Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Difficult neighbour or am I being a tiger mum?

238 replies

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 10:26

Genuinely can’t see the wood for the trees here so hoping for your thoughts.
Lived in same semi detached house for nearly 10 years, at first neighbour who I’m attached to was friendly but fairly quickly I realised we are quite different so kept polite distance (one of many examples was when she asked for my help to talk to a bordering neighbour garden about their new trees overlooking her house and she wanted support to do this so I agreed, but when we got there it was a very different conversation to what I thought we were going to have, she was verbally aggressive and rude to this poor lady and I stood there mortified, and later went round with flowers to apologise and say had I known that’s what she was going to do / say I wouldn’t have come with he).
fast forward 7 years and I’m now on my own here with 2 kids, one of whom has autism and sensory needs. He offloads by playing basketball in the front which I make sure is only for 20-30 mins at a time and never past 7pm or before 7am. He does meltdown in and outside house about 1-2 times a day with screeching / shouting / hitting himself/ stimming which most of my neighbours know about and kindly “ignore” as he becomes more distressed with input from people talking at him when melting down. He does need to be outside at these points as inside he is a risk to his little sister and smashes things so I was advised to let him be outside for these meltdowns which last around 15 mins.

over the last year it’s become nearly impossible with my Neighbour, every day there’s a new problem she arrives at my door to talk about: my son making noise, her music students not liking walking past our house if my son is outside (she works from home teaching music) our dog walking past her driveway and setting off the ring door bell, my working from home and she can hear my calls through kitchen wall (this feels unlikely but even if true I can’t not work from home), my bins not being in the right place, and then finally my straw broke so to speak when she arrived at my door when I was mid-work call to say my son had sworn outside (to himself, not at her) when she was walking past with a friend and she wants me to stop the anti social behaviour. I was pretty short with her, explaining I was working and that my son is 10, has autism and does meltdown and I manage that as best I can, he’s in the house 7pm - 7am at least so he can’t bother the neighbours but she just kept going until I had to shut the door on her. I’ve woken up to a note saying she’s installing cctv and will be recording the disturbance from my son and general noise. I feel really upset by it as I try my best, I know my son is challenging but he’s not challenging her, it’s all on my property (Albeit attached to her) but I just hoped for some understanding that it’s not easy and I do the best I can.
what do I do now? I’ve tried being nice, made all the accommodations I think I can, and now I feel relations have completely deteriorated and I simply don’t know what else I can do. I don’t like the idea of cctv recording but it’s her property so 🤷‍♀️

i feel like she’s making me out to be a shameless Style family with a single mum and unruly kids but I try my best. What, if anything, should i do? Thank you 🙏

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TheYearOfSmallThings · 09/10/2023 12:04

FlowFle · 09/10/2023 11:05

don't be ridiculous. OP can't supervise her 10 year old son everytime he goes outside

No, you are being ridiculous. If he has special needs, uncontrollable meltdowns, and is out swearing at or near people passing by, she absolutely needs to supervise him. Obviously.

wildwestpioneer · 09/10/2023 11:57

I'd stop engaging with her, if she comes to the house simply ask her to put her complaint in writing, each and every time, then shut the door.

That way you have a record of all the instances. Also keep a diary of every time she speaks to you.

It sounds like you are managing your ds as best as anyone could given the circumstances.

You need to keep a record of her engagement with you whilst keeping a distance. Also as a pp said, keep a record of her comings and goings - just in case

SparkyBlue · 09/10/2023 11:45

OP she sounds like a pain in the arse take no notice of her. I can guarantee you if her issue wasn't with your son making noise or your work calls it would be something else. That type always find something to complain about. I've an eight year old with autism and while I'm blessed he doesn't have meltdowns he is sensory seeking and in his case he needs to run. For those saying your son shouldn't make noise I'm genuinely very very interested to know how OP should get her son to have a quiet meltdown. I'm sure all parents with children who frequently have meltdowns would also love this piece of information.

ownedbymydog · 09/10/2023 11:44

I think YOU are being very tolerant of HER behavior. You simply cannot do anymore for her, literally NOTHING is going to appease her because she is just that sort of person. Please use your back garden as it was intended, take a deep breath and adopt the bright and breezy no-nonsense approach with this bully. You have more important things to deal with.

muddyford · 09/10/2023 11:40

7am is far too early for anyone to be out playing with a basketball. The bouncing sound is very disturbing, as is shouting. Other people have unseen challenges too.

CasaAmarela · 09/10/2023 11:39

ErinAndTonic · 09/10/2023 11:37

Hit the nail on the head here. I think you are both annoying the crap out of each other, neither is fully in the wrong or right and both could be more considerate. I'd really struggle with daily basketball (as a person who is also ND) so I can really sympathise there. Can he not go to a local park to do this instead?

I agree with all of this.

literalviolence · 09/10/2023 11:39

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 11:36

he
never shouts at anyone other than me, and would never hurt anyone else, it’s more loud vetting and drumming which comes
with a high humming noise, he does also swear to himself, always on my
property. I stopped letting him in the back garden as she said over a year ago it bothered her when she was in the back so I now let him in the front instead. His dr says the fresh air acts as a circuit breaker to a
meltdown so he can’t stay inside when he’s melting down/
stimming, they use outside space at school and I have to be consistent
with that at
home too. I know that’s hard for her but I can’t keep him locked inside ☹️

No you can't keep him locked up but someone being outside swearing loudly is triggering for many people. It's scary. I think that all things considered, this would be more appropriate in the back garden - though is that what already happens? Is the basket ball out the front always calm with never any swearing?

ErinAndTonic · 09/10/2023 11:37

AliciaJohnson · 09/10/2023 11:28

She does sound like a complete pita, btw, but I'd say it was six of one, half a dozen of the other.

Hit the nail on the head here. I think you are both annoying the crap out of each other, neither is fully in the wrong or right and both could be more considerate. I'd really struggle with daily basketball (as a person who is also ND) so I can really sympathise there. Can he not go to a local park to do this instead?

Hulaballoola · 09/10/2023 11:37

I can't imagine OP son is out there 7am having meltdowns daily she's just saying that within the official 'quiet time' he is inside anyway. Is he the back garden as sounds like is out front if students/neighbour walking past see him?

Most of neighbours complaints don't seem valid and seems has history for being difficult. She can't set up CCTV to cover your property but she may just want the sound recording from it. Not sure how far you'd get complaining about an autistic child's noise during meltdowns given its a disability. It's sounds like you've already tried to minimise the noise only thing could think of is having something he's allowed to take physically take frustration out on indoors that he knows he can go to like his basketball, tbh that would be really annoying early morning as usually the balls noisy but tolerable rest of day in short bursts.

Assume you mean dog setting off ring video when walking it as she's convinced your letting it toilet on her front yard not that its also wandering about unattended while sons out.

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 11:36

user1471522343 · 09/10/2023 11:33

Let her install her CCTV.
If there is any unreasonable behaviour by you or yours then you will have a better understanding of where she’s coming from and can address it.
If her claims of unreasonable behaviour are unfounded she’ll have no evidence, or if she’s being ridiculously petty about normal neighbour noise, then her CCTV ‘evidence’ will also show this.
If she does infringe upon your privacy with her CCTV then her footage will also show this.
I’d let her get on with it to be honest and see it as a positive move.

Thank you that’s a positive way to look at it.

OP posts:
Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 11:36

literalviolence · 09/10/2023 11:31

Your son should be able to stim to his hearts content. But some shouting, screeching, hitting himself is genuinely intimidating for other people and depending on what you mean by this, I think perhaps your son should be in the back garden if he can't stop doing those things. It depends on what you mean because shouting ranges from a loud noise which he enjoys to loud aggressive threatening shouting. Clearly the latter is difficult for others to be around.

he
never shouts at anyone other than me, and would never hurt anyone else, it’s more loud vetting and drumming which comes
with a high humming noise, he does also swear to himself, always on my
property. I stopped letting him in the back garden as she said over a year ago it bothered her when she was in the back so I now let him in the front instead. His dr says the fresh air acts as a circuit breaker to a
meltdown so he can’t stay inside when he’s melting down/
stimming, they use outside space at school and I have to be consistent
with that at
home too. I know that’s hard for her but I can’t keep him locked inside ☹️

OP posts:
user1471522343 · 09/10/2023 11:33

Let her install her CCTV.
If there is any unreasonable behaviour by you or yours then you will have a better understanding of where she’s coming from and can address it.
If her claims of unreasonable behaviour are unfounded she’ll have no evidence, or if she’s being ridiculously petty about normal neighbour noise, then her CCTV ‘evidence’ will also show this.
If she does infringe upon your privacy with her CCTV then her footage will also show this.
I’d let her get on with it to be honest and see it as a positive move.

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 11:31

Lordofmyflies · 09/10/2023 11:29

I think I'd do 2 things. Firstly, pop a little card through the door thanking her for informing you of her intention to install CCTV. Inform her that, as she is aware, your son has autism and how you are attempting to manage it and that you will try to keep him from playing outside between 7pm and 9am. 7am is too early. You could request that any future complaints be in writing 'as evidence for you to give to CAHMs' but importantly, evidence for you to use as an harassment case against her in the future. Plus, she wont bother you verbally!

Secondly,I'd be keeping a record of all her complaints, time, date and nature of the complaint. Also noise and traffic disturbance to you from her music students. You may find her behaviour constitutes harassment if she continues to complain and this can be evidence.

This sounds so helpful, thank you so much, I’ll do this.

OP posts:
literalviolence · 09/10/2023 11:31

Your son should be able to stim to his hearts content. But some shouting, screeching, hitting himself is genuinely intimidating for other people and depending on what you mean by this, I think perhaps your son should be in the back garden if he can't stop doing those things. It depends on what you mean because shouting ranges from a loud noise which he enjoys to loud aggressive threatening shouting. Clearly the latter is difficult for others to be around.

ErinAndTonic · 09/10/2023 11:30

LegendsBeyond · 09/10/2023 10:55

I would be so annoyed at 7am noise like that outside. That’s unreasonable. I agree that she may also be neurodiverse, so it isn’t just about you & your DC’s needs.

I'm inclined to agree with this too. And yes 7am is way too early and just unfair - people shouldn't expect to be awoken by screaming. I think a safe space within the house would be better for everyone.

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 11:30

ErinAndTonic · 09/10/2023 11:27

How are you working from home and looking after your son - surely he would need a childminder until you have finished if you're on calls etc?

He’s 10 and in full time
school, I work around school times. This call was a one off as he was on line with his camhs support group so I could take
a call with my manager. doesn’t normally happen and he wasn’t even making any noise.

OP posts:
Lordofmyflies · 09/10/2023 11:29

I think I'd do 2 things. Firstly, pop a little card through the door thanking her for informing you of her intention to install CCTV. Inform her that, as she is aware, your son has autism and how you are attempting to manage it and that you will try to keep him from playing outside between 7pm and 9am. 7am is too early. You could request that any future complaints be in writing 'as evidence for you to give to CAHMs' but importantly, evidence for you to use as an harassment case against her in the future. Plus, she wont bother you verbally!

Secondly,I'd be keeping a record of all her complaints, time, date and nature of the complaint. Also noise and traffic disturbance to you from her music students. You may find her behaviour constitutes harassment if she continues to complain and this can be evidence.

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 11:28

Raineverywhere · 09/10/2023 11:22

I feel for you OP, it sounds like a very difficult situation.
I do think 7am is too early to be outside making noise in general ( even if it doesn't seem to be upsetting her). What happens at weekends?

Weekends we generally
go out and about so nothing very different apart
from they are
not in school and I’m not working. If we are home
i give him 15-20 mins bursts on his basketball and he will have on average 1-2
meltdowns a day for about 15
mins At a time.
sorry to have been unclear, my
7-7 rule is more
my house rule. He’s rarely up before 7 as is on sleeping medication and we leave
for
school 7:40 so the earliest he might make
a noise outside is 7:30 but all the kids in the street are shouting to each other and saying hi at that point before we
walk to school so I really don’t think it’s just him making noise then,

OP posts:
AliciaJohnson · 09/10/2023 11:28

She does sound like a complete pita, btw, but I'd say it was six of one, half a dozen of the other.

ErinAndTonic · 09/10/2023 11:27

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 10:26

Genuinely can’t see the wood for the trees here so hoping for your thoughts.
Lived in same semi detached house for nearly 10 years, at first neighbour who I’m attached to was friendly but fairly quickly I realised we are quite different so kept polite distance (one of many examples was when she asked for my help to talk to a bordering neighbour garden about their new trees overlooking her house and she wanted support to do this so I agreed, but when we got there it was a very different conversation to what I thought we were going to have, she was verbally aggressive and rude to this poor lady and I stood there mortified, and later went round with flowers to apologise and say had I known that’s what she was going to do / say I wouldn’t have come with he).
fast forward 7 years and I’m now on my own here with 2 kids, one of whom has autism and sensory needs. He offloads by playing basketball in the front which I make sure is only for 20-30 mins at a time and never past 7pm or before 7am. He does meltdown in and outside house about 1-2 times a day with screeching / shouting / hitting himself/ stimming which most of my neighbours know about and kindly “ignore” as he becomes more distressed with input from people talking at him when melting down. He does need to be outside at these points as inside he is a risk to his little sister and smashes things so I was advised to let him be outside for these meltdowns which last around 15 mins.

over the last year it’s become nearly impossible with my Neighbour, every day there’s a new problem she arrives at my door to talk about: my son making noise, her music students not liking walking past our house if my son is outside (she works from home teaching music) our dog walking past her driveway and setting off the ring door bell, my working from home and she can hear my calls through kitchen wall (this feels unlikely but even if true I can’t not work from home), my bins not being in the right place, and then finally my straw broke so to speak when she arrived at my door when I was mid-work call to say my son had sworn outside (to himself, not at her) when she was walking past with a friend and she wants me to stop the anti social behaviour. I was pretty short with her, explaining I was working and that my son is 10, has autism and does meltdown and I manage that as best I can, he’s in the house 7pm - 7am at least so he can’t bother the neighbours but she just kept going until I had to shut the door on her. I’ve woken up to a note saying she’s installing cctv and will be recording the disturbance from my son and general noise. I feel really upset by it as I try my best, I know my son is challenging but he’s not challenging her, it’s all on my property (Albeit attached to her) but I just hoped for some understanding that it’s not easy and I do the best I can.
what do I do now? I’ve tried being nice, made all the accommodations I think I can, and now I feel relations have completely deteriorated and I simply don’t know what else I can do. I don’t like the idea of cctv recording but it’s her property so 🤷‍♀️

i feel like she’s making me out to be a shameless Style family with a single mum and unruly kids but I try my best. What, if anything, should i do? Thank you 🙏

How are you working from home and looking after your son - surely he would need a childminder until you have finished if you're on calls etc?

CasaAmarela · 09/10/2023 11:27

She sounds like a massive PITA but YABU about the basketball. Not letting him do it before 7am isn't saying much. You'd let him bounce a ball at 7.30am? It's a special kind of torture listening to that.

AliciaJohnson · 09/10/2023 11:26

user1497207191 · 09/10/2023 10:47

Does she have change of use planning permission to allow her to have clients visiting her at her home for business purposes, i.e. music lessons?? Does she have public liability insurance in case of injuries etc whilst her clients are in her house?? PP is usually needed for any business (which private tuition is!), unless only admin etc is done at home, i.e. when there are clients visiting, PP is usually needed!

I can't imagine her complaining to the council and mentioning her business customers if she's not got the proper planning permission/approval to do it.

Sounds more like a load of hot air, so just carry on as best you can and ignore her.

This is complete bollocks!

OP, do not go down this route because you will look like a complete pillock. Unless she is no longer living in her house, and is solely operating it as a business premises, she doesn't need PP. She is well advised to have public liability and professional indemnity insurance, but is likely to have both of those because she's also likely to be a member of the MU as a freelance music teacher.

I also have an autistic child, and am well versed in meltdowns. However, I never felt that my neighbours needed to be so well versed in them, especially not at 7AM.

Itcanhappeninanysituation · 09/10/2023 11:25

The thumping of basket ball for 15-20min daily would really annoy me. But I would probably just put headphones on and ignore it.

Our neighbour teaches music and sometimes it's annoying as it'll be 40mins. We just put our headphones on or try and ignore.

Also I'm not sure if she can film you on CCTV without permission.

Daphnis156 · 09/10/2023 11:24

It is totally unreasonable to say she should move.
Perhaps it is you who should move.
I would not want to live near you.

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 11:24

NoWinterYear · 09/10/2023 11:13

Apart from the basketball thumping nothing that your son is doing sounds that extreme. How often does he play basket ball? The only concessions give her is to maybe be mindful of when she has the music lessons and to try to minimise playing basketball then. Do you have a back garden where he could play? Is there any material you could lay down that would dampen the sound?

I'm sorry she's giving you a hard time. I don't think you are doing anything illegal that she can actually use against you.

Thank you 🥰I’m not sure I’ll look Into material to help the noise, I hadn’t thought of that. I’d put it in the front to avoid the back where she’s previously askemdme
to keep the noise down with them playing as our gardens are tiny and separated by a small fence. So I thought the front was preferable but can see why
it
annoys her, I’m just reluctant to let it go because it helps hIm and I honestly think she’ll just move
on to the next
annoying thing we / he / I do ☹️

OP posts: