Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how parents deal with once child being more successful than the other?

331 replies

User5512 · 08/10/2023 18:54

Is it hard to not feel sorry for the “poorer” child?

DC A : Got lucky with their first job at a start up, successful exit after 5 yrs. invested wisely and is now a multi millionaire. Great lifestyle, flexible pay, very high paying jobs (C level) etc

DC B: NHS consultant, stressful job, relatively lower pay, very little flexibility. Married to another NHS doctor.

Parents support DC B a lot (childcare mostly) and DC-A gets quite annoyed as they don’t get as much support. They can afford to pay, but you can’t buy grandparents.

DC-B feels left out when DC-A takes parents on exotic holidays with their family, gives them expensive gifts (cars and watches etc)

Parents feel stuck in the middle !

OP posts:
SeptemberSuns · 10/10/2023 09:05

Sounds like a stealth boasting post to me.

Ffion21 · 10/10/2023 09:04

OP what’s the issue as you’re neither the parents or child so making up a non-existent issue? Which party is unhappy because it’s nothing to do with you either?

In a childcare situation however I understand the time spent with DCB due to their professions. It’s not about money but childcare availability. As doctors they’ll work some weird and unpredictable hours. You can’t get childcare that is that flexible and consistent during evenings etc. I know as I have a similar setup and my mum helps me out due to this (we have the money and I actually pay her an hourly rate like a childminder. She didn’t want this but I was happier doing this as she helps me 3 days per week which is significant). My sister has less money but a standard hours job so getting child care is easier.

My sister is proud of me (corporate high flyer bla bla bla) and I her (works in a more meaningful job as a civil servant) and would never ask me to pay for her or give her money. She isn’t a charity case and acting in this way changes the sibling dynamic. People also live within their means so DCA will have much higher expenses.

I just think this is a non-issue and if jealousy between them it would be from childhood favouritism not adult monetary earnings.

DriftingDora · 10/10/2023 08:51

TrayBaker · 08/10/2023 19:04

Ha, I am an ‘unsuccessful’ full time NHS consultant. Yes I am paid a lot less than City friends but I am in no way a failure. I have worked really hard, and consider it a privilege to do my job. I have rewarding moments that cannot be measured in terms of money. And have shared my working life with so many interesting and diverse people. Colleagues and patients.

My ‘success’ is not about my bank account. Though I consider myself well-paid anyway.

Absolutely agree with this. In fact, I'd say DC B is the most successful - he/she didn't 'get lucky', they worked bloody hard to get where they are (and nobody can 'gift you' the abililty to get through long years of studying medicine, you do it through your own ability, blood, sweat and tears). We need another 'financial wizard' like a hole in the head, they're ten a penny and it's not exactly unknown for them to come a cropper at some stage - but we sure as hell do need hospital consultants.

I find the OP really strange in its' intimation of what constitutes 'success'.

MrsRaspberry · 10/10/2023 08:11

It doesn't sound like either one of them need support. A couple with a few holidays a year don't need free childcare. Your financially better off adult child also doesn't but if you're helping one with childcare why not the other. They're both your adult offspring treat them equally. No need to feel for the "poorer" one as you put it. They're not multi millionaires but also not poor seeing as they both have well paid NHS job roles. Seems your kids need to appreciate what they have rather than dwell on what they don't have

Jem123456789 · 10/10/2023 06:44

Wow, just wow. Two docs earning £200k plus between them is poorer than their multimillionaire sibling. Neither need our tears tbh. If the docs want to take their parents away then take them for a week in the med and Stfu.

Vodkafairy99 · 10/10/2023 05:15

Seriously??

CKMc2b · 10/10/2023 03:23

Um, I think anyone would consider DC B well off and successful. Lol

JustAMinutePleass · 09/10/2023 23:41

I’m child A in this scenario. I didn’t get lucky, I sacrificed a lot. I got my highly paid jobs because I was careful & didn’t have 2 back to back accidental pregnancies like my DB and Sil & didn’t get locked into a low paid job by a ‘final salary pension’ I didn’t understand like my DS. I chose investments wisely. I married an equal instead of a dependant like my siblings did (DB chose sil specifically because she was gorgeous and low paid, so his career could come first; and then ended up resenting her for it. DS purposely chose a lazy twat because he was rich and she inadvertedly ended up doing everything). I bought a house much smaller than I could afford as we needed to pay for IVF and when that worked it seemed natural to divert our money into nice things for DS like outstanding nurseries and private schools.

It frustrates me that my DP whittles everything down to how much we earn. They will bend backwards to give childcare / do school drop offs for my neices and nephews but when I want it will mess me around so badly I’ve now stopped asking. It has gotten to the stage where DS, who is only 3, has begun to notice - and while yes we can and do pay for childcare. Time with grandparents should be free and provided wholeheartedly.

