Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to go it alone at 23?

153 replies

youcannevergoback · 08/10/2023 12:51

I'm 23, I'm a primary school teacher and enjoying it well enough. I live in a very cheap area of the UK and have bought a house. I've always loved children and recently started looking seriously at the process of becoming a foster carer now that I have my own place.

However I've always been desperate for children of my own and have been waiting for the right man to come along, except I've just sat down and given it a thought-- I can't imagine living with a man. I never really have, unless my little brother counts. I've never really felt that urge to have a relationship and was only in one short lived one once.

I don't really want to travel (I spend a month or so a year with family that lives abroad and have since I was about 5). I've never liked going out. I adore children and think I do well with them, so I'm asking myself now why not just look into having children alone. I feel ready and most girls my age (in my area) already have children, so I don't see why I wouldn't be capable. Work will definitely be the biggest issue as it seems so sad to put your child in nursery young but then again I don't suppose there are many housewives around so that would be the same with a partner!

Poke some holes in my plans please Smile

OP posts:
Siameasy · 09/10/2023 10:56

MotherofaToad · 09/10/2023 09:51

@Siameasy it's homophobic as it implies that children with single sex parents are in a worse position than children from a family with a mum and dad.
It's pointless for a child to have 2 parents if one of them is totally useless. You just need to look at the boards here to see how many fathers out there don't do their fair share of childcare or carrying the mental load.
I was very truthful to the op about how hard it is being a solo mum. I wouldn't change it at all though.

Ideally though a child needs a mum and a dad. I’m not sure I fully agree with same sex parents because the child needs a male and a female parent. If that means I hate gay people to you then I find that incorrect but that’s your take.
Fatherless children (the more likely option in today’s world) do badly statistically and ultimately this is bad for society. You may not fit the stats and I also know some great single mums but these would be the exception.
There are some dreadful men but also some women making terrible choices and also, not marrying before having kids thus putting themselves at risk.Women initiate 80% of divorces so it’s more women choosing to leave a marriage. But our sex doesn’t like reality very much 🤷🏻‍♀️

MotherofaToad · 09/10/2023 09:51

@Siameasy it's homophobic as it implies that children with single sex parents are in a worse position than children from a family with a mum and dad.
It's pointless for a child to have 2 parents if one of them is totally useless. You just need to look at the boards here to see how many fathers out there don't do their fair share of childcare or carrying the mental load.
I was very truthful to the op about how hard it is being a solo mum. I wouldn't change it at all though.

caerdydd12 · 09/10/2023 09:50

Siameasy · 09/10/2023 08:54

Hi can you explain how a child doesn’t need a mum and a dad? That makes no sense at all. I’m not sure how that’s homophobic as I never mentioned gay people at all yet your mind went straight to that?!

Children of single mothers have statistically poor outcomes because there isn’t a man in the house. There’s a reason why we say “wait until your father gets home”. A single mum will struggle to handle an errant 15 year old boy who is bigger than her, for instance.

Its kind to tell people the truth.

Jesus Christ what a load of crap.

Of course it's homophobic. You're saying a child needs a mum and a dad, ergo any mum/mum and dad/dad setups aren't as good.

And no, children of single mothers have statistically poorer outcomes because they face different challenges. Likelihood of depression, lack of familial support, lack of social and inter community support, fewer resources within the family owing to one wage and often men who don't pay maintenance, lower school achievement because of availability of time spent with the child. You have one parent working, cooking, cleaning, shopping, no second parent to pick up that slack. All of these are because of the lack of two parents, not the lack of a father.

Siameasy · 09/10/2023 08:54

MotherofaToad · 08/10/2023 23:24

@Siameasy Utter bollocks! A child needs to form secure attachments to care givers. A child does not need a mum and a dad. That is a horrible homophobic view. Children of single parent families have less desirable outcomes due to many contributory factors but not because there's only one adult to love them.

Hi can you explain how a child doesn’t need a mum and a dad? That makes no sense at all. I’m not sure how that’s homophobic as I never mentioned gay people at all yet your mind went straight to that?!

Children of single mothers have statistically poor outcomes because there isn’t a man in the house. There’s a reason why we say “wait until your father gets home”. A single mum will struggle to handle an errant 15 year old boy who is bigger than her, for instance.

Its kind to tell people the truth.

MotherofaToad · 08/10/2023 23:24

@Siameasy Utter bollocks! A child needs to form secure attachments to care givers. A child does not need a mum and a dad. That is a horrible homophobic view. Children of single parent families have less desirable outcomes due to many contributory factors but not because there's only one adult to love them.

Siameasy · 08/10/2023 23:18

Choosing to be a single parent is madness. All the statistics point towards less desirable outcomes for children of single mothers. A child needs his or her Dad. Wait until you’re ready for a relationship.

