Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools and charity status

243 replies

The6thQueen · 08/10/2023 20:03

Yes, another thread. But, maybe from a different angle?

I'm interested to know how many mumsnet readers know that most universities are charities or are charity exempt (including Oxford). That we don’t pay VAT on university fees, or services from healthcare providers (including non registered, if they are supervised by registered healthcare), including pharmacies and, that private healthcare suppliers fall under this exemption.

I’m raising as Labour’s altered plans with regard to charity status and taxes for private schools may be far more complicated than the public expects. Legalities and the far reaching impact the policies may have beyond education and its VAT exempt status.

I suppose my AIBU is that most of the general public don’t realise the use of charity status and VAT exemption and how removing them from the private education sector is not that simple.

OP posts:
FloorWipes · 09/10/2023 07:04

Asiatoyork · 09/10/2023 02:38

It’s so weird to me that no one has considered that private schools are not obliged to pass the full cost equivalent on the parents. They could operate more efficiently, maybe reduce the fancy stuff and therefore not need to increase the total fees by 20%

We are always told that many other institutions must find efficiencies etc. Feels like this should be part of of the conversation too from private school leadership.

We have considered it it’s just that we know already that many schools have very small margins as it is, particularly with the impact of energy price rises and inflation. There isn’t anything “fancy” to cut, besides maybe the classroom temperature. Because the reality of private school isn’t like the fantasy people seem to have in their heads.

Imjusttootired · 09/10/2023 06:53

@Morechocmorechoc there is no way I could ever afford private school for both my SEN children but does not mean we are any less capable than you.
most parents of SEN children are aware of everything you discussed.

Imjusttootired · 09/10/2023 06:50

Off topic but to the comment about 10k a year ?
where are these schools 😂
30-40k a year here !

Dibblydoodahdah · 09/10/2023 06:36

Asiatoyork · 09/10/2023 02:38

It’s so weird to me that no one has considered that private schools are not obliged to pass the full cost equivalent on the parents. They could operate more efficiently, maybe reduce the fancy stuff and therefore not need to increase the total fees by 20%

We are always told that many other institutions must find efficiencies etc. Feels like this should be part of of the conversation too from private school leadership.

Well I’ve listened to presentations from two headteachers of two different schools in the past week and both have said that the schools will be doing everything they can to reduce what they pass on to parents (e.g. by reclaiming VAT). The problem is that the smaller schools have a lot less flexibility to do this. They will be the ones that close. Also, reclaiming VAT means that Labour’s £1.7 billion figure is wrong. They won’t net any where near that amount.

fattytum · 09/10/2023 04:17

MotherEarthisaTerf · 08/10/2023 21:55

I wouldn’t be able to send mine. I’ll put what school fees we would have spent into solicitors for spanking ehcps including state funded private schools like a semh. Council will pay for transport, the document will last till they’re 25. I’ll take up teachers and school staff time making sure my kids get what they’re legally entitled to which will be iron clad in the ehcp I will pay privately to make excellent clear legal provisions for the kids.

id rather a small community school with tiny class sizes and the provision for sensory needs and dyslexic learning styles.

without this the kids will need to be mainstream educated until they inevitably crash - push against resources in CAMHS and they’re secondary school and probably need to be home educated for a stint.

educated resourceful parents like myself pushed out of private education are going to be a fucking nightmare for mainstreams.

confused about why you think you are more educated and resourceful than other state school parents?

GreenwichOrTwicks · 09/10/2023 04:04

Airy assumption that teachers will move to the state sector - most won’t. The best will remain in the fewer remaining fee-paying schools and the rest will find other jobs. So teacher recruitment will be even harder because of the increased numbers in the state schools will making teaching in them even less desirable than now.
The PP who said this is an envy tax was right.

Asiatoyork · 09/10/2023 02:38

It’s so weird to me that no one has considered that private schools are not obliged to pass the full cost equivalent on the parents. They could operate more efficiently, maybe reduce the fancy stuff and therefore not need to increase the total fees by 20%

We are always told that many other institutions must find efficiencies etc. Feels like this should be part of of the conversation too from private school leadership.

asterel · 09/10/2023 01:58

Why would, say, loads of surplus Latin or music teachers suddenly exiled from the private sector be a good thing for state schools? With no budget to hire them and no Classics programmes for them to teach or instruments for kids to play on? It’s just deluded to think that it would be good for the state education if lots of children left the private sector to go into the state sector. There would be less budget per child to go around, plus more pressure on resources.

I long for a decent government and a fairer, better economy - but this is just a really bad policy, based on an appeal to inverted class snobbery rather than any improvement it would deliver to state education. As a pp says above, education is not something we should be taxing right now. We should be taxing unproductive wealth hoarded in assets, tackling rentierism, redistributing housing wealth. It doesn’t make sense to tax education - we need more of it, not less.

It’s just an appeal to pure inverted snobbery; and it seems to rest on a rather nasty desire that some other people’s children should be unhappy and punished so that a few toffs don’t get to Eton. Bear in mind that many kids in the private sector are there purely because the state sector is not a good fit for them, because of SEN or a whole lot of other reasons — or because they were unhappy in a state school and there was no other viable alternative.

For every genuinely rich aristo heading off to Roedean, there will be other kids who were bullied at a previous school, or have dyslexia, or another reason why they are in private provision. And I’m pretty uncomfortable with a policy that doesn’t really do much aside from make a few kids unhappier — because if you think it’ll bring in loads of money, that the genuinely rich will be affected, or that suddenly they’ll stop getting all the nice high paying jobs in the city — or that state comps will miraculously suddenly be teaching Classics and rowing — then you’re really just kidding yourself.

DdraigGoch · 09/10/2023 01:07

The extra children bring extra funding,
It doesn't work like that @fattytum . The DfE has a fixed budget from the Treasury. Increasing the number of pupils will just decrease the per pupil funding.

and the extra specialist teachers being available saves the school money too
What makes you think that they'd want to?

asterel · 09/10/2023 01:00

Commonhousewitch · 09/10/2023 00:24

They are not charities and therefore shouldn't take advantage of tax breaks made for charities. And yes I also believe in "removing tax exemptions from real profit making companies; raising corporation tax; taxing energy companies’ profits; or even reducing all the massive grants we hand out each year to privatised transport companies just so that they can deliver big profits to their shareholders" - and getting rid of non-dom status and removing loopholes in CGT and IHT
Private education is only for the rich- if you can afford it you are richer than most

Right - well, they currently ARE charities; so you saying they aren’t doesn’t make much difference to that. I’m willing to bet there are lots of different kinds of charities you’d disapprove of, too, and which have not a great amount of what you might consider public benefit; so are you planning to vet them all?

And private education really isn’t only for the rich. There are many more small private schools that don’t charge massive fees than the big famous ones that do.

Are you genuinely suggesting that, say, spending 10k a year on private school fees makes you “rich”? Plenty of people spend more than that every year on holidays and new kitchens and cars and so on, but wouldn’t call themselves “rich”. By paying 10k, they also save you 5-7k in public funding; so you’re not exactly getting a bargain by making it unaffordable for them just because of being chippy.

There are many more people like that than there are oligarchs sending their kids to Marlborough.

Why don’t we tax a few buy to let landlords instead?

ittakes2 · 09/10/2023 00:58

fattytum · 08/10/2023 20:28

There are too many schools in the country to staff them all, private schools closing because of this will be very good for the state sector, as the number of children changing to the state sector will be more than compensated for by the increase in the pool of teachers to fill state sector positions.

Many teachers mix time in each sector throughout their career, but teaching in a state school often offers better pay and conditions, and staff who are in a bit of a rut in the private sector would benefit from the freedom too

Honestly and just where do you think the money will come from to pay private school teachers moving to government schools?
I can’t understand how anyone thinks all these kids in private schools in theory moving into free government school places are going to be funded.

DdraigGoch · 09/10/2023 00:57

Whereforartthoudave · 08/10/2023 20:39

Most of us don’t use private schools and most of us are sick of the tax dodging that the wealthy are so good at.

Will Labour be promising to put Capital Gains Tax back up to the same levels as Income Tax (less indexation) like it used to be then?

Dibblydoodahdah · 09/10/2023 00:46

tpxqi · 09/10/2023 00:44

The fact that this is Labour’s flagship policy tells you everything you need to know. Talk about re arranging the deckchairs.

At the next GE, one set of clowns will be replaced with another.

This is so true. The fact they have focused so much on this is very worrying. It means they have nothing else…

tpxqi · 09/10/2023 00:44

The fact that this is Labour’s flagship policy tells you everything you need to know. Talk about re arranging the deckchairs.

At the next GE, one set of clowns will be replaced with another.

Dibblydoodahdah · 09/10/2023 00:37

Commonhousewitch · 09/10/2023 00:24

They are not charities and therefore shouldn't take advantage of tax breaks made for charities. And yes I also believe in "removing tax exemptions from real profit making companies; raising corporation tax; taxing energy companies’ profits; or even reducing all the massive grants we hand out each year to privatised transport companies just so that they can deliver big profits to their shareholders" - and getting rid of non-dom status and removing loopholes in CGT and IHT
Private education is only for the rich- if you can afford it you are richer than most

The VAT exemption has nothing to do with charitable status. Please educate yourself.

DdraigGoch · 09/10/2023 00:35

Zampa · 08/10/2023 20:30

Labour aren't intending on removing the charitable status of schools. Just adding VAT to fees.

I wonder whether Starmer still feels that we should rejoin the EU. VAT on education would have been illegal before we left.

Dibblydoodahdah · 09/10/2023 00:34

@Yazo and to an extent it doesn’t matter whether the policy is introduced now or not, a lot of damage has already been done. I have never known so many kids take the 11 plus for state grammar at my DS’s prep as they did this year. It’s an all though so the majority usually stay on. Lots of people openly saying that they cannot afford the fees for seniors because the 20% VAT will push them over the edge. I looked at another very small private school yesterday and other prospective parents were actually discussing at the open day how they were worried that the school wouldn’t survive if VAT is imposed. There is nothing elite about that school. It’s full of children who couldn’t cope with state school or larger private schools. Lord knows what will happen to those children if it does close. Maybe they will end up at an Outstanding comp like my niece who is getting stuff thrown at her by other pupils in some of her classes! Oh well, I’m sure that the VAT generated can be used to deal with any mental health issues they suffer as a result.

Commonhousewitch · 09/10/2023 00:24

They are not charities and therefore shouldn't take advantage of tax breaks made for charities. And yes I also believe in "removing tax exemptions from real profit making companies; raising corporation tax; taxing energy companies’ profits; or even reducing all the massive grants we hand out each year to privatised transport companies just so that they can deliver big profits to their shareholders" - and getting rid of non-dom status and removing loopholes in CGT and IHT
Private education is only for the rich- if you can afford it you are richer than most

Dibblydoodahdah · 09/10/2023 00:20

Yazo · 09/10/2023 00:02

@Dibblydoodahdah because it's not about wanting what you've got, teachers or otherwise. Some people like myself are a bit dubious that it's better, let alone 'elite' from the best of the state sector, which is fantastic where it works well. It's about where taxes and tax exemptions should go and doesn't make sense for them to go to private schools when we have poorly funded state schools and support for children and young people across the country.

Oh and as for it not being better than the best of the state sector, well it depends on what you are looking for. My DS1 is at a top ten state school. The academic results are definitely better there than at DS2’s private school but the private school offers a lot of other things that the state school doesn’t. My DS2 hates noise and big groups of people and suffers from anxiety. There are no state schools in our area that can offer him small classes and a small year group as well as an on-site counsellor. I value his mental health far more than I do exam results.

EBearhug · 09/10/2023 00:19

Partner works in one of the most expensive fee-paying schools. He has a PGCE and state school experience - while some of his colleagues also do, many others don't but do have doctorates in their subject. Being very knowledgeable about a subject doesn't always make you the best teacher. (I knew that before hearing him rant about it...)

asterel · 09/10/2023 00:17

Yazo · 09/10/2023 00:02

@Dibblydoodahdah because it's not about wanting what you've got, teachers or otherwise. Some people like myself are a bit dubious that it's better, let alone 'elite' from the best of the state sector, which is fantastic where it works well. It's about where taxes and tax exemptions should go and doesn't make sense for them to go to private schools when we have poorly funded state schools and support for children and young people across the country.

But the lack of funding for state schools is a government policy? Charging VAT on private school fees isn’t going to make any kind of measurable difference to the state sector and probably won’t even go anywhere near schools funding (we have very few taxes in the U.K. which are hypothecated, and I’ve seen no evidence that Labour would hypothecate this extra VAT intake for education.) It’s just purely a policy to attract voters because they think it sounds like it’s against the rich. It’s a dog in the manger policy, essentially, no?

If you really wanted to raise money for state education, you’d be removing tax exemptions from real profit making companies; raising corporation tax; taxing energy companies’ profits; or even reducing all the massive grants we hand out each year to privatised transport companies just so that they can deliver big profits to their shareholders. You wouldn’t be making martyrs out of small prep schools for VAT pennies, would you?

BungleandGeorge · 09/10/2023 00:15

@The6thQueen cant understand what you mean about pharmacies, they’re NHS contractors the same as GP practices? GP practices are also private businesses what is it you think they should be paying VAT on that they don’t currently? Hospital pharmacies are all run by hospitals. Some hospitals have a branch of a community pharmacy inside for out patients, that’s not a hospital pharmacy, in the same way as they have branches of costas, WH Smith etc.

Dibblydoodahdah · 09/10/2023 00:13

@yazo but it’s going to raise very little money for the state sector. It won’t raise the £1.7 billion Labour have said it will for a start because schools will be reclaiming as much VAT as possible. Then there’s the children that will transfer to the state sector at a cost of £7k per year per pupil (not to mention capital costs of creating extra state school places in some cases). For the families that do keep their children in the private sector, they will cut back on other discretionary spending to save money - so there will be less VAT paid on that spending.

It’s basically a vote winner aimed at a certain sector of society in the same way as Brexit was going to reduce immigration. Those of us with an ounce of intelligence knew that was total bullshit and this is the same. I can’t believe that you as a teacher are falling for it! It will be the poorest children that suffer the most when they are pushed out of the best state schools and it will make private schools
more elitist.

MintJulia · 09/10/2023 00:06

@yazo All of the teachers in ds' independent school have QTS, and many come from the state sector. We had five new appointees in Sept, Three from U.K. state sector (one each, maths, physics & PE) and two language teachers (Spanish & German) from overseas.

Yazo · 09/10/2023 00:02

@Dibblydoodahdah because it's not about wanting what you've got, teachers or otherwise. Some people like myself are a bit dubious that it's better, let alone 'elite' from the best of the state sector, which is fantastic where it works well. It's about where taxes and tax exemptions should go and doesn't make sense for them to go to private schools when we have poorly funded state schools and support for children and young people across the country.