Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Difficult neighbour or am I being a tiger mum?

238 replies

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 10:26

Genuinely can’t see the wood for the trees here so hoping for your thoughts.
Lived in same semi detached house for nearly 10 years, at first neighbour who I’m attached to was friendly but fairly quickly I realised we are quite different so kept polite distance (one of many examples was when she asked for my help to talk to a bordering neighbour garden about their new trees overlooking her house and she wanted support to do this so I agreed, but when we got there it was a very different conversation to what I thought we were going to have, she was verbally aggressive and rude to this poor lady and I stood there mortified, and later went round with flowers to apologise and say had I known that’s what she was going to do / say I wouldn’t have come with he).
fast forward 7 years and I’m now on my own here with 2 kids, one of whom has autism and sensory needs. He offloads by playing basketball in the front which I make sure is only for 20-30 mins at a time and never past 7pm or before 7am. He does meltdown in and outside house about 1-2 times a day with screeching / shouting / hitting himself/ stimming which most of my neighbours know about and kindly “ignore” as he becomes more distressed with input from people talking at him when melting down. He does need to be outside at these points as inside he is a risk to his little sister and smashes things so I was advised to let him be outside for these meltdowns which last around 15 mins.

over the last year it’s become nearly impossible with my Neighbour, every day there’s a new problem she arrives at my door to talk about: my son making noise, her music students not liking walking past our house if my son is outside (she works from home teaching music) our dog walking past her driveway and setting off the ring door bell, my working from home and she can hear my calls through kitchen wall (this feels unlikely but even if true I can’t not work from home), my bins not being in the right place, and then finally my straw broke so to speak when she arrived at my door when I was mid-work call to say my son had sworn outside (to himself, not at her) when she was walking past with a friend and she wants me to stop the anti social behaviour. I was pretty short with her, explaining I was working and that my son is 10, has autism and does meltdown and I manage that as best I can, he’s in the house 7pm - 7am at least so he can’t bother the neighbours but she just kept going until I had to shut the door on her. I’ve woken up to a note saying she’s installing cctv and will be recording the disturbance from my son and general noise. I feel really upset by it as I try my best, I know my son is challenging but he’s not challenging her, it’s all on my property (Albeit attached to her) but I just hoped for some understanding that it’s not easy and I do the best I can.
what do I do now? I’ve tried being nice, made all the accommodations I think I can, and now I feel relations have completely deteriorated and I simply don’t know what else I can do. I don’t like the idea of cctv recording but it’s her property so 🤷‍♀️

i feel like she’s making me out to be a shameless Style family with a single mum and unruly kids but I try my best. What, if anything, should i do? Thank you 🙏

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
readsalotgirl63 · 09/10/2023 15:10

If she installs CCTV then it should only be recording activity on her property. If she records/films you or your son on your property she is in breach of GDPR.

landofgiants · 09/10/2023 15:09

Wow, she sounds worse than my neighbour! I think 7am is too early for noisy children outside, but in every other way she sounds unreasonable. I would be tempted to ignore her and let her crack on with her CCTV and noise recording (if your household is not generating an unreasonable level of noise, then you have nothing to worry about). Don’t engage.

My neighbour has gone all out with her CCTV and can now see watch my comings and goings from her other (main) home. I don’t like it, but what can you do 🤷🏼‍♀️

My worry would be that she will go one stage further and start to yell at/tell off your child directly. This is what my neighbour has done and it has left my autistic child to be fearful and have nightmares. If this happens you should consider making your own recordings because I think it is totally unacceptable. If she doesn’t like what she sees she can look away!

Loubelle70 · 09/10/2023 15:08

Leah5678 · 09/10/2023 14:59

Your son should be able to play basketball in YOUR front garden for as long you like as long as it's not night time. If he wants to play for longer than twenty minutes mid day in his own garden she has no right to complain. Don't let her micro manage your family life
If he's having meltdowns at night I can understand her finding that annoying although I'm not sure what you can do about it.

Yes

cannaecookrisotto · 09/10/2023 15:07

The ragey half of me would be tempted to tell her to shut the fuck up and get a grip, BUT - the sensible side of me would likely knock on, ask for a chat and ask what her end game is. I'd say we need to sort this out because it's going to take so much energy maintaining a neighbourly feud and I just don't have the time for it. So find out the compromise.

Then if that didn't work I'd let the fuck offs free.

Balloonhearts · 09/10/2023 15:05

7am is far too early for basket ball and is very antisocial. I'd be very very pissed off being woken by ball thudding at 7am. A child screaming or crying in distress is just one of those things that can't be helped and needs understanding but it's not fair to send him outside to scream and wake up everyone else. After 8.30 I'd say its reasonable to have him let off steam outdoors. From their point of view, he isn't their child and his problems shouldn't be made their problem and as nice as it would be if they made allowances, they aren't wrong.

As for her music students, I'd tell her to fuck off, snooty bitch but I do think you need to be more aware of others. Yes your son has autism but that doesn't mean his rights come above everyone else's.

superninny101 · 09/10/2023 15:03

Mother of a child with autism here and I really don't think it is acceptable at all that your son has his meltdowns outside - either for him as he ages or for your neighbours, people walking by etc. -especially if he is unsupervised. Even more inappropriate for this to happen at the front of the house. I am shocked that you think this is ok - he is very vulnerable to very negative interactions with strangers. You need to create safe spaces for both your children inside. I also think 7am is far too early for any loud activity outside and you need to find other regulating activities apart from basketball. Your neighbour may be irritating etc. but you asking them to put up with far too much

Pushpull · 09/10/2023 15:01

Some of the responses here are really vile. It sounds like max there is a couple of times a day your son needs to be outside to de escalate. I personally would use the back garden for this as it's probably safer for him and honestly it sounds like whatever you do she will complain and moan. I would have one to at saying calmly (but her previous experience with tree related drama suggests it won't work) that you have decided it's safer and less distressing for all that your children use your back garden and that is what you'll be doing. Remind her that you haven't given consent to film the children or the property.

Absolutely ignore people saying your child should be inside with a fan on and moaning about basketball. I have a neighbour (well their daughter) who plays football in the back garden for hours at a time. It sometimes irritates me a bit. But I would never complain because everyone has to compromise in order to live in a reasonable society and accommodate those who need help.

All this talk of her being triggered is such a reach. She hasn't said that and she wasn't presumably triggered by your neighbors tree. She's just an unreasonable and mean spirited woman.

Leah5678 · 09/10/2023 14:59

Your son should be able to play basketball in YOUR front garden for as long you like as long as it's not night time. If he wants to play for longer than twenty minutes mid day in his own garden she has no right to complain. Don't let her micro manage your family life
If he's having meltdowns at night I can understand her finding that annoying although I'm not sure what you can do about it.

literalviolence · 09/10/2023 14:54

WillowCraft · 09/10/2023 14:43

The obvious solution there is for your neighbour to get rid of the dogs if she can neither train them or cope with them being in her house. That is her choice to make. The noise may be similar but the underlying issue isn't.

The noise of a meltdown is obviously not ideal, but if we want to live in a society where children with autism can live at home with their families then people will have to tolerate it. The alternative is to go back to a system where autistic children are taken from their families, sedated and kept locked away from the general public. Or euthanased as in Nazi Germany.

Maybe the OP can't cope with the meltdown inside, but can cope if it's outside in the garden (where her son is not actually doing anything to the neighbours other than making noise). It's extremely difficult caring for a child like this anyway and OP is following the advice that professionals have given. What would you say to her if you were her neighbour? Would you really want this child to go into residential care because you don't want the noise of the outside meltdown? Or could you be kind and understand how hard things already are and that she is doing all she can as a loving mother? It's not like the OP is making a choice to be antisocial.

No but it's also not like traumatised people are choosing to be triggered. Personally, I think the (I assume enclosed) back garden is the middle ground plus attempts to minimise the noise as much as possible. I think the OP and the neighbour both have understandable points and are both being, in parts, unreasonable.

Bunnyannesummers · 09/10/2023 14:49

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 13:16

He’s a 10 year old boy with autism, not
a grown man and my neighbour is not in a refuge
(where, by the way, the children of abused mothers are allowed
to stay including neurodivergent children who will meltdown).

He’s a 10 year old boy now but he won’t be forever and at some point in the not too distant future seeing him meltdown WILL be intimidating, especially if you’ve got him in the front yard, to intimidate anyone and everyone going past.

you need to get a handle on it now before you’ve got random people phoning the police on you.

definitely swap him to the back yard as that’s the lesser of two evils. If she doesn’t like his small periods in the back yard to meltdown and play basketball, tough shit. No one’s entitled to total peace and quiet in their back yard, but him being there instead of in the front would solve a lot of issues

WillowCraft · 09/10/2023 14:43

AWIAANGAF · 09/10/2023 14:11

I think I’m slightly more on the side of the neighbour, but can understand your situation. I know it’s the advice you have been given, but to the neighbour it will feel like you can’t cope with the meltdown and the damage you say your child causes inside, so you move the ‘problem behaviour’ outside and inflict him on the neighbours instead. Just because other neighbours don’t say anything, doesn’t mean people don’t think it.
To compare (but not likening your son to it, just the noise of it IYSWIM). My neighbours dogs get yappy in the house which annoys my neighbour because they start peeing in their excitement. My neighbours solution is to send them outside where the yapping is so much louder for everyone else, but quieter for her. One of the neighbours has vocalised they don’t like it, the rest of us smile politely but secretly don’t like her much as a result.
I can understand it’s difficult for you and you are carrying out the instructions you have been told, but the neighbours are paying the price for it. Hearing other kids chattering is not the same as hearing a meltdown.

The obvious solution there is for your neighbour to get rid of the dogs if she can neither train them or cope with them being in her house. That is her choice to make. The noise may be similar but the underlying issue isn't.

The noise of a meltdown is obviously not ideal, but if we want to live in a society where children with autism can live at home with their families then people will have to tolerate it. The alternative is to go back to a system where autistic children are taken from their families, sedated and kept locked away from the general public. Or euthanased as in Nazi Germany.

Maybe the OP can't cope with the meltdown inside, but can cope if it's outside in the garden (where her son is not actually doing anything to the neighbours other than making noise). It's extremely difficult caring for a child like this anyway and OP is following the advice that professionals have given. What would you say to her if you were her neighbour? Would you really want this child to go into residential care because you don't want the noise of the outside meltdown? Or could you be kind and understand how hard things already are and that she is doing all she can as a loving mother? It's not like the OP is making a choice to be antisocial.

Daffodilwoman · 09/10/2023 14:41

Someone upthread (sorry I can’t remember the poster) suggested agreeing with her, stating that your son is under CAMS and that you and they are trying your hardest to manage your child’s condition. They said to tell the neighbour to put everything in writing as evidence for you to take to CAMS. I think this is excellent advice.
It shows your neighbour that you are taking her concerns seriously, it also stops her from a barrage of verbal abuse, plus she is more likely to think about what she is prepared to write down. It might also make her stop and think. Think that you are trying to do your best. Think that your child cannot help it, think that perhaps as you mention professionals that the actions you are taking are those advised to you.
I would do this. Everyone she comes round.
’Hi June, remember now, it needs to be in writing, thanks bye.’

Passwordfatigued · 09/10/2023 14:29

I think you have been very reasonable with neighbour and tried to resolve as many of her complaints as you can. If you don't mind me saying.... maybe a bit too reasonable?! She is taking advantage of your kind approach and using it against you. You already have alot going on ( I also have an Autistic child) and you shouldn't need to be worrying about a grown adult next door when your son is experiencing meltdowns... equally stopping him from doing the things which regulate his system is going to increase the likelihood and duration of his meltdowns. Uurgh I just wish society was kinder to our beautiful Autistic kids 😢. Let her go to the council.... they will not take it seriously. He is in his own garden (I would also make sure he is in the back garden where he is safer.... it doesn't matter she complains anyway!). She is being very unfair. Do you hear her teaching music through the walls?! Has she even considered her own impact on you. Ignore, ignore, ignore.... you have done your best.

anareen · 09/10/2023 14:22

I am so sorry you and your son are experiencing this!

I would get your own camera and audio system and record yourself. Then it will capture every time she comes to your home to speak such nonsense.

I wonder if this would fall under harassment/ harassment anti social behavior. I also wonder if you could get a Personal Protection Order. Especially with a minor being involved! I would definitely document any evidence you can going forward!

Justgivemeasec · 09/10/2023 14:19

sueelleker · 09/10/2023 14:03

"Many people basically think disabled people aught to just disappear as if by magic so that they never have to encounter one."
Or that they ought to still be locked up in institutions.

Yep, except then they would just moan about hard working taxpayers money being spent to keep us.

SapphireSeptember · 09/10/2023 14:18

I'd love to know where people live if they think any outside noise is unreasonable before 7am! I start work before that some mornings, other people are going to work. Any comments on the other noisy kids down OP's street in the mornings? OP was not saying her DS is outside for 12 hours playing basketball and having meltdowns for goodness sake 🙄 She's already stopped her kids from using the back garden because her neighbour didn't like that either!

Autumny · 09/10/2023 14:15

Feraldogmum · 09/10/2023 14:04

Jesus wept the poor woman must be at the end of her tether.If your son is so out of control that he's a risk to his sister,what on earth are you doing leaving him unsupervised/unsupported in public in violent rages . I sympathise with your situation but it seems you're abdicating responsibility during the day,what happens as he grows and is too big to manage? If he's a risk to his sister,what happens if he hurls things as a teenager at others.
It seems to me that you should be caring full time and not ignoring whilst working or getting childcare.
Yes she's intolerant to a degree, but the constant unrelenting pressure she's enduring chips away at rational responses over time.

That was my first reaction too. I have a ND family, and struggle daily with autism and ADHD. I bought a detached fixer-upper for the same price as a semi to have space from neighbours. I've had a horrible time in a terrace from other neighbours behaviour and would never inflict anything like that on others.

I wonder if OP can sort out a safe room inside the house for her 10-year-old and try out some new strategies. I know a few mums who have gym mats on the floor and mats on the walls with various sensory things. What is triggering the meltdowns? Are the neighbours music lessons winding him up? It isn't sustainable to leave a 10-year-old boy raging outside.

Soontobe60 · 09/10/2023 14:13

Tangofantastic · 09/10/2023 13:15

Severe autism isn’t used anymore so you’re showing your ignorance. It’s just “autism”. Whether you care
what professionals
say or not is irrelevant (though odd). This incident was when was winding down outside in my secure driveway after a meltdown with me
watching him from inside at the advice of
camhs. This had happened the day before she arrived, to talk to me when I was on. A work call and he was in school. In no way
do I neglect my children, I keep them safe and cared for. Your ignorance speaks
volumes.

Apologies - I read it as you were on the call when he was outside having a meltdown, which is why I was so concerned. I realise now that you were on the call when she came round to complain.
CAMHs sometimes give shit advice though. I know that from experience. Putting a child in a public space in which they are at their most vulnerable is definitely shit advice.
Interestingly, I received a draft EHCP last week for a Year 1 child. The EP report states that he has ‘severe autism’. Whilst I appreciate what you say, for some people whose autism impacts their lives so severely that they require special school or residential care, that IS severe.
https://www.sarahdooleycenter.org/news/the-difference-between-moderate-to-severe-autism/
https://www.verywellhealth.com/what-is-severe-autism-260044#:~:text=Severe%20autism%2C%20known%20as%20level,1

The Difference Between Moderate To Severe Autism | Sarah Dooley Center for Autism

The Sarah Dooley Center for Autism provides academic and behavioral education to children with autism and other developmental disabilities. Learn more.

https://www.sarahdooleycenter.org/news/the-difference-between-moderate-to-severe-autism/

Rosscameasdoody · 09/10/2023 14:12

Theunamedcat · 09/10/2023 13:35

So you can't use your back garden you can't use your FRONT garden snd she can hear noise coming from your house so she would be able to hear him in your house too....just where is she expecting you to put your child?

Also Google is unclear it seems to say you can record your property and your children but not your neighbours property or your neighbours children? Which is in effect what she is threatening to do

We clarified this when we installed a ring camera. If a neighbours CCTV records onto your property the position is regulated under GDPR and the Data Protection Act. Simply put, it’s illegal to film you on your own private property in areas where you would have an expectation of privacy. So if someone films you in your front garden you probably don’t have a case, but in the back garden you most definitely have an expectation of privacy so it would be illegal. You also have the right to ask them to stop filming at any point and if they don’t comply, you may also have a case for a harassment or nuisance claim depending on the extent of the filming and the circumstances. I think I also remember being told it’s illegal for someone to film a child on their own private property without the consent of the parent.

purplecorkheart · 09/10/2023 14:12

Is your dog entering or cutting through her property? I agree with others who say that although you understand his is a child it may be terrifying for other people who do not know particularly as he gets bigger and stronger. I it would be more appropriate to use the back gardens. She cannot tell you that you cannot use it.

With regards to the basketball I can see her point to an extent. It is pure torture after a while. Could you look at getting something like foam matting etc and put on the surface where he plays basketball to quieten down the sound a bit.

Loubelle70 · 09/10/2023 14:11

Feraldogmum · 09/10/2023 14:04

Jesus wept the poor woman must be at the end of her tether.If your son is so out of control that he's a risk to his sister,what on earth are you doing leaving him unsupervised/unsupported in public in violent rages . I sympathise with your situation but it seems you're abdicating responsibility during the day,what happens as he grows and is too big to manage? If he's a risk to his sister,what happens if he hurls things as a teenager at others.
It seems to me that you should be caring full time and not ignoring whilst working or getting childcare.
Yes she's intolerant to a degree, but the constant unrelenting pressure she's enduring chips away at rational responses over time.

Shes a meddling old goat!!
Where would you suggest OP lets her son blow off steam? Its her house and garden. This neighbour is unreasonable, she knows OP is reasonable because of the other neighbour situation, therefore thinks she can control her neighbours. Also, why now? Tell you why... because OP wasnt one of her flying monkeys.

anon0007 · 09/10/2023 14:11

Tell her it's great she's recording her discrimination because you'll also be using the footage when you counter claim for harassment and discriminating behaviour.

AWIAANGAF · 09/10/2023 14:11

I think I’m slightly more on the side of the neighbour, but can understand your situation. I know it’s the advice you have been given, but to the neighbour it will feel like you can’t cope with the meltdown and the damage you say your child causes inside, so you move the ‘problem behaviour’ outside and inflict him on the neighbours instead. Just because other neighbours don’t say anything, doesn’t mean people don’t think it.
To compare (but not likening your son to it, just the noise of it IYSWIM). My neighbours dogs get yappy in the house which annoys my neighbour because they start peeing in their excitement. My neighbours solution is to send them outside where the yapping is so much louder for everyone else, but quieter for her. One of the neighbours has vocalised they don’t like it, the rest of us smile politely but secretly don’t like her much as a result.
I can understand it’s difficult for you and you are carrying out the instructions you have been told, but the neighbours are paying the price for it. Hearing other kids chattering is not the same as hearing a meltdown.

Pancakeorcrepe · 09/10/2023 14:10

This sounds like a very difficult situation all round.
I would say if your son poses a risk to your daughter during the meltdowns like you have mentioned, then you do need to look a alternative solutions to manage the situation. You can’t just leave him outside in the front garden. You sound like a wonderful mum but perhaps you have become immune at some of the natural reactions that your son’s behaviour can cause.

RedToothBrush · 09/10/2023 14:10

DsTTy · 09/10/2023 10:33

So she’s unable to regulate her emotions, struggles in social situations, becomes hyper-fixated and is a fixed thinker? Have you considered she might be neurodiverse and isn’t getting the help she needs?

You need to fight this fire by pouring water all over it but unfortunately I don’t have any ideas on how to do this.

All your complaints are not for things that unreasonable for me to do in my own home or passing your house. We have tried to be understanding up until this point and do make every effort to be respectful of the neighbours however your note through the door is the last straw and has broken down the goodwill we have tried to maintain despite your demands.

I intend to start a diary of all your unreasonable requests trying to control the behaviour of my family whilst living day to day in a normal way as it is now becoming intolerable and is starting to become persistent harassment.

I would like to remind you that for a complaint about anti-social behavior to be upheld thats the behaviour has to 'unreasonably and substantially interfere with the use or enjoyment of a home or other premises' or 'injure health or be likely to injure health'. We are no where near close to meeting this threshold. It is not unreasonable for my family to use our home and garden in whatever why we like. We are not making noise in a way which consistuents being outside the bounds of normal every day activities and we restrict certain activities in the evening and early in the morning to try and appease the situation.

We beleive this harassment is being deliberated targeted at us due to my son's disability. He has issues which are at times difficult to manage, but we do our best and this is not something that we are able to change because a neighbour is making unrealistic and unreasonable demands.

I would remind you that if you are using CCTV to monitor me and my family's behaviour on our own property this is an invasion of our privacy and is unlawful. All CCTV footage must be restricted to your own property. If it is brought to our attention that this is not respected, we will have no other option but to act accordingly.

We do not wish for this to escaluate further but if necessary we will look to the council for mediation, or seek legal advice regarding an harassment order.