Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guest staying for 2 full weeks every Christmas without asking

259 replies

Lightthatnevergoesout · 08/10/2023 19:57

I have got a great relationship with both of DH's divorced parents. We get along fine and I love it when they come over. However, DH's relationship with his dad has always been really cold and all they talk about is grandchildren (our kids) and sports. It becomes even more obvious when they can spend hours sitting next to one another on a sofa without having any deep conversations. I end up constantly coming up with the topics to talk about.

Every single winter my father in law comes over and stays in a flat in a house next to us every Christmas. He hasn't got any interests of his own so comes to simply follow whatever we are doing. For example he would often come over to our house at 7 am and leave at 22.30 to sleep in his accommodation. During the day he would stay in the living room the whole day expecting for us to have some kind of plans every single day.

Christmas break is the only break my DH gets from his job and because his father in law comes for these whole 2 weeks we often don't even get a chance to spend one on one time together. He is bad at babysitting kids ad he shouts and gets anxious if they misbehave and on the times we attempted to sneak out on a date he lost it with the kids.

We have politely hinted that we might have plans/friends over/a short booked trip but that really doesn't seem to change much as he would just come for 1 day less. DH gets really anxious prior to him coming but then again failed to say anything and now we are once again stuck with him coming for 14 full days which would mean us cooking every single day, cleaning, washing and planning activities . We feel often trapped in our house as he can knock on the door when we are still sleeping or stay till 23 when we both just want to spend time together !

AIBU To think that my husband should have talked to him earlier (he had whole year since last Christmas) and explained that it is too long for a visit and really doesnt leave us with any time to just sit in our pyjamas and relax the way we might want to?

OP posts:
Lightthatnevergoesout · 09/10/2023 20:21

Chamomileteaplease · 09/10/2023 18:50

Last year was particularly bad as my DH was quite sick with strep and needed antibiotics. It was just a few days before FIL was due to come so we were all tired but FIL insisted that he didn't care whether he was sick or contagious his holiday was happening anyway

But I bet you didn't say, FIL DH has strep so we need you to arrive four days later. I bet you hinted at what you wanted. And of course, not only is FIL not a mind-reader but if autistic then won't get hints anyway.

As someone else said, you can't change him, you have to change yourself.

You denied being foreign but said you had lived here since being a student which means you weren't here for your childhood. You may not like people making cultural assumptions but honestly it is very unusual for a British person to put up with this shit.

Best of luck being stronger dealing with this man.

I absolutely don't like being defined as 'foreign' . I have got a British passport and don't define myself as being foreign. You say its unusual for a British person... but how do you even define a British person in a multicultural country?

I know many many ' British' people who put up with all sorts of things. I also know British people who kicked homeless Ukrainian refuges out who they applied to host because they couldn't 'put up' with them anymore.

My line of work is exactly working with cultural assumptions and how that actually creates boundaries between people. This situation is a common situation and can happen in any cultural set up. Me being a 'foreigner' has got nothing to do with that.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 09/10/2023 20:10

If he's already booked to come and there's no way of putting him off, I'd present him with a schedule for the two weeks with the blocks of time you are free to spend with him highlighted in green. None before 10am or after 8pm. Just mark the time before 10am "Slobbing in PJs, not entertaining guests" and a similar description of the time after 8pm. If you're planning days out with friends, mark that time as unavailable.

CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 09/10/2023 20:03

neveradullard · Today 19:54

I messaged about the dates and he agreed to change his booking and come for 2 days less.

You had a perfect opportunity to reduce his visit time down to a reasonable 7 days or less but he's still coming for 12 days! Surely he can change the booking for more than 2 days! You need to be clear and firm with him if this is to change. Don't leave it so late in the year to spell it out to him.

Well done OP, you got it reduced by two days for this year. I understand your difficulty and why you seem to be ignoring the advice - it's a lousy situation that you're doing your best to please everyone and are losing out yourself. Now use this year's success to whittle it down by another two days next year, and keep going til you've got it down to a week.

But you really need to address the bathroom thing - no matter how you feel, he needs to understand bathroom time is sacrosanct. Just shout out I'm in here, go away and wait your turn, or do as suggested and call out for everyone to use the loo now because you're having a bath and it won't be free for an hour. That is not being rude or disrespectful or spoiling anyone's fun, it's just being practical. Then have a nice soak wearing ear plugs, and ignore any knocking.

As I said before, good luck..

neveradullard · 09/10/2023 19:54

I messaged about the dates and he agreed to change his booking and come for 2 days less.

You had a perfect opportunity to reduce his visit time down to a reasonable 7 days or less but he's still coming for 12 days! Surely he can change the booking for more than 2 days! You need to be clear and firm with him if this is to change. Don't leave it so late in the year to spell it out to him.

BettyPhuckzer · 09/10/2023 19:01

If FIL has just contacted you saying he's coming to stay next door from 15th Dec 30 Dec you contact him back saying :

That's great but we're only available to host/see you from 24th Dec to 27 Dec and only between 10 am and 6 pm

Whats the problem with that?

Trianglesandcircles1 · 09/10/2023 18:56

I tried to arrange them 2 to spend time together so I can take a bath in my house or just go for a nap without answering questions 24/7. It doesn't happen.

Why do you have to concern yourself with 'arranging' them before you can take a bath or a nap? Just go and take a bath. Get up of the sofa and say to DH "I'm going to have a bath". If you feel the need you could add "keep an eye on the kids".
That's all there is to it.

You said earlier that 'I'm not that sort of person'. I suspect your problem is that you won't let yourself be 'that person' because it is utterly ingrained in you to be nice to everyone and put everyone else before yourself, to be polite and a good hostess and make sure everyone else is happy and comfortable. And you think that is a good way to behave.
This is not actually a good trait. It is not something to be proud of. You are setting your DC a bad example by being an over-passive doormat. Daughters will grow up copying your behaviour, or going to the other extreme, and sons will grow up expecting their wives/girlfriends to be totally submissive, passive, self-effacing and with no boundaries.

Learn how to sit in silence without feeling you have to make conversation. If they are both on phones, get your own phone out, or put the TV on.

One more thing - this business about 'is it safe to come in' the bathroom - it is difficult if there is only one toilet, so just say to everyone in a loud voice 'use the toilet now because I am going to take a bath for an hour and I won't be letting you in". Then keep the door locked. If FIL knocks, just say "no you can't come in, you'll have to wait."

booksandbeans · 09/10/2023 18:53

Your FIL at sounds a bit like my DF. I just keep to small talk & bring a iPad with me & keep
visits to 4 days.

your DH & FIL sound quite similar in many respects. But I think you both could handle things differently.

who invited these people etc', 'this boy is ruining our day'. Which then led to a big argument between my DH and him in the evening

dont rise to this - just keep calm, smile & wave and walk away or deflect. No point arguing with him. Once he learns that this behaviour gets him ignored he might tone it down a bit.

could you this Xmas suggest that next week he just has Xmas week with you & the other week some other time? Break it up a bit?

Chamomileteaplease · 09/10/2023 18:50

Last year was particularly bad as my DH was quite sick with strep and needed antibiotics. It was just a few days before FIL was due to come so we were all tired but FIL insisted that he didn't care whether he was sick or contagious his holiday was happening anyway

But I bet you didn't say, FIL DH has strep so we need you to arrive four days later. I bet you hinted at what you wanted. And of course, not only is FIL not a mind-reader but if autistic then won't get hints anyway.

As someone else said, you can't change him, you have to change yourself.

You denied being foreign but said you had lived here since being a student which means you weren't here for your childhood. You may not like people making cultural assumptions but honestly it is very unusual for a British person to put up with this shit.

Best of luck being stronger dealing with this man.

Judecb · 09/10/2023 18:44

Be clear and firm about the situation now before he has time to plan his two week stay!

ironblancmange · 09/10/2023 18:43

I've only come on to this thread late but what you said about autism reminds me of my much older brother. I realized after he died that he must have been autistic.
Before that, I was teaching abroad and though I had long summer holidays, I had a lot of marking and preparation to do and really needed a break. Every year my brother would come for two weeks and want to follow me around shopping and doing all the things I needed a break from. I never succeeded in stopping him coming. It would have been too cruel. I didn't have a family or children though. Ideally we went for a short trip to another town or once a coach trip to Verona. This was something like 20 years of my life when I couldn't really relax. Looking back at it now I don't know what else I might have done. I am sorry for your situation.

FreebieWallopFridge · 09/10/2023 18:39

Pipsquiggle · 09/10/2023 17:53

So just tell FIL your family want to do all of that.....
Christmas markets/theatre/coffee shops /watching movies together

Tell FIL this is your plan - he can join in, stay next door, decide to come for a week or decide not to come.

The more you write about FIL, the more I think you should just say 'we've got lots on this year, please come for 5 nights' - yes it will be awkward the first time you mention it, but at least it breaks this bloody awful cycle.

You’re more generous than me. Based the most recent updates, one out of OP and her husband needs to tell FIL he’s not coming at all

Cherrysoup · 09/10/2023 18:30

You’ve asked him to come for 2 days less, you can ask him for more.

He follows you into the kitchen and the kids’ room and even asks to come in the bathroom? This all needs to stop, bloody well tell him! And while you’re at it, tell him not to knock before 10 so you can lie in. I would want to stab someone who did this. Your Dh needs to step up, I’d have no respect for someone who let this just carry on.

TeresaMayspants · 09/10/2023 18:22

I think one day you are going to snap. He follows you to the loo and lies on your bed with you while you read to your children. He comments on what you eat.

Theres only so much someone can put up with. One day you will blow your top at him and for him it will be unexpected and seemingly come from nowhere!

You are not doing him or yourself any favours.

Givemethereins · 09/10/2023 18:15

The thought of this is giving me hives...how in gods name have you both let this continue?
I would flee my own house if this was going to happen every year. How are you staying sane about this?

Pipsquiggle · 09/10/2023 17:53

So just tell FIL your family want to do all of that.....
Christmas markets/theatre/coffee shops /watching movies together

Tell FIL this is your plan - he can join in, stay next door, decide to come for a week or decide not to come.

The more you write about FIL, the more I think you should just say 'we've got lots on this year, please come for 5 nights' - yes it will be awkward the first time you mention it, but at least it breaks this bloody awful cycle.

Lightthatnevergoesout · 09/10/2023 17:40

forrestgreen · 09/10/2023 13:36

Ask your Dh, if you had a magic wand what would Christmas look like. Do you want your dad to come. How many days for, how long each day. Pin him down
It's pointless the both of you living in angst

Then work out how to make it happen. This happens each year because it's not addressed.
Write a message together, then ask dh if he wants to send it or should you?

Only a rough outline
'Hi dad, thanks for you message, we hadn't realised it'd gotten that close to Christmas.
We'd like it if you could make some alterations to your booking please. My (dh) job has been really stressful this year and I/he needs a massive break at Christmas. So the most we can have you over is x days from x to y.
Also please can only pop round after 1pm as the mornings are needed for lie ins for us all. We're happy to cook dinner for you each day but might have to kick you out if we're having an early night. We realise these are big changes to our arrangements but hope that we can make this shorter time, a more quality family time. And as always the kids will look forward to seeing you very much. Op and Dh'

In all honesty he would want him not to come at all. He would want the 4 of us to go on a nice trip together where kids can have fun during the day and we can have wine and nice cheese in the evenings. Of course financially we can't do flat but just going to Christmas markets/theatre/coffee shops /watching movies together is brilliant for DH (and myself).

Their relationship has been bad for a while and to be honest FIL is at fault. He doesn't ask his son nothing about his work/health/ what his plans and goals are. All he talks about is kids and what they are doing each day and some sports.

Last year was particularly bad as my DH was quite sick with strep and needed antibiotics. It was just a few days before FIL was due to come so we were all tired but FIL insisted that he didn't care whether he was sick or contagious his holiday was happening anyway. He then gaslighted my husband repeatedly calling it a 'bad cold' . That's been their relationship most of Dh's life. They wouldn't even go to a pub together and I tried to arrange them 2 to spend time together so I can take a bath in my house or just go for a nap without answering questions 24/7. It doesn't happen.

Dh is only tolerating his father because he knows he got noone else and so the kids can have a grandad in their lives. Also FIL is 66 and his health is not the same so here is that too.

OP posts:
T1Dmama · 09/10/2023 17:10

Lightthatnevergoesout · 09/10/2023 13:01

On his last visit we met up all together with some of our family friends with children too because that would have been our normal day. We went to the museum and then for a quick lunch. My FIL didn't deal well with it because my friend's child was having a tantrum and it made him somehow extremelly anxious and he kept on whispering nasty comments to my DH along the lines 'who invited these people etc', 'this boy is ruining our day'. Which then led to a big argument between my DH and him in the evening about that fact that we were just meeting our friends and any kid can have a tantrum and he was acting childish etc. I felt uncomfortable as I was worried that my friend would hear his comments.

He is not good with people outside of our family and gets very socially anxious and says passive aggressive comments.

So in many ways this is what makes it harder than it has to be for me. Because unfortunately as a doormat I often have to do things to avoid these confrontations or situations. Yes, I know I shouldn't be a control freak but I just don't want my kids listening to that. FIL had a completely different rough upbringing and he is alright one on one with the kids as he loves them dearly.

I don’t think you’re a doormat or a control freak…
Its a hard situation and we women often try to keep everyone happy!
You husband needs to ask his dad to come down for a few days over Christmas, or maybe a week, but not 2
weeks…. He needs to be the one talking to his dad, I don’t think you should be doing it at all, isn’t fair on you…. If it annoys him then he should talk to him.
maybe you should book and go out with your kids and leave DH home with his dad .. maybe then he’ll take control and speak up

Gymmum82 · 09/10/2023 16:39

Your husband is too spineless to stand up to his dad so you’ll have to.
‘Sorry Derek coming on the 15th doesn’t work for us as we have plans until the 20th so won’t be around until then’
‘On Sunday we’re going out with some friends, I remember last year you didn’t enjoy that as one of the children got upset so it’s probably best you entertain yourself that day and we’ll see you for dinner’
’Im absolutely shattered please don’t call round before 9am and we’ll be heading to bed by 10 so it’s probably best you head home then’

use your words if you continue pandering to him nothing will ever change and you’ll continue to be resentful

Isittimeformynapyet · 09/10/2023 16:27

aloris · 08/10/2023 22:19

if your FIL and your husband argue, or your FIL gets mad because you watched Frozen with your kids 5 times in a row, or he dislikes eating ice cream for every lunch, or he disapproves of cheese sandwiches for tea, or he gets bored because you haven't planned "outings" then this seems all to the good because maybe then he'll decide not to stay so long next year. Do you and your dh even get to be intimate with your FIL around for your entire waking hours of your holiday? It just sounds like he comes over and ruins your kids' entire two weeks of holiday time by grumping and expecting to be catered to and treated like a whiny 3 year old who must always be given whatever he wants lest he have a huge tantrum. He's not bringing anything to the table, whether in grandpa-ness or dad-ness. He's just taking from all of you, including the kids.

I didn't get that FIL whines like a three year old or is demanding or that he ruins the kids' whole holiday. I didn't get that he grumps away, expects to get whatever he wants or has regular tantrums.

I did get that OP takes it upon herself to do much more than she needs to for a close family member staying so long. She may be following protocols from childhood Christmases where hosts went all-out for a couple of days. She needs to know she doesn't have to do this for 15 days straight.

Isittimeformynapyet · 09/10/2023 16:01

Unicorn2022 · 08/10/2023 22:17

How does he manage to rent the property at the same time every year? Is this his own property next door?

Your second question totally cancels out the first, Silly Billy.

Choux · 09/10/2023 16:01

Gosh @mindutopia

We get both MIL and BIL/his partner. They come to ours because none of us is welcome at MIL's because her partner doesn't allow her family to visit (in her own home, it's not even his home, this is a whole other issue).
So she paid for the house and now he rules the roost? And at the expense of her relationships with her kids and grandkids? Yet presumably she won't kick him out for some reason? Loneliness, his pension?

BIL/partner couldn't fit us all in at their house, but frankly, they couldn't afford the cost of hosting anyway, so have never offered. But they are the same in that they don't really talk to each other much. Yet they insist on being together. No one really says much except about the weather or really general topics. Until someone (mostly MIL) gets roaring drunk (common on Christmas day) and cries about something from 20 years ago. And they come and sit and expect to be fed and watered for the week, 3 meals a day, plus snacks and booze, without contributing a thing.
I would downgrade your food slightly this year and when the moment is right say it's expensive to host every year, cost of living etc and perhaps everyone could bring something next year eg BIL and family bring booze, Christmas desserts and MIL bring Turkey and other meats. You will take care of veg, potatoes, breakfasts, cooking it etc. at least then you will just be annoyed that they are there rather than also annoyed at how much the sorry affair is costing you.

It's tedious. I hate it. It fills me with anxiety every year. It fills dh with anxiety every year because he actually doesn't like spending time with them, even though he would never admit it. He'd want them visiting every month if I'd allow it, but then tries to hide and not have to talk to them when they're here.
Bloody men love to invite their families and then let the wife deal with the planning, cooking, chatting etc. Good on you for putting your foot down.

Isittimeformynapyet · 09/10/2023 15:50

saltinesandcoffeecups · 08/10/2023 21:59

First things first…I wouldn’t be happy with a guest for 2 weeks.

That being said @Lightthatnevergoesout you can change how you interact with the situation. Stop treating him as a guest and treat him as a family member.

“Hey Phil, here’s some money and a list of things I need from the shop. Thanks”
”Oof… bit of a headache today… I’ll be down for a nap”
”Mind watching the kids on Tuesday night, we’ve been invited to a work do”
”We’re going to the home improvement store tomorrow to pick up the paint for the hallway”
”How are you with a screwdriver…the hallway door hinge needs tightening”

Stop trying to get your DH and FIL to have deep conversations…like I don’t even know what that means. Let them grunt at the sports on tv and talk about the weather.

In other words just get on with it with him added to the mix. Plan a few things but other than that he seems pretty content to just hang out.

Perfect post

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 09/10/2023 14:22

Are none of your children at school yet?
Why on earth was your FIL planning to turn up a full week before the school holidays even start?!
Can't you just say to him that you're all busy with work and school and Xmas shopping and other plans (trips, skating, whatever) until the 22nd or thereabouts?

And when he does arrive, he seems to be staying in the house next door....
Why can't your DH go and spend time sitting in uncomfortable silence with him there?
Why can't the children go round there to play with him?
Why does he need to come and sit in your house/ barge into your bathroom?
You could invite him to yours for meals at set times, on certain dates, and make it clear that you expect him to cater for himself at breakfast/ other times.
You could even suggest that he cooks dinner for all of you in his rented place at least once?
I liked a PP's suggestion that you get a huge jigsaw for him to do with his grandchildren, and again, would suggest that he does it in his place, not yours.

Make sure you invite your friends, and your children's friends, round to your house during the fortnight, and send your DH off to spend time entertaining his dad by himself during these visits. This will help him to better understand the problem, and hopefully develop better communication skills before next October.

mindutopia · 09/10/2023 13:54

"Ask your Dh, if you had a magic wand what would Christmas look like. Do you want your dad to come. How many days for, how long each day. Pin him down. It's pointless the both of you living in angst."

I think the above is good advice. What would happen with your dh if you just got in touch with FIL and said, sorry, we have plans, we can only do 3 nights? Honestly, this sounds like hell. I have to deal with it for like 5 days, but 14 days, and I would probably have a breakdown.

We get both MIL and BIL/his partner. They come to ours because none of us is welcome at MIL's because her partner doesn't allow her family to visit (in her own home, it's not even his home, this is a whole other issue). BIL/partner couldn't fit us all in at their house, but frankly, they couldn't afford the cost of hosting anyway, so have never offered. So the only way anyone would see anyone is at our house. But it's every bloody year. I never have a year when I just get to sit down and relax. But they are the same in that they don't really talk to each other much. Yet they insist on being together. No one really says much except about the weather or really general topics. Until someone (mostly MIL) gets roaring drunk (common on Christmas day) and cries about something from 20 years ago. And they come and sit and expect to be fed and watered for the week, 3 meals a day, plus snacks and booze, without contributing a thing.

It's tedious. I hate it. It fills me with anxiety every year. It fills dh with anxiety every year because he actually doesn't like spending time with them, even though he would never admit it. He'd want them visiting every month if I'd allow it, but then tries to hide and not have to talk to them when they're here. This year I've said, I can have them 3 nights and that's it. They can choose the 3 nights, but then they need to go, so I can actually enjoy my annual leave with my children and not spend it entertaining people who just want free room and board for a week. And when they are here, as much as possible, I disappear and do whatever I enjoy. Obviously not on Christmas, but on the in between days. If they want to stay, dh has to entertain them and they all have to look after the kids. 😂You may find that actually though your dh finds some solace in you setting the boundary if he is unable to do it for whatever reason. You may have to be the meanie, but it can save Christmas for you.

Farmageddon · 09/10/2023 13:52

OP from the sounds of it you are determined to not make your FIL uncomfortable, and make all sorts of allowances for him because you perceive him to be a difficult character, set in his ways etc.

Which is all very nice, but the flip side is that it seems to be making you incredibly uncomfortable. Which I'm sure he doesn't mean to do, but all the same you and your family are having to deal with the awkardness.

Can you try this year to do things a bit differently, you have already negotiate less days. What about being clearer when he is around that you have a schedule to keep or need to be busy doing certain things and don't have time to entertain him. Or better yet, have him babysit your children while you do something else - you said he is very good with them ,so put him to good use. It doesn't have to be all day, just find a few things for him to do throughout the day and leave him to it for a while. Or alternatively arrange for a few things for you to do and let him know that you need time alone.

You assume he will be affronted, but you don't know, maybe he will surprise you, maybe he just needs more firm instructions and boundaries.