Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think right to buy scheme should be scrapped?

104 replies

MumOfTheNorth · 08/10/2023 01:02

There was a debate on LBC today about the shortage of social housing and the presenter said no party would support scrapping the right to buy scheme as it is too popular.

To me it seems mad to be selling off social housing at a discount, further depleting our national stock of social housing, despite thousands of people being on waiting lists.

I get it is a massive boost for the person you sell it to but in the long run wouldn't keeping it help more families in need?

I hope this isn't massively controversial - genuinely interested in if there is huge support for this scheme and if so why?

OP posts:
paulaparticles · 08/10/2023 14:13

Fair enough. But it is what it is. I've a family member in a 3 bed HA house on their own after their parent passed away. Wanting to downsize for a few years now.
Before anyone jumps on and says they only need a one bed they have a health condition that requires someone to stay with them which has been proven and accepted so has been on the list for a 2 bed and been unsuccessful so far.
Even though there are lots of 2 beds in our area all new and have just been given out and they have missed out.
A 3 bed which could easily house a family of 6 and we wait still. I thought in this situation it would be straightforward but obviously not.

BIossomtoes · 08/10/2023 13:26

My problem isn’t with people who availed themselves of RTB, it’s with the entire concept and the way it’s messed up the housing market. I don’t know why you think people who bought on the open market without a subsidy shouldn’t have a view @paulaparticles.

paulaparticles · 08/10/2023 13:04

With mine I have to offer it back if selling within 5 years and they don't have to buy it back but I've no intention of doing so in that timeframe. I don't know what I'll be doing with it yet. It's a beautiful area. Small cul de sc. I agree that lots of the tenants wouldn't be moving and needing rehoused anyway. Of course everyone dies that's life. I wonder how many of you complaining own your home or is it just rtb families you have a problem with.

paulaparticles · 08/10/2023 12:57

Yes but receiving money back instead of paying rent.

BIossomtoes · 08/10/2023 12:47

A lot of those lifetime tenants will have died since 1980.

rwalker · 08/10/2023 12:10

Fully agree with right to buy realistically a lot of these homes would have the same lifetime tenants so unlikely they’d be freed up to house people

BUT when they come to sell they can only sell back to local authorities at the same discounted rate they bought at

dewclaw · 08/10/2023 12:03

Mammyloveswine · 08/10/2023 12:01

It should never have been brought in in the first place!!!

The impact has just been catastrophic on social housing!

Absolutely- ridiculous policy which has been disastrous for this country!

Mammyloveswine · 08/10/2023 12:01

It should never have been brought in in the first place!!!

The impact has just been catastrophic on social housing!

Beezknees · 08/10/2023 11:47

paulaparticles · 08/10/2023 11:21

I've just bought my home on rtb. In Northern Ireland although it's permanently over now. It was my only chance at owning a home and give my family security. It feels amazing and only completed last Friday. I get what some of you are saying but if it was any of your only opportunity to buy would you not then in my position 🙄

I am in your position and am not buying my place. There's not enough secure housing as it is, I want my home to benefit someone else struggling when I die. My DS will have the opportunity to create his own security by living at home as long as he wants until he can save enough to buy his own home, I did not have that opportunity.

paulaparticles · 08/10/2023 11:21

I've just bought my home on rtb. In Northern Ireland although it's permanently over now. It was my only chance at owning a home and give my family security. It feels amazing and only completed last Friday. I get what some of you are saying but if it was any of your only opportunity to buy would you not then in my position 🙄

Bellringers · 08/10/2023 11:05

RTB has been scrapped in practice, if not in law, for the majority. It's one of the major reasons that many councils handed over their housing stock to be managed by housing associations or set up ALMOs, as RTB doesn't apply to HA tenancies. There is no benefit to councils to lose their housing stock, they don't even receive the money for the property (it goes to central government)

MenopauseSucks · 08/10/2023 10:47

I'm against it.
As far as I know, council tenants already have assured tenancies at decent rent so don't need to buy whereas for private renters, buying a house takes them out of a precarious situation, reliant on the whims of their landlords.

It's up to the local authorities & government to build more council stock which they didn't do which is the real disgrace about right to buy.

However people are less likely to strike, etc if they have a mortgage to pay - just being cynical.

Right to buy should be removed from future council tenancies just as there was the cut off date for multiple child benefit.
It has to end sometime.

KimberleyClark · 08/10/2023 10:37

At the very least the councils should have been allowed to use the revenue from council house sales to build more houses, but that’s not what Thatcher wanted. She wanted to create more Tory voters.

BertieBotts · 08/10/2023 10:37

It could be phased out gradually so it's not a giant change. But honestly what they should really do is just replace the stock.

I think it's a good idea in general to have government contracts for housing, both building and renting. It means you can stipulate minimum standards etc while leaving the wider market open for more variety.

gamerchick · 08/10/2023 10:36

Sisiwawa · 08/10/2023 09:29

It shouldn't be automatic lifelong housing. I know people who were given 2/3 bed houses years ago to raise their families. Those kids have left home and the tenants still live there, some are subletting! Others are doing v well financially now with holiday homes abroad and still clogging up social housing here, that just isn't fair, but they're not doing anything illegal, just a bit immoral, but nobody addresses that...

Some could say it's immoral for people to buy up family homes and rent them out for 1500 quid a month. Before anyone takes a look at SH, I'd take a good look at the private rental thing first. Long and hard.

caringcarer · 08/10/2023 10:35

I have always thought social housing should be kept for people who need it not sold off cheaply.

Sapphire387 · 08/10/2023 10:31

FloweryName · 08/10/2023 09:29

Yes it is, and private individuals are at liberty to do that with their own earned and taxed money. That doesn’t mean the state should be doing the same. Parents have a responsibility towards their own children. The state has a responsibility towards everyone and shouldn’t be actively giving some people an advantage over other others, especially when there is a housing crisis.

But a lot of the money has not been earned, has it? The profit has been made through our broken housing 'market'.

The whole system is broken.

Cosycardigans · 08/10/2023 09:49

I'm in a council property and I would support the scrapping of RTB. They would have to write it into new tenancy agreements though. I live on a 'council estate' and I would say around 60 percent of the houses are owned after RTB tenants bought them years ago, so I think it's probably too late to make a real difference.

However, I would only relenquish my RTB if I knew there was something in my tenancy that meant my daughter would have right to rent the property should something awful happen to me. I'm a single mum and she's got no-one else and I wouldn't want her thrown into the awful world of private renting in her late teens/twenties with no family to fall back on. That's my main incentive for one day wanting to use my RTB- to give her security in this crazy housing crisis. I think the right to inherit a tenancy should be means tested though. Not just automatically kick a grown child with no ability to buy somewhere, out of a property to give it to someone else who is in the same situation as the deceased tenant's family. That makes no sense to me- the person being kicked out, is in just as much need as the new person being given the home. I don't see RTB as being the main issue in the housing situation but something people jump on, driven by all the other issues in the housing market. It all needs reworking to be fair for all.

itsgoingtobeabumpyride · 08/10/2023 09:40

I bought my council house on the RTB 25 years ago, I paid £28.5k, 2 bed, the mortgage was cheaper than my rent, for me the RTB scheme was my only chance of home ownership as a single working parent who could never have afforded to buy a house otherwise.
I never gave a thought to the repercussions of the scheme, the lack of social housing it would cause, for me it was an opportunity and I grabbed it with both hands.
I recently sold for £200k more than I paid for it but in my defense my new house is also an ex council that was bought by the previous owner on the RTB.
On my estate there's probably more bought houses than council owned.
The plus side of this is the estate has become a nicer place to live.
Before anyone jumps on me, when I moved here 30 yrs ago our estate was practically a no-go area, taxi drivers didn't come onto the estate, buses wouldn't come up here, gangs roamed freely causing mayhem, police were attacked if they came onto the estate (I once saw a policewoman being chased by a knife wielding youth), cars set on fire, burglaries (stealing from people who didn't have anything to begin with), targeting families who didn't fit in with violence and smashing their windows.
As people bought houses and took care of them the trouble families became the minority.
Now, even though I benefited from the scheme, I do think it needs an overhaul, young families don't stand a chance.
When I first went on the waiting list I waited three weeks for a property, unheard of now.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 08/10/2023 09:31

NoMor · 08/10/2023 08:56

Not true. Building a house costs less than the price the buyer pays or constructions companies wouldn't build them.

But the council would be selling at a 30-55% discount (including on land value, which makes up a huge proportion), and then acquiring or using land at 100%. No construction company would do that in any area with high land value (where most demand is), and no ability to set price.

quickqpls · 08/10/2023 09:31

A significant proportion of RTB's are now being rented out with full or partial housing benefit paying the rent. So the house that was built to support those in need, is being lived in by those in need but instead of the reduced rent burden, the state now contributes the inflated rent and effectively pays the mortgage on a property that it once owned. It's crazy!

Sisiwawa · 08/10/2023 09:29

It shouldn't be automatic lifelong housing. I know people who were given 2/3 bed houses years ago to raise their families. Those kids have left home and the tenants still live there, some are subletting! Others are doing v well financially now with holiday homes abroad and still clogging up social housing here, that just isn't fair, but they're not doing anything illegal, just a bit immoral, but nobody addresses that...

FloweryName · 08/10/2023 09:29

Sapphire387 · 08/10/2023 09:21

Yes but what about those who have parents who own homes and then give them money from the bank of mum and dad for house deposits etc, and then they inherit money too? That's also perpetuating inequality, is it not?

Yes it is, and private individuals are at liberty to do that with their own earned and taxed money. That doesn’t mean the state should be doing the same. Parents have a responsibility towards their own children. The state has a responsibility towards everyone and shouldn’t be actively giving some people an advantage over other others, especially when there is a housing crisis.

ActDottie · 08/10/2023 09:25

I agree.

The tenants get a life tenancy so a home for life. With the shortage of social housing it seems mad that government are still selling those houses off.

Soontobe60 · 08/10/2023 09:23

The thing is, if the scheme didn’t exist social housing capacity wouldn’t increase because the tenants who no longer had the right to buy would just stay there.
People forget that as a tenant you may be able to receive greater benefits if needed, such as money towards rent, but as owners you don’t get help towards mortgage payments.
What should have happened is that councils who have benefitted from this scheme in monetary terms should have had systems in place whereby all profits from the Right to Buy scheme should have been ringfenced into a fund that pays for new social housing.