Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools and charity status

243 replies

The6thQueen · 08/10/2023 20:03

Yes, another thread. But, maybe from a different angle?

I'm interested to know how many mumsnet readers know that most universities are charities or are charity exempt (including Oxford). That we don’t pay VAT on university fees, or services from healthcare providers (including non registered, if they are supervised by registered healthcare), including pharmacies and, that private healthcare suppliers fall under this exemption.

I’m raising as Labour’s altered plans with regard to charity status and taxes for private schools may be far more complicated than the public expects. Legalities and the far reaching impact the policies may have beyond education and its VAT exempt status.

I suppose my AIBU is that most of the general public don’t realise the use of charity status and VAT exemption and how removing them from the private education sector is not that simple.

OP posts:
Barbadossunset · 09/10/2023 10:28

ItsAllgoingtobefine.
Thank you for answering my question

Whereforartthoudave · 09/10/2023 10:12

‘My point being, if we start adding VAT to private education then it won’t be long before it gets added to all other private providers too,’

mmm, well let’s start with taxing private schools properly and take it from there, shall we? I’m up for that.

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 09/10/2023 09:59

Barbadossunset · 09/10/2023 09:55

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · Today 08:52
I've always been dead against private schools. Yet PIL are now paying for DDs school fees as she couldn't cope at state school

I hope you’re not still ‘dead against private schools’ as if so, you’re a massive hypocrite.

Yes, I have changed my mind a bit. Until I personally had need of alternative provision I'm ashamed to say I hadn't considered the fact that some parents sent their kids to private schools because a state school couldn't meet their needs (rather than wants).

I think that currently they are a necessary evil. In an ideal world every child should have easy access to a state school that can meet their needs. Unfortunately, I cannot see how that can be achieved.

Barbadossunset · 09/10/2023 09:55

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · Today 08:52
I've always been dead against private schools. Yet PIL are now paying for DDs school fees as she couldn't cope at state school

I hope you’re not still ‘dead against private schools’ as if so, you’re a massive hypocrite.

The6thQueen · 09/10/2023 09:34

@Daisymay2 I haven’t said pharmacies are charities. Just that healthcare, including pharmacies don’t pay VAT. This includes all private healthcare providers. Private pharmacies don’t pay VAT, in fact there is a loophole which means they pay even less tax than NHS pharmacies.

My point being, if we start adding VAT to private education then it won’t be long before it gets added to all other private providers too, including post 18 education like universities and private healthcare providers, like the majority of pharmacies. That, or Labour won’t be able to raise anything like their promised 1.7 bn because there are too many legal loopholes/insurmountable legal battles.

OP posts:
FinallyPeakedNow · 09/10/2023 09:34

Circe7 · 08/10/2023 21:33

I'm a tax lawyer and also interested in how this would be implemented. I agree with pp that VAT is a bit of a mess anyway so taking private schools out of the VAT exemption won't necessarily make it noticeably worse.

But the education exemption will end up being very odd and inconsistent - i.e. VAT charged on education for children but not for adults (because universities and training providers for adults will presumably retain exemption). This includes providers like law schools which are expensive and not generally covered by the tuition fee loan scheme (fees are usually covered by law firms for their trainees). Plus what do you do about vocational training courses for 17 year olds - is a full time vocational training course a school?

You then potentially have e.g. music lessons and swimming lessons out of school exempt but VAT charged if a music lesson or swimming lesson is provided in the context of a private school (unless the private school can find a way to split out that element and exempt it). And you have to decide what to do about tuition in e.g. maths and english outside of a school context, which would currently often be exempt.

If they try to keep education for children with SEN exempt that's even more complex.

You also have the issue of a significant divergence from EU law. We have generally tried to avoid this so far as it causes all sorts of legal issues.

I think it is an "attack" much more than a money maker though. There would be many easier ways to raise the amount of tax involved and it is very hard to predict the amount this policy might raise. Private schools are likely to delay capital projects until after the exemption is removed so that they can claim back VAT on construction costs - the wealthier private schools spend millions on these sorts of projects so that could have a significant impact. There is then the displacement of students into the state sector, which will be uneven and may result in needing additional classroom space in some areas. Plus some parents will pay years of tuition fees in advance of the VAT coming in which will reduce the VAT received in the first few years.

But in terms of private schools being charities, plenty of charities are businesses. They just need to have an asset lock so that shareholders can't take profit out and it has to be ploughed back into the charitable purpose. Private schools are some of the first charities and a lot of the point of charity law is to transcend politics so that charitable status can't just be removed on a political whim.

Can you be in charge please

artemis9 · 09/10/2023 09:28

I think it's an important point also worth noting that some so called 'trusts' getting involved in small private schools groups are not in fact charitable at all. They are using the word 'trust' to make parents think they are charitable and putting profits back in to the school; in fact when you dig, you will find these are fat-cat business people taking profits entirely for themselves. So it's worth doing due dilligence this. I have recently seen a few charitable trust buy-outs by Ltd companies posing as Trusts. It stinks. They are called 'trust' but when listed on companies house they are Ltd companies with shareholders... generally one! They have no interest) and for some, little knowledge, in the business of education and are flying by the seat of their pants pretending they do... while taking out large profits for themselves. These tend to be small schools groups, often the choice of parents who are saving hard to pay for education because they believe their DC need a smaller and more personalised setting - and it's very difficult to get to the bottom of these 'Trusts' accounts! Be warned if you are looking at a small private school I think.

MotherEarthisaTerf · 09/10/2023 09:24

The 30-40k figure will be for boarding schools, not just private schools.

and incidentally it’s likely the schools will start to bill the teaching and boarding side separately- as the gov won’t be able to charge VAT on boarding fees.

so these large elistist boarding schools will more or less continue on as before - and continue to get influx of VAT free donations from super rich.

having said that i know a boarder at a v top boarding school. He comes from a toxic home life, lives in a crowded council home and has SEN. He was offered scholarships to board at some of the top schools in the country due to top grades.

GogoGobo · 09/10/2023 09:18

Circe7 · 08/10/2023 21:33

I'm a tax lawyer and also interested in how this would be implemented. I agree with pp that VAT is a bit of a mess anyway so taking private schools out of the VAT exemption won't necessarily make it noticeably worse.

But the education exemption will end up being very odd and inconsistent - i.e. VAT charged on education for children but not for adults (because universities and training providers for adults will presumably retain exemption). This includes providers like law schools which are expensive and not generally covered by the tuition fee loan scheme (fees are usually covered by law firms for their trainees). Plus what do you do about vocational training courses for 17 year olds - is a full time vocational training course a school?

You then potentially have e.g. music lessons and swimming lessons out of school exempt but VAT charged if a music lesson or swimming lesson is provided in the context of a private school (unless the private school can find a way to split out that element and exempt it). And you have to decide what to do about tuition in e.g. maths and english outside of a school context, which would currently often be exempt.

If they try to keep education for children with SEN exempt that's even more complex.

You also have the issue of a significant divergence from EU law. We have generally tried to avoid this so far as it causes all sorts of legal issues.

I think it is an "attack" much more than a money maker though. There would be many easier ways to raise the amount of tax involved and it is very hard to predict the amount this policy might raise. Private schools are likely to delay capital projects until after the exemption is removed so that they can claim back VAT on construction costs - the wealthier private schools spend millions on these sorts of projects so that could have a significant impact. There is then the displacement of students into the state sector, which will be uneven and may result in needing additional classroom space in some areas. Plus some parents will pay years of tuition fees in advance of the VAT coming in which will reduce the VAT received in the first few years.

But in terms of private schools being charities, plenty of charities are businesses. They just need to have an asset lock so that shareholders can't take profit out and it has to be ploughed back into the charitable purpose. Private schools are some of the first charities and a lot of the point of charity law is to transcend politics so that charitable status can't just be removed on a political whim.

This is a really interesting perspective, thank you. I hope it doesn’t happen.

asterel · 09/10/2023 09:16

Imjusttootired · 09/10/2023 06:50

Off topic but to the comment about 10k a year ?
where are these schools 😂
30-40k a year here !

My niece for example, with anxiety and dyslexia, goes to a small private school in the north of England which costs around 10k a year. Her parents earn a decent income for the area, but aren’t “rich”. They genuinely have given up holidays and so on to send her to her school. Yes, it’s a lucky position to be able to; but what kind of social justice agenda would it serve to make my niece unhappy in a state school which can’t really provide for her, merely because of a fantasy about somehow getting one over on the rich? There are a lot more of these schools and kids than there are the top public schools, which would carry on regardless.

This isn’t a policy which is going to improve state education. It’s merely a kind of revenge on the rich populism, when a much better policy would be a rethink of state education provision overall and big rises in schools funding, ideally paid for by taxing property and actual corporations.

