Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think right to buy scheme should be scrapped?

104 replies

MumOfTheNorth · 08/10/2023 01:02

There was a debate on LBC today about the shortage of social housing and the presenter said no party would support scrapping the right to buy scheme as it is too popular.

To me it seems mad to be selling off social housing at a discount, further depleting our national stock of social housing, despite thousands of people being on waiting lists.

I get it is a massive boost for the person you sell it to but in the long run wouldn't keeping it help more families in need?

I hope this isn't massively controversial - genuinely interested in if there is huge support for this scheme and if so why?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BIossomtoes · 08/10/2023 17:40

It’s too late. If it was scrapped tomorrow it would make no difference. The damage is irreparably done.

Butterkist8 · 08/10/2023 16:48

It needs to be scrapped now.

So many of these former council properties ended up being bought by private sector businesses that flourished and became vast Housing Associations whereby they'd spend as little as possible on refurbs and maintenance but claim vast amounts of housing benefits on behalf of tenants.

It's interesting to note that so many of these Housing Associations have so many properties in previous council estates.

Topsyturveymam · 08/10/2023 16:09

I can understand Council tenants not wanting to let go of Right to buy. However I don’t think it’s fair given that a fifth of people in council accommodation earn above minimum wage.
https://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/news/article-2097557/amp/Thousands-tenants-live-council-houses-earn-100-000.html

It would be great to have a better, wider scheme for helping ALL people on a lower wage get on the housing ladder.

The six-figure council house tenants: 6,000 who earn more than £100,000 can stay in home 'if they pay market rent'

There are 15,000 tenants in social housing even though they have household incomes of more than £80,000 – with 6,000 earning more than £100,000.

https://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/news/article-2097557/amp/Thousands-tenants-live-council-houses-earn-100-000.html

IsGoodIsDon · 08/10/2023 16:06

I agree that it’s crazy that such profits have been made on social housing.
I feel that the policy could be tweaked a bit and once the house is sold on again or inverted then a percentage of the profits needs to go back to the council to pay for more social housing. It still benefits the person who had right to buy and also the council will gain from the increase value of the property as well.

PumpkiPie · 08/10/2023 16:01

BoobyDazzler · 08/10/2023 15:57

Their house was repossessed during the 90’s recession and we spend 3 years in temporary housing.

So they got a 3 bed to meet the needs of the family at the time then, as should other families. Nothing to do with "people having more kids then they can house". Perhaps they were like your parents, could afford/house them when they had them but life circumstances changed and they found themselves needing a 3 bed council house.

PumpkiPie · 08/10/2023 15:58

gamerchick · 08/10/2023 15:56

Excellent. I'm assuming you'll be happy to give up your council property as soon as you have a spare bedroom?

That's the spirit.

I don't have a council house 🤷🏼‍♀️ Nor a spare bedroom

BoobyDazzler · 08/10/2023 15:57

PumpkiPie · 08/10/2023 15:43

So how did your parents end up in a 3 bed?

Their house was repossessed during the 90’s recession and we spend 3 years in temporary housing.

gamerchick · 08/10/2023 15:56

PumpkiPie · 08/10/2023 15:41

To make way for people who need those extra bedrooms that are currently sitting empty because their kids have grown up and left home. It's just logic, nothing to do with being inferior.

Excellent. I'm assuming you'll be happy to give up your council property as soon as you have a spare bedroom?

That's the spirit.

Tribevibes · 08/10/2023 15:55

There’s no way I would downsize into a shitty 1 bed flat with no garden. I lived in a flat for 10 years overcrowded. Did my time. This is why they introduced the bedroom tax but I don’t pay that anyway because I pay full rent so it’s not applicable to me.

Nat6999 · 08/10/2023 15:45

Sheffield City Council have got loads of land that used to have schools on it before they were demolished, that would be perfect for housing & have planning permission included. Some sites have been up for sale for over 10 years, if they were given the money to build, xthey could build at least 3000 homes.

2chocolateoranges · 08/10/2023 15:44

Should never have been allowed in the first place.

mil bought her 3 bed house for 27k and sold for 140k
sil bought her 3 bed house for 24k and sold it for 98k

its bloody ridiculous that council houses were allowed to be sold when there are so many people desperate for social housing which is in dire straits.

PumpkiPie · 08/10/2023 15:43

BoobyDazzler · 08/10/2023 15:39

My parents live in a 3 bed social housing property, they’ve both recently retired and have always paid their own rent. They have an office,
a craft room as well as their bedroom. Why should they be expected to move for someone who’s chosen to have more children that they can house?

Edited

So how did your parents end up in a 3 bed?

PumpkiPie · 08/10/2023 15:41

BIossomtoes · 08/10/2023 15:35

Building more would make a massive difference. Just replacing all the stock that’s been sold off. Why should social housing tenants be forced to downsize as if they’re in some way inferior?

To make way for people who need those extra bedrooms that are currently sitting empty because their kids have grown up and left home. It's just logic, nothing to do with being inferior.

BoobyDazzler · 08/10/2023 15:39

My parents live in a 3 bed social housing property, they’ve both recently retired and have always paid their own rent. They have an office,
a craft room as well as their bedroom. Why should they be expected to move for someone who’s chosen to have more children that they can house?

BIossomtoes · 08/10/2023 15:35

Building more would make a massive difference. Just replacing all the stock that’s been sold off. Why should social housing tenants be forced to downsize as if they’re in some way inferior?

PumpkiPie · 08/10/2023 15:27

It's the lifetime tenancy that screws things up for current families. So many people in 3 bed houses when their kids have long left home, but there's no 1 beds available, or if there were they wouldn't want to downsize anyway. Meanwhile families with young children can't get into 3 bed housing so are stuck overcrowded. It's not a case of building more, you could be just building forever, it needs a bloody good reshuffle.

Thelnebriati · 08/10/2023 15:22

I'm a HA tenant and I'd ban it. The only people I know who used right to buy sold as soon as they could to local landlords.

Tribevibes · 08/10/2023 15:17

Fuck buying my council house. My “mortgage” would be double my rent even with the discount. I would also have to pay for repairs. Makes no sense to my quality of life at all.

BoobyDazzler · 08/10/2023 15:16

Yes I would ban it.

However - I would also buy my house if I lived in a council house and could benefit from it. Who wouldn’t?

,

NoMor · 08/10/2023 15:09

TheYearOfSmallThings · 08/10/2023 09:31

But the council would be selling at a 30-55% discount (including on land value, which makes up a huge proportion), and then acquiring or using land at 100%. No construction company would do that in any area with high land value (where most demand is), and no ability to set price.

That's discount on the value on the open market, not the actual building or land cost. Councils own a lot of land, they often sell it to developers they should build on it themselves. Do they also have the option of compulsory purchase...? There is also a lot of building going on on low value green belt land, why can't the council build rather than private for profit companies?

You're also forgetting that you have to have rented a council house for at least 3 years to earn the right to buy, with social housing now costing as much or sometimes more than private rents, they also have that income to cover building costs.

Daphnis156 · 08/10/2023 14:39

It is too late. It has been in place about 40 years and all those houses and flats will never be replaced, some are now privately rented.
One of Thatcher's many ill thought out legacies.

paulaparticles · 08/10/2023 14:34

It's permanently finished in Northern Ireland for HA. HE tenants can still buy but that too will be stopping at some stage. I accept your points but it was the only way for us to get on the ladder and I know how lucky I am and im very grateful for the opportunity. Now im not stuck paying rent forever and even mentally that has benefited me.

BIossomtoes · 08/10/2023 14:32

PTSDBarbiegirl · 08/10/2023 14:21

Yes, it's subsidised for a reason so to profit from that seems askew. Others pay for the subsidy through tax presumably. I wish the scheme had never started. It's caused misery for many as good quality housing stock was sold off and not replaced. Where I live the ex council stock is so extremely desirable as part of the first cohort of buildings and they are gorgeous, probably 200k more expensive than the new private builds.

It’s the same where I live. Huge plots with mature trees. They’re snapped up the moment they’re put on the market.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 08/10/2023 14:21

Yes, it's subsidised for a reason so to profit from that seems askew. Others pay for the subsidy through tax presumably. I wish the scheme had never started. It's caused misery for many as good quality housing stock was sold off and not replaced. Where I live the ex council stock is so extremely desirable as part of the first cohort of buildings and they are gorgeous, probably 200k more expensive than the new private builds.

Birch101 · 08/10/2023 14:16

Honestly RTB was stupid and one reason I will never vote for Tories, if a party pledge to stop that I would vote for them.