Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL trouble! What should we do now!

89 replies

ridingalonginmyflashcar · 08/10/2023 23:45

I have name changed for this as posted lots about my life/job etc under my other name.

This might be long as I don't want to drip feed.

My PILs and I don't really get on, it's always been a bit strained but almost 5yrs ago there was a massive row and things have never really recovered. My MIL in particular had very extreme views and I have had to tell her multiple times to please keep her thoughts/opinions to herself when they may upset others.
My husband, our children (6&4 boys) live approx 3 hrs from them so we only have to see them once a year (although they do not work they don't wish to come anymore than this and although this upsets my husband as I think he'd like them more involved he's settled for weekly Skype calls)
My four year old son, since the summer has been very interested in "beautiful twirly whirly dresses" unicorns, sparkles, glitter, hairclips etc (things that are stereotypical of little girls) myself and my husband have not discouraged or encouraged this, we have simply given him a choice, just as we do his older brother and he has consistently chosen from the girls section rather than the boys. No issues throughout the summer, he wore dresses with shorts underneath and all was well. My husband got very worried when we went into preschool that either he or his elder brother would be teased if he wore a dress so (as a compromise - to show I respect my husbands opinion even if I don't agree! Very happy for my son to wear a dress every day if he wants!) we tried to encourage him to save his beautiful dresses for home "so they wouldn't get messy" but let him have free rein on what he wears otherwise (unicorn jeans and teeshirt for example!)
During one of the weekly Skype calls today, MIL went on and on and ON about my son who was wearing a dress and even started calling him the female version of his name. My husband has asked her to stop repeatedly but she carried on, I got involved and told her to STOP BEING UNKIND NOW or stop phoning as she wasn't being fair, he is only 4yrs old! Then she stormed off and left FIL on the phone! My little boy was nearly in tears saying to me "why are Grandma and Grandad being mean to me? About my beautiful dress?" My elder one was comforting him saying "Don't worry X, just come and play with me if they're being mean. If you love it, you wear it. You look great!" Honestly, it nearly broke my heart to hear that!
So, where do I go from here? I know she will expect me to apologise, but I am not going to! How dare she say things like "she'll make him gay" and "oh X! Why have you got a silly dress on for!"🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬

OP posts:
RedSuedePump · 09/10/2023 06:51

she sounds very rude!! my son went through a princess dress phase when he was 3 - even went to Disney on Ice dressed as Elsa. All he wanted for xmas that year was an Elsa dress. i remember the nursery girls saying how some boys aren’t allowed to dress up in any “girls” costumes there and i thought that was really sad. they are only little! he’s now 9 and lives in football kits and is mortified if i ever mention his Elsa phase 😂

Iinventedmckenzie · 09/10/2023 06:49

They sound awful tbh. Don't apologise of course! I'd just go about my business not seeing them. Wouldn't even do the once a year as they sound like horrible people. Of your dh wants to see them he can crack on obviously.

I think the comments people are making about him getting picked on aren't necessarily true depending on the area you live in. There's a big difference between some parts of rural Ireland for example (I'm Irish before anyone thinks I'm being anti irish) and North London for example. Although, I think most people everywhere would refrain from being a massive twat to a small child about their appearance

EverythingYouDoIsaBalloon · 09/10/2023 06:41

DuplicateUserName · 08/10/2023 23:50

She should've kept her thoughts to herself obviously, but none of you are doing the poor boy any favours by making a massive 'right on' thing about what are (at the end of the day) just clothes.

Yes, kids will definitely take the piss and even if he grows out of this phase he will always be known as the boy who wore dresses in the infants.

That's fine if you think he can handle it, but honestly you come across here as ridiculously try hard.

Bit cynical. OP is just letting her DS be who he is within the safety of his own home. That isn't 'try hard' or 'right-on', it's just what a loving parent does.

It's a sad world we're living in if we're teaching kids not to be themselves at the age of four.

Shoxfordian · 09/10/2023 06:36

Your mil sounds very rude: what did your dh think about it? I would let him make the calls on his own for a while

Luddite26 · 09/10/2023 06:30

It's funny as I have a gd who likes wearing trousers and has a batman and a hulk outfit and marvel bedding and everyday wear is marvel.
We have a bit of a ban on unicorns and princess dresses anyway as I personally think it's a bit conditioning aiming them at girls. She has had a Cinderella dress but only put it on once.
Nobody really bats an eye lid at a girl in the dark clothes although her mum says come home in pink clothes to her.
My DD has boys and she's always bought a few bright clothes which would be marketed for girls and people are more judgemental about that than girls in dark clothes
There is so much sparkly stuff everywhere you can understand some boys taking an interest and why not. I think your in laws just don't seem very nice and a bit out of date.
I think shops should sell more unisex clothes anyway.
When is the in-laws annual visit?

SequinsandStiIettos · 09/10/2023 06:30

"Don't worry X, just come and play with me if they're being mean. If you love it, you wear it. You look great!"

From a six year old?

disappear · 09/10/2023 06:26

Love what your DS1 said to his little brother. Such empathy from a 6 year old. You’re obviously doing an excellent job in raising these DCs. It gives me hope for the future.

honeyandfizz · 09/10/2023 06:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I don't think I would like such a potty mouth daughter in law either. Bonkers.

Wouldyouguess · 09/10/2023 06:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You sound like a charming person!

luckysonofagun · 09/10/2023 06:11

I think you sound great. He wears what he wants at home but understands that for school he has to wear certain clothes. Good preparation for uniform.

I'd stop contact with pil it doesn't sound like your children benefit

WhatsCookingFlora · 09/10/2023 06:09

PrudeyTwoShoes · 09/10/2023 04:55

OP, I think this is a little more than a phase, which I say in the kindest possible way and with absolutely no judgement. I think, therefore, you need to nip this in the bud with PIL sooner rather than later. Definitely don't apologise. It's probably best coming from DH so they know you are united in this, but I'd send a firm message. Something along the lines of, 'We are comfortable with whoever our son turns out to be and will always encourage him to be his best and authentic self. If you are not able/willing to support his choices then we would appreciate you taking a step back.' If you're feeling a bit petty you could aslo add 'We are not ashamed of how DS chooses to dress and the only one who should be ashamed is you after your despicable behaviour.'

Why on earth do you think this is "a little more than a phase" for the 4 year old child?

It is a very common thing for little boys at this age and has no more implications than children who refuse to wear anything other than the same spiderman outfit or cat ears for months on end.

Maybe he'll continue to wear dresses forever or maybe he'll lose interest tomorrow. He's 4.

LAMPS1 · 09/10/2023 05:24

If you only see the in laws once a year, they will have very little understanding of your family at all and probably haven’t come across a situation like this before.
It’s sad that they are difficult and bigoted and therefore missing out on the joys and delights and fun of your little boys growing up in more enlightened times.

OP, you have described your children so well here. Could you and your DH write to them or Skype to bring them up to date on your parenting approach and explain how creative, imaginative and joyful your son is with his beautiful dresses. And how experimenting with clothes is perfectly normal at that age and totally acceptable even though it was frowned upon in years gone by.

Or could your DH make a trip to see them to gently explain and discuss how they are being left behind with their lack of acceptance and in their thinking generally.

I think you shouldn’t apologise but I do think there should be lots and lots of discussion to at least try to bring them up to date so they feel more included and can be less estranged / isolated in their thinking. If they are willing to listen that is, maybe you have already tried.
It may be just a matter of educating them or should I say re-educating them. We all need that as we get older and I’m so grateful that our sons kindly and lovingly coach me forward at times.

I may be well off the mark here but I feel one visit a year when they only live 3 hours away is so sad, even though they are difficult. It would be no wonder they are stuck with their old fashioned viewpoints if they have little day to day interaction with any young modern families.

NeunundneunzigHorseBallonz · 09/10/2023 05:13

Definitely get DH to jam a tiara and earrings on for the next face time!

PrudeyTwoShoes · 09/10/2023 04:55

OP, I think this is a little more than a phase, which I say in the kindest possible way and with absolutely no judgement. I think, therefore, you need to nip this in the bud with PIL sooner rather than later. Definitely don't apologise. It's probably best coming from DH so they know you are united in this, but I'd send a firm message. Something along the lines of, 'We are comfortable with whoever our son turns out to be and will always encourage him to be his best and authentic self. If you are not able/willing to support his choices then we would appreciate you taking a step back.' If you're feeling a bit petty you could aslo add 'We are not ashamed of how DS chooses to dress and the only one who should be ashamed is you after your despicable behaviour.'

Tilllly · 09/10/2023 04:22

Someoneonlyyouknow · 09/10/2023 04:19

I would like to suggest that your DH and elder son also wear dresses for next week's Skype call (you should obviously wear a collar and tie). Failing that, keep the children out of the calls and if this is queried say you'll include them when your PiL promise to behave politely towards them.

Oh yes! Do this, please!
And report back

Someoneonlyyouknow · 09/10/2023 04:19

I would like to suggest that your DH and elder son also wear dresses for next week's Skype call (you should obviously wear a collar and tie). Failing that, keep the children out of the calls and if this is queried say you'll include them when your PiL promise to behave politely towards them.

TammyJones · 09/10/2023 04:16

DuplicateUserName · 08/10/2023 23:50

She should've kept her thoughts to herself obviously, but none of you are doing the poor boy any favours by making a massive 'right on' thing about what are (at the end of the day) just clothes.

Yes, kids will definitely take the piss and even if he grows out of this phase he will always be known as the boy who wore dresses in the infants.

That's fine if you think he can handle it, but honestly you come across here as ridiculously try hard.

Totally agree.
Kids can be cruel so it would wise to not set him up to be on the firing line.
(And no it won't make him gay) but kids do like to fit in.

LadyBitsnBobs · 09/10/2023 04:06

Yanbu of course. You do not apologise to MIL for politely but firmly curtailing the conversation in which she was saying unkind things to your child.

I honestly think you don’t say anything to MIL. Wait for her to raise the subject and if she does you can say, “these are our kids and we are raising them well. If you think wearing a dress “makes children grow up gay” then we are always going to disagree but I would ask you to keep those comments within adult conversations between DH and ourselves as bullying our 4 year old about it isn’t only going to upset and confuse him.”

I also had to deal with in-laws comments about my “poor” children who wear second hand clothes (it is my choice to make second hand purchases for environmental reasons) and also my DH worries about me letting DS have his toenails painted or wear a rainbow coloured T-shirt or anything with pink on it in case somehow it “turns ds into a girl”. if I let ds go out in a dress I would never hear the end of it!

Clothes are a huge part of identity and imagination, and I’m not blind to the fact that my ds’s life will be easier if he makes conventional choices but at age 4 if a child wants to be a monster or feel beautiful or wear head to toe waterproofs so they can play in the mud really who cares? Balance in all things.

DreamTheMoors · 09/10/2023 03:32

@ridingalonginmyflashcar

I had a cruel grandmother, too. As I grew older I learned to stay away from her and never ever to be alone with her in the same room — because that’s when she got truly mean and nasty. I suspect it was self-preservation.

Your son will learn to stay away from his granny, too — give him time. In the meantime, try to keep him out of her way the best you can.

Not every grandmother has a comfy lap and bakes biscuits and reads stories- some are more like Cruella.

NeunundneunzigHorseBallonz · 09/10/2023 02:46

My son had two sisters and used to love being Princess Superman. (Half of one costume on top and half on the other.) A friend of my DH came over while I was painting the kid’s nails. My DS wanted his done and chose sparkly forest green. The friend said “That’s child abuse! Boys don’t wear nail polish!!!” I quickly put him in his place and told him it would be far more abusive to say that he couldn’t because he was a boy after spending so much time on his sister’s nails.
DS is now 17 with a mullet and his wardrobe consists of grey, black and navy now. All his choices. I kinda miss Princess Superman.

momonpurpose · 09/10/2023 01:13

DuplicateUserName · 08/10/2023 23:50

She should've kept her thoughts to herself obviously, but none of you are doing the poor boy any favours by making a massive 'right on' thing about what are (at the end of the day) just clothes.

Yes, kids will definitely take the piss and even if he grows out of this phase he will always be known as the boy who wore dresses in the infants.

That's fine if you think he can handle it, but honestly you come across here as ridiculously try hard.

It's not popular but I agree. I think some people really enjoy saying look at what open minded people we are!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 09/10/2023 00:57

She sounds horrible! Why are some people so unkind to children?

ForeveraBluebird · 09/10/2023 00:50

Your little boy sounds lovely , nice that he and his brother are beautifully spoken too.
Probably best not to yell fucking moron if they can hear you though.

millerpie · 09/10/2023 00:37

Get rid of the MIL, your kid sounds awesome! if he’s happy who cares.

PurpleOrchid42 · 09/10/2023 00:10

I think your PIL sound likes a complete waste of time. They only live 3 hours away, yet you only see them ONCE a YEAR? That's shocking. My advice would be to absolutely not apologise. You don't have anything to apologise for, they were in the wrong, and should apologise to your son (though I highly doubt they'd be willing). If your husband agrees, just don't contact them, and let them make the effort. If they don't, then that will be a bonus.