Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guest staying for 2 full weeks every Christmas without asking

259 replies

Lightthatnevergoesout · 08/10/2023 19:57

I have got a great relationship with both of DH's divorced parents. We get along fine and I love it when they come over. However, DH's relationship with his dad has always been really cold and all they talk about is grandchildren (our kids) and sports. It becomes even more obvious when they can spend hours sitting next to one another on a sofa without having any deep conversations. I end up constantly coming up with the topics to talk about.

Every single winter my father in law comes over and stays in a flat in a house next to us every Christmas. He hasn't got any interests of his own so comes to simply follow whatever we are doing. For example he would often come over to our house at 7 am and leave at 22.30 to sleep in his accommodation. During the day he would stay in the living room the whole day expecting for us to have some kind of plans every single day.

Christmas break is the only break my DH gets from his job and because his father in law comes for these whole 2 weeks we often don't even get a chance to spend one on one time together. He is bad at babysitting kids ad he shouts and gets anxious if they misbehave and on the times we attempted to sneak out on a date he lost it with the kids.

We have politely hinted that we might have plans/friends over/a short booked trip but that really doesn't seem to change much as he would just come for 1 day less. DH gets really anxious prior to him coming but then again failed to say anything and now we are once again stuck with him coming for 14 full days which would mean us cooking every single day, cleaning, washing and planning activities . We feel often trapped in our house as he can knock on the door when we are still sleeping or stay till 23 when we both just want to spend time together !

AIBU To think that my husband should have talked to him earlier (he had whole year since last Christmas) and explained that it is too long for a visit and really doesnt leave us with any time to just sit in our pyjamas and relax the way we might want to?

OP posts:
Lightthatnevergoesout · 09/10/2023 11:42

captainmarvella · 09/10/2023 11:27

What do you want from this thread, OP?

We cannot change your FIL. We can only tell you what you can do. But you seem to be saying that you will not change anything for reasons x y z, you will do everything the same, the exact same things that have landed you in this difficult situation, yet you want a different outcome?

“Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.” - Rita Mae Brown

Are you Asian/Indian by any chance?

Edited

I have said that I will be asking him to reduce the days he comes for as I want to have a few days with my friends and to get some proper rest in my own house. Thats us being clear that we can't accommodate him for longer than x amount of days.

No I am not Asian nor Indian what a weird assumption to make. Also all Asian people do not have the same 'Asian' mentality so you can go 'ah get it she is Asian that explains everything'. And its not my family its my white British FIL and yes I can't simply tell him to back off when he comes because of just some basic respect.

OP posts:
captainmarvella · 09/10/2023 11:41

It's very hard for us to carry on as we normally do when my FIL is here firstly because he doesnt go and do anything himself at all and when he is in the house he comments on everything.

He will not change. It is up to you to set boundaries. If it's me, I will smile (or not) but stop replying. A conversation cannot happen if the other person does not reply. Let him comment. You just turn a deaf eye and keep doing your chores. I will do this every time he is being a pest, until he gets the message.

For example if I leave to a kitchen and have a piece of chocolate he would follow just to make a joke 'is it you snacking again on some chocolates away from the kids'.

He will not change. It is up to you to set boundaries. If it's me, I'd say, "Yes I love chocolates. Do you want one?". If the FIL teases me further and I am feeling particularly snarky, I'd say, "Yes, I am eating chocolates. Don't you think I deserve to eat things I love?" I will do this every day, until he gets the message.

Sometimes I will be reading a bed time story to my kids on my bed and he will just come over and lay on a bed next to me and listen to me read which makes me uncomfortable.

He will not change. It is up to you to set boundaries, tell him he is making you uncomfortable. Or, if that is too confrontational, I will just lock the door before he comes in, saying I need to change my dress. I will do it every night until he gets the message.

OP, if you are so scared of setting even simple boundaries, you are either terrified of offending people even when they cause you discomfort (if yes, please ask yourself why), or you are such a doormat/people pleaser that you will never be comfortable in your own home. And no, you are not being a good role model to your kids, I'm sorry to say. My mother was exactly like you, she will always put the needs of the guests before us, and it created lifelong issues for us.

Silvers11 · 09/10/2023 11:37

So no we can't just do whatever we normally do as he is not used to living with other people and just leaving them at peace for 10 mins or so. I know it's not my problem but it's impossible to change him at this stage and I don't fancy spending Christmas holidays trying to change someone who us not even my father. I got my hands full with my kids and just want to enjoy a holiday season.**

I'm a bit confused now @Lightthatnevergoesout . In one of your earlier posts on this thread, you said 'my father in law sits and looks in his phone and my husband is listening to his music in headphones'. The picture you painted until this post I'm quoting from, is that your FIL doesn't do anything, sits around doing nothing and not saying very much. You certainly gave the impression that you had to organise everything in order to do anything, which is why many of the replies have given the advice they have.

I can't quite marry that up with 'he never leaves anyone at peace for even 10 minutes', which indicates a different issue overall. Please don't get me wrong, I absolutely understand how resentful you are that a whole 2 weeks at Christmas having another person practically living with you - at any time in fact- is spoiling the season and I completely understand that you are sorry for him - but you do have choices: even if that choice is 'I am going to put up with it because I am sorry for him and couldn't do otherwise' it IS still a choice.

However, your OP asked if you were unreasonable to think your husband should have spoken to your FIL before now - and no YANBU to have expected him to do that, he should have. But it seems to me that you would be happy to see FIL much less as long as your husband deals with it, so actually, whether you recognise it or not, I think you just don't want to be seen as the bad one and aren't as sorry for FIL as you say, as long as your DH is the one that deals with it and not you? I say that gently and kindly

captainmarvella · 09/10/2023 11:27

Lightthatnevergoesout · 09/10/2023 07:02

The problem is we can't really have a break with him. I want a short break with my husband too during Christmas! His dad doesn't have any activities or interests of his own so it's difficult. If I go to the room he knocks to see what I am up to/ask what are we doing next. If the kids go to play quietly he knocks to see what they r up to . Even if we are in the bathrooms he knocks to see what we are up to and 'if its safe to come in'. Our house is not big enough for me to go somewhere and just be on my own.

My FIL as lovely as he is lived most of his life alone and doesn't understand how to give other people space. When its happening from 7 till 23 every day and I don't even have a chance to go take a bath it becomes too much .

What do you want from this thread, OP?

We cannot change your FIL. We can only tell you what you can do. But you seem to be saying that you will not change anything for reasons x y z, you will do everything the same, the exact same things that have landed you in this difficult situation, yet you want a different outcome?

“Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.” - Rita Mae Brown

Are you Asian/Indian by any chance?

Lightthatnevergoesout · 09/10/2023 11:09

Will take the comments on board! It's not as simple as some posters here put it though when he comes. It's very hard for us to carry on as we normally do when my FIL is here firstly because he doesnt go and do anything himself at all and when he is in the house he comments on everything. For example if I leave to a kitchen and have a piece of chocolate he would follow just to make a joke 'is it you snacking again on some chocolates away from the kids'. Sometimes I will be reading a bed time story to my kids on my bed and he will just come over and lay on a bed next to me and listen to me read which makes me uncomfortable. I don't think he realises those things he is just lonely and lacks social skills. So boundaries whilst he is here don't really work and but being firm on the days is the way to go. So hoping to re arrange for him to come for at least less days.

So no we can't just do whatever we normally do as he is not used to living with other people and just leaving them at peace for 10 mins or so. I know it's not my problem but it's impossible to change him at this stage and I don't fancy spending Christmas holidays trying to change someone who us not even my father. I got my hands full with my kids and just want to enjoy a holiday season.

OP posts:
Silvers11 · 09/10/2023 10:31

Bigbrotherpropoganda · 08/10/2023 22:27

You seem to allow your FIL to change the way you live when he is around.
Just carry on as normal.

If he’s there for meals just do an extra plate,
If he’s around and he joins in the conversation that’s great, if not hay ho.
Dont ignore him, don’t avoid him, but if he fancies a cup of tea then hay, he can make one for everyone.

Hang around the house if you want to, lol on the sofa in you jammies. Tell him it’s a relax day. Or just tell him the days you’ve organised something, if he wants to join you, whilst all other days are free.

Personally I wouldn’t arrange anything for the first few days at all. Just to make the point.
When grandparents live with their children they don’t normally expect constant entertainment,( adults are not young children )so don’t provide it.

Meanwhile you need to set boundaries re the current situation of him turning up early and leaving late, for example.

I agree with this. STOP thinking that your FIL is a guest and that therefore you HAVE to entertain him and change what you would normally do. Change your mindset. He is Family.

Just do the things you want to do - like sitting watching lots of Kids programmes on TV, eating ice cream in your jammies whatever. Don't go to all the effort of trying to make conversation, etc.

In my view, it is a bit late now to tell him to come for only a few days, since he has booked the rental property and presumably paid it, as it is at Christmas. But you can start, by telling him to please not come over before 10am or 11 am or whatever suits, as you need some time to be organised as a family. It is NOT rude to go and have a nap - or go to your room and read a book or whatever.

It seems to me you are making a rod for your own back by feeling the need to 'entertain' FIL instead of him just slotting into whatever routine you want over Christmas. Also not rude to tell him you want need an early night and you are going to bed - so would he mind heading back to his rental place

It's not too late to inform him there will be changes this year.

'Hi FIL
Thanks for letting us know the dates you have booked for Christmas. I need to let you know that we need to make some changes this year, as we are both very tired/had a busy year and really need some downtime over the Christmas Holidays, instead of still being exhausted when we go back to work, like we usually are.

To that end, we need you to not come over to us until after (x) time every morning. After that, you need to take us as you find us. We won't always be going out and we may have takeaways some nights .etc. May also have friends over some days, and/or be invited out to friends, when you'll have to find things to do on your own while we are out. I'm sure you won't mind, but thought it best to forewarn you now. Etc etc '

LookItsMeAgain · 09/10/2023 10:22

@Lightthatnevergoesout - I think you're getting angry at the wrong people here. You've commented to @SaturdayGiraffe and now @PosterBoy but they are only able to post what they have because they are going on what you have said about your FiL.

You (and I count your DH in that) are being passive about dealing with the situation, because it keeps happening to you and your children.
Please send him a message as soon as you can to let him know that he can't visit with you for the time frame that he has booked. Your FiL and your DH's dad has absolutely no idea that he is and has overstayed his welcome. Time to lay it out for him.

You're not his social crutch here. If he doesn't have friends, he needs to make some. He needs to start socialising and expanding his social group so he has more places to go. He's an adult and is not your responsibility.

Bumblebeestiltskin · 09/10/2023 10:10

Lightthatnevergoesout · 08/10/2023 22:48

I can't do that because I am not this person. I am prepared and happy to give him the time , care and attention for some time but not for half a month because at this stage it's becoming too much for everyone and my own family suffers. Hence the title of my OP. I don't want the person to be treated like furniture or with regard whilst he is in my house. He is my family and I love him but not for 15 days straight.

Stop moaning then, if you're happy to keep being a doormat every year.

Lightthatnevergoesout · 09/10/2023 09:29

Xxdeborahxx · 09/10/2023 08:25

It seems like he sticks to a routine in all aspects of his life so changing his visiting routine will be difficult for him to adjust.

Does he live miles away? That may be a reason for his long visits.

Can't you visit him one Christmas to break the routine?

Do you only see him at Christmas?

You mention he is old and in the next breath you say he works. I'm not saying you don't work when you are old, just trying to work out what his day to day life is like.

Regarding you saying you try to start a conversation with your husband and father in law as otherwise they sit in silence. One with headphones on and the other on their phone. On one hand it's quite common to sit in compatible silence, however I think it's rude of your husband to have headphones on. That's like telling the father in law, kids and you not to disturb him. I would be offended by this. I've had similar experiences when my late husband was alive. He would invite his parents over then fall asleep so I would have to entertain them. Or he would be in the garage or cutting the grass. He had a very good relationship with both parents. I did say to him in the end that if he doesn't make more of an effort then don't invite them over. He did listen and made more of an effort. It wasn't that he was consciously ignoring them. He worked away a lot so when he had a chance to be at home, he liked doing jobs indoors.

Yes he lives about 5 hours away. He has a very demanding job and Christmas is the time where he can have a longer stretch off. No we can never visit him at his place as its not suitable for children to stay there.

OP posts:
Lightthatnevergoesout · 09/10/2023 09:15

Naunet · 09/10/2023 08:24

This is ridiculous, your husband is spineless and you’re a martyr. This is a grown man you’re talking about for god sake, not a lost 5 year old. Why aren’t you insisting he cook and help with housework whilst he’s there instead of running around serving him for two weeks solid? Why can’t either of you tell him to leave early evening because you want some time together as a couple? I don’t understand what’s so hard about that.
When does your husband ever see his MiL? You said you get on with her, yet the kids never see her, why? When does she ever get to visit and see her grandkids at Christmas or any other time?

My mother in law works during Christmas. Its her busy time. When she comes she stays with us in our bedroom and we go in a different room. It's easier with her as DH gets along well with her and she in return respects him and respects our boundaries. She only comes for 5 days at a time because she understands that we need time to ourselves. She normally visits 2 or 3 times a year when she gets a chance and we feel at ease around her. Again the main reason for that is because DH is calm and chatty and I can just go to sleep or read a book myself knowing that they r having nice chat and laugh about things in the next room. I also often go shopping with her/ can meet with a friend whilst she is at home playing with the kids. She is more easy going.

OP posts:
Blough · 09/10/2023 09:13

No child should ever have to ‘stand up for themselves’ against their grandparent. Not sure what the thread is for, you’ve dismissed people’s advice entirely.

sandyhappypeople · 09/10/2023 09:04

Lightthatnevergoesout · 09/10/2023 07:46

The person struggles with boundaries a lot so this is very hard to make him understand at his age. When he is at his home he does the same thing every single day and doesn't need to negotiate with nobody. He is goes to work and rhen he is just on his own.

We tried and tried to set boundaries but unfortunately he just doesn't understand that. We have negotiated that he would come for 2 days less as we will have other people coming over for lunch/dinner.

We care about him a lot and I don't want to constantly tell him come now/go away by 7/ sorry can't see you today. He comes a long way to be with his family and I want it to be a quality time. I don't mind that at all. The problem is the ammount of days leaving us with just a few days to clean the house and then being back in work.

I will try and adjust his days for a couple of days less.

the problem isn’t your FIL op, it’s the fact that you’re a martyr, all the good advice about accommodating him without doing anything different in your day to day from what you’d normally be doing you seem to just be ignoring in favour of arguing with people who think you should set more harsh boundaries, there is a middle ground here, if you can’t tell him you and DH want an early night, or you want to go for a nap etc, or you’re going out with friends then I’m not sure what you’re expecting from this post to be fair?

one thing you do need to be doing is STOP intervening in this ‘awkward’ silence nonsense, your FIL lives on his own, he will spend at least 90% of his home life in silence, to him it’s not awkward, he probably just appreciates being with you DH, even if they’re not actively ‘chatting’ just leave him/them to it.

With regards to him pestering you, I’m assuming you have locks on certain doors like bathrooms? So if he’s knocking you up just ignore if it’s not convenient, the other thing you could do is wear ear buds around the house sometimes so he SEES you using them, then if he ever questions why you didn’t answer him, you can just say sorry I had my headphones in (even if you didn’t), it’s a bit of a get out clause when you need a break.

The best thing you could do for everyone’s sake is to stop treating him as a special guest and start treating him as an extra member of the family for 2 weeks.

andtheworldrollson · 09/10/2023 08:50

and just do whatever you want to do - why on earth does having him around stop you inviting friends over or going out

"We're off to meet some friends tomorrow - you're welcome to use our home if that helps and I'll leave bread and milk available "

Xxdeborahxx · 09/10/2023 08:48

I would hate to think I was over staying my welcome at a relative or friends house.
I can understand him going to see what the children are doing if they are in another room. Just seems like he has been left in a room so he goes to see where everyone is to be sociable.
Knocking on bathroom doors seem odd unless you don't have a separate toilet and he is busting to go to the loo.
Are you sure you are not making it sound worse than it is because you are frustrated with the situation.
Would it be better to change things around a bit.
One year he visits Christmas, another time Easter or even in kids school holidays.
Could you invite your parents over at the same time do he has someone of his own age to chat to?
Depending how fit he is, spend a couple of hours bowling, cinema etc where you would have fun too. He might even be up for swimming.

Think of somewhere different that is out of your comfort zone and it might make you feel empowered and happy that you tried something different.

Pipsquiggle · 09/10/2023 08:39

@Lightthatnevergoesout

You seem to be wracked with guilt and this seems to be stopping you from making change.

If you think you can't change the dates this year (BTW you can) - you need to explicitly say 'Please don't come round before 10am.' 'Please make yourself tea.' 'We'll be going to bed at 10pm tonight.'

You seem to think change will just happen organically - it won't. Your DH &/or you are actually going to have to SAY something to your FIL - being specific and directional. If your DH won't do it, then you are going to have to do it. If you do nothing, nothing will change.

andtheworldrollson · 09/10/2023 08:35

When someone comes that long I think you need to treat them as one of the immediate family not a visitor

So when you say you couldn't go up for a nap or spend all day on your pyjamas as that's rude ... no it's not .

Similarly it's ok to say "I cooked yesterday - so are you cooking today ?"

Passepartoute · 09/10/2023 08:27

now we are once again stuck with him coming for 14 full days which would mean us cooking every single day, cleaning, washing and planning activities

Why does it mean you have clean and wash every single day, over and above what you would normally do?

Xxdeborahxx · 09/10/2023 08:25

It seems like he sticks to a routine in all aspects of his life so changing his visiting routine will be difficult for him to adjust.

Does he live miles away? That may be a reason for his long visits.

Can't you visit him one Christmas to break the routine?

Do you only see him at Christmas?

You mention he is old and in the next breath you say he works. I'm not saying you don't work when you are old, just trying to work out what his day to day life is like.

Regarding you saying you try to start a conversation with your husband and father in law as otherwise they sit in silence. One with headphones on and the other on their phone. On one hand it's quite common to sit in compatible silence, however I think it's rude of your husband to have headphones on. That's like telling the father in law, kids and you not to disturb him. I would be offended by this. I've had similar experiences when my late husband was alive. He would invite his parents over then fall asleep so I would have to entertain them. Or he would be in the garage or cutting the grass. He had a very good relationship with both parents. I did say to him in the end that if he doesn't make more of an effort then don't invite them over. He did listen and made more of an effort. It wasn't that he was consciously ignoring them. He worked away a lot so when he had a chance to be at home, he liked doing jobs indoors.

BiddyPop · 09/10/2023 08:25

Oh and if he won't babysit, (or can't), book a babysitter for you and DH to go out for dinner one night, and also send fil home early at least once with suggestive winks that you and DH need couple time (whether that is upstairs or just you both chilling with a movie snuggled up together).

Totalwasteofpaper · 09/10/2023 08:24

FreebieWallopFridge · 09/10/2023 08:13

If he comes to you at 7am, send your husband around at half 6. Your husband will have to learn the word ‘no’ to deal with all attempts yourFIL makes to come to your house before an agreed time.

Next year - starting in March and repeated monthly: “it’s lovely seeing you at Christmas, but we can only do a week between X and Y this year” and stick to it.

It’s quite frustrating to read your responses. You don’t like what’s happening but won’t have a direct conversation, instead hinting when you know he doesn’t pick up hints. You won’t make the time more bearable for you by doing any of the things suggested because you’re “not that person”. Which means the status quo persists, he carries on walking all over you, and your resentment builds.

YANBU for not wanting him in your house for 16 hours every day for 2 weeks, following you from room to room, and not even able to use the bathroom in peace.

YABU for expecting it to change without any direct action from you.

All evidence suggests that any action will have to come from you. Your FIL is oblivious, and your husband is too enmeshed in a dysfunctional relationship to tackle it.

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

Naunet · 09/10/2023 08:24

This is ridiculous, your husband is spineless and you’re a martyr. This is a grown man you’re talking about for god sake, not a lost 5 year old. Why aren’t you insisting he cook and help with housework whilst he’s there instead of running around serving him for two weeks solid? Why can’t either of you tell him to leave early evening because you want some time together as a couple? I don’t understand what’s so hard about that.
When does your husband ever see his MiL? You said you get on with her, yet the kids never see her, why? When does she ever get to visit and see her grandkids at Christmas or any other time?

BiddyPop · 09/10/2023 08:23

I think you need to start putting foot down with FIL.

He knocks at 7:30am in the morning - tell him a couple of evenings as he leaves that everyone needs an extra sleep in the morning so he is NOT to knock until 10am (perhaps send him home with the makings of breakfast for suggest a nice cafe that is open early).

Tell him you are having visitors certain days - let DCs have play dates they can't normally. Have a couple of friends in for coffe, cake and natter; have 1 or 2 other couples or families in for relaxed dinner...normal things families do with their time off.

Tell him one afternoon that you need a chance as a family to relax together with a movie as you both work so hard you never get a chance to have fun with the DCs.

Tell him before he comes that this year, you have realised that, as a family, you are not making enough time for each other, you've all had a hell of a year and need to decompress and relax. That lovely as he is, his presence is not relaxing. So you would prefer if his stay is a few days shorter this year.

And you need to stop making so much effort. It is DH's DF so he needs to be far more involved in organising and entertaining. You are allowed to go out and meet friends or go shopping or have a couple of hours getting mails done or whatever. You can meet friends for drinks,(9 to dc pre- Christmas school events, watch a movie in a cinema, or just go for a long walk as a family in peace.

NonMiDispiace · 09/10/2023 08:23

I would tell my DH to go and stay with his father for one week, I couldn’t carry on like this.
My FIL was oblivious to anything anyone else, he put himself first and I ended up being barely civil to him. Some men just think themselves far more important than anyone else.

FreebieWallopFridge · 09/10/2023 08:13

If he comes to you at 7am, send your husband around at half 6. Your husband will have to learn the word ‘no’ to deal with all attempts yourFIL makes to come to your house before an agreed time.

Next year - starting in March and repeated monthly: “it’s lovely seeing you at Christmas, but we can only do a week between X and Y this year” and stick to it.

It’s quite frustrating to read your responses. You don’t like what’s happening but won’t have a direct conversation, instead hinting when you know he doesn’t pick up hints. You won’t make the time more bearable for you by doing any of the things suggested because you’re “not that person”. Which means the status quo persists, he carries on walking all over you, and your resentment builds.

YANBU for not wanting him in your house for 16 hours every day for 2 weeks, following you from room to room, and not even able to use the bathroom in peace.

YABU for expecting it to change without any direct action from you.

All evidence suggests that any action will have to come from you. Your FIL is oblivious, and your husband is too enmeshed in a dysfunctional relationship to tackle it.

PosterBoy · 09/10/2023 08:11

I'd start with the holiday entitlement to be honest.

It's a legal requirement, unlike the requirement to sit in your house for 2 weeks with someone irritating. That's just a choice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread