Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools and charity status

243 replies

The6thQueen · 08/10/2023 20:03

Yes, another thread. But, maybe from a different angle?

I'm interested to know how many mumsnet readers know that most universities are charities or are charity exempt (including Oxford). That we don’t pay VAT on university fees, or services from healthcare providers (including non registered, if they are supervised by registered healthcare), including pharmacies and, that private healthcare suppliers fall under this exemption.

I’m raising as Labour’s altered plans with regard to charity status and taxes for private schools may be far more complicated than the public expects. Legalities and the far reaching impact the policies may have beyond education and its VAT exempt status.

I suppose my AIBU is that most of the general public don’t realise the use of charity status and VAT exemption and how removing them from the private education sector is not that simple.

OP posts:
Rudderneck · 08/10/2023 22:58

I have always had the impression that people don't really get the concept of charity status, because they are confused by the word"charity". And it tends to bring a sense that an institution is doing some kind of good work for poor people.

But it can also be about the state not getting tax from basic parts of human life, so long as they are not being operated on a for-profit basis.

So parts of human life that are seen as necessary/important for people to do - like educating their children. Yes, the state does offer education, but no one is required to submit their kids to what the state sees fit.

Parents have a duty to see their kids educated and the right to do so in the way they think best, without paying taxes to the state for that privilege, (so long as the form of education does not go so far as to deny the child their right to a good education.)

One way parents can do that is to hire a tutor, or get together with other parents and fund a school. So long as it's not a for-profit enterprise, why would it pay taxes? The parents are already paying their own taxes, the teachers etc hired are paying taxes, and they are all paying taxes to fund state schools. The idea that the state would make parents pay extra to educate their own kids rather than send them to state school is quite invasive really.

doubleshift · 08/10/2023 22:58

@Nowanextraone my LA pay for my child's EHCP place in an independent (mainstream) school. No way you should fund yours.

MotherEarthisaTerf · 08/10/2023 22:58

Circe7 · 08/10/2023 22:38

@MotherEarthisaTerf
I’ve read that education for children with SEN may remain exempt (obviously no guarantees). Labour will probably need to consult on VAT on school fees. Most tax changes like this go through consultation. This process might be rushed because they want to push it through quickly. At that point I would recommend responding to the consultation to highlight the issues for children with SEN and get as many other parents as you can to respond. My firm and other law firms often respond to these sorts of consultations to suggest areas where the proposed law won’t work or would be unfair and would do that here specifically on the SEN point. I think you have a good chance of getting special treatment for children with SEN but the key will be getting the legislation wide enough to cover all children affected.

I hope they will be given an exemption but I’m not hopeful.

im also concerned because any form of diagnosis and support in schools / camhs for neurodivergency is barely there. Only if your child is in crisis. People whose children are barely coping in education who decide a small quiet school will suit them may not appreciate it’s because their child has undiagnosed SEN. In our area dyslexia isn’t even diagnosed?!

many parents who push for private out of need may not get the Sen qualification for reduction in vat. All this to distribute wealth. To tax a ‘luxury’ spend. Just feels really backwards to me.

we need our country to grow in education, innovation, technical services etc. we want to be industry leading in lots of areas - Labour want to achieve this by taxing learning?

Circe7 · 08/10/2023 22:55

@RoseAndRose
I would have assumed it requires legislation because the definition of eligible body is in the notes to group 6 of Sch 8 VATA and the notes are amended by legislation. Charitable private schools currently meet that definition. Would be interested if there’s a different view though? It obviously does depend how they implement it.

Davros · 08/10/2023 22:54

Not all private schools have charitable status. Some are purely a business and might be part of a large group

Scaevola · 08/10/2023 22:50

VAT is not charged on essential goods like milk, bread, even physical books

Physical books (and certain other printed materials) are free of all sales taxes across the world (UN treaty, the Florence Agreement) - no tax on knowledge/education

Essential foodstuff are subject to VAT in some EU countries (eg Sweden). They are not VAT exempt, rather they are zero-rated in some countries including UK

WineIsMyCarb · 08/10/2023 22:47

Will independent schools not be able to disaggregate their fees and charge separately for the education element to the childcare/ food / other aspects of school life?

RoseAndRose · 08/10/2023 22:44

Circe7 · 08/10/2023 22:38

@MotherEarthisaTerf
I’ve read that education for children with SEN may remain exempt (obviously no guarantees). Labour will probably need to consult on VAT on school fees. Most tax changes like this go through consultation. This process might be rushed because they want to push it through quickly. At that point I would recommend responding to the consultation to highlight the issues for children with SEN and get as many other parents as you can to respond. My firm and other law firms often respond to these sorts of consultations to suggest areas where the proposed law won’t work or would be unfair and would do that here specifically on the SEN point. I think you have a good chance of getting special treatment for children with SEN but the key will be getting the legislation wide enough to cover all children affected.

Are you sure it requires legislation?

Why wouldn't the issuing of a new VAT notice suffice?

