Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Difficult neighbour or am I being a tiger mum?

238 replies

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 10:26

Genuinely can’t see the wood for the trees here so hoping for your thoughts.
Lived in same semi detached house for nearly 10 years, at first neighbour who I’m attached to was friendly but fairly quickly I realised we are quite different so kept polite distance (one of many examples was when she asked for my help to talk to a bordering neighbour garden about their new trees overlooking her house and she wanted support to do this so I agreed, but when we got there it was a very different conversation to what I thought we were going to have, she was verbally aggressive and rude to this poor lady and I stood there mortified, and later went round with flowers to apologise and say had I known that’s what she was going to do / say I wouldn’t have come with he).
fast forward 7 years and I’m now on my own here with 2 kids, one of whom has autism and sensory needs. He offloads by playing basketball in the front which I make sure is only for 20-30 mins at a time and never past 7pm or before 7am. He does meltdown in and outside house about 1-2 times a day with screeching / shouting / hitting himself/ stimming which most of my neighbours know about and kindly “ignore” as he becomes more distressed with input from people talking at him when melting down. He does need to be outside at these points as inside he is a risk to his little sister and smashes things so I was advised to let him be outside for these meltdowns which last around 15 mins.

over the last year it’s become nearly impossible with my Neighbour, every day there’s a new problem she arrives at my door to talk about: my son making noise, her music students not liking walking past our house if my son is outside (she works from home teaching music) our dog walking past her driveway and setting off the ring door bell, my working from home and she can hear my calls through kitchen wall (this feels unlikely but even if true I can’t not work from home), my bins not being in the right place, and then finally my straw broke so to speak when she arrived at my door when I was mid-work call to say my son had sworn outside (to himself, not at her) when she was walking past with a friend and she wants me to stop the anti social behaviour. I was pretty short with her, explaining I was working and that my son is 10, has autism and does meltdown and I manage that as best I can, he’s in the house 7pm - 7am at least so he can’t bother the neighbours but she just kept going until I had to shut the door on her. I’ve woken up to a note saying she’s installing cctv and will be recording the disturbance from my son and general noise. I feel really upset by it as I try my best, I know my son is challenging but he’s not challenging her, it’s all on my property (Albeit attached to her) but I just hoped for some understanding that it’s not easy and I do the best I can.
what do I do now? I’ve tried being nice, made all the accommodations I think I can, and now I feel relations have completely deteriorated and I simply don’t know what else I can do. I don’t like the idea of cctv recording but it’s her property so 🤷‍♀️

i feel like she’s making me out to be a shameless Style family with a single mum and unruly kids but I try my best. What, if anything, should i do? Thank you 🙏

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Soontobe60 · 09/10/2023 12:58

Ihadenough22 · 09/10/2023 12:50

I think that you doing your best to deal with a hard situation. Meanwhile you have a neighbour that seems to have form of finding fault with her neighbours.
At this stage I keep a note of every interaction with her, date, time and nature of her complaint. I also note when her music customers park in your spot, you can hear her or when she complains that your dog is setting off her ring door bell.
I chat to the other neighbors and see if she is doing the same with them.

When she comes complaining I tell her could you ask car reg number to stop parking in my space? Put a note on the car as well.
If she says anything about the CCTV make a note of it but don't make a comment. If she puts up CCTV and sets it up to record your house I ring the police as by law she can't do this.

I ring the local council and say your thinking of opening a business offering music lessons at home and are you allowed to do this?, What are the rules for this? Note what they are telling you. She might not have permission for this. She might need council permission for this. I wonder as well if she is letting the tax man know about all her music students?
You could nicely say something about the council or tax man and see how she reacts. If she stops off, says anything you know who to ring about her.
Some people just want to moan and find fault with everyone or everything and she sounds like this.

I know with your son meltdowns that you have been asked by cams to let him outside and basketball helps. In the past I have seen a big ball made of sponge that you can throw but it does not bounce. Perhaps this could let your son deal with the meltdown without the bouncing noise.
I also think you can get a swingball with a soft ball - it might be a junior swingball and hitting this ball with the bat should not be loud.
I know one lady who got a big, soft teddy so her child with autism could hit when they had a meltdown. It helped them and they were not hurting themselves or someone else doing this.
Perhaps I let your son go to the back garden rather than the front of the house when he is having a meltdown as he is not in front of her or her students.

She can't expect you to live next door, not go outside or make noise to suit her.
If she continues like this I ring the council and report for having a business at her home and that her customers cars are parking in your space. That's why I keep records of all things going forward so you have proof of this.

You don't need anyone’s permission to tutor in your own home. You may need additional insurance or a DBS, but certainly not permission from the local council.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 09/10/2023 12:56

AFaik she is not allowed to make images of your son without his/your permission as this is a breach of data protection. And no way is she allowed to make audio recordings of you or your child outside your own home, I take it this is your front yard/garden she is talking about?

This is such bollocks. Of course she doesn't need permission to record how noisy something is from her own property. And half the country seem to have ring doorbells now, which are essentially CCTV and often cover at least part of the neighbour's front gardens too. So many people seem to think they have some sort of right to control what other people choose to video in public - you don't!

OP, I would honestly just ignore her. Your son needs to be outdoors when he has a meltdown. Tbh, I'd never have given in to moving him from the back to the front. He is safer if his meltdown is in a secure back garden than in the front.

User0000009 · 09/10/2023 12:54

LegendsBeyond · 09/10/2023 10:55

I would be so annoyed at 7am noise like that outside. That’s unreasonable. I agree that she may also be neurodiverse, so it isn’t just about you & your DC’s needs.

This. I wouldn’t want to live next door to someone chucking a basket ball about whatever time it was.

Soontobe60 · 09/10/2023 12:53

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 11:17

Thank you, he’s in full time school and I work my hours around that so he is always supervised, but
we have been advised
by CAMHS that when he’s stimming and melting down it’s better for him to be outside in the air which calms him with no input from me.
When she came to complain he was happily in his room on a
screen with his support
group so definitely not unsupervised or making a noise at that point.

You said that he was outside unsupervised having a meltdown whilst you were on a work call.

she arrived at my door when I was mid-work call to say my son had sworn outside (to himself, not at her) when she was walking past with a friend and she wants me to stop the anti social behaviour. I was pretty short with her, explaining I was working and that my son is 10, has autism and does meltdown and I manage that as best I can, he’s in the house 7pm - 7am at least so he can’t bother the neighbours but she just kept going until I had to shut the door on her

I would be very concerned if a 10 year old child with what sounds like quite severe autism was left alone outside to have a meltdown. I really don't care what you've been told by CAMHs, That’s bordering on neglect. You need to be watching your child at all times when he is in crisis, for his own safety.

Selfishlazyme · 09/10/2023 12:53

I would hate to be your neighbour.
Sorry OP but ITUABU by making your problem your neighbour’s problem.

Meltdowns need to be inside and you need to protect your DD rather than allowing this to impact your neighbourhood.

Very difficult situation so I do have sympathy.

(The rest it’s just part of having neighbours so YANBU)

Allthorpe100 · 09/10/2023 12:52

Tell her to get t’fuck!

LakieLady · 09/10/2023 12:50

Your DN sounds quite intolerant and not at all understanding, OP, and I say that as a noise-sensitive, child-free, grumpy old woman.

Does she realise that some of his behaviours are because he's ND? If she does and she's still complaining about them, she's an unsympathetic twat. The only bit that would bother me at all would be the ball noise, and as long as it didn't go on for hours as I'd put up with it.

And as for hearing you on work calls, that's ridiculous. Presumably you speak at, or close to, normal volume while you're on the phone, so it's really no different to having a conversation with another person in the house. And I'd like to know what she expects you to do about it. I do a lot of my work over the phone, and I can't do it from the office as it's all open plan and not suitable for making loads of phone calls.

Iknowthis1 · 09/10/2023 12:50

In your position I think I'd look at moving house for an easier life. People like your neighbour don't change. There's no reasoning with them.

Ihadenough22 · 09/10/2023 12:50

I think that you doing your best to deal with a hard situation. Meanwhile you have a neighbour that seems to have form of finding fault with her neighbours.
At this stage I keep a note of every interaction with her, date, time and nature of her complaint. I also note when her music customers park in your spot, you can hear her or when she complains that your dog is setting off her ring door bell.
I chat to the other neighbors and see if she is doing the same with them.

When she comes complaining I tell her could you ask car reg number to stop parking in my space? Put a note on the car as well.
If she says anything about the CCTV make a note of it but don't make a comment. If she puts up CCTV and sets it up to record your house I ring the police as by law she can't do this.

