Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools and charity status

243 replies

The6thQueen · 08/10/2023 20:03

Yes, another thread. But, maybe from a different angle?

I'm interested to know how many mumsnet readers know that most universities are charities or are charity exempt (including Oxford). That we don’t pay VAT on university fees, or services from healthcare providers (including non registered, if they are supervised by registered healthcare), including pharmacies and, that private healthcare suppliers fall under this exemption.

I’m raising as Labour’s altered plans with regard to charity status and taxes for private schools may be far more complicated than the public expects. Legalities and the far reaching impact the policies may have beyond education and its VAT exempt status.

I suppose my AIBU is that most of the general public don’t realise the use of charity status and VAT exemption and how removing them from the private education sector is not that simple.

OP posts:
Dibblydoodahdah · 09/10/2023 00:01

Yazo · 08/10/2023 23:58

@MintJulia they're not all Eton, but when you're talking about distributing tax exemptions, it doesn't make sense to distribute them to those most able to pay. Although private schools offer some bursaries, on the whole they're funded by the wealthiest in society (whether they consider themselves wealthy or not if you have a 5 figure sum spare each year you are)

I know plenty of people who earn more than me and send their children to state school. In fact I earned the same as my state school teacher brother when my DS1 started at private school. Do you consider him wealthy?!

Yazo · 08/10/2023 23:58

@MintJulia they're not all Eton, but when you're talking about distributing tax exemptions, it doesn't make sense to distribute them to those most able to pay. Although private schools offer some bursaries, on the whole they're funded by the wealthiest in society (whether they consider themselves wealthy or not if you have a 5 figure sum spare each year you are)

asterel · 08/10/2023 23:56

Circe7 · 08/10/2023 23:40

@bellamountain
It’s worth noting that even if private schools weren’t charities are were subject to corporation tax they would pay little to none because spending on tennis courts, new theatres, staff salaries etc is all deductible for corporation tax (over time).

Labour has probably dropped the charitable status thing because private schools would pay very little tax on normal principles.

Yes indeed - I think people simply don’t understand that private schools, like universities, are not making profits. Because they are charities any surplus gets reinvested, there isn’t anyone to pay it to - so it wouldn’t generally be taxable anyway. But most educational charities aren’t making surpluses, no matter how plush they seem. Generally, they’re expensive because what they’re providing is expensive. The biggest costs are usually on salaries and building maintenance; and the more staff you have (the selling point of most private schools), the more it costs.

I’m no fan of expensive private schools - went to a comprehensive myself - but I’m a trustee of three very different educational charities, and of course I know how their accounts all work: and even at the most expensive private schools the biggest costs will be all the Latin teachers, all the specialist music teachers and choirmasters, all the sports teachers, all the housemasters and matrons, etc. etc.; and the buildings maintenance. Fees in that sector are expensive because the parents are paying for more, and more expensive, staff.

If you don’t like the idea that rich people can pay to get someone to teach their kid Ancient Greek, or medieval counterpoint on the organ, because you think that if the local comp doesn’t do it then nobody should be able to, fine! Just don’t kid yourself that it’s going to benefit anyone in the state sector in any way.

MintJulia · 08/10/2023 23:55

@fattytum There are a growing number of privately run universities in the U.K. Buckingham is one, BPP is another. We are up to about 50 now. So there is a growing private alternative that earns billions for the U.K. every year and provides thousands of jobs.

The independent school my ds attends is not a business, it makes no profit, has no shareholders and provides scholarships, bursaries and charitable services such as providing the provision for the key workers during covid because the local state school refused. Ours also provides for the children of members of the armed forces, who have been posted abroad.

You need to fully understand the wide ranging damage a change to VAT rules would cause. Not all private schools are Eton, or anything like.

Dibblydoodahdah · 08/10/2023 23:52

Yazo · 08/10/2023 23:47

@Dibblydoodahdah how would you even know? Do they have to tell you where they go? Some reasons include not having to be onsite evenings and weekends for extras, more progression, better pay and conditions. Of course a tougher job in a state school but some state schools are better and more pleasant to work in than some independent schools.

We always get told where a leaving teacher is going to. It’s published in newsletters. My DS2’s state school do the same!

Dibblydoodahdah · 08/10/2023 23:51

Yazo · 08/10/2023 23:44

@Dibblydoodahdah from the isc "Some independent schools will appoint teachers with no training or experience but plenty of potential, others will not." It happens more than they'd say! Top schools too where you're a friend or relative of the right person

In ten years at my DC’s prep they’ve appointed one newly qualified class teacher and even they were fully qualified, they just didn’t have any post qualification experience. In fact, when my DS1 was in pre-school they even had two fully qualified teachers in there, not just nursery nurses as they did in his day nursery. Anyway, if the private sector is so full of non-qualified teachers why are people getting their knickers in a twist about the “elitism” of private schools?!!!

Yazo · 08/10/2023 23:47

@Dibblydoodahdah how would you even know? Do they have to tell you where they go? Some reasons include not having to be onsite evenings and weekends for extras, more progression, better pay and conditions. Of course a tougher job in a state school but some state schools are better and more pleasant to work in than some independent schools.

Yazo · 08/10/2023 23:44

@Dibblydoodahdah from the isc "Some independent schools will appoint teachers with no training or experience but plenty of potential, others will not." It happens more than they'd say! Top schools too where you're a friend or relative of the right person

Dibblydoodahdah · 08/10/2023 23:41

Fleabane · 08/10/2023 20:29

Universities are open to everyone who meet their entry criteria. Private schools aren't.

Universities are academically selective but many private schools are not. There are many private schools that are less elite than Oxbridge, for example.

Circe7 · 08/10/2023 23:40

@bellamountain
It’s worth noting that even if private schools weren’t charities are were subject to corporation tax they would pay little to none because spending on tennis courts, new theatres, staff salaries etc is all deductible for corporation tax (over time).

Labour has probably dropped the charitable status thing because private schools would pay very little tax on normal principles.

asterel · 08/10/2023 23:38

Fleabane · 08/10/2023 20:29

Universities are open to everyone who meet their entry criteria. Private schools aren't.

I’m not sure why you think this - they really aren’t. Regardless of whether you meet the formal entry criteria, a university doesn’t have to make you an offer. There are a certain number of places; and admissions staff decide who is offered one. They pick the students, not the other way around!

Plenty of applicants meet the criteria but are not offered a place, especially at the most competitive universities.

Circe7 · 08/10/2023 23:36

RoseAndRose · 08/10/2023 22:58

They're not planning on this being a measure just for private schools which are charities, but for all private schools.

Does that make any difference?

I don’t think so. The education is drafted in terms of eligible bodies. Most charities meet this definition which is what makes supplies of education by private schools which are charities VAT exempt. If a private school isn’t currently an eligible body it will probably already be charging VAT on fees. Some VAT notices or parts of them have the force of law but only where the law says that detailed rules are set out in a notice and notices don’t directly contradict law.

Dibblydoodahdah · 08/10/2023 23:33

Yazo · 08/10/2023 23:31

Teachers I know working in the private sector were unsuccessful for public sector jobs and/or not qualified to work in the public sector. Regardless, private schools aren't going to close at such a number that there are lots of teachers at a loose end. It makes sense to me, they're not charities and serve the wealthiest in society. Universities are different, as someone said the entry criteria is not based on wealth although like everything in life, is certainly easier to get in with it. Besides, no need to conflate the issue and private schools and the impact on tax receipts is reasonable to look at.

Many of the teachers at my DS’ private school taught in state schools before they moved to the private sector. I can ensure you that they are all properly qualified.

asterel · 08/10/2023 23:33

R37sraY · 08/10/2023 20:53

I don’t think it will.

They are attacking independence. It’s not about money.

Govt controls almost all the universities and won’t attack itself.

Separate question whether degrees are worth it. This is something every teenager now needs to consider. What will her career look like with a degree, what will it look like without? Is that worth c.£100k with interest by the time she pays it back?

If she expects lower pay, is it worth the extra 9% tax annually for 30 years?

On day 1, will she have a competitive advantage at all over a school leaver who by now has three years of experience and maybe ATC, ACCA etc

This post is a bit bizarre. The government doesn’t “control” universities - they are independent educational charities just like private schools are. Nearly all government funding has been removed from the university sector - that was the entire point of fees, remember?

Universities, like private schools, generally operate at break even, or often at a small deficit. Any surplus - unusual, tbh - is then reinvested or used to pay down any borrowing/make payments into pensions/invest in infrastructure - stuff like that. Most private schools’ accounts essentially look like state schools’ do - except the funding us coming from fees rather than from the government. Essentially, very like the situation that universities are now in with fees. That’s why the OP’s point is important.

State schools are also technically what are called “exempt charities” under the DfE (as the regulator instead of the Charity Commission).

It doesn’t really make economic sense to want to treat private schools as businesses - it’s a policy based entirely on not liking the idea that some parents are paying. As to what would happen if they all closed? The education budget - your taxes - would need to pay for those children’s education instead; so it would/will cost you personally more if private schools are abolished/disappear, as either taxes would need to rise to cover it, or public funding elsewhere would need to be cut. It wouldn’t be as negligible an amount as you think, either.

Charity law is pretty complex, and OP is right that there are all sorts of ramifications when you try to remove exemptions in some places (for example, a minute tax break enjoyed in my field was unable to be removed despite HMRC wanting and trying to, because its removal would essentially impact on the funds of the entire Church of England, which would then be unable to afford to pay its ministers. Bizarre, I know.)

Yazo · 08/10/2023 23:31

Teachers I know working in the private sector were unsuccessful for public sector jobs and/or not qualified to work in the public sector. Regardless, private schools aren't going to close at such a number that there are lots of teachers at a loose end. It makes sense to me, they're not charities and serve the wealthiest in society. Universities are different, as someone said the entry criteria is not based on wealth although like everything in life, is certainly easier to get in with it. Besides, no need to conflate the issue and private schools and the impact on tax receipts is reasonable to look at.

Dibblydoodahdah · 08/10/2023 23:29

fattytum · 08/10/2023 20:28

There are too many schools in the country to staff them all, private schools closing because of this will be very good for the state sector, as the number of children changing to the state sector will be more than compensated for by the increase in the pool of teachers to fill state sector positions.

Many teachers mix time in each sector throughout their career, but teaching in a state school often offers better pay and conditions, and staff who are in a bit of a rut in the private sector would benefit from the freedom too

You are absolutely deluded. I have not known one class teacher at my DS’ private school leave for the state sector. A few for senior leadership roles but that’s it. Why would they want to change from teaching 20 in a class to 30 plus, to get less holiday, no fee discount on their children’s school fees… they will either move to other private schools or leave teaching altogether.

Dibblydoodahdah · 08/10/2023 23:22

Whereforartthoudave · 08/10/2023 20:39

Most of us don’t use private schools and most of us are sick of the tax dodging that the wealthy are so good at.

The policy won’t affect the wealthy or the most elite schools. It will affect the smaller private schools and the middle class families who spend a significant part of their income on fees. There is no tax dodging. I earn four times as much as someone on minimum wage and pay ten times as much tax. It would cost the state £7k per year to educate my DS. I am saving the taxpayer that amount whilst contributing £25k in tax myself.

bellamountain · 08/10/2023 23:18

Whereforartthoudave · 08/10/2023 20:39

Most of us don’t use private schools and most of us are sick of the tax dodging that the wealthy are so good at.

Exactly and the argument that private schools are 'not for profit' is frankly absurd. They certainly profit when they have the means available to build new language centres, tennis courts, science centres.... the list goes on. Meanwhile, state schools down the road are literally crumbling.

doubleshift · 08/10/2023 23:12

@Penguinmouse the 'profit' for want of a better word is going back into education - bursaries, partnerships, outreach, education etc.
How is a school 'business' different from any other charity that pays CEOs exorbitant salaries. Schools aren't making profit for shareholders or a CEO to cream off in dividends.

Dibblydoodahdah · 08/10/2023 23:11

declutteringmymind · 08/10/2023 20:32

Keir Starmer, being a lawyer has studies the law to see if it's feasible, and I'm guessing it is.

Our children's independent school already has a plan, and are expecting to impose a 7 percent increase in increments. We are lucky that it is in a position to do that.

He’s such a good lawyer that it took him a years to work out that abolishing charitable status would be very difficult from a legal perspective. So he only abandoned that policy about a week ago even though many of us have been pointing out the problems with ending charitable status for a very long time.

doubleshift · 08/10/2023 23:09

@MotherEarthisaTerf what about SEN (EHCP) children in mainstream independent schools?

Penguinmouse · 08/10/2023 23:09

What charitable benefit do private schools provide? They are businesses. They aren’t teaching kids out of the goodness of their hearts.

stonedaisy · 08/10/2023 23:02

Rudderneck · 08/10/2023 22:58

I have always had the impression that people don't really get the concept of charity status, because they are confused by the word"charity". And it tends to bring a sense that an institution is doing some kind of good work for poor people.

But it can also be about the state not getting tax from basic parts of human life, so long as they are not being operated on a for-profit basis.

So parts of human life that are seen as necessary/important for people to do - like educating their children. Yes, the state does offer education, but no one is required to submit their kids to what the state sees fit.

Parents have a duty to see their kids educated and the right to do so in the way they think best, without paying taxes to the state for that privilege, (so long as the form of education does not go so far as to deny the child their right to a good education.)

One way parents can do that is to hire a tutor, or get together with other parents and fund a school. So long as it's not a for-profit enterprise, why would it pay taxes? The parents are already paying their own taxes, the teachers etc hired are paying taxes, and they are all paying taxes to fund state schools. The idea that the state would make parents pay extra to educate their own kids rather than send them to state school is quite invasive really.

I completely agree and i'm so surprised amd disappointed Keir Starmer would be even considering this

RoseAndRose · 08/10/2023 23:01

One way parents can do that is to hire a tutor, or get together with other parents and fund a school. So long as it's not a for-profit enterprise, why would it pay taxes?

The parental funding (ie fees) would be subject to VAT under these plans, no matter how small the school. Plus the parents would have to cover all the governance standards of a school, which might prove onerous.

RoseAndRose · 08/10/2023 22:58

Circe7 · 08/10/2023 22:55

@RoseAndRose
I would have assumed it requires legislation because the definition of eligible body is in the notes to group 6 of Sch 8 VATA and the notes are amended by legislation. Charitable private schools currently meet that definition. Would be interested if there’s a different view though? It obviously does depend how they implement it.

They're not planning on this being a measure just for private schools which are charities, but for all private schools.

Does that make any difference?

Swipe left for the next trending thread