Daddybegood · 08/10/2023 22:41

Not for profit, no dividends, legal covenants & charitable board oversight = charity
As a collective private schools provide £930m towards bursaries / scholarships pa, making it one of the biggest charitable providers in the UK.
No other charity pays VAT, no other education (including tutoring, university tuition fees) services pays VAT.
No other country in the world charges VAT on any educational service or registered charity
I'm Labour too, its a terrible regressive policy. Raise taxes, stop copying the Tories tax code & stop throwing red meat untruths around to justify this nonsense

Circe7 · 08/10/2023 22:38

@MotherEarthisaTerf
I’ve read that education for children with SEN may remain exempt (obviously no guarantees). Labour will probably need to consult on VAT on school fees. Most tax changes like this go through consultation. This process might be rushed because they want to push it through quickly. At that point I would recommend responding to the consultation to highlight the issues for children with SEN and get as many other parents as you can to respond. My firm and other law firms often respond to these sorts of consultations to suggest areas where the proposed law won’t work or would be unfair and would do that here specifically on the SEN point. I think you have a good chance of getting special treatment for children with SEN but the key will be getting the legislation wide enough to cover all children affected.

carlydiamond · 08/10/2023 22:36

As a previous poster said, the idea that the state sector will benefit from teachers living from the private sector is a fallacy. They will simply move abroad to international schools or leave the profession.

Scaevola · 08/10/2023 22:32

Universities aren't "charity exempt" re VAT on fees

Private schools that are run as businesses, not charities, are exempt
Private schools that are charities are exempt

Preschools and nurseries, whether business or charitable, are exempt.

That is because EU enshrined in VAT law/regulations "no taxation on education"
Since Brexit, we can rewrite those rules.

The charity angle is completely irrelevant.

But if they change it so that there is VAT on fees for education in certain circumstances (which already exists btw to a certain extent for crammers that just sell the course, rather than the full range of school/university life) then it will be achieved (probably) by defining the institution which must charge it.

edwinbear · 08/10/2023 22:30

As @Circe7 mentioned, we’ll pay all DC’s fees until the end of 6th form up front, before it’s implemented. A huge number of parents at DC’s school are considering the same. It will be cheaper to remortgage the house to fund it than pay 20% VAT.

MotherEarthisaTerf · 08/10/2023 22:28

MrsPuddle · 08/10/2023 22:22

@MotherEarthisaTerf I feel for you, I really do. The state doesn’t offer decent support for parents with statemented children and should be grateful you are willing to pay for help. To add 20 % more is a nightmare.

Thank you, the past few years fighting for support for their hidden disabilities has been absolutely harrowing. My children need more, I’ll make sure they get it.

MotherEarthisaTerf · 08/10/2023 22:24

NalafromtheLionKing · 08/10/2023 21:37

I agree with this, and definitely don’t think VAT should be charged on uni fees (young people get too rough a deal as it is, these days, without adding yet more to their burden).

What about super wealthy uni students? The ones who will pay VAT at private schools before they go to uni? They are disproportionately represented at uni already.

what annoys me is it’s not a tax on wealth or at the source of earnings. It’s on what they consider easy to grab, even if it affects children. Yes people who attend private school have wealthier parents than average - but this wealth is vastly different from family to family.

fwiw we plan on funding our private school by downsizing, moving somewhere cheaper and using equity. the eldest starts secondary in 2 years- if labour comes into power we will instead go for plan B.

MrsPuddle · 08/10/2023 22:22

@MotherEarthisaTerf I feel for you, I really do. The state doesn’t offer decent support for parents with statemented children and should be grateful you are willing to pay for help. To add 20 % more is a nightmare.

Waitingfortheconferencehosttojoin · 08/10/2023 22:10

Well completely @MotherEarthisaTerf - they’ve not thought about all us parents saving them a fortune by paying school fees for independent school rather than forcing the LA to pay via an EHCP. SEN is the only reason any of my kids are in independent schools.

Angrymum22 · 08/10/2023 21:56

I agree with your point re the knock on effect in other vat exempt businesses. I am a dentist, we effectively sub contract to the NHS but also provide private services. A significant proportion of the private work is elective cosmetic treatment which really should attract VAT. It does save a lot of hassle not having to do VAT returns.
If they do change the law re private schools then there is a good chance they will start to look at other easy forms of revenue from elective private health sector. Then where will it stop.

MotherEarthisaTerf · 08/10/2023 21:55

Waitingfortheconferencehosttojoin · 08/10/2023 21:32

Well they’re not going to get any more money out of me by putting VAT on school fees - because I’ll just have less money to spend on other things (that I would also pay VAT on…) that must be true of a lot of people?

I’m not a tax avoider by any means. I pay a lot of it and (until the tories started spaffing it up the wall) happy to pay it, because I believe in the welfare state. VAT on school fees just seems ill-thought out to me. It won’t stop me voting Labour at the next election, but I’m sure it will stop others.