I ring the local council and say your thinking of opening a business offering music lessons at home and are you allowed to do this?, What are the rules for this? Note what they are telling you. She might not have permission for this. She might need council permission for this. I wonder as well if she is letting the tax man know about all her music students?
You could nicely say something about the council or tax man and see how she reacts. If she stops off, says anything you know who to ring about her.
Some people just want to moan and find fault with everyone or everything and she sounds like this.

I know with your son meltdowns that you have been asked by cams to let him outside and basketball helps. In the past I have seen a big ball made of sponge that you can throw but it does not bounce. Perhaps this could let your son deal with the meltdown without the bouncing noise.
I also think you can get a swingball with a soft ball - it might be a junior swingball and hitting this ball with the bat should not be loud.
I know one lady who got a big, soft teddy so her child with autism could hit when they had a meltdown. It helped them and they were not hurting themselves or someone else doing this.
Perhaps I let your son go to the back garden rather than the front of the house when he is having a meltdown as he is not in front of her or her students.

She can't expect you to live next door, not go outside or make noise to suit her.
If she continues like this I ring the council and report for having a business at her home and that her customers cars are parking in your space. That's why I keep records of all things going forward so you have proof of this.

tachetastic · 09/10/2023 12:49

My heart goes out to the OP. This must be terribly difficult.

However, for the neighbour it must also be very difficult to live next to a child who by your own admission shouts, swears and stims outside every day, even if it is between 7am and 7pm and is directed at themselves or at you only. And if she is in the house attached to yours then there is a good chance she hears all the noise from inside your house too.

I am not saying the neighbour is a nice person, and I don't have a solution, but I do understand that if she feels unable to enjoy her own garden, or to have friends or family, or her pupils, around, then sadly there is a limit on how long someone can be understanding and sympathetic.

I feel terribly sorry for both of you.

Soontobe60 · 09/10/2023 12:47

StBrides · 09/10/2023 10:37

Tell her she's discriminating.

As your neighbour, only thing I'd want is a quiet outside until 9am but I realise I'm in a minority on mumsnet.

It's unreasonable in a semi to expect that you never hear your neighbours.

She can educate her music students, they're probably more tolerant of people with asd anyway and once they know the issue I'm sure they'll understand.

If she really can't tolerate things then I suppose she'll have to move.

If your son swore at her then he should apologise, but honestly, that's the only thing.

She sounds like a nightmare. And you might have a counter-case for harassment.

Why is she discriminating? How do you not know she would respond in exactly the same way if the child wasn’t neurodiverse?

usernamealreadytaken · 09/10/2023 12:46

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 11:17

That’s a great idea, I hadn’t thought of that.
thank you 😊

What on earth makes you think you can raise a complaint about people parking "near" your drive? Or somebody having people coming to their house? I guess if the doorbell is genuinely disturbing you then you could ask her whether she can do anything about that, but making a spurious complaint about things which don't actually either impact or annoy you appears just weird and malicious for the sake of it.

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 12:43

AutumnFroglets · 09/10/2023 12:25

He does meltdown in and outside house about 1-2 times a day with screeching / shouting / hitting himself/ stimming
^^ This can be very intimidating or triggering for many women. You do not know her past. Recently I cannot cope with slamming doors despite never being physically hit, you would never know just by looking at me.

^^ People who put their dogs outside and shut the door never hear how bad the barking is, but it can send neighbours mad, even those streets away. You putting him outside affects multiple others not just her. Sound carries/bounces off buildings.

My final, hopefully helpful, point is I've noticed you've repeatedly mentioned fresh air as his circuit breaker. What is he like when put in front of a fan at different speeds/distances?

He has a fan to help him asleep actually, so that is helpful, but when melting down he needs cold
fresh air and change of environment (I don’t understand the psychology behind it but it’s apparently commonly used with sensory
overload and ND meltdowns) I appreciate it might
be hard for her
to see him hitting himself or screeching or swearing at himself
but he’s a 10 year old boy not engaging at all with anyone else and on his own property (he literally
to a fault doesn’t engage with anyone he doesn’t know) so I really can’t see why this could intimidate her? I’m sorry you have this experience.

OP posts:
Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 12:39

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at OP's request

Really? I need to move because my son has additional needs? I’m sorry but that is preposterous.

OP posts:
forrestgreen · 09/10/2023 12:38

I'd put the basketball and anything that will help with his meltdowns in the back garden. Then nothing is visible when she walks past with her dog...
Stick to your 7-7 timetable

And stop answering the door. You really don't have to.

usernamealreadytaken · 09/10/2023 12:37

user1497207191 · 09/10/2023 10:47

Does she have change of use planning permission to allow her to have clients visiting her at her home for business purposes, i.e. music lessons?? Does she have public liability insurance in case of injuries etc whilst her clients are in her house?? PP is usually needed for any business (which private tuition is!), unless only admin etc is done at home, i.e. when there are clients visiting, PP is usually needed!

I can't imagine her complaining to the council and mentioning her business customers if she's not got the proper planning permission/approval to do it.

Sounds more like a load of hot air, so just carry on as best you can and ignore her.

What absolute rubbish! Planning permission would only be needed if the whole property was being substantially changed in order to run a business, ie becoming a business premises rather than residential. If the property is still mainly a residential home, then PP is not required. The only part of your assertion that's correct would be the need for insurance, and for her home insurer to be aware that she runs a business from home.

ohdamnitjanet · 09/10/2023 12:30

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 11:17

That’s a great idea, I hadn’t thought of that.
thank you 😊

Absolutely keep a log and definitely get a camera, in case she says anything to your son while he’s outside, and also to record all the comings and goings.
Whether she’s insured or not could be very interesting too….
She sounds absolutely horrible, I think you’ve tried to appease her enough, maybe time to fight back.

AutumnFroglets · 09/10/2023 12:25

He does meltdown in and outside house about 1-2 times a day with screeching / shouting / hitting himself/ stimming
^^ This can be very intimidating or triggering for many women. You do not know her past. Recently I cannot cope with slamming doors despite never being physically hit, you would never know just by looking at me.

^^ People who put their dogs outside and shut the door never hear how bad the barking is, but it can send neighbours mad, even those streets away. You putting him outside affects multiple others not just her. Sound carries/bounces off buildings.

My final, hopefully helpful, point is I've noticed you've repeatedly mentioned fresh air as his circuit breaker. What is he like when put in front of a fan at different speeds/distances?

Meeting · 09/10/2023 12:23

In all honesty if my neighbour threatened to install a CCTV camera to record my disabled child having a meltdown then all she would get is a video of me destroying said camera.

AInightingale · 09/10/2023 12:15

AFaik she is not allowed to make images of your son without his/your permission as this is a breach of data protection. And no way is she allowed to make audio recordings of you or your child outside your own home, I take it this is your front yard/garden she is talking about? Outrageous intrusion esp as this is a disabled child. And if your dog is setting off her doorbell camera sensor thing - tough. If it wasn't your dog it would be a cat or a fox.

I'd speak to a solicitor as it sounds like quite a serious privacy breach issue.

As this is MN, people are sympathising with the neighbour over the basketball sound. Could you buy him a softer type ball to play with or put the hoop above grass etc?

Peachee · 09/10/2023 12:13

Don’t try and regulate anything anymore do what you need to do and be how you want to be. If she doesn’t like it her and her students will have to move. Theres nothing she can do and she has no power over you. No one can enforce anything on you and she’s being wholly unreasonable.
And absolutely install cctv on your own property and she harasses collect evidence for a report.

Nevermind31 · 09/10/2023 12:13

After reading your updates it doesn’t sound as bad initially. The outside meltdowns and basketball sound very annoying. However, if she complains about you working from home then surely her teaching music is an issue for you too?
if her doorbell picks up your dog - on her property? Or the pavement?
I would start making a list…

  • teaching music - loud and disruptive to your work. Happening x times a day for y minutes.
  • parents inconsiderate parking
  • constant doorbell
  • dog in public space - she should reset her doorbell and put up signage if she is recording public spaces
  • CCTV- it must not cover your property, and if it does you will need to call the police - she cannot record on your property. She especially cannot record a minor
  • bins etc - none of her business

next time she comes… Look, if you think we are loud, here are the things that bother us - if works both ways.

flowerr · 09/10/2023 12:11

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at OP's request

NeunundneunzigHorseBallonz · 09/10/2023 12:11

Also, write in your note that as per her previous complaints, you moved him from the back to the front garden to allow her quiet time and space there.

seulement · 09/10/2023 12:06

very difficult for you - I am looking for a new house and one of the things I am nervous of is we're currently detached and I may need to buy a semi...and my son drums for self-regulation (not early or late, and in short bursts, but it is audible...) luckily I currently have very tolerant neighbours, unlike you.

In case it helps over the weekend I saw something online about a low-noise basketball? Hopefully the repetitive bouncing would still feel the same to your son, without the endless pat-pat-pat of a normal ball?