 09/10/2023 14:55

Oh god, the whooping and ululating and shrieking at the theatre - for even the most mediocre performance. It's literally painful if you're sitting next to one of them.
I agree with @grassy82. We didn't shriek like this even as children.
I was at a friend's degree ceremony - admittedly not at a prestigious university - and the parents were doing this.

willWillSmithsmith · 09/10/2023 14:54

@1month I’m going to guess you are either a teenager or early twenties. Screaming at meeting a friend or other ‘excitable’ things that don’t really merit a scream don’t tend to be done by more mature adults. That’s not because they’re humourless or uptight, you just grow out of it, like any behaviour that is predominately the domain of children. It’s just a natural progression. I can get very excited about things but it doesn’t translate into screaming.

A squeal of delight isn’t the same as a performative scream.

I didn’t read you’re autistic until just now. Maybe that is why you have a different take on screaming when meeting a friend. People around you aren’t going to know so they’ll just feel the irritation of what seems like performative screaming/screeching.

1month · 09/10/2023 14:53

I suppose we should be grateful that @1month doesn't have many exciting things happen to her, hence has few opportunities for performative screaming.

@PyramusandThisbe

Yes my life is very boring.

I guess every cloud has a silver lining 🤣🤣

AvengedQuince · 09/10/2023 14:48

If you would do it in church or similar then that's not a problem as that's a genuine reaction you can't control. If you wouldn't, then it's polite to consider others. Many people, especially ND people can't cope with sudden, high pitched noises.

SnowflakeCity · 09/10/2023 14:45

1month · 09/10/2023 13:44

Ahh that makes me so sad!

Go out and enjoy life.

Taking the stick out of your ass isn’t going to kill you.
You may even enjoy it 😁

Posts like this are what makes me think its performative. Look at me, I'm enjoying myself, I'm so much fun. It's very possible to enjoy yourself without screeching, other people might not know that oh my god this is the best thing ever, I'm having so much fun but I'm perfectly happy without strangers validation.

CleoCha0man · 09/10/2023 14:43

Newusernameforthiss · 09/10/2023 14:39

OK OK but you can shout "bravo" (alright "brava" for the pedants") at the opera can't you? At the end? Or scream "I love you Jarvis" at a Pulp concert?? Just at the end in the clapping bit? Definitely not screaming in the street but I would think effusive noise to praise a musical performance is OK?

Sorry everyone I've upset over the years but I just feel those hot baritones deserved my middle aged shrieking!?!?

Yes tbf and despite my comment above, I enjoyed a good whoop at a burlesque show I went to. Seemed very appropriate!

1month · 09/10/2023 14:43

anythinginapinch · 09/10/2023 14:36

Screaming and flapping hands, and that tippy tappy "dance", are what two year olds do when their birthday cake comes in.

In anyone else, it's just fucking annoying attention-seeking twattery.

Or it’s because I have autism.

But even if I didn’t, so what.
Why are you so judgemental over something that doesn’t affect you at all?

If someone is happy or excited and doing something, I’m not going to judge them for it.

As long as they’re not overly loud or rude, then who’s to say what is and isn’t acceptable behaviour.

As I’ve said there’s a big difference between obnoxious, over the top screaming which can be heard across the streets vs smaller screams that you do with your friends or because you’ve just got the job you were praying for.

CleoCha0man · 09/10/2023 14:40

I can't be doing with performative screaming either. I had someone do it recently at me at a dinner dance thing. I'd not seen her in a couple of years and she was quite pissed, and she did it right in my ear and nearly deafened me. I was quite started 😂

Newusernameforthiss · 09/10/2023 14:39

peakyblenders · 09/10/2023 12:55

Didn't realise Elgar got people so excited.

😄 😄 😄 😄

OK OK but you can shout "bravo" (alright "brava" for the pedants") at the opera can't you? At the end? Or scream "I love you Jarvis" at a Pulp concert?? Just at the end in the clapping bit? Definitely not screaming in the street but I would think effusive noise to praise a musical performance is OK?

Sorry everyone I've upset over the years but I just feel those hot baritones deserved my middle aged shrieking!?!?