Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think right to buy scheme should be scrapped?

104 replies

MumOfTheNorth · 08/10/2023 01:02

There was a debate on LBC today about the shortage of social housing and the presenter said no party would support scrapping the right to buy scheme as it is too popular.

To me it seems mad to be selling off social housing at a discount, further depleting our national stock of social housing, despite thousands of people being on waiting lists.

I get it is a massive boost for the person you sell it to but in the long run wouldn't keeping it help more families in need?

I hope this isn't massively controversial - genuinely interested in if there is huge support for this scheme and if so why?

OP posts:
Sapphire387 · 08/10/2023 09:23

YANBU but the housing situation is much bigger than that and needs tackling as a whole.

We need rent controls for private rentals, and secure tenancies.

We need to ban second home ownership.

Buying and renting property should not be seen as a legitimate way of making money. Being a landlord is not a job.

We need to ban the purchase of property in London in particular by foreign investors under the guise of companies.

As a start.

StEtienne93 · 08/10/2023 09:23

I also agree and have been saying this for years.

Sapphire387 · 08/10/2023 09:21

FloweryName · 08/10/2023 09:12

The RTB scheme is massively unfair and I agree it should be scrapped. It should have been scrapped a long time ago.

There are many people who would benefit from social housing but have not been fortunate enough to have been granted it. Instead they have struggled to pay private rents prices leaving them unable to save and have lived with the insecurity that private renting brings. At the same time, those who were lucky enough in the first place to be allocated social housing have had lower rent to pay so had more opportunity to save. Then to add insult to injury those people are also offered a massive discount in a house and never have to pay moving costs.

It is a huge advantage in life for those who are lucky enough to benefit from it and simultaneously takes opportunity from others who needed it as much if not more. It is crazy that the government actively chooses to perpetuate this inequality.

Yes but what about those who have parents who own homes and then give them money from the bank of mum and dad for house deposits etc, and then they inherit money too? That's also perpetuating inequality, is it not?

gotomomo · 08/10/2023 09:17

For long term council tenants, buy the house they already live in makes sense because the council no longer has to maintain it IF that money is ring fenced to build replacement housing stock.

The huge gains in value are pretty regional too, the person I know bought their 3 bed council house in 1985 for £32k and sold for £98 in 2018, this is not a huge gain, they would have made more investing the money! Because a few london house owners hit the jackpot doesn't mean that's the case everywhere, especially ne England and parts of the midlands

unsync · 08/10/2023 09:16

The mechanism needs to change. The money goes to central government and it should go to the LA and be ringfenced for reinvestment into provision of social housing. They could also put a covenant in that any resale within 30 years which generates an uplift in value, the LA gets a % of the uplift.

Beezknees · 08/10/2023 09:16

NoMor · 08/10/2023 08:47

The Tories scrapped lifelong leases, they're usually 2/3 years now. I had a friend who got a HA house had to carpet it and provide all kitchen appliances. Her rent was higher than mine and I'm in a private rental with all those things included and her lease was only 2 years.

Wow really? I didn't know that, I got mine a long time ago. I do know they usually come without carpet now though!

FloweryName · 08/10/2023 09:12

The RTB scheme is massively unfair and I agree it should be scrapped. It should have been scrapped a long time ago.

There are many people who would benefit from social housing but have not been fortunate enough to have been granted it. Instead they have struggled to pay private rents prices leaving them unable to save and have lived with the insecurity that private renting brings. At the same time, those who were lucky enough in the first place to be allocated social housing have had lower rent to pay so had more opportunity to save. Then to add insult to injury those people are also offered a massive discount in a house and never have to pay moving costs.

It is a huge advantage in life for those who are lucky enough to benefit from it and simultaneously takes opportunity from others who needed it as much if not more. It is crazy that the government actively chooses to perpetuate this inequality.

Totaly · 08/10/2023 09:10

I brought on my own - ex council house done up to sell, at the time the owner had to keep the property for 3 years. I think an elderly person brought the property or her family did - and sold it to me.

I could afford this on x3 salary £35K

My friends did the same. Sold 4 years later £30K profit.

The issue isn’t council housing V rented - it’s the fact eh population is growing wildly and housing is in short supply - which drives up the cost.

Have we enough council properties
Prices would be lower and people could afford their own home.

Badbadbunny · 08/10/2023 09:09

dewclaw · 08/10/2023 09:05

Right to buy should be scrapped immediately. It was always going to cause problems and Labour should be at the forefront of ending it. A tiny minority benefit and I don't think it is the vote loser they think it is. All the major parties are avoiding tackling the woeful housing crisis we have in the U.K. and the knock on effects on people's finances, physical and mental health.

Labour had 13 years to end it and not even a squeak from them. They've got their snouts in the trough re making money from housing, so won't want to rock the boat. House prices and rentals shot up during Labour's 13 years - snouts in the trough.

wiseoldtree · 08/10/2023 09:06

It should never have been introduced in the first place and I'd vote to have it scrapped.

dewclaw · 08/10/2023 09:05

Right to buy should be scrapped immediately. It was always going to cause problems and Labour should be at the forefront of ending it. A tiny minority benefit and I don't think it is the vote loser they think it is. All the major parties are avoiding tackling the woeful housing crisis we have in the U.K. and the knock on effects on people's finances, physical and mental health.

gamerchick · 08/10/2023 09:03

If this country wasn't so obsessed with "owning your own home' as the ultimate goal there wouldn't have been a need for it. People look down on social housing and even now, when SH is the most secure affordable housing there is, above private rents and those suffering with their mortgages. People still want to look down on it.

