Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

is dp reasonable to not want to continue dating because I won’t take off my bra?

264 replies

ReeseRose · 09/10/2023 10:36

namechanged for obvious reasons and going to try and keep this short. I lost a lot of weight some years ago now, it was a couple years before I met dp (I guess my boyfriend but that sounds extremely juvenile) who I have been with for 6 months but known for almost 2 years. I had abdominal skin removed before we started dating and honestly I am definitely still full of imperfections and my boobs are very deflated (I’m in my 20s so it’s definitely a big insecurity) so I have always kept a bra on. He’s never been a fan of that but tries to be understanding the thing is, he’s made it worse by always complimenting them in a bra/clothes like they obviously look completely different to if they weren’t and I don’t think he understands how bad they may look and therefore it’s making it even worse for me. I will honestly have them lifted (no implants) soon but he’s going on about how he doesn’t actually think it’s necessary based on “how they look in a bra” WELL NO SHIT. I just don’t want the self esteem crush of getting them out and him agreeing with me or something. Plus; it would just make me feel uncomfortable. Am I being unreasonable though? Like is this a dealbreaker to most men? I think he should just accept it how it is because I don’t see how it’s the biggest deal in the world, especially when lingerie is known to be attractive and perfectly reasonable to wear in the bedroom.

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 09/10/2023 12:56

I am torn. I don’t think anyone should be able to demand to see you naked but at the same time seeing someone naked is part of the intimacy of a relationship. Also not letting them see you naked suggests a lack of trust and not being fully comfortable them. This is a perfectly acceptable reason for him to want to end things:

Timewentfast · 09/10/2023 12:55

OP I completely understand. I'm old now but when I was a young thing around your age I had huge insecurities. My breasts were large, firm, nicely shaped but with quite severe stretch marks which made me hate them. I understand the thing about men are expecting one thing based on what you look like with clothes/bra and then what they look like naked.

Mine was easier to deal with than yours and much easier to manage.

If this man is demanding to see them or he is off then the relationship is over anyway. Nobody that gives you an ultimatum is ever going to make you feel safe, valued and loved. It doesn't matter what the subject matter is. Ultimatums cause resentment and fear and broken bonds.

I completely understand your feelings of embarrassment and worry. It sounds like if you took your bra off you wouldn't enjoy sex anyway as you would be far too tense.

There is always going to be things in a relationship that you don't want to do (or your partner does not want to do). If he's the one for you, he will accept you for who you are. If he's not the one for you he will push you to do things you don't want to.

You have explained the stress and anxiety you are feeling re your breasts. Even if it is 'expected' for men to see them during sex you have made your feelings clear. He either accepts this or leaves.

Would it help to show him pictures of a person who has lost a lot of weight and what it has done to their breasts? I'm sure google would have something similar you could show him which would give him an idea of what you are talking about without actually showing him?

Other ideas that came to mind is there anyway to give 'access' without fully seeing them. So a sexy push up but low cut bra where he could access the nipple without removing the bra?

There is no clear cut answer here. You say you love him and want to stay with him but do you still feel safe and loved here? I am guessing he will either accept it or leave or you will either show him or break up with him. Only you can decide what to do but you have my heartfelt sympathies.
Only someone who has had huge insecurities can understand how it effects you.

I wish you luck whatever you decide.

Mrsttcno1 · 09/10/2023 12:52

ReeseRose · 09/10/2023 12:36

I am not sure why it’s being compared to hiding from him after a pregnancy or something. The way your body changes from a pregnancy is very different to losing over 15 stone, it just is! I’m not taking away how women feel after babies either; but it’s not like because I hated the over 14 lbs of loose skin I had on my stomach, I’d not let him see me after carrying a baby

This is because the way your body looks after weight loss is actually extremely similar to how your body looks after carrying a child and very similar to how your boobs look after feeding a child- saggy, droopy, a lot of loose skin, add to that the intense hormones of post partum and it really is basically the same.

If you continue to look at your imperfections as something that needs to be “fixed” then that’s also how you will feel looking at your pregnant or post baby body as it will not look how it looks now.

