Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

is dp reasonable to not want to continue dating because I won’t take off my bra?

264 replies

ReeseRose · 09/10/2023 10:36

namechanged for obvious reasons and going to try and keep this short. I lost a lot of weight some years ago now, it was a couple years before I met dp (I guess my boyfriend but that sounds extremely juvenile) who I have been with for 6 months but known for almost 2 years. I had abdominal skin removed before we started dating and honestly I am definitely still full of imperfections and my boobs are very deflated (I’m in my 20s so it’s definitely a big insecurity) so I have always kept a bra on. He’s never been a fan of that but tries to be understanding the thing is, he’s made it worse by always complimenting them in a bra/clothes like they obviously look completely different to if they weren’t and I don’t think he understands how bad they may look and therefore it’s making it even worse for me. I will honestly have them lifted (no implants) soon but he’s going on about how he doesn’t actually think it’s necessary based on “how they look in a bra” WELL NO SHIT. I just don’t want the self esteem crush of getting them out and him agreeing with me or something. Plus; it would just make me feel uncomfortable. Am I being unreasonable though? Like is this a dealbreaker to most men? I think he should just accept it how it is because I don’t see how it’s the biggest deal in the world, especially when lingerie is known to be attractive and perfectly reasonable to wear in the bedroom.

OP posts:
theduchessofspork · 09/10/2023 12:12

@ReeseRose

actually I would edit your original post to add that you’ve lost 220 pounds, as a lot of people are just reading that and not getting it

Mirabai · 09/10/2023 12:11

What he’s really saying is that he can’t cope with an intimate relationship with a woman who cant be naked with him. That’s ok. But it’s equally ok to say you don’t want to take your bra off for the moment.

You both have your boundaries they just don’t match.

5128gap · 09/10/2023 12:10

Mari9999 · 09/10/2023 11:58

@JaxiiTaxii

There is no blackmail involved here, there is only a statement of different perspectives and expectations by 2 people.

What exactly do you view as the terms of the blackmail? The OP may walk away. He may walk away. If the OP says that she will leave if he insists on seeing her breast , is that blackmail, or is it just a statement of her intent? If he says that he will leave if she does not, is that not just a statement of his intent?

The 2'people have agency over their own actions, how is that in any way, shape, or form any kind of blackmail?

The difference is that one person (him) is using the relationship as leverage to coerce the other into doing something they don't want to do.
The other (the OP) would be merely exiting a situation where someone was trying to coerce her. Blackmail is a threat to extort gain (seeing her breasts). The OP is not trying to gain anything from him, merely protecting what is already hers by right, her privacy and bodily autonomy.

theduchessofspork · 09/10/2023 12:09

Neither of you are being unreasonable - you both feel how you feel and have good reasons to do so.

Well done on such a tremendous weight loss. Do you have a plan/date to get your boobs lifted? If that’s your only issue - ie you take off your clothes other than your bra, then this is one case where surgery might sort it without recourse to therapy.

Some posters haven’t clocked that you lost 220 pounds or what that means for lose skin.

Good luck with it all - if this relationship does end, it’s not the end of the world.

Whattodo112222 · 09/10/2023 12:05

Sadly, you don't sound compatible.
You do have complex self esteem issues though OP.
No relationship you have will work until you've addressed that.

Heyhoherewegoagain · 09/10/2023 12:02

BittIeLastard · 09/10/2023 10:46

You both have valid points. And if the points don't agree then yes its a deal breaker.

Genuine question, are they honestly down to your belly button?

Edited

They very possibly are…I’ve just stood in front of a mirror with my top half naked and my nipples are about an inch higher than mine. As with OP, I’m an e up but it’s skin rather than actual breast tissue which fills my bra

BettyPhuckzer · 09/10/2023 12:01

Malificent1 · 09/10/2023 10:58

The responses on this thread! My god. Bottom line, your body, your choice.

Any dickhead telling me he was going to break up with me because he couldn’t see my tits would be dropped so fast his head would spin. What a prince.

This

You should be dumping HIM if he can't be understanding about this issue

It's obviously huge for you

He should care enough to get it

Roughashouses · 09/10/2023 12:00

Take your bra off or I'll leave you. Sounds pretty blackmaily to me.

Mari9999 · 09/10/2023 11:58

@JaxiiTaxii

There is no blackmail involved here, there is only a statement of different perspectives and expectations by 2 people.

What exactly do you view as the terms of the blackmail? The OP may walk away. He may walk away. If the OP says that she will leave if he insists on seeing her breast , is that blackmail, or is it just a statement of her intent? If he says that he will leave if she does not, is that not just a statement of his intent?

The 2'people have agency over their own actions, how is that in any way, shape, or form any kind of blackmail?

HandbagMarinara · 09/10/2023 11:57

SylvieLaufeydottir · 09/10/2023 10:45

He wants to be, you know, intimate with you. And I don't mean sex. I mean open with each other, vulnerable with each other. Sharing the parts of yourselves that you're insecure about so you can be fully yourself, accepted, safe.

It's not unreasonable for him to decide that if you can't or won't do that he can't be with you. Longer term, all of our bodies degrade. A relationship that's based solely on perky tits is no relationship at all.

And swap removing bra for anal sex. Is it still acceptable then?

saffronsoup · 09/10/2023 11:57

He can certainly decide that your issues make the two of you incompatible. Just like if he had insecurities that meant you had never seen him naked, never seen his penis and he would only have sex with his boxers on - you might decide that those issues were not healthy for you.

Major insecurities that impact the other person and the relationship often tend to lead to the end of a relationship.

He needs to decide if he is okay with your issues or not. If they aren't healthy for him and he is seeing the relationship as unhealthy, then he should end it. It is clearly something he has communicated to you and that you do not wish to change. He now gets to decide what he wants to do about it.

Heyhoherewegoagain · 09/10/2023 11:56

ReeseRose · 09/10/2023 10:44

@ShellySarah wow you have no idea what it’s like to lose 220 pounds and have the skin left. None at all, of course he would have bloody noticed. They are down to my belly button for gods sake

I know EXACTLY what it’s like because I’ve done it over the last 2 years with almost identical numbers, and probably have similar skin issues. I frame it as the loose skin and non existent breasts are a million times better than the smooth skin and full boobs that I used to have…my partner has absolute ZERO issues with it as he sees the whole package, and the increased confidence in every other area. I’m not having skin removal surgery.

Oh and bloody well done, unless you’ve been in this position with extreme weightloss, you don’t know that it’s almost more about the head stuff than the body stuff, and having the (in my case) size 12 body doesn’t suddenly wipe out the head stuff

ChampagneLassie · 09/10/2023 11:56

Neither of you is being unreasonable. If he’s decent and loves you then it should be a supportive experience. If he’s not then you’ll get rid of him. But if you won’t share yourself with him then you’ll never know. Equally it’s a barrier to relationship progressing so I can see why he’d want to be with someone more open. A friend of mine would never let men see her naked (lights off only) and that killed many a relationship for her. I suppose you’ve got to decide what’s better to loose, show him and potentially deepen your relationship or loose the relationship without trying

Pr1mr0se · 09/10/2023 11:51

Please seek some counseling. You shouldn't feel like this about your own body. A partner who loves you will be supportive of you and will make you feel good about yourself - including feeling good naked.

PyramusandThisbe · 09/10/2023 11:49

1month · 09/10/2023 11:42

I completely understand where you’re coming from and I think some posters don’t understand what boobs look like after a massive weight loss or after BF multiple kids.

But I also understand where he’s coming from as I would feel upset that I couldn’t see my DP naked and would feel that him being so uncomfortable around me means that’s he’s not as into me as I am off him.

If it was me I would compromise.
Tell him you aren’t going to take your bra off when you have sex, else you won’t be able to enjoy the sex but you don’t mind taking it off in front of him when you’re getting changed etc.

He just wants you to be open and comfortable around him, which is fair enough but unless someone has ever been insecure about something they can’t ever understand how you truly feel.

I perfectly understand how the OP feels, but it's her boyfriend's choice whether he wants to deal with this level of insecurity/body issues etc in a fairly new relationship.

I think it’s unreasonable to comment that my self esteem issues are extreme. It’s difficult losing so much weight and being left in a body of a 90 year old lady in your 20s. It doesn’t mean I’m just a walking anxiety ridden person who can’t function in their body because of how I feel. Counselling isn’t going to change the fact I have boobs of a 90 year old in my 20s and I’m pretty confident most people wouldn’t exactly be jumping at the idea of someone seeing them and clearly never being able to find them sexy. It just is what it is.

yes, he has said if it continues like this, he doesn’t think the relationship can continue

Not unreasonable for you to feel any of this, but he has a perfect right to decide that this isn't something he wants to deal with.

I certainly wouldn't have wanted to deal with significant body issues in a new relationship in my 20s. It would be a different matter in a longterm relationship where I already loved and was committed to the person.

Cosycardigans · 09/10/2023 11:49

I'm on your side OP. Imagine if the man had a life changing scar somewhere which he kept covered up and OP was saying she would leave the relationship, if he didn't show her before surgery to improve it, next year.

Niinja · 09/10/2023 11:49

I think it's ok for you to split up over this. But your future together would not look any brighter if you took off your bra for him. Giving in to blackmail is never a solid foundation for a relationship.

