Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children hitting childminder

107 replies

Vand · 08/10/2023 22:36

NC for this.

I have worked in childcare for 15 years and never have encountered behaviour like I have seen in the past 12 months. 3 different children who are between the ages of 6-8 have hit me, kicked, elbowed and pushed on several different occasions.

My approach to children has not changed in those 15 years and I have always had great relationships with the children I care for. I have other children I look after who would not dream of behaving this way so it isn’t a lack of boundaries issue. None of the children who hit have SEN.

I am honestly gobsmacked. I expect hitting from toddlers but developmentally children should be able to control physical outbursts by about 4 years old. The children in question do all have similarities in their home life. Parents working very long hours (sometimes unavoidable I understand) and then children are attending clubs all weekend so are barely getting any time with parents.

AIBU to think it’s linked to this? Because I’m seriously feeling down about my job. I do not go to work to get hit multiple times a week by children and I’m now questioning my ability and whether to pack it all in even though there are other children in my care I have really lovely relationships with. I’ve never known this with multiple children of that age in 15 years of doing this to think they are okay to hit an adult especially someone outside of their family.

OP posts:
Shopper727 · 09/10/2023 20:11

My ‘sen’ kid never hit anyone it’s not an excuse some children with asd do not understand but I know my son knows hitting is wrong.

however I’ve just spent the day being kicked and hit by 3 year olds whilst giving them flu vaccine. Parents negotiating with children who don’t understand, it’s a bit infuriating, lots of ‘we don’t say no’ etc fair enough but I have 5 mins per appointment I don’t have time for tantrums and parents trying to negotiate treats or begging a kid who is screaming etc to get a nasal vaccine.

I understand it’s scary coming to the nurse if they’ve had a previous bad experience or whatever I’m kind and patient with parents and kids, but am sick of parents letting their kids kick and hit me. I’ve decided I’m not putting up with it, I wouldn’t allow my children (have 4) to kick anyone! You hold them and are firm with them re kicking etc I was shocked today tbh and like op I don’t go to work to be kicked

WillowCraft · 09/10/2023 20:02

CanvaQueen · 09/10/2023 10:18

I agreed with you until this post. You are being judgemental and frankly sound jealous. Many senior jobs don’t allow reduced hours and you have no idea of their finances. They might be paying off debt or studying all hours for a career change to allow more time at home for all you know. Very few parents actively want to be away from their children.

The parents sound weak but they’re paying your wages, so if you don’t like the children then give them notice. Hopefully the children get a childminder who is able to achieve proper behaviour in them soon.

I know plenty of parents who would rather spend time anywhere than with their children, particularly dads . This is why boarding school is popular with richer people, and slightly less well off people can manage the next best thing with long hours in childcare.

I think it's pretty selfish to have both parents work full time with primary aged children, unless both parents are in low paid jobs (but it's never low earners that do it, probably because min wage work is worse than spending time with your kids). It is prioritising the parents lifestyle over the welfare of the child.

WillowCraft · 09/10/2023 19:51

unvillage · 09/10/2023 01:16

Time outs are very outdated. Early years settings don't use them any more. The children learn nothing from them.

Not true. Two nurseries attended by my children use time out and so does my son's primary school (reception class). Only today the health visitor told me I should put my 2 year old in time out if he hits his brother.

Worriedmotheroftwo · 09/10/2023 19:49

As people on MN are typically quite career driven im not surprised how they are getting defensive.

Urgh.

Worriedmotheroftwo · 09/10/2023 19:44

So if the children are diagnosed with SEN does that give them a free pass to hit their carers? While I appreciate there are different levels of SEN surely all children need to learn that some types of behaviour is not acceptable.

Of course not. Who mentioned a free pass? But surely you know that some more are developmentally very very delayed- some have basically the impulse control of 2 or 3 year olds. I'm desperately trying everything I can to stop my 4 year old from hitting - and he feels so ashamed after - but it's not about him 'learning' that this sort of behaviour is unacceptable. He KNOWS! I can't believe how uninformed some people are about SEN!

Vand · 09/10/2023 12:16

Ace56 · 09/10/2023 11:14

Why is it the childminder’s job to instil proper behaviour in them? This is the parents’ job and the child carer/nanny/teacher/whoever else is in the child’s life should be there as a support to back this up. It is not someone else’s job to raise your kids.

At the end of the day if you are working very long hours and never see your children, no matter your financial circumstances, you need to accept that this will likely cause some issues. As I said upthread, children who continuously feel that they come second to their parents’ jobs are likely to lash out against this in some way and it’s the OP who is bearing the brunt of this.

As people on MN are typically quite career driven im not surprised how they are getting defensive.