You will spend all of the money getting your boobs “fixed” now, but after you carry a child and potentially breastfeed, they will likely look again how they do now, are you going to get another boob job then? If not, are you not going to let him see them again then? Your boobs sag, they droop, your nipples grow and darken- if you maintain this attitude of not showing your partner anything that isn’t perfect then you’re going to feel the same way after a baby.

Being a true partner is being there for the good, the bad and the downright ugly. Give him a chance to be a partner to you, discuss honestly with him how you feel. If you only ever share the good bits with your partner, you can bet that relationship won’t last because the “good bits” don’t last either.

5128gap · 09/10/2023 12:51

No @saffronsoup he is threatening her with leaving if he can't see her breasts. Like some adolescent boy, seeing a woman's naked breasts is more important to him than the woman herself.
The OP has explained perfectly reasonably why this is off the table at the moment. She, like all women is entitled to reveal as much or as little of her body as she chooses, to whoever she pleases, and doesn't need to be steered into therapy to have her 'issues addressed' to ensure that ties in with what a man wants to see of her.
If seeing her breasts is more important than all the other things the OP brings to the table and he wants to leave, then he is free to just do so. Instead he is staying around trying to persuade the OP to let him have what he wants at the expense of what she wants.
You can attribute higher minded concerns about not wanting a partner with low self esteem all you like, the odds are he's simply pressuring her because he wants to look at her breasts.

User63847439572 · 09/10/2023 12:50

OP I see where you’re coming from but you might be pleasantly surprised and maybe he just won’t care!
as a first step have you tried just getting (or letting him get) one of both out of the cup while you’re still wearing your bra? Then he can see and touch your nipples but the underwire underneath still gives some lift
how would you feel about him if he had some sort of scar or body issue? I bet it wouldn’t change how you felt about him, loving someone is about loving their whole selves as they are

Llloydwells · 09/10/2023 12:49

To be fair OP, 6m isn't long and during your 20's a big aspect of dating is fun. I think it's fair enough of him to decide so soon and so young that an aspect of your relationship isn't working for him.

If this situation arose after you'd been together much longer then my view would be different.

OrlandointheWilderness · 09/10/2023 12:49

It sounds like to him it isn't a sexual aspect - more he feels like you aren't opening up to true intimacy and trusting him. If he feels you are always guarded around him I can understand why he feels that way tbh. Why not try? Let him see them, in a non sexual way and take it from there?!

Coyoacan · 09/10/2023 12:49

I just want to say, OP, congratulations on losing all that weight. That is incredible. You have obviously done an awful amount of work on yourself to lose all that weight and keep it off.

But, not being able to touch your breasts must be very frustrating for your bf

StorminanDcup · 09/10/2023 12:48

At 6 months in I’d let this one go OP.
We don’t owe anyone full, unfiltered access to any parts of ourselves - mentally or physically.

You are still on a long journey of self discovery and acceptance and whilst it sounds like he has been fairly supportive, he is pushing at a boundary you have set and you’re not ready to adjust yet.

We all have “no go areas” - some are physical, some mental or emotional. We don’t owe our partners - or anyone - unlimited access to the parts of us we haven’t made peace with.

You don’t have to be forced into revealing parts of you you’re not comfortable with on the threat of being left.

If that’s his reasoning then let him go. Maybe he feels like you don’t trust him not to judge but somehow it has shown you more about his character hasn’t it. That he is happy to push your boundary to satisfy / validate himself. That is the kicker.

Congratulations on your achievement OP. Listen to that voice of determination that got you this far and do what you know is right for you!

Boating123 · 09/10/2023 12:48

Firstly well done for losing so much weight. That must have been hard.

I would say you don't want to end it and when the excess skin has been removed you'll take your bra off but it's not coming off until then.

Mirabai · 09/10/2023 12:47

No she does not have to show him her boobs. No obligation whatsoever there. But equally he’s not obliged to stay with partner who declines to get naked with him.

Startingagainandagain · 09/10/2023 12:46

OP, I am quite shocked by the all the critical comments.

It is obvious that it is something that has deeply affected you. People should try to understand that.

Frankly a man who knows you are struggling with this part of your body and who decides to leave because of it is not worth dating. You are more than just a pair of tits...

Pinkdelight3 · 09/10/2023 12:45

*him being a 'boob man', would be enough for me to end it.

He can go and find himself Miss Perfect Boobs elsewhere.*

He didn't say he was a boob man, did he? OP is describing him as that because she knows him, same as any of us could say what our DPs liked, and lots of them like boobs. Doesn't make him some boob man bastard on the hunt for Miss Perfect Boobs ffs.

ReeseRose · 09/10/2023 12:44

@Carpediemmakeitcount we are intimate extremely often! And have a good sex life, it’s literally just the whole boob/bra issue that’s a problem. He touches them over a bra…

I also think saying I’m not ready for a relationship is meh. I’ve spent my whole life realising I wasn’t ready for a relationship and had to end things with 2 people I really liked (didn’t even kiss) because I knew it would never work. I feel completely fine in this relationship! We share so much together and do loads, even when it comes to being intimate, I’m not acting completely insecure etc. it’s literally just the fact I don’t want them out dangling about and he can’t even grab them because of what they are actually like, like it’s bad, really bad. It’s not going to be what he imagines because they aren’t what you’d expect when in a bra. It’s not that I’m not ready for a relationship surely? There’s more to a relationship than having your boobs out

OP posts:
Stopbloodybanging · 09/10/2023 12:43

Ultimately you to have to show him your boobs. If he dumps you because he doesn’t like them, he’s not the man you should be with. If he accepts you and loves you regardless, you can relax and it might help you accept your body more.
Do you think that maybe the relationship is not strong enough? I don’t say that lightly, but you don’t trust him not to go off you when he sees your boobs and he’s said he’s unwilling to stick it out. Although to me this sounds like he’s just doing his best to convince you that he loves you as you are. The leaving threat might be just a very clumsy attempt to get you to do it, then he can reassure you that he loves you and the shape of your boobs don’t matter to him.
You can’t force him to be happy for you to always wear your bra, just as he can’t force you to do something you’re uncomfortable with. Someone will have to compromise or the relationship is doomed.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 09/10/2023 12:42

ReeseRose · 09/10/2023 12:32

Thank you for all the opinions.

I suppose in my mind I do understand the fact he wants me to feel comfortable with him and not feel like I need to hide etc but I also wish he could understand that it’s something I am actually going to be getting fixed (I’d have had it with the first surgery if I was allowed but due to needing an FDL tummy tuck I just had too much skin to be removed + my blood results were a bit iffy) and it’s not something forever. It feels like that’s just not good enough because he has taken it personally already but also because he feels like he should get to see what they’re like now because he’s my partner. I don’t know, I just feel a bit sad that he’s making it such a big deal to the point he has to throw in about leaving and I must admit that is putting me off a bit especially when this isn’t a forever situation.

I know it’s quite a short relationship at 6 months but I think based on living my life so big and insecure and never having other relationships before him (this is my first) it feels quite important and special to me. He’s actually a bit insecure himself but not about his body but will be a bit anxious in public with things like sometimes we are somewhere and I may have to ask or order or something if he is having a bad day, so it’s not like he has no issues himself and so I feel he should really be understanding here. I do really love him though, we get on really well apart from this so I don’t know. Not to be crude but he’s definitely more of a boob person which is maybe why it doesn’t help

Him throwing in about leaving over it and him being a 'boob man', would be enough for me to end it.

He can go and find himself Miss Perfect Boobs elsewhere.

This guy will just continue to make you feel uncomfortable and insecure.

Bigcat25 · 09/10/2023 12:40

Dishwashersaurous · 09/10/2023 10:40

I don't think it's fair on him to be in a relationship with someone who clearly has complex self esteem issues.

This is never going to be a healthy relationship.

Work on yourself, mentally, to be content in your body, and then and only then start thinking about dating.

I think some of these comments are a bit harsh on op. I've seen where op is coming from as I used to work as a bra fitter. The loose skin in pants, etc, is a drag bc it does get in the way and op is young. She also worked hard to loose weight but doesn't get as much of a positive outcome as you might expect.

All I'm trying to say is wanting to remove some of that surgically doesn't mean she has low self esteem.

As far as the boyfriend goes, I would maybe show him a picture of someone with similar breasts so he knows what to expect, so his reaction is slightly less personal and he can be prepared. It is valid I'd he wants that part of intimacy but he should give you time.

Good luck op. Sometimes drs do recommend implants instead of a lift as there can be less scarring but I think I'd do the same thing. A word of caution is that something similar can happen with pregnancy and nursing, I think skipping breast feeding can help with that from what I've seen in my work.

Pinkdelight3 · 09/10/2023 12:40

I do understand the fact he wants me to feel comfortable with him and not feel like I need to hide etc but I also wish he could understand that it’s something I am actually going to be getting fixed

I feel like this sums it up really well OP - these two things are both reasonable but incompatible stances. Your concern is getting it fixed, his concern is not about whether it needs fixing or not but about trust/being comfortable with him as you are. So you can't really understand each other and this is the friction and surgery won't fix that. It will however help with your own issue so I think you have to focus on that if it's your priority and let him go if he needs to.

LoobyDop · 09/10/2023 12:39

Menora · 09/10/2023 10:50

I think this about trust really. He doesn’t feel that you trust him enough to like you the way you are. It’s not clear if he’s giving you enough reassurance or if there is any point but sounds like he’s trying? He’s saying he likes the way you look. He wants to be intimate with you. I’m not sure I really blame either of you, you are both totally entitled to feel the way you each do. You shouldn’t do anything you do not want to and he shouldn’t force you, however he may also feel like it’s not going anywhere if there are barriers so perhaps it has run it’s course? I do think he maybe could be more tactful but it’s clearly causing a huge issue.

You are deciding what he thinks of your boobs and in a relationship that’s not going to work. He makes up his own mind. You can’t decide he will feel repulsed by you when he really doesn’t. However you don’t have to take your bra off if you don’t feel comfortable enough

I agree with this. Neither of you are wrong, and you certainly shouldn’t feel bullied into doing something you aren’t comfortable with. But the fact that you aren’t comfortable with it after six months, that you don’t trust him enough to let your guard down, suggests that the relationship isn’t right.

80s · 09/10/2023 12:39

there’s no denying he can’t understand what my boobs actually look like
Perhaps bite the bullet and give him a really honest, no-holds-barred description?

After just 6 months, I don't think he can expect you to trust him implicitly.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 09/10/2023 12:38

Are you intimate with him?

saffronsoup · 09/10/2023 12:37

Is he allowed to touch your breasts (over or under your bra) or are they off limits to him?

ReeseRose · 09/10/2023 12:36

I am not sure why it’s being compared to hiding from him after a pregnancy or something. The way your body changes from a pregnancy is very different to losing over 15 stone, it just is! I’m not taking away how women feel after babies either; but it’s not like because I hated the over 14 lbs of loose skin I had on my stomach, I’d not let him see me after carrying a baby

OP posts:
Fatcat00 · 09/10/2023 12:36

he can end it for whatever reason he’d like tbh op. It would get on my nerves too. But it’s also entirely your choice which means you are not compatible.

I had my boobs done when I was 19 as they were saggy and smaller than I’d like. I had a tummy tuck and lipo at 26 after a C section. I’ve since had further lipo. I have veneers I have fillers in every area of my face and Botox (all of these things no one knows I have and can’t believe when I say xyz isn’t natural) - all of this will never fix a self esteem issue as there’s always something else you’d like to change. I have quite high self esteem (and yes I do before anyone says I only had these things done as I had low self esteem). My point being, I have these things as I love how it looks and yes I think I look amazing for it all, however I do have flaws that I know wouldn’t be fixed by surgery.

Likening it to your situation, it sounds as though you will need surgery AND therapy. As the feeling of your before will stay with you anyway.

best of luck op.

SatsumaNightmare · 09/10/2023 12:35

OP, have you sat down and had the conversation with him about how you feel about yourself and how serious this is to you? I don’t mean flippant comments when he says he wants to see, b it a genuine conversation? Because I think if you’ve done that and he’s still pushing then he’s not a very nice person.

I completely understand why he wants to see, but if he truly understands, from your perspective, how bad you feel, and that you are doing things to address that so therefore there will be s time when you will be more comfortable, then he needs to back the hell off.