MotherofaToad · 08/10/2023 23:16

Hi op, I'm a solo mum and also a primary school teacher so I can give a lot of advice since I'm in a similar situation. Save as much money now as you can. My fertility treatment was 10k and that seems to be pretty average amongst my friends. I would also recommend saving another 10k for mat leave. Nursery fees will be about 1k a month so I would start putting that away now so that you're not used to having that money.
I would also recommend saving money now so that you can pay for a cleaner/housekeeper/ gardener etc once the baby is here coz running a house and working full time as a teacher with a baby is intense. My day starts at 5.30 and I need to work once dd is in bed so I normally finish at 11.
If possible, try to move around stages as much as possible at school so that you have a bank of resources and plans for each stage which will make it easier for going back after mat leave. I'd recommend going down the school so that you have lots of resources for little kids and they can be used to when differentiating to support learners at any stage in the future.
Make sure that you have support to look after your baby for things like training sessions and parents night.
My dd is now 3 and is the best thing to have ever happened to me. Good luck!

VestaTilley · 08/10/2023 22:42

YABVU. 23 is crazily young in this day and age. Live a bit first. You change a lot between 23 and 33; leave it five years - you’ll be a much better Mum for it.

And raising a child alone on a newly qualified teacher’s salary? Madness. Have you even looked in to the cost of childcare? Do you even have savings?

AngryBirdsNoMore · 08/10/2023 22:39

It isn’t something I would do OP, but at 23 I still had a hell of a lot of growing up to do and I’ve changed a lot as a person since then. I had my first child when I was ten years older than you.

But to give you your due, you sound really mature and thoughtful and like you’ve really thought about it. My big worry for you would be finances and support network, especially on a young teacher’s salary. But I wish you all luck whatever you choose to do.

5YearsLeft · 08/10/2023 20:15

Uggtrending · 08/10/2023 19:51

@5YearsLeft I've read your post again. Sorry to hear about your health.

Everybody is entitled to their opinions. I gave mine as a mother at 23. I said OP is on a very good path. You've looked back in hindsight but I've given my actual lived experience as a mother and I was in no way pulling OP down at all if it seemed that way, I wasn't

@Uggtrending Oh, I actually wasn’t referring specifically to your comment. I was more referring to some that only say, “At 23??” Or one that just said, “You think you’ll be approved as a foster carer at 23? Yeah, that’s naïve.” (Impossible to even say that without knowing OP’s area, or anything about foster care rules and needs there). I think it’s really valuable of you to share your lived experience as a mother with OP; we’re both sharing different points of view with her and that will hopefully help her a bit. Sharing your experience is important advice, and I don’t think you condescended to OP at all.

UsingChangeofName · 08/10/2023 20:07

so I do think that some comments just being automatically dismissive of her and calling her naïve because she’s 23 are a bit unkind, yes.

I haven't called her naive because she is 23.
I have called her naive because thinking she will be able to teach, and be a foster carer. There are reasons that dc are in foster care. It needs one parent to be available in a way a teacher couldn't possibly be, for the overwhelming majority of foster children.
Plus, not wanting to be in a relationship or have your own dc at 23 is not uncommon, but most people continue to grow and change - and yes, meet different people - through their 20s and they are very different people 8 - 10 years down the line.

Uggtrending · 08/10/2023 19:51

@5YearsLeft I've read your post again. Sorry to hear about your health.

Everybody is entitled to their opinions. I gave mine as a mother at 23. I said OP is on a very good path. You've looked back in hindsight but I've given my actual lived experience as a mother and I was in no way pulling OP down at all if it seemed that way, I wasn't

5YearsLeft · 08/10/2023 19:48

Uggtrending · 08/10/2023 19:24

@5YearsLeft nobody is being unkind. But OPs take on not being sexual attracted to a man or wanting a relationship needs exploring. What has caused this? Yet she wants to Foster as a lone parent this isn't exactly the norm at 23 is it.

@Uggtrending I think when OP is already a teacher AND she wants to be a foster carer, that should be commended. So what if it’s not the norm? We need more people who aren’t the norm, if it means helping others. OP sounds like she’s trying to do this the right way (think it through carefully; ask for advice) so I do think that some comments just being automatically dismissive of her and calling her naïve because she’s 23 are a bit unkind, yes.

Also, no, OP’s sexuality does not “need” exploring. OP did not ask for advice on that. Perhaps she knows exactly why she feels the way she does, but it’s a painful or personal matter. Asking for advice, to help her see her own blind spots about whether becoming a single parent, as a teacher at 23, is feasible, does not give anyone commenting a right to “explore” or force OP to “explore” her sex life.

jannier · 08/10/2023 19:33

23 is young many are still living at home at this age. My niece didn't want children and was having bad periods so asked for a hysterectomy.....6 years later had a child.
I wouldn't rush any decision so young.