However there is a massive difference between, for example:
Child A’s mum and dad work mon-fri in a shop and as a workman. They have to attend a breakfast club and are picked up at half 6. They spend the weekend typically with both parents and go to the park etc although sometimes either parent has to work a weekend shift.

Child B’s parent1 works from home and does the drop off at breakfast club and picks up at 7pm. Parent 2 stays at work until 8pm. Both have careers that mean they travel abroad once each a month for a week at a time. 2 weeks of the month there is only one parent home. Child B’s weekends are packed with swimming, football, drama, tennis etc while parents go to coffee shop to do work. They are fed by me in the evening and go home are bathed by a parent and put into bed for a 6.30am start the next day. They have several holidays abroad a year. But typically spend about 2 hours a day with their child.

OP posts:
Ace56 · 09/10/2023 11:14

CanvaQueen · 09/10/2023 10:18

I agreed with you until this post. You are being judgemental and frankly sound jealous. Many senior jobs don’t allow reduced hours and you have no idea of their finances. They might be paying off debt or studying all hours for a career change to allow more time at home for all you know. Very few parents actively want to be away from their children.

The parents sound weak but they’re paying your wages, so if you don’t like the children then give them notice. Hopefully the children get a childminder who is able to achieve proper behaviour in them soon.

Why is it the childminder’s job to instil proper behaviour in them? This is the parents’ job and the child carer/nanny/teacher/whoever else is in the child’s life should be there as a support to back this up. It is not someone else’s job to raise your kids.

At the end of the day if you are working very long hours and never see your children, no matter your financial circumstances, you need to accept that this will likely cause some issues. As I said upthread, children who continuously feel that they come second to their parents’ jobs are likely to lash out against this in some way and it’s the OP who is bearing the brunt of this.

caban · 09/10/2023 10:36

This behaviour is common in schools now too and isn't particularly linked to working parents - there are plenty of SAHP's who have children with social, emotional and behavioural problems.

You're not paid enough to deal with this though, especially as a lone worker - and you can't let over 5s impact on your care of little ones.

I'd have a zero tolerance policy on violence or non-compliance for school age children from now on - immediate notice for this kind of behaviour.

Boymamabee · 09/10/2023 10:32

@Vinrouge4 I’ve noticed a strange shift lately. When I was growing up, SEN kids (including myself) were expected to totally conform to society without reasonable accommodations, which of course was wrong. But now it’s too far the other way and it’s like some parents want to keep them stuck. It should be somewhere in the middle I think. My son has asd and is in a nurture setting. Everyday I hear the teacher informing parents that the kids were hitting or “didn’t have kind hands” as they prefer to put it. Parents seem nonplussed and now my son is starting to imitate these behaviours (even copying their tone of voice etc)

CanvaQueen · 09/10/2023 10:18

Vand · 09/10/2023 04:38

@DivorcingEU Thank you for your reply! It’s almost comforting to know I’m not the only one in this boat. I of course have no issue with working parents, I will add though that the parents of the children I am talking about in my OP are not working class and work to make ends meet. They are people with very developed careers and make a lot of money. So I suppose I am less sympathetic.

It must be great money wise and fulfilling To them to be so far into their careers. But at what cost? Would cutting down hours and having one or two less holidays abroad a year not be worth spending more time with your child On a day to day basis so that they don’t have violent behavioural problems? No brainier to me but I don’t think that opinion would go down well on MN.

I agreed with you until this post. You are being judgemental and frankly sound jealous. Many senior jobs don’t allow reduced hours and you have no idea of their finances. They might be paying off debt or studying all hours for a career change to allow more time at home for all you know. Very few parents actively want to be away from their children.

The parents sound weak but they’re paying your wages, so if you don’t like the children then give them notice. Hopefully the children get a childminder who is able to achieve proper behaviour in them soon.

helpfulperson · 09/10/2023 10:14

unvillage · 09/10/2023 01:16

Time outs are very outdated. Early years settings don't use them any more. The children learn nothing from them.

So what do you suggest she does when hit repeatedly by a child?

Jellycatspyjamas · 09/10/2023 10:08

No but I expect the childminder to be available to all the kids as needed, particularly when there are known behavioural issues. Time in isn’t a great way of managing behaviour in situations with one adult and a group of kids.

Polopolly · 09/10/2023 10:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previouslly banned poster.

Jellycatspyjamas · 09/10/2023 09:57

Given there seems to be a fair amount of poor behaviour and hitting I’d not be confident at leaving them to play unsupervised while I did time in with another child.

Polopolly · 09/10/2023 09:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previouslly banned poster.

Jellycatspyjamas · 09/10/2023 09:38

time out is outdated and most if not all childcare and school settings don’t do it anymore. Time in is more appropriate

Time in is fine if you have one child, what do the other kids do when the OP is sitting having time in with the child who is hitting. Some kids just don’t manage group after school care, because for whatever reason they can’t regulate their behaviour to cope with a group setting. I’d be talking to the parents about the need to find an alternative care provider who can cater to their needs. SEN or not if they aren’t able to regulate and the cater can’t keep the kids and herself safe it’s the wrong setting for them.

Valeriekat · 09/10/2023 09:37

EachPeachPearNectarine · 09/10/2023 02:01

Nope they don't. I still wouldn't want a childminder who judged my parenting/working and didn't like my DCs.

No one likes children who hit them.

Polopolly · 09/10/2023 09:26

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previouslly banned poster.

Desecratedcoconut · 09/10/2023 09:25

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 09/10/2023 09:23

@Ponoka7

The children OP is discussing are not toddlers or pre school, they are Eight or older. Quite soon, they will be able to cause significant injury to an adult, and even more significant injury to a child.

Didn't she say 6-8? Not ideal but some way off getting an asbo.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 09/10/2023 09:23

@Ponoka7

The children OP is discussing are not toddlers or pre school, they are Eight or older. Quite soon, they will be able to cause significant injury to an adult, and even more significant injury to a child.

Ponoka7 · 09/10/2023 09:12

Vinrouge4 · 09/10/2023 07:57

So if the children are diagnosed with SEN does that give them a free pass to hit their carers? While I appreciate there are different levels of SEN surely all children need to learn that some types of behaviour is not acceptable.

They don't get a free pass, but as you understand that children under two can't always regulate their feelings, or have impulse control, some children who have SEN can't until much later. So the methods used change. It's difficult when a child is at a childminders because the triggers might be present. My youngest GC didn't stop hitting until five. I'd had enough and threatened to hit back, her elder sister started to hit back, she stopped. It can be a reason why 1-to-1 care is needed, though

DriftingDora · 09/10/2023 09:08

EachPeachPearNectarine · 09/10/2023 01:30

You seem very judgemental about the parents and not to like the kids. If you were my childminder I'd prefer you to just give me notice so I could find someone else.

What a stupid, ill-informed comment. So you let your kids just use you as a punch bag, do you? Or expect that their childminders/teachers will allow them to run riot? What a wonderful parent you must be.

Ace56 · 09/10/2023 09:00

BBno4 · 09/10/2023 07:38

As a childcare worker I judge parents, all of us do.

We had a child who was in 7.30 till 6 then went home with a babysitter. They were in 51 weeks of the year we were open.

They were crying out for their parents attention, management ended up having to force them to give her a break, her behaviour was very bad.

It doesn't mean we are in the wrong career, it means we can see the patterns of behaviour and the causes behind it as we have years and years of experience with multiple children that parents don't have.

I am also a parent myself and have used nurseries so I understand the need for childcare but there needs to be a balance between career chasing and spending time with your children.

We have had parents go on annual leave, go abroad and still leave their children in nursery getting grandparents to collect them. And they will collect them at the last possible minute. This won't be from parents who spend regular time with their children and want a break, but from parents who don't.

We have had parent in shock that we close down Christmas Eve and are shut until New year asking us what are they going to do with their child.

So yes, we do judge.

I agree with this.

ALL childcare workers and teachers make assumptions and judgements about a child’s home life and parenting. Anyone who thinks they don’t is very naive!

And so they should. Someone like OP has been in the business for 15 years, they know what’s ‘normal’ for a child and what’s not, and also can see the patterns in behaviour in those children who never see their parents and those who do. Of course parents have to work, but if your child continuously feels that they come second to your job there will undoubtedly be issues.

itsgettingweird · 09/10/2023 08:02

SEMH difficulties in children is increasing massively.

The cause? Who knows. But I think it's a whole combination of things.

I'm an absolute advocate for all behaviour is communication. But I feel it's taken too far now that people think the behaviour is ok because^^ it's communicating rather than tell them the behaviour isn't ok, teach better ways and getting to the root cause.

I work in pastoral care and I do a combination of extra nurture alongside the firm boundaries. Most of the children do get it in the end that hitting me won't get them attention - they'll get that attention regardless of their behaviour. So the behaviour does stop. But it's not easy and a long road to that recovery.

Flowers
Vinrouge4 · 09/10/2023 07:57

So if the children are diagnosed with SEN does that give them a free pass to hit their carers? While I appreciate there are different levels of SEN surely all children need to learn that some types of behaviour is not acceptable.