I wouldn’t be able to send mine. I’ll put what school fees we would have spent into solicitors for spanking ehcps including state funded private schools like a semh. Council will pay for transport, the document will last till they’re 25. I’ll take up teachers and school staff time making sure my kids get what they’re legally entitled to which will be iron clad in the ehcp I will pay privately to make excellent clear legal provisions for the kids.

id rather a small community school with tiny class sizes and the provision for sensory needs and dyslexic learning styles.

without this the kids will need to be mainstream educated until they inevitably crash - push against resources in CAMHS and they’re secondary school and probably need to be home educated for a stint.

educated resourceful parents like myself pushed out of private education are going to be a fucking nightmare for mainstreams.

The6thQueen · 08/10/2023 21:43

@Circe7 you’ve made my point far more eloquently than I did!

OP posts:
NalafromtheLionKing · 08/10/2023 21:37

buckingmad · 08/10/2023 20:37

But school budgets are stretched as it is? Then you’re adding more students who would have originally been privately educated to already oversubscribed classes? I’m not sure the budgets stretch to hiring all these extra teachers you’re talking about.

To me it sounds like a jealousy tax. Discouraging people from using private education doesn’t make state schools better/provide more money. It won’t discourage the ultra wealthy but it will hit the middle class (as per) the worst.

VAT is not charged on essential goods like milk, bread, even physical books (it is charged on digital downloads). It should not be added to education.

I agree with this, and definitely don’t think VAT should be charged on uni fees (young people get too rough a deal as it is, these days, without adding yet more to their burden).

MrsPuddle · 08/10/2023 21:33

fattytum · 08/10/2023 20:28

There are too many schools in the country to staff them all, private schools closing because of this will be very good for the state sector, as the number of children changing to the state sector will be more than compensated for by the increase in the pool of teachers to fill state sector positions.

Many teachers mix time in each sector throughout their career, but teaching in a state school often offers better pay and conditions, and staff who are in a bit of a rut in the private sector would benefit from the freedom too

why Do you think teaching in the state sector offers better pay and conditions? Nonsense I’m afraid. Unless of course state schools have suddenly started to offer: smaller classes, more resources, free lunch, less micromanagement, fewer statemented pupils, better behaviour etc etc

this doesn’t mean private school teachers are better than state school, not at all. It just means a large percentage would not want to swap to state school. It is a different environment.

Circe7 · 08/10/2023 21:33

I'm a tax lawyer and also interested in how this would be implemented. I agree with pp that VAT is a bit of a mess anyway so taking private schools out of the VAT exemption won't necessarily make it noticeably worse.

But the education exemption will end up being very odd and inconsistent - i.e. VAT charged on education for children but not for adults (because universities and training providers for adults will presumably retain exemption). This includes providers like law schools which are expensive and not generally covered by the tuition fee loan scheme (fees are usually covered by law firms for their trainees). Plus what do you do about vocational training courses for 17 year olds - is a full time vocational training course a school?

You then potentially have e.g. music lessons and swimming lessons out of school exempt but VAT charged if a music lesson or swimming lesson is provided in the context of a private school (unless the private school can find a way to split out that element and exempt it). And you have to decide what to do about tuition in e.g. maths and english outside of a school context, which would currently often be exempt.

If they try to keep education for children with SEN exempt that's even more complex.

You also have the issue of a significant divergence from EU law. We have generally tried to avoid this so far as it causes all sorts of legal issues.

I think it is an "attack" much more than a money maker though. There would be many easier ways to raise the amount of tax involved and it is very hard to predict the amount this policy might raise. Private schools are likely to delay capital projects until after the exemption is removed so that they can claim back VAT on construction costs - the wealthier private schools spend millions on these sorts of projects so that could have a significant impact. There is then the displacement of students into the state sector, which will be uneven and may result in needing additional classroom space in some areas. Plus some parents will pay years of tuition fees in advance of the VAT coming in which will reduce the VAT received in the first few years.

But in terms of private schools being charities, plenty of charities are businesses. They just need to have an asset lock so that shareholders can't take profit out and it has to be ploughed back into the charitable purpose. Private schools are some of the first charities and a lot of the point of charity law is to transcend politics so that charitable status can't just be removed on a political whim.

Waitingfortheconferencehosttojoin · 08/10/2023 21:32

Well they’re not going to get any more money out of me by putting VAT on school fees - because I’ll just have less money to spend on other things (that I would also pay VAT on…) that must be true of a lot of people?

I’m not a tax avoider by any means. I pay a lot of it and (until the tories started spaffing it up the wall) happy to pay it, because I believe in the welfare state. VAT on school fees just seems ill-thought out to me. It won’t stop me voting Labour at the next election, but I’m sure it will stop others.

The6thQueen · 08/10/2023 21:06

And the suggestion that any VAT would ‘simply be added to education for those under 16’, it’s not that easy! You’d wipe out music tuition, sports coaching and private tutors in one fell swoop.
Of course it’s doable, but it’s not the clean cut it’s being made out to be. And will have ramifications far beyond a few private schools closing and a drop in the ocean of money for the state education sector.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread