Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools and charity status

243 replies

The6thQueen · 08/10/2023 20:03

Yes, another thread. But, maybe from a different angle?

I'm interested to know how many mumsnet readers know that most universities are charities or are charity exempt (including Oxford). That we don’t pay VAT on university fees, or services from healthcare providers (including non registered, if they are supervised by registered healthcare), including pharmacies and, that private healthcare suppliers fall under this exemption.

I’m raising as Labour’s altered plans with regard to charity status and taxes for private schools may be far more complicated than the public expects. Legalities and the far reaching impact the policies may have beyond education and its VAT exempt status.

I suppose my AIBU is that most of the general public don’t realise the use of charity status and VAT exemption and how removing them from the private education sector is not that simple.

OP posts:
AnnoyingPopUp · 09/10/2023 14:49

Sorry, I was trying to quote another poster and failed!

AnnoyingPopUp · 09/10/2023 14:48

You’re assuming that most private school teachers will happily apply for jobs in state schools….

Mammyofonlyone · 09/10/2023 14:23

MotherEarthisaTerf · 08/10/2023 20:50

Labour have already agreed they are likely going to leave private schools charity status as is.

but they will implement VAT on private school fees - taxing children’s education when parents are already reducing costs on state education.

this is because they don't have the balls to go after the Uber rich - Russian oligarchs and global corporations like Amazon making mints of the public. The rich will continue to get richer and Labour will continue to make punitive changes to aspirational families

I think that's a really good summary, as well as the PP who referred to it as a jealously tax aimed to win cheap votes by vilifying 'the rich' without fully understanding the implications of what they are voting for

Mammyofonlyone · 09/10/2023 14:19

Whereforartthoudave · 08/10/2023 20:39

Most of us don’t use private schools and most of us are sick of the tax dodging that the wealthy are so good at.

How do you define wealthy?

DdraigGoch · 09/10/2023 14:00

Imjusttootired · 09/10/2023 06:50

Off topic but to the comment about 10k a year ?
where are these schools 😂
30-40k a year here !

https://www.st-gerards.org/fees/

One near me ranges between £9k for infants to £13.7k for upper secondary. Those are day fees of course and that's at the lower end of the scale.

Fees :: St Gerard's

https://www.st-gerards.org/fees

JustAMinutePleass · 09/10/2023 13:59

More would be raised if VAT were added to university fees as EVERYONE would be forced to pay. I think that’s Labour’s real agenda - removing charitable status for private schools is just a test.

Another76543 · 09/10/2023 13:46

It’s also worth noting that Starmer said, only a couple of weeks ago, that he had no desire to diverge from EU law. Imposing VAT on education will do exactly that.

Another76543 · 09/10/2023 13:44

Smartiepants79 · 09/10/2023 13:17

I’m state sector teacher myself and I my heart I’m a bit of a socialist. I strongly believe that changes that force independent schools to provide more burserys and to share their facilities and training with other local schools should be put in place. I’d vote for that. But this has the potential to destroy my DDs lovely school (extremely important for our family right now).
Certain things labour stand for right now make it very hard for me to vote for them.
We’ve got to choose a new mp next week. The Lib Dem candidate is looking tempting.

Unfortunately, by financially penalising private schools, bursaries and financial assistance are likely to become even more difficult to obtain. The policy will make private schools even more elite.

Smartiepants79 · 09/10/2023 13:17

I’m state sector teacher myself and I my heart I’m a bit of a socialist. I strongly believe that changes that force independent schools to provide more burserys and to share their facilities and training with other local schools should be put in place. I’d vote for that. But this has the potential to destroy my DDs lovely school (extremely important for our family right now).
Certain things labour stand for right now make it very hard for me to vote for them.
We’ve got to choose a new mp next week. The Lib Dem candidate is looking tempting.

fiftiesmum · 09/10/2023 13:16

Our local private schools made a big thing locally of offering their sports facilities for local children to use via their sports clubs and Scout groups at a token cost to prove their charitable ways.
It seemed like every other week it was cancelled as they needed it themselves or made out the weather was too bad (one black cloud in an otherwise blue sky)

Smartiepants79 · 09/10/2023 13:05

fattytum · 08/10/2023 20:28

There are too many schools in the country to staff them all, private schools closing because of this will be very good for the state sector, as the number of children changing to the state sector will be more than compensated for by the increase in the pool of teachers to fill state sector positions.

Many teachers mix time in each sector throughout their career, but teaching in a state school often offers better pay and conditions, and staff who are in a bit of a rut in the private sector would benefit from the freedom too

I suspect that you’re a bit optimistic about the number of these teacher who would stay in the profession or even in the country.
The staff at my Dds (fairly ordinary independent school) have been recruited from all over the place, international schools etc. I believe that a lot of them would simply go and find somewhere else to be.

Barbadossunset · 09/10/2023 13:05

There’ll be even more farmers leaving their land if the reports that the Labour Party are considering scrapping agricultural property relief are true.

Yes. I think the Labour Party hates farmers nearly as much as it hates private schools.

Araminta1003 · 09/10/2023 13:00

I have been struggling legally in my head with this proposed policy for some time and it also evokes irrational deja vu of Brexit in me (because of the contravention of EU law).

However, more than rationally I am really struggling with this policy emotionally. How is it OK for a government (especially a professed left leaning government) to incite hatred towards any school children, including some children with disabilities? What if children in private school uniform end up getting beaten up after such vilification by the press? I just cannot stand for such a policy.

It reminds me of the eternal question should a society have capital punishment as a deterrent? It is a deterrent policy inciting hatred towards a certain group of children. It is revolting. Children do not in most cases choose where their parents send them to school.

I am also quite interested to know how private school teachers feel about the policy and other workers in the sector who would normally vote Labour.

Another76543 · 09/10/2023 12:50

fattytum · 08/10/2023 20:28

There are too many schools in the country to staff them all, private schools closing because of this will be very good for the state sector, as the number of children changing to the state sector will be more than compensated for by the increase in the pool of teachers to fill state sector positions.

Many teachers mix time in each sector throughout their career, but teaching in a state school often offers better pay and conditions, and staff who are in a bit of a rut in the private sector would benefit from the freedom too

teaching in a state school often offers better pay and conditions

Why have state school teachers been on strike? I thought it was about poor pay and conditions?

Very few private school teachers will want to switch to the state sector even if they’ve taught there before. They’re more likely to take early retirement or move into a different job. There’s increasing demand for private school teachers internationally now as well.

Another76543 · 09/10/2023 12:44

R37sraY · 08/10/2023 20:45

There are people struggling to feed their families.

There are people whose small businesses went down through Govt action.

There are farmers leaving the land they had for generations.

At a recent group meeting of tax disputes practitioners, all of them had recent experience of client suicide.

There is nothing more virtuous and useful than having a small business that provides services to others and feeds your family.

Healthcare exemption doesn’t necessarily require charitable status anyway.

Yes. Hospices should pay tax on their profits. Do they have any? And face the same level of Govt scrutiny as people trying to feed themselves.

There are farmers leaving the land they had for generations.

There’ll be even more farmers leaving their land if the reports that the Labour Party are considering scrapping agricultural property relief are true.

Another76543 · 09/10/2023 12:40

Let’s be honest - this policy is nothing more than a perceived populist vote-winning policy. Even the optimistic estimates about how much money will be raised from the policy amounts to around 1% of the state education budget. Let’s not pretend that, by taxing private schools, state schools will miraculously improve.

It was only 4 years ago that the Labour Party voted at their conference to abolish all private schools and reintegrate the assets into the state system. I think they may have overlooked the human rights implications of this policy. Once they realised this wouldn’t work, they announced that they would abolish charitable status (not realising that this would have no impact on the VAT status). They’ve now abandoned that idea because they’ve realised that wouldn’t be possible. They’re now pledging to impose VAT on private schools. They are scrabbling around to find a way to harm private schools.

The main Labour Party flagship policies at the moment seem to be harming private schools and getting teachers to clean kids’ teeth. I think we can all agree that they’re an are bigger problems with the country to worry about.

This policy won’t harm the truly wealthy. Those parents won’t notice a few thousand pounds a year. The more expensive, higher profile, schools won’t be affected as much because they have huge capital expenditure on which VAT can be claimed back. The parents it will harm are those already stretching themselves to fund private education, often for children who have been failed by the state system. The schools it will harm are the smaller more nurturing private schools without all the flash extras.

I cannot possibly understand why any political party wants to attack a very good education system - a system in which many children thrive and have a wonderful school experience. It’s a system which is recognised internationally as being good. Why do we want to get rid of that? Let’s concentrate on making state schools so good that people don’t want to use the private system.

Clamping down on tax evasion (very different from tax avoidance) would raise billions a year; much more than taxing private school parents. That would involve hard work and effort to sort out though.

It concerns me that the Labour Party are so focussed on attacking 6% of parents and children for a relatively tiny tax gain that they are overlooking the bigger problems.

justteanbiscuits · 09/10/2023 12:34

Penguinmouse · 08/10/2023 23:09

What charitable benefit do private schools provide? They are businesses. They aren’t teaching kids out of the goodness of their hearts.

We have a number of local private schools. They do the absolute bare minimum in order to be a "charity". They offer a number of bursaries which cover up to 40% of their fee's - only about 5 bursaries, and covering 40% still leaves it WAY out of reach for most parents.

I believe if a school if a charitable private school, then the loop holes need tightening up, but they need to do more than the very bare minimum.

NoWinterYear · 09/10/2023 12:29

Imjusttootired · 09/10/2023 06:50

Off topic but to the comment about 10k a year ?
where are these schools 😂
30-40k a year here !

Dd's private school is about 11k a year, which will increase (currently) to about 15k a year for secondary. By the time we get to secondary it will probably be a lot more but there are many private schools that are no where near 30-40k. I suspect most aren't but when people think of private schools they think of the likes of Eton and the people who tend to go there and wonder why they should subsidise them. It's a purely populist policy, which is worrying considering it's coming from labour.

We are barely managing the fees as is (and won't be able to afford sending dd2 private) but felt we had to do so as DD just didn't settle into her state school and was desperately unhappy there. If the fees increase substantially I don't know what we'll do. I grew up in a country where private schooling is virtually unheard of and I still feel it goes against my principles but your children's happiness is more important than your principles. However, if we can't afford the fees dd will have to go to a state school just as everyone else who can't afford private school fees so it's not unfair. But that doesn't mean it makes sense or is a good thing. For anyone.

Barbadossunset · 09/10/2023 12:18

A plan to seize and redistribute private assets is pretty extreme as is an attempt to have complete state control of education. A lot of people would oppose such a policy regardless of whether they used private schools.

Yes seizing assets is the policy of a dictator. Did Angela Rayner think it would be a popular policy or was it just wishful thinking on her part?

Mia85 · 09/10/2023 12:13

Barbadossunset · 09/10/2023 11:51

There would be huge legal problems in doing that and it's much more unpopular than removing VAT.

Mia85 I agree there would be huge legal problems but surely it would only be unpopular with the 7% who privately educate their dc?
However it seems odd when Angela Rayner said about integrating private schools into state schools, that she hadn’t bothered to check on the legal ramifications.

I don't think it's as simply as saying only those affected will oppose a change. On the current VAT policy there are some private school parents who think that's fair. There are other people who don't use private schools but who oppose the policy and went private themselves, or who have friends/family members who go or who value having the possibility of a more accessible escape route if things go badly for their child. Further, some people are concerned about divisive policies and the quality of decision-making.

On the Corbyn policy my recollection is that opinion polling suggested it was much more unpopular than the VAT measure. A plan to seize and redistribute private assets is pretty extreme as is an attempt to have complete state control of education. A lot of people would oppose such a policy regardless of whether they used private schools.

Barbadossunset · 09/10/2023 11:55

At what point do you say that a talented poor ballet student has to pay VAT but a poor autistic child with an unusual aptitude for maths doesn’t? Or maybe they both should if they want an education that doesn’t exist in the state sector?

Good points asterel. As I said in my last post, it seems odd that the Labour Party hasn’t thought of this. I suppose they want to be seen to have a go at private education in whatever way they can as a vote winner.

DdraigGoch · 09/10/2023 11:53

Circe7 · 08/10/2023 22:38

@MotherEarthisaTerf
I’ve read that education for children with SEN may remain exempt (obviously no guarantees). Labour will probably need to consult on VAT on school fees. Most tax changes like this go through consultation. This process might be rushed because they want to push it through quickly. At that point I would recommend responding to the consultation to highlight the issues for children with SEN and get as many other parents as you can to respond. My firm and other law firms often respond to these sorts of consultations to suggest areas where the proposed law won’t work or would be unfair and would do that here specifically on the SEN point. I think you have a good chance of getting special treatment for children with SEN but the key will be getting the legislation wide enough to cover all children affected.

Not all SEN children are in specialist schools. Some manage fine in mainstream private schools because of the small class sizes.

Barbadossunset · 09/10/2023 11:51

There would be huge legal problems in doing that and it's much more unpopular than removing VAT.

Mia85 I agree there would be huge legal problems but surely it would only be unpopular with the 7% who privately educate their dc?
However it seems odd when Angela Rayner said about integrating private schools into state schools, that she hadn’t bothered to check on the legal ramifications.

Mia85 · 09/10/2023 11:43

Barbadossunset · 09/10/2023 08:15

Whatever Labour says now about private schools and tax, if in power they will set about dismantling them. Angela Rayner said “And we will set that Commission to work on making the whole education system fairer through the integration of private schools’.
If they are planning on integrating them then they will also have to requisition the private schools’ buildings and facilities.
That won’t be totally fair either. Children going to the state schools which were once Eton or Marlborough will have far better facilities than most other schools.
These buildings also cost a fortune to maintain so that will have to be paid for - though maybe Labour will knock down medieval buildings and build modern ones which are more practical.

Angela Rayner said that when Corbyn was leader and the party was committed to abolishing private schools and redistributing their assets. I imagine that there are many in the party (probably including Rayner) who'd still like to do that but it's not what they're now proposing to do. There would be huge legal problems in doing that and it's much more unpopular than removing VAT.

asterel · 09/10/2023 11:08

Whereforartthoudave · 09/10/2023 10:12

‘My point being, if we start adding VAT to private education then it won’t be long before it gets added to all other private providers too,’

mmm, well let’s start with taxing private schools properly and take it from there, shall we? I’m up for that.

@Whereforartthoudave Could you provide us with a list of what kinds of education are Good and should be VAT-free; and what kinds of education are Bad and should have VAT on? What about non-school providers like the old National extension college? Further education colleges that offer a mix of A-levels and vocational courses? Special needs schools? Performing arts schools? At what point do you say that a talented poor ballet student has to pay VAT but a poor autistic child with an unusual aptitude for maths doesn’t? Or maybe they both should if they want an education that doesn’t exist in the state sector? Let’s make every kid that doesn’t fit state provision as miserable as possible, if their parents have the temerity to give up holidays to send their kid to a private provider.

Because we sure as hell know it won’t have an impact on Wills and Kate’s kids, and the kids of the other genuinely rich parents in this country. Nor on all the London parents who can afford £1m to buy a house in the catchment of a selective state school or tutor their kids for a nice grammar.

A policy that doesn’t really do what it is supposed to, but makes many children miserable along the way, is not what I’d call a good one IMO. What next, should we have means-tested VAT on tampons and books if you’re well off enough to afford them? That will serve the rich right, won’t it?