Uggtrending · 08/10/2023 19:24

@5YearsLeft nobody is being unkind. But OPs take on not being sexual attracted to a man or wanting a relationship needs exploring. What has caused this? Yet she wants to Foster as a lone parent this isn't exactly the norm at 23 is it.

JessicaBrassica · 08/10/2023 19:24

I work with a number of kids who are in foster care. All of them have non-working parent. It's the only way of fitting in all of their appointments.

I don't know how easy it is to work whilst fostering - but good teachers are hard to find. The profession would be worse off without you.

dortisa · 08/10/2023 19:23

Above comment is for you @5YearsLeft x

dortisa · 08/10/2023 19:23

I have to say this is wonderfully kind and balanced advice. I just know you’re a lovely genuine person and some of your points are food for thought for everyone

5YearsLeft · 08/10/2023 19:19

I think people saying you’re young and naïve are being unhelpful and possibly unkind. You’re doing everything right - you want something, you’ve tried to think it through logically, and you’ve come here to ask for advice from people who might have more experience than you. That’s smart at 20 or 70. The fact is simply that you can’t know what you don’t know, and that’s true at any age.

You think you’re ready at 23. I respect that. People have given you some good advice of how to make sure you’re the most ready you can possibly be (save up for a year or two, prepare for nursery costs ahead of time, etc). I have a different story to share.

At 23, like you, I wasn’t much interested in relationships.

At 25, I was married to the love of my life and probably going to have children within a few years.

By 28, a diagnosis meant I was never going to have my own biological children, and if I’d had them before this point, they could have had the disease I’d just been diagnosed with and it would have been horrific.

By 30, I realized I was never going to be able to have a child of any sort as my illness was progressing.

By 35, my body was so broken that I could no longer do a lot of things I’d taken for granted - working in an office, going out of an evening, being able to take a full breath.

By 37, I was divorced but still living with my ex because I needed the physical help. He also immediately married a woman that I thought had been my friend, and she lives with me now, but doesn’t speak to me.

By 38, I was told my diseases (since there were now two) would be life-limiting, combined.

And here at 39, almost 40, I’m dying.

My timeline is a crazy one, yes. My point is just that it is so, so impossible to know the path life will take you on. One of the benefits of raising as child with a partner, I’m afraid to say, is that if I’d had a child and then years later gotten my terminal diagnosis, I would have the comfort of knowing they’d have another parent to care for them (another reason to try your best to pick a man who won’t be a shitbag, absentee father, although there are NO guarantees).

By giving it a few extra years (to 25, or even 27), you are more likely to have run into one or more of the things you could never have predicted in your own life, and they won’t affect your child when the time is right. Maybe you find a partner. Maybe you win the lottery. Maybe it’s something less positive, unfortunately, and you lose your job. Maybe nothing changes at all, and your life continues on as is. The point is it’ll be behind you.

I would give it a few more years. Take this time to save up for the baby, and know that you’re not in a rush and you have time to see the shape your life takes.

ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 08/10/2023 18:44

I am a lone parent. Not by choice, DCs father fucked off when they were around 15 months old. A life with one parent is not one I would have willingly chosen. I feel guilt ridden and absolutely shit the older she gets. Especially when in school making fathers day cards etc. I don't think its right to do this deliberately and I certainly wouldn't given the choice. It also isn't fair for you to say you think you'd have family to rely on for childcare, I thought I did, my DC is never minded and to be honest it isn't their responsibility so I wouldn't complain. You'll also find once the ability to go out and about alone is completely gone, you'll miss it.

Poppysmom22 · 08/10/2023 18:42

You are 23 I would honestly wait a few years just potter about enjoy yourself indulge in some hobbies and generally mingle and enjoy the space of being on your own. I got married at 23 and while it's been a great marriage if you were my niece I would advise you to wait. You do alot of growing as a person in your late 20's

UsingChangeofName · 08/10/2023 18:24

You are being incredibly naïve about fostering if you think you can do that, so young. Plus, if you think you can do it whilst teaching, as a lone parent.
I doubt any fostering agencies would approve you.

Believe me, people change a lot during their 20s. What you want now and what you want when getting closer to 30 is likely to be very different.

Hankunamatata · 08/10/2023 18:21

How long have you been teaching? If its only a couple of years I'd considered working 2 more years then review

cartoontree · 08/10/2023 18:19

Also you don’t have to go straight to ivf, she did iui

cartoontree · 08/10/2023 18:18

You HAVE to go on YouTube and look up Precious Star Vlogs! She started fostering babies very young, maybe at 21 or so, and then went it alone and now has a 6 month old as a solo parent. She is asexual (not aromantic) and situation sounds almost identical to what you’re saying. Think she is around 25 now :)

Swipe left for the next trending thread