YANBU to draw your own boundaries and keep private whatever parts of your body you wish. He is free to decide that touching naked boobs is a non-negotiable for him and therefore you're not the right person for him. What is not OK is this blackmail thing - show them to me or else.

ThinWomansBrain · 09/10/2023 11:46

Wow, huge congratulations on losing so much weight.

It makes me feel so sad that you are still adversely affected by your body image, but I hope that you get to a place where you feel more comfortable with your body.

1month · 09/10/2023 11:42

I completely understand where you’re coming from and I think some posters don’t understand what boobs look like after a massive weight loss or after BF multiple kids.

But I also understand where he’s coming from as I would feel upset that I couldn’t see my DP naked and would feel that him being so uncomfortable around me means that’s he’s not as into me as I am off him.

If it was me I would compromise.
Tell him you aren’t going to take your bra off when you have sex, else you won’t be able to enjoy the sex but you don’t mind taking it off in front of him when you’re getting changed etc.

He just wants you to be open and comfortable around him, which is fair enough but unless someone has ever been insecure about something they can’t ever understand how you truly feel.

Kisskiss · 09/10/2023 11:42

ReeseRose · 09/10/2023 10:42

I think it’s unreasonable to comment that my self esteem issues are extreme. It’s difficult losing so much weight and being left in a body of a 90 year old lady in your 20s. It doesn’t mean I’m just a walking anxiety ridden person who can’t function in their body because of how I feel. Counselling isn’t going to change the fact I have boobs of a 90 year old in my 20s and I’m pretty confident most people wouldn’t exactly be jumping at the idea of someone seeing them and clearly never being able to find them sexy. It just is what it is.

yes, he has said if it continues like this, he doesn’t think the relationship can continue

If he’s serious about wanting to dump you because you won’t take your bra off then it’s a massive red flag and you should dump him now. He’s showing very little empathy and support for your reasons tbh

ReadingSoManyThreads · 09/10/2023 11:41

ReeseRose · 09/10/2023 11:07

I’m hoping the breast lift will honestly be done next year, I’m saving still. He has said he gets it will be temporary but feels hard done by that even when that’s done and he can see those, he will never have seen my “actual boobs” I’ve told him I’m only having them lifted and they are no different to calling what I have not my actual boobs either considering all the skin and he just seems annoyed that I’m not comfortable to show them now

I think any man who gets annoyed at not being able to see their partner's body parts, particularly after pressuring them about a part that they are uncomfortable about, is not a man to stay with.

I actually think YOU should end it with HIM.

fivenonrouses · 09/10/2023 11:41

JaxiiTaxii · 09/10/2023 11:39

Anyone who blackmails someone into doing something through threats of leaving unless you do what they want is IMO abusive. It's your body, it's not a democracy where he gets a say, it's a dictatorship and only you get to chose.

BUT I can understand that it would hurt that someone you love won't share themselves with you because they're scared of your reaction. It's pretty much saying you think they're shallow and only want you for your appearance.

Only you can sift through which of these apply to your boyfriend, but IMO anyone who would throw away a loving, supportive, otherwise healthy relationship because their partner has an isolated issue with one body part which affects nothing except seeing that body part naked, is an idiot.

Forcing someone to stay in a relationship and expecting them to handle the burden of whatever you have been through in the past, to me, is abusive.

At 6 months imo you'll still testing the waters.

Fionaville · 09/10/2023 11:41

I get everything you've said OP. Honestly though, I think you should just go for it and get your boobs out for him. You are denying him the chance to show that he loves every part of you. What's the worst that can happen? He's disgusted by your boobs and can't bring himself to stay in a relationship with you? I really don't think that's going to happen. But so what if it did? You are disgusted in your own boobs and think that they are a relationship breaker.
Or he'll agree that you need surgery? Again, so what? You already think you do and plan to anyway.
Just give him the chance to show that he loves every part of you. He might be hurt that you think hes so shallow. And skin to skin contact is so much better than wearing underwear to bed.

JaxiiTaxii · 09/10/2023 11:39

Anyone who blackmails someone into doing something through threats of leaving unless you do what they want is IMO abusive. It's your body, it's not a democracy where he gets a say, it's a dictatorship and only you get to chose.

BUT I can understand that it would hurt that someone you love won't share themselves with you because they're scared of your reaction. It's pretty much saying you think they're shallow and only want you for your appearance.

Only you can sift through which of these apply to your boyfriend, but IMO anyone who would throw away a loving, supportive, otherwise healthy relationship because their partner has an isolated issue with one body part which affects nothing except seeing that body part naked, is an idiot.

Daffodil18 · 09/10/2023 11:38

I understand your point of view however even if he agrees with you, if he is loving and supportive then he will be there for you, because you’ve said you are going to have surgery on them anyway.