It's weird.

BIossomtoes · 08/10/2023 08:57

Councils use the rent money to patch holes in council budgets, not on their housing stock.

They don’t. The housing account is ringfenced.

NoMor · 08/10/2023 08:56

TheYearOfSmallThings · 08/10/2023 08:26

YANBU.

And in terms of "It would be fine if the council replaced the properties sold", that is not going to be possible if they sell at a discount, which they do.

Not true. Building a house costs less than the price the buyer pays or constructions companies wouldn't build them.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 08/10/2023 08:53

It should have been scrapped years ago. Labour are very good at bewailing Thatcher’s introduction of it, but they had 13 years in which to abolish it - but didn’t.
Presumably because they thought it’d lose them votes.

Though in fact it had been going on to some extent well before Thatcher. A dd bought an ex council house which (as dh found out from a good old nose on the Land Reg) the former owners had bought from the council in 1971 - well before Thatcher.

They had paid almost exactly 1% of what dd paid.

Blackbyrd · 08/10/2023 08:52

Absolutely should be abolished. A very common situation is a older couple occupying a decent sized council house. They sit on Housing Benefit/Housing Costs Element of UC for years effectively living rent free. Then when one of them dies, the family swoop in and purchase the property under RTB before the other one also dies or goes into care. So the taxpayer gets to pay both ways. If you can't get a mortgage in your own name as a tenant then you don't get to buy. A reminder that adapted properties are exempt from RTB before anyone starts moaning on

Spare room subsidy should be extended to older tenants, and the Housing Act completely rewritten to ensure social housing goes to those who appreciate and deserve it. Because housing is needs based now, mixed estates don't exist and that can often lead to downward spirals. A massive amount of fraud is involved in obtaining social housing and this needs to be addressed, the trouble is many councils are simply incapable of managing their housing stock effectively

Badbadbunny · 08/10/2023 08:52

And there needs to be a law to prevent a right to buy house ever being used as an Air BNB or holiday let! In fact, the buyers shouldn't be allowed to even rent it out. It should be on a kind of long lease, where they live in it for their lifetime and then the council have to buy it back at market value when they die, to put back into the council rental market stock. Cut the investors out completely!

Badbadbunny · 08/10/2023 08:50

The whole premise was bonkers and it's crazy that no government has rectified the madness. The idea itself is sound, i.e. being able to buy the house you've rented for years, but the discounts were way too high, and the monies raised should have been compulsorily re-invested in replacement homes, not just languishing in council bank accounts earning paltry interest (or stupidly invested, and lost, in Icelandic dodgy banks).

FuckYouEzekiel · 08/10/2023 08:50

Emmalin · 08/10/2023 01:32

It's fine if councils build houses to replace the ones they've sold.

I think yab a bit u anyway. No one wants to be renting into retirement, even at social housing level rents. So it makes sense on an individual level for people to buy. They can have a happier and healthier old age.

And the affordable housing crisis is largely fuelled by credit oriented demand. If you want to tackle it you need to look at the bigger picture. There are entire housing developments across the country that are only available to buyers who will never live in them - they can't, because owner occupiers are excluded from purchase.

We're talking about globally positioned billionaires who are rinsing the market and rigging it for everyone. In the face of that, Barry and Kath getting a hold of a two bedroom place in a neighborhood most mumsnetters would turn their noses up at, and which they would otherwise have had lifelong occupancy of anyway regardless, is pretty small beans.

I think if i ever met you, i would really like you.

NoMor · 08/10/2023 08:47

Beezknees · 08/10/2023 07:47

Well yeah but there's a whole lot of stuff in between. Many people live in private rentals and won't get deposits from their parents either, they're the ones I feel most sorry for, at least in social housing we have lifelong housing.

The Tories scrapped lifelong leases, they're usually 2/3 years now. I had a friend who got a HA house had to carpet it and provide all kitchen appliances. Her rent was higher than mine and I'm in a private rental with all those things included and her lease was only 2 years.

CrotchetyQuaver · 08/10/2023 08:43

Yes it's time it went.
Britain today is vastly different in so many different ways to the late 70's early early 80's when RTB came in.

We need every single council house to stay available for rent and a few thousand more being built in every local authority area as well

PictureFrameWindow · 08/10/2023 08:36

Yanbu, they just get sold on for a massive profit. It should have been scrapped years ago.

piintheski · 08/10/2023 08:35

Your argument does not make any sense

Right to buy does not in any way deplete housing stock - it isn't "right to demolish" is it.

People are still living in the property after it is bought, mostly the same people, and now with a chance to improve their circumstances, and at less cost to the council, as they take over the responsibility for upkeep.

It shouldn't be possible to rent out a right to buy property as a landlord though, and the council should be using the profits to invest in further housing - that is the point

Zebedee55 · 08/10/2023 08:34

RTB would have been fine if councils had replaced the stock. That's what should be happening.

Banana1979 · 08/10/2023 08:32

Sorry for the typos!