The real elephant in the room of the U.K. economy is a vastly overinflated housing market, which has sucked out productive investment and massively affected living standards for younger generations. Fiddling with populist envy policies, rather than addressing the deeper issues, does not make me think Labour have a grip on the real economic problems we face.

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 09/10/2023 08:52

I've always been dead against private schools. Yet PIL are now paying for DDs school fees as she couldn't cope at state school. She is going private due to the quiet small class sizes and good SEN provision.

It's shit that kids / grandkids of wealthy people have access to a better education. But unfortunately at the moment if you "level the playing field" you level it to the currently crap level of state schools - huge schools, large classes, lots of disruptive behaviour, NQTs being hired then fired annually to keep costs down...

It's a really difficult complex issue to fix, hence the headline grabbing VAT. But the way to level the playing field is to make state schools as good as private schools in the ways that matter.

Scaevola · 09/10/2023 08:35

Circe7 · 08/10/2023 23:36

I don’t think so. The education is drafted in terms of eligible bodies. Most charities meet this definition which is what makes supplies of education by private schools which are charities VAT exempt. If a private school isn’t currently an eligible body it will probably already be charging VAT on fees. Some VAT notices or parts of them have the force of law but only where the law says that detailed rules are set out in a notice and notices don’t directly contradict law.

No, they will not be charging VAT on fees, just like all schools across the EU, where education delivered by nurseries/pre-schools, schools or universities is exempt

Not zero-rated, but completely exempt - ie outside the scope of VAT completely.

It is this exemption thar Labour plans to end, because since UK left the EU, we can now do that. They have not yet said whether there will be a new exemption for eg nurseries/preschools and universities, or if they will be included but zero-rated

Highandlows · 09/10/2023 08:32

Labour winning is not a done deal. A lot of things happening in the world would go against them soon. The pitfalls of this policy will be dissected property later in the campaign. I really doubt that even if they are elected this would go ahead. KS would make a fool of himself answering questions on this VAT proposal.

Newbutoldfather · 09/10/2023 08:26

@Labtastic ,

That is a bit of a simplistic way of looking at things. Class sizes (senior) are only about 20% smaller than state, yet income (in schools I know) are nearly 3x as much.

Staff includes a massive and overpaid SLT, marketing department, theatre technicians etc etc.

In addition, that is 80% of fee income. They also raise money from parents for expensive projects, so it is a lower percentage of total income.

Labtastic · 09/10/2023 08:20

Asiatoyork · 09/10/2023 07:27

We have considered it it’s just that we know already that many schools have very small margins as it is, particularly with the impact of energy price rises and inflation. There isn’t anything “fancy” to cut, besides maybe the classroom temperature. Because the reality of private school isn’t like the fantasy people seem to have in their heads

My kids go to private school, albeit in slightly strange circumstances. I know that some are very fancy! But I agree they also vary massively.

So if the only thing to cut is the heating, what does the money actually go on? The service offer might need to change.

I do agree that it will not recoup the £1.7 Bn. It seems a reasonable enough policy to me, albeit not one I’d choose to prioritise above all costs at the moment.

So if the only thing to cut is the heating, what does the money actually go on? The service offer might need to change.

At least 80% of a private school's outgoings will be on staff costs, which can only be cut by changing the main thing that differentiates a private school from a state school - class sizes and specialist teaching for different subjects. Also means that 80% of the outgoings aren't vatable and therefore no VAT for the school to reclaim to reduce the VAT charged on fees. Margins are tight.

Daisymay2 · 09/10/2023 08:18

@The6thQueen Sorry to derail, but where are you getting the idea that most pharmacies are charities . Several are privately owned eg Day Lewis but are not charities.
Are you confused by prescriptions not attracting VAT which is nothing to do with charitable status. It is unwieldy but pharmacies pay vat on medicines bought. from a wholesaler and reclaim it when they do their vat return.
VAT is payable on medicines purchased over the counter but not on scripts.
I was a pharmacist for over 40 years in different roles but can’t think of a pharmacy run by a charity.

Barbadossunset · 09/10/2023 08:15

Whatever Labour says now about private schools and tax, if in power they will set about dismantling them. Angela Rayner said “And we will set that Commission to work on making the whole education system fairer through the integration of private schools’.
If they are planning on integrating them then they will also have to requisition the private schools’ buildings and facilities.
That won’t be totally fair either. Children going to the state schools which were once Eton or Marlborough will have far better facilities than most other schools.
These buildings also cost a fortune to maintain so that will have to be paid for - though maybe Labour will knock down medieval buildings and build modern ones which are more practical.

Dibblydoodahdah · 09/10/2023 07:55

Asiatoyork · 09/10/2023 07:30

Well I’ve listened to presentations from two headteachers of two different schools in the past week and both have said that the schools will be doing everything they can to reduce what they pass on to parents (e.g. by reclaiming VAT). The problem is that the smaller schools have a lot less flexibility to do this

I wasn’t really thinking of VAT claim back. More that they may need to adapt in the way that is expected of many other organisations in terms of innovation, service offer etc.

Yes and as I said the smaller schools have a lot less flexibility to do that. For example, if a school only has one class per year group it can’t cut back the number of classes and make the existing classes larger. If a school has three classes per year it can.

needtonamechangeagain · 09/10/2023 07:51

Commonhousewitch · 09/10/2023 00:24

They are not charities and therefore shouldn't take advantage of tax breaks made for charities. And yes I also believe in "removing tax exemptions from real profit making companies; raising corporation tax; taxing energy companies’ profits; or even reducing all the massive grants we hand out each year to privatised transport companies just so that they can deliver big profits to their shareholders" - and getting rid of non-dom status and removing loopholes in CGT and IHT
Private education is only for the rich- if you can afford it you are richer than most

They are Charity and have given us free education for a financially hard period of time due to their charitable status, they also give free places yearly to 5 children.

They open for local events, support the local state schools with cross country events and swimming and give back as much to the community as possible.

needtonamechangeagain · 09/10/2023 07:47

Fleabane · 08/10/2023 20:29

Universities are open to everyone who meet their entry criteria. Private schools aren't.

Yes they are? That's an odd comparison.

Private schools have exams to enter and cost money, unis have exams to enter and cost money.

Newbutoldfather · 09/10/2023 07:41

Charity status and VAT are two different things. I think charity status is actually hard to discard, and doesn’t confer a meaningful advantage anyway.

OTOH, it is hard to see private schooling as anything other than a luxury.

As someone up above said, the actual VAT cost is around 15%, not 20%, as they can reclaim 5%. In reality, they can pass on some of it and find savings for the rest. State schools get around £5,200/pupil/annum. You can add about £3,000 for buildings, which comes from a different pot, but you can still see it is a fraction of what private schools cost.

As to where savings could be found, have a look at the size and salaries of the SLT. Do schools really need a marketing department at all, let alone a large one on large salaries? And then there is the constant facilities upgrades, luxury sixth form centres, professional staffed theatres, climbing walls etc etc

Legally, OP, you are right, how could you apply it to private schools and not tutors, for instance? I don’t think that is insurmountable, though. And nor would it be hard to grant exceptions to special needs schools.

Asiatoyork · 09/10/2023 07:30

Well I’ve listened to presentations from two headteachers of two different schools in the past week and both have said that the schools will be doing everything they can to reduce what they pass on to parents (e.g. by reclaiming VAT). The problem is that the smaller schools have a lot less flexibility to do this

I wasn’t really thinking of VAT claim back. More that they may need to adapt in the way that is expected of many other organisations in terms of innovation, service offer etc.

Asiatoyork · 09/10/2023 07:27

We have considered it it’s just that we know already that many schools have very small margins as it is, particularly with the impact of energy price rises and inflation. There isn’t anything “fancy” to cut, besides maybe the classroom temperature. Because the reality of private school isn’t like the fantasy people seem to have in their heads

My kids go to private school, albeit in slightly strange circumstances. I know that some are very fancy! But I agree they also vary massively.

So if the only thing to cut is the heating, what does the money actually go on? The service offer might need to change.

I do agree that it will not recoup the £1.7 Bn. It seems a reasonable enough policy to me, albeit not one I’d choose to prioritise above all costs at the moment.

Morechocmorechoc · 09/10/2023 07:25

@Imjusttootired I'm very confused by your post, i assume you quoted the wrong person. My post on the first page refers to the stupidity of both Conservative and Labour politicians who create policies to get votes, above helping the country.

Nothing in my post regarding sen kids. Just the welfare of all kids in state schools who will have less provision and bigger classes. I certainly didn't say my kids go private either!

Dibblydoodahdah · 09/10/2023 07:05

Imjusttootired · 09/10/2023 06:50

Off topic but to the comment about 10k a year ?
where are these schools 😂
30-40k a year here !

We pay £14,850 per year (for prep). The senior department starts at £21,000. That’s the South East. Average private school fees across the UK are around £15,200.