Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Splitting the bill equally or paying for what you’ve ordered?

252 replies

Mamatolittleboy · 07/10/2023 23:10

Would you agree on splitting the bill equally or do you ask to just pay for what you’ve ordered?

Went out for dinner as a group of 3 couples last night. One couple had lots of wine, expensive steaks etc. When bill arrived they worked our bill / 3 couples so equal shares. Myself and DH paid because we felt a bit awkward saying anything at the table as didn’t want to look petty. However, in the car mentioned to each other we would have got a couple of extra drinks each plus sides for the money we paid on top of what we ordered.

We have a big meal out for a friends milestone birthday soon where there are probably 18-20 people. We know some of these friends will be drinking many alcoholic beverages and enjoying more expensive meals (absolutely fine of course) however are now wondering what we should do bill wise.

Not sure if this matters but I’m currently on SMP so our income has almost halved.

Would we be unreasonable to ask to pay for what we have ordered to save us money or is that petty? Thinking about mentioning it once the bill arrives makes me feel embarrassed however DH thinks we should tell them we can’t afford more than what we’ve ordered.

OP posts:
mondaytosunday · 08/10/2023 14:34

Ask fir drinks to be calculated separately. My friend err on the side of generosity so never had this issue. If one like her wine she makes sure she pays for more (more than she drinks even). I'm usually the one calculating what people owe and the tip and i try to be as fair as possible in terms of people who only ordered two courses vs three etc, without being so specific as to seem obnoxious about it.

InMySpareTime · 08/10/2023 14:32

It doesn't "all even out in the end", the vegetarian teetotaller won't become the steak 'n lobster eating quaffer.
People who expect others to subsidise their expensive choices will not suddenly become happy to stick to a starter and water while others eat three courses with wine.
It's a fallacy spouted by takers and CFs so they can continue their gravy train.

skyeisthelimit · 08/10/2023 14:29

YANBU. I always pay for my own after being caught out too many times. I would have 2 courses and no alcohol and end up paying £20 more than I actually ate.

When I became a single parent I really had to watch my money, so would just make it clear that I would pay for my own then they could split the difference. After they had all paid, I would add a tip (otherwise my tip got knocked off what they owed!).

you find that the people who usually want to split are the ones who have the most money, or eat/drink the most.

Yes it can be easier to just split it, but its not fair if its not equal ish consumption.

purser25 · 08/10/2023 14:13

I can remember as a teenager with not much money going out for a group meal .one person would always order all the expensive things then the expensive coffees etc. They would always say split the bill. So they got a subsidised meal and those who were hard up paid a lot more. At times going out with people from work some would be ordering loads of extra’s expensive meals loads of wine etc. if I had split I would have paid about twice the cost of the meal. I made an excuse I had to leave early so paid the waitress direct for my drinks. Then left the cost of my meal rounded to the nearest pound then a tip and left and got the bus. Didn’t feel guilty as I had been caught before.

QueenBitch666 · 08/10/2023 13:42

Separate bill here. Just advise whoever takes your order. Perfectly acceptable

Comefromaway · 08/10/2023 13:40

I’ve never seen a menu in the U.K. that doesn’t include VAT either.

snd I can use my banking app to request a payment from a friend

Hufflepods · 08/10/2023 13:34

@partypant It's not always on the menu

Do you actually eat out?

I would say I eat out 2-5 times a week and I’ve never once seen a menu in the uk that was exclusive of vat.

Hufflepods · 08/10/2023 13:33

@RampantIvy I don't understand why you need an app to work out the cost of your meal. All phones have a calculator on them.

The apps being talked about are not calculators though, they are for making split payments easier. You can automatically send a request for half the amount of your taxi for example to your friend with just their phone number and it takes them 2 seconds to pay it vs setting up a standard payment via online banking.

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 08/10/2023 13:32

If it was similar amounts I would split but I tend to order one course, no sides and don’t have more than 1-2 alcoholic drinks so don’t want to subsidise others unless birthday/celebration. I don’t mind having the money conversation although some of my friends do but I don’t see the problem talking about money. It’s not a dirty secret.

partypant · 08/10/2023 13:32

Hufflepods · 08/10/2023 13:30

@partypant that's good. So often people pay just the menu price 'oh I just had pizza so here is my £15. But they should be adding 30-35% to take into account vat and service so £20-25 not £15.

I’ve never once seen a menu in the uk that is exclusive of vat, in fact I’m pretty sure it’s not allowed.
It would not be £15 + 35% it would be £15 + 12.5/15% service at most.

It's not always on the menu

Splitting the bill equally or paying for what you’ve ordered?
Hufflepods · 08/10/2023 13:30

@partypant that's good. So often people pay just the menu price 'oh I just had pizza so here is my £15. But they should be adding 30-35% to take into account vat and service so £20-25 not £15.

I’ve never once seen a menu in the uk that is exclusive of vat, in fact I’m pretty sure it’s not allowed.
It would not be £15 + 35% it would be £15 + 12.5/15% service at most.

Hufflepods · 08/10/2023 13:27

For the most part we just split equally unless someone has noticeably had less or whatever.
But we socialise regularly and our friends are all as generous as us so it balances out and no one feels taken advantage of. If we’ve had slightly more for dinner one time we will cover the coffees and pastries the next day, friends are similar.

Clarich007 · 08/10/2023 13:25

Like another poster, I just take plenty of cash, tot up while I am ordering.At the end of the meal, I just pass over the cash plus tip .It's easy, fair and no hard feelings.
It works for me anyway.

Un7breakable · 08/10/2023 13:20

You just need to tell your server at the start you need a separate bill. The problem comes when people leave it till paying to say this.

ClaraBourne · 08/10/2023 13:19

Could you check with restaurant if they can do an individual bill ?

I'll never forget much first meal out with a group, watching the pennies and being really careful about what I ordered. Hadn't really ever eaten out much so had no idea about one bill.

So shocked at having to subsidise everybody else's expensive choices!

I'm sure these days there are Apps that deal with these instances.

partypant · 08/10/2023 13:07

@RampantIvy that's good. So often people pay just the menu price 'oh I just had pizza so here is my £15. But they should be adding 30-35% to take into account vat and service so £20-25 not £15.

poetryandwine · 08/10/2023 13:06

NImumconfused · 08/10/2023 11:46

This is the killer - we had a work Christmas meal (about 20 of us) a few years back where multiple people left early and handed over the money to cover their share before the bill came.

When the bill arrived and everyone who was left put in what they thought covered their share, we were several hundred pounds short of the total bill. I suspect quite a few people who left early put in the £30 quid or whatever for the fixed menu price, but ignored drinks and supplements for steak etc.

This.

When I am not usually one of the bigger spenders, I generally thank my lucky stars that I am in a position to go along with the crowd’s decision. On the rare occasions when I am, I usually suggest that those of us who have had something extra add in extra. If my main was £10 more than the others I will suggest taking £10 off (for me to pay) before sharing out the bill. Usually other spenders will step up.

And I am happy to occasionally sub those who are struggling. But too often I’ve found that those who are are adamant about only paying for their own food leave out a substantial amount of shared food and seem averse to tipping. Of course anyone has the right to refrain from tipping but in our local establishments these people are coasting on the known generosity of others in the group. And they know it.

RampantIvy · 08/10/2023 13:05

partypant · 08/10/2023 13:02

Just make sure that of you only pay for what you have, you add on service and VAT. So many people say they are only paying for what they have and then pay just the menu price which means their tax and service is covered by everyone else

None of the people I have eaten out with have done that. We have always added on a tip if there is no service charge. Last time I ate out in a group the waiter took each of our payments separately and we waited to make sure it all added up (plus tip) before we left. Everyone, including the waiter, was happy.

partypant · 08/10/2023 13:04

@NImumconfused This is the killer - we had a work Christmas meal (about 20 of us) a few years back where multiple people left early and handed over the money to cover their share before the bill came.

When the bill arrived and everyone who was left put in what they thought covered their share, we were several hundred pounds short of the total bill. I suspect quite a few people who left early put in the £30 quid or whatever for the fixed menu price, but ignored drinks and supplements for steak etc

VAT & service. People always just pay the menu price and negate ti add their portion of tax and service charge

partypant · 08/10/2023 13:02

Just make sure that of you only pay for what you have, you add on service and VAT. So many people say they are only paying for what they have and then pay just the menu price which means their tax and service is covered by everyone else

ToadOnTheHill · 08/10/2023 13:00

The right etiquette as far as I'm concerned is either -

If I order a lot more e.gm bill will be 70% mine, I offer to pay for both.

If its nearer 60/40 (and I have ordered more) when the bill comes I ask to pay seperately.

Friends who do rounds never let the soft drinkers pay as theres usually only 1 or 2 in a group of 10 and often he soft drinker will drive some people home.

That's how my friends do it.

MilesAndMilesOfLights · 08/10/2023 12:51

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ArtAndMusic · 08/10/2023 12:34

With friends, we just split the bill equally. We go out regularly and it all evens out in the end. If that's not the case for you, just ask to pay separately for your own.

NImumconfused · 08/10/2023 11:46

LovelyMMOG · 08/10/2023 11:10

Either is fine, just make sure everyone knows what’s what from the off. Would also really urge people who keep a mental note of what their meal costs to try to do this accurately- there’s always someone who has to leave early and sticks in £20 thinking that covers their meal, forgetting they’ve also had bread and bottled water and service etc etc.

This is the killer - we had a work Christmas meal (about 20 of us) a few years back where multiple people left early and handed over the money to cover their share before the bill came.

When the bill arrived and everyone who was left put in what they thought covered their share, we were several hundred pounds short of the total bill. I suspect quite a few people who left early put in the £30 quid or whatever for the fixed menu price, but ignored drinks and supplements for steak etc.

Comefromaway · 08/10/2023 11:40

But surely you just transfer straight into your friend’s account.

that’s what my kids & their friends do (age range 18-23)

Swipe left for the next trending thread