Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools and charity status

243 replies

The6thQueen · 08/10/2023 20:03

Yes, another thread. But, maybe from a different angle?

I'm interested to know how many mumsnet readers know that most universities are charities or are charity exempt (including Oxford). That we don’t pay VAT on university fees, or services from healthcare providers (including non registered, if they are supervised by registered healthcare), including pharmacies and, that private healthcare suppliers fall under this exemption.

I’m raising as Labour’s altered plans with regard to charity status and taxes for private schools may be far more complicated than the public expects. Legalities and the far reaching impact the policies may have beyond education and its VAT exempt status.

I suppose my AIBU is that most of the general public don’t realise the use of charity status and VAT exemption and how removing them from the private education sector is not that simple.

OP posts:
Baconisdelicious · 09/10/2023 22:32

fattytum · 08/10/2023 20:25

private schools are businesses, and it is right they pay VAT

How many schools do you k ow that are out there making a profit for shareholders?

Labtastic · 09/10/2023 22:21

Knifeandforkwhocares · 09/10/2023 20:22

I just cannot get over how out of touch so many private school parents are! I send my child private due to a minor sen need which is completely ignored in state school and easily met in private school. Yes things are a bit tight but if we can stretch to private school we can stretch to the VAT too. If things we so tight that we couldn’t afford an extra 20% then we would have deemed it unaffordable in the first place.

to send your kids to private school you have to be wealthy, no question about it. Why are so many of these wealthy parents though wailing like banshees at the prospect of an extra 20%? Jeez guys, read the room here! Public services are on their knees. You can afford to cough up some VAT on what is UNDOUBTEDLY a luxury!

If things we so tight that we couldn’t afford an extra 20% then we would have deemed it unaffordable in the first place.

We are an example of the kind of people that can afford it now, but probably not the extra 20%. We budgeted for a 5-7% rise year on year, and have largely been quite a bit under that, partly due to benefiting from a fee freeze two years in a row because of Covid. Our spreadsheet is drilled down into the minute detail and the budget has worked for it. Ours will be out of private education by 2025 so this shouldn't affect us too badly even if it comes in straight away, but if we had years to run, a sudden 20% rise in the middle of that careful budgeting on top of the normal annual increases would throw us out completely and we probably couldn't manage it long term. I don't think we're that unusual.

Another76543 · 09/10/2023 22:12

Knifeandforkwhocares · 09/10/2023 20:22

I just cannot get over how out of touch so many private school parents are! I send my child private due to a minor sen need which is completely ignored in state school and easily met in private school. Yes things are a bit tight but if we can stretch to private school we can stretch to the VAT too. If things we so tight that we couldn’t afford an extra 20% then we would have deemed it unaffordable in the first place.

to send your kids to private school you have to be wealthy, no question about it. Why are so many of these wealthy parents though wailing like banshees at the prospect of an extra 20%? Jeez guys, read the room here! Public services are on their knees. You can afford to cough up some VAT on what is UNDOUBTEDLY a luxury!

A lot of parents don’t have thousands of pounds a year spare. A lot of families have more than one child. The VAT would be on top of increased living costs (lots of families have mortgages for example), and on top of large fee increases last year because of inflationary pressures.

dancingdaisies · 09/10/2023 22:08

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the request of the poster.

carltonscroop · 09/10/2023 22:03

Araminta1003 · 09/10/2023 21:19

The thing is if they are going to suddenly tax some people with children in education money, why don’t they also tax those earning over 100k using state education, for example. What is the actual difference? It is a sudden stealth tax on high earning people with children. We are a high earning household with 4 children using state education- should we be taxed more? I would obviously argue the opposite because they will need our children to work hard and pay taxes in the future. Besides, rich intelligent people should be incentivised to have children, not the opposite?

One thing this is not is sudden

This thread is from May 2017
AIBU that VAT on school fees makes no economical sense? | Mumsnet

From the Labour manifesto that year:
"To aid attainment, we will introduce free school meals for all primary school children, paid for by removing the VAT exemption on private
school fees."

Blinkingbonkers · 09/10/2023 21:53

I’m just having a giggle at the pp somewhere in the early pages who said something along the lines of ‘Kier Starmer’s a lawyer, he wouldn’t have suggested it if he hadn’t already worked out how to do it”😂🤣. News flash - Tony Blair (previous PM & trained barrister) also tried and failed to figure this one out… stop trusting that politician’s policies are something they’ll actually stand by and effect, sadly it’s mostly just not the case!

FrancisFriedFish · 09/10/2023 21:30

The UK Labour Party reversed its policy of scrapping charitable status for private schools, meaning they will retain some of their current taxation perks, while still facing increased charges if the opposition comes to power.28 Sept 2023

FrancisFriedFish · 09/10/2023 21:28

Labour have stated they are not planning to remove charitable status. They will be making them pay VAT.

Dibblydoodahdah · 09/10/2023 21:26

Knifeandforkwhocares · 09/10/2023 20:22

I just cannot get over how out of touch so many private school parents are! I send my child private due to a minor sen need which is completely ignored in state school and easily met in private school. Yes things are a bit tight but if we can stretch to private school we can stretch to the VAT too. If things we so tight that we couldn’t afford an extra 20% then we would have deemed it unaffordable in the first place.

to send your kids to private school you have to be wealthy, no question about it. Why are so many of these wealthy parents though wailing like banshees at the prospect of an extra 20%? Jeez guys, read the room here! Public services are on their knees. You can afford to cough up some VAT on what is UNDOUBTEDLY a luxury!

We’d baked the 20% in to our calculations since the last election when this policy was first touted. What we hadn’t accounted for is our household bills increasing by £1k per month in a very short period of time.
No one could have predicted that…I’ve noticed people tightening their belts at DS’ private school in the past year. For example, Porsches being swapped for minis or other small cars. Disposable income has been eaten up by the cost of living crisis and this is an increase too far or some people.

renovationheavenandhell · 09/10/2023 21:25

@Fleabane 🤣🤣🤣🤣 that’s a load of old cobblers if you believe that…..

Gingerbee · 09/10/2023 21:21

I have taught in two private schools. One overseas and one in the home counties. The one in Australia had a true bursary system, that is, places given to genuinely bright state school pupils. Not Prep or tutored for 11 plus etc. They also had an allowance.
The one in the home counties only interviewed students who had gone to Prep and hadn't got into the exceptional grammar school. I spent considerable amount of time in Prep 4 preparing for Common Entrance exams
It didn't seem charitable or just. The Prep school use to 'charitable donation' of worn out equipment. In the end the local state schools suggested they just pay for a skip.

Araminta1003 · 09/10/2023 21:19

The thing is if they are going to suddenly tax some people with children in education money, why don’t they also tax those earning over 100k using state education, for example. What is the actual difference? It is a sudden stealth tax on high earning people with children. We are a high earning household with 4 children using state education- should we be taxed more? I would obviously argue the opposite because they will need our children to work hard and pay taxes in the future. Besides, rich intelligent people should be incentivised to have children, not the opposite?

Spendonsend · 09/10/2023 21:07

The University of Law is for profit and not a charity. I think BPP is for profit too.

Circe7 · 09/10/2023 20:57

@Knifeandforkwhocares
That might be your opinion but it’s not true in legal terms. Education, including teaching, is a charitable purpose itself. It doesn’t need to include research. Universities would still be charities if they did no research - there are some universities which only teach and don’t research like University of Law. Most universities have dual charitable objects of education/ teaching and research.

Education, which includes teaching in schools, has been a charitable purpose since the beginning of charity law.

Summerlonging · 09/10/2023 20:51

I send my child to a private school because he was let down by the state system, my friend’s son is already out of education by year 8 and she has an uphill battle to find a appropriate school setting. I was lucky to afford private but can not afford the 20 % increase so he’ll have to go back to state and have tutors and hope he’ll be fine and have his confidence destroyed yet again

JustAMinutePleass · 09/10/2023 20:50

Newbutoldfather · 09/10/2023 20:05

These threads bring out the champagne socialists at their worst!

Private schools have been raising fees by way more than inflation for decades (my school which was £700/term in the early 80s is now £8,000/term) with nary a complaint from parents, but a one off raise of 10% or so to help others is met with total apoplexy.

Ask parents for £3,000 for a ski or netball trip, or to contribute a few thousand for a state-of-the-art technology centre, and it is also not generally an issue.

And the vengeful posts about how bursaries will be the first to go, rather than any luxuries, are the worst. The realities are that most bursaries are not funded out of general fees but from hypothecated donations from generous alumni and bequests.

Of course, some will struggle and a few will leave (1/14 according to the IFS) but, for the vast majority, it will make very little difference to their disposable income.

This is so true. We’ve already seen 4 new funds / scholarships become available in the selective secondary school of DS’ primary that are only available to pupils who went through the school’s primary. The Secondary has also started to offer deep discounts to parents who send their children up from Primary to keep them - proposals about keeping fees equal from preschool to 6th form are being considered too.

JustAMinutePleass · 09/10/2023 20:42

Knifeandforkwhocares · 09/10/2023 20:29

The difference between schools and university’s is interesting. A university is a genuine charity, a private school is not.

A private school meets the need to provide mandatory schooling to your child.

A university is a charity due to its research work. They exist to expand global understanding of the world and everything in it, and the publish their research extensively in order for others the world over to help promote the development of knowledge. Yes they teach some people things as part of that, but it’s not mandatory to go, and they are teaching with the aim of producing researchers that will solve the worlds problems, not cause Tristram wants to spend 3 years propping up the bar in a students union. Speak to any academic and research is why they do what they do, not teaching.

Public schools (ie the most expensive private schools) ALL conduct research. Eton College produces more research on education (particularly on improving educational outcomes for disadvantaged children) than some universitities. So if we used research as some nominal differentiator then the filthy rich would still be able to keep their schools tax free & it would be the cheaper private schools that middle class parents use that would be targetted.

Knifeandforkwhocares · 09/10/2023 20:29

The difference between schools and university’s is interesting. A university is a genuine charity, a private school is not.

A private school meets the need to provide mandatory schooling to your child.

A university is a charity due to its research work. They exist to expand global understanding of the world and everything in it, and the publish their research extensively in order for others the world over to help promote the development of knowledge. Yes they teach some people things as part of that, but it’s not mandatory to go, and they are teaching with the aim of producing researchers that will solve the worlds problems, not cause Tristram wants to spend 3 years propping up the bar in a students union. Speak to any academic and research is why they do what they do, not teaching.

Knifeandforkwhocares · 09/10/2023 20:22

I just cannot get over how out of touch so many private school parents are! I send my child private due to a minor sen need which is completely ignored in state school and easily met in private school. Yes things are a bit tight but if we can stretch to private school we can stretch to the VAT too. If things we so tight that we couldn’t afford an extra 20% then we would have deemed it unaffordable in the first place.

to send your kids to private school you have to be wealthy, no question about it. Why are so many of these wealthy parents though wailing like banshees at the prospect of an extra 20%? Jeez guys, read the room here! Public services are on their knees. You can afford to cough up some VAT on what is UNDOUBTEDLY a luxury!

MintJulia · 09/10/2023 20:11

According to the HoC report and the ISC, '70% (978 out of 1,395) of private schools are charities. However not all private schools are ISC members.'

More than half of all independent schools are thought to have charitable status.

Newbutoldfather · 09/10/2023 20:05

These threads bring out the champagne socialists at their worst!

Private schools have been raising fees by way more than inflation for decades (my school which was £700/term in the early 80s is now £8,000/term) with nary a complaint from parents, but a one off raise of 10% or so to help others is met with total apoplexy.

Ask parents for £3,000 for a ski or netball trip, or to contribute a few thousand for a state-of-the-art technology centre, and it is also not generally an issue.

And the vengeful posts about how bursaries will be the first to go, rather than any luxuries, are the worst. The realities are that most bursaries are not funded out of general fees but from hypothecated donations from generous alumni and bequests.

Of course, some will struggle and a few will leave (1/14 according to the IFS) but, for the vast majority, it will make very little difference to their disposable income.

declutteringmymind · 09/10/2023 19:46

Our school will likely pay by reducing bursaries as they won't want to bite the hand that feeds them.

MrsPuddle · 09/10/2023 16:45

Such an interesting thread. I hope the female Labour MPs are reading them!

It might be worth a quick clarify, (apologies if you have worked this out…but some people haven’t:)

  • charity status means you don’t pay income tax, or business rates (200,000 pa), but you have to provide some help to other schools/bursaries etc.
  • not all private schools are charities, a large percentage are businesses.
  • It is legally very difficult to unravel the covenants surrounding charities, so Labour have turned their focus on VAT.
  • VAT is not payable on education (says EU). But now we are not in the EU so…
  • Labour wants to tax school fees paid for directly by parents.
  • the private schools are already thinking about how to reduce this effect, but there is no money tree so in the end the parents have to pay for through their fees.
  • labours assumption is…what exactly? I can’t work out if he wants the private schools to close in the name of equality, or stay open and feed the coffers. The latter means it’s just a tax grab, aren’t there more lucrative ones?
Rudderneck · 09/10/2023 16:41

RoseAndRose · 08/10/2023 23:01

One way parents can do that is to hire a tutor, or get together with other parents and fund a school. So long as it's not a for-profit enterprise, why would it pay taxes?

The parental funding (ie fees) would be subject to VAT under these plans, no matter how small the school. Plus the parents would have to cover all the governance standards of a school, which might prove onerous.

I think you maybe missed the point, I am saying that these would be natural ways for parents, in any situation, to think about educating kids. We take it for granted they go to schools someone else set up, but in the past most schools were set up by groups of parents, or community groups like churches, seeing a need for children under their care.

For the state to tax this kind of enterprise is stupid.

The whole thing is about class hatred in the end which is a poor approach to policy.

Araminta1003 · 09/10/2023 15:48

“Whereforartthoudave · Yesterday 20:39

Most of us don’t use private schools and most of us are sick of the tax dodging that the wealthy are so good at”

This one is the height of it - most people paying for private schools are 40 or 45% PAYE tax payers and funding the lifestyle and in work benefits of others in society, not the other way round. Many of those higher rate tax payers have children with more hidden disabilities, things such as autism, dyslexia etc. On my team, in my law firm, we have several colleagues with autism who pay those kind of taxes. Some of their children also have autism and go to private schools (autism can be genetic). That is the way their children will eventually also become higher rate tax payers. They are very clever, but bullied and struggling in the state sector (noise, rigid discipline, huge classes, being bullied for being bookish/nerdy). There are so so many kids like this across the UK. And many of them are actually going to be really productive adults one day, if supported properly now.
Under diagnosis of autism in highly academic people is a thing.

On the other hand, if there is an exemption for SEN in the legislation, it will open the floodgates to people seeking private diagnoses all at once. Same people who previously just paid up and made do. That can in turn indirectly pull resources away from the NHS and those who really need the state funding, if the mental health professionals work in both sectors.

From Google:
“What percentage of Cambridge students are autistic?
12% of Cambridge students are on the spectrum, compared to only 2 to 3% in the general population.2 Nov 2018” (in a rush currently, can’t get to the best source)

Swipe left for the next trending thread