Harry12345 · 09/10/2023 23:40

They both sound immature and ungrateful. Also can’t imagine being a multi millionaire and not taking my sibling and family on holidays too

theduchessofspork · 09/10/2023 23:35

Both kids are successful

A is wealthy, whereas B is comfortable

When they behave like twats the parents just need to say - stop being a twat about your brother

That’s it. No more engagement.

sadaboutmycat · 09/10/2023 23:24

You lost Je when you said a medical consultant is 'less successful'
All depends on how you measure it frankly

Pinkfluff76 · 09/10/2023 23:21

My sister is wealthy and has a very successful career. I’m comfortable (money wise) and happy and a SAHM. Totally different lives. Why is it a competition? We’re different people! Money isn’t everything. It’s not like DC-B is poor! Sounds like you’re all focused too much on the money. Group therapy?

Nily4567 · 09/10/2023 22:53

I don’t equate money with success - being an NHS is hopefully a positive, yet exhausting, experience - being part of something that amazing sounds like the definition of success

Tryingtohelp12 · 09/10/2023 22:41

As the person t who watches their children receive less Time with their beloved grandparent (sil is helped with school drop of and pick up -including dinner and washing uniforms etc) x5 days per week plus a weekly Saturday sleepover. My children are regularly asking to see grandad but he is exhausted from constant childcare.

treat your kids equally. Even where one seems to be doing slightly better financially it’s time which cannot be replicated

Dragonsmother · 09/10/2023 22:38

Well done parents on raising successful ambitious kids.

There is clearly sibling rivalry. Do A and B spend time together?

I have siblings who have been supported financially, with childcare, emotionally and I have had zero support. I do not speak with said sibling. My DP are to blame and should have been fairer with parenting.

Perhaps DPs need to be fairer and split time and support equally

Uggtrending · 09/10/2023 22:35

@Luckyduc true BUT I think people are saying OP needs to gain some perspective. Doctors DO earn more than a lot of us could dream of granted its hard work but still a very good wage. Most people won't compare to a millionaire.

HateLongCovid · 09/10/2023 22:35

WaitingfortheTardis · 08/10/2023 18:57

Depends how you measure success really.

Absolutely this! Money is not the only measure or even a measure of success . We just live in a capitalist society where the government want you to think like this. It's very sad.

Ivymom · 09/10/2023 22:35

The time and energy the grandparents spend with the grandkids should have nothing to do with the financial success of the parents. They should strive to treat their grandchildren as equally as possible. This doesn’t seem to be a case of one child living locally to the grandparents, so the grandparents see those kids more often. This also doesn’t seem to be a situation where one child can’t afford childcare for school holidays and the grandparents step in to fill the gap.

From what I see, the grandparents are trying to make up the salary/lifestyle difference between their children by favoring the grandchildren of the child who makes less money. They are fostering jealousy between their children and grandchildren. At some point, DCA and their children may reciprocate the lack of effort and stop inviting them on the exotic vacations, which sound like the only time the grandparents are spending with them.

The grandparents should at least offer to split the school holiday visits between their DC and DGC. Having more money to hire childcare doesn’t replace a visit from grandparents.

Luckyduc · 09/10/2023 22:27

Sorry but no. Two NHS consultants are on a high wage. Not millionaire wage but definitely not minimum wage. Would say both children turned out fine and should get on with it.

Saoirse82 · 09/10/2023 21:53

ZenNudist · 08/10/2023 19:02

I can't believe the 2 doctor family is your definition of poor. Jesus.

I know, WTF!

Some of us mere mortals live in the real world OP.

Didshejustsaythatoutloud · 09/10/2023 21:52

Aww, boohoo, your poor little 2nd child only earning 100,000pa...at least, such a shame, how will they cope without handouts from their sibling.

Purpleturtle45 · 09/10/2023 21:50

LookingforMaryPoppins · 09/10/2023 19:00

Exactly this!

My parents bent over backwards with childcare for my sibling, didn't do the same for me for similar reasons. It was never about "free" childcare to me but the relationship I hoped my children would have with their grandparents.

My parents never saw this, my children subsequently don't really have much of a relationship with them.

My eldest is almost 14 and has recently mentioned her grandparents having "favourites" - this is 100% her perception of the situation.

Same for me. My Mum looks after my brother's kids every week and wouldn't do the same for me and makes no effort to make it up in any way. Kids all go to the same school so my kids need to see their Gran picking up their cousins every week and never them. She has a completely different relationship with mine and I don't think I will ever get over the hurt of it all.

eastegg · 09/10/2023 21:50

TrayBaker · 08/10/2023 19:04

Ha, I am an ‘unsuccessful’ full time NHS consultant. Yes I am paid a lot less than City friends but I am in no way a failure. I have worked really hard, and consider it a privilege to do my job. I have rewarding moments that cannot be measured in terms of money. And have shared my working life with so many interesting and diverse people. Colleagues and patients.

My ‘success’ is not about my bank account. Though I consider myself well-paid anyway.

Indeed. Good grief I’d be bursting with pride if one of my children had what it takes to become an NHS consultant and achieved it. None of them are showing any signs though, and I’m not sure I’d wish the stress on them.

rantinglunatic · 09/10/2023 21:47

It must be horrendous going on those exotic holidays!

rantinglunatic · 09/10/2023 21:46

This literally has to be the ultimate first world problem post!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread