Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Yitzhak Rabin assassination - do you remember / know?

34 replies

Huwipulotu · 07/10/2023 21:42

In 1995 Yitzhak Rabin - the Israeli prime minister - was assassinated by an Israeli terrorist - Yigal Amir - who was opposed to the monumental peace efforts that Rabin had made with the Palestinians. He had worked with Arafat to sign the Oslo peace accords.

Rabin was an inspirational Israeli who risked so much (and paid the ultimate price) to find a peaceful solution only to be killed by an Israeli terrorist.

most of the Palestinian people want peace, most of the Israelis want peace, but in BOTH sides there are violent men who are only focused on the destruction of the other side.

The terrorist acts or not just from one side.

OP posts:
Meshigenus · 08/10/2023 14:51

Believeitornot · 07/10/2023 23:02

The “creation” of the Isreal state was an absolute bin fire and done from a colonial mindset. Ie “we can take this bit of land and the people already living there are irrelevant”.

But the current population aren’t to blame for that.

There is no way really to undo what was done back then, but blowing each other to shit and oppressing a population really isn’t the answer either.

I think this will drag on for decades to come.

No it wasn't. Not at all.

My own family, who moved to Palestine in the middle of the 19th century during Ottoman rule, were ethnically cleansed from Hebron.

How is taht colonial? Do tell....

Before the creation of the State of Israel, under Ottoman and British rule, all land was legally purchased from the landowners. They couldn't be colonial since they were living under someone else's Empires. It makes absolutely no sense. To have a colony, you have to exert control.

When the British were leaving when there was a nasty civil war and then after the establishment of the State of Israel during the war, yes, there was the nakba and massive displacement. That's a tragedy for the Palestinian people. But it's still not colonialism.

I think you need to read up on what colonialism is and isn't. It's a word bandied about to sound cool but is meaningless int he context of pre-1967 Israel.

Meshigenus · 08/10/2023 14:43

BlippiIsAnnoying · 07/10/2023 22:44

Israel was created to divert European guilt for its antisemitism and role in the Holocaust. The just thing to do would be to create a Palestinian state in the birthplace of Arthur Balfour, author of the Balfour Declaration or in Germany.

Wrong. The State of Israel was created by the Israelis. What Europeans "created" Israel? Perhaps you mean that winning the vote for partition in the UN in 1947 was due to guilt? Or maybe, jsut perhaps, an understanding that Jews needed their own national home after being left at the mercy of the world to endure the horrors of the holocaust (the British even turned desperate refugees away from Palestine).

But why the UN vote result was as it was is a moot point since anyway the arabs didn't accept partition of Palestine with a state for Jews and a state for them. They wanted it all and to throw the Jews into the sea (their words, not mine). When the State of Israel was declared after the British left (and they really did just up and leave) by....the now Israelis, not the British....five Arab countries immediately invaded (Iraq, Lebanon, jordan, Egypt and Syria). And they lost. Hence the State of Israel remained.

BlippiIsAnnoying · 08/10/2023 14:17

LuluBlakey1 · 07/10/2023 22:55

Not sure you can possibly be serious. Balfour was born in Scotland. The Palestinians would not want a homeland state in Scotland or Germany- it would have no religious or cultural significance at all.

I know, but there seems no way out of this mess.

Believeitornot · 07/10/2023 23:02

The “creation” of the Isreal state was an absolute bin fire and done from a colonial mindset. Ie “we can take this bit of land and the people already living there are irrelevant”.

But the current population aren’t to blame for that.

There is no way really to undo what was done back then, but blowing each other to shit and oppressing a population really isn’t the answer either.

I think this will drag on for decades to come.

LuluBlakey1 · 07/10/2023 22:55

BlippiIsAnnoying · 07/10/2023 22:44

Israel was created to divert European guilt for its antisemitism and role in the Holocaust. The just thing to do would be to create a Palestinian state in the birthplace of Arthur Balfour, author of the Balfour Declaration or in Germany.

Not sure you can possibly be serious. Balfour was born in Scotland. The Palestinians would not want a homeland state in Scotland or Germany- it would have no religious or cultural significance at all.

BlippiIsAnnoying · 07/10/2023 22:44

Israel was created to divert European guilt for its antisemitism and role in the Holocaust. The just thing to do would be to create a Palestinian state in the birthplace of Arthur Balfour, author of the Balfour Declaration or in Germany.

Huwipulotu · 07/10/2023 22:28

i did t mention Hamas. I just pointed out that Rabin was murdered by an Israeli who didn’t want any form of peace with Palestinians.

there is very deep hatred on both sides. That needs to be recognised

and the Oslo accords were never put in place so not sure why Israelis feel they have lost out. The land grab from Palestinians has continued unabated since the Reagan era.

OP posts:
Spambod · 07/10/2023 22:13

People not pope, didn’t mean to bring the pope into it all fgs

Spambod · 07/10/2023 22:12

It’s not as simple or black and white as this op. Hamas have stated their aim to destroy Israel, no negotiations, no compromise. There has never been a peace initiative from hamas. Hamas run Gaza, they are the government. They treat the pope, like shit and use the money from aid to line their own pockets. Money that is supposed to go to build schools and hospitals etc for the people. Is it really in hamas interests to have peace. The top brass of hamas will lose an awful lot of power and money if there is peace. Gaza relies heavily on israel, many Palestinians live and work in Israel.
considering these current events many Israelis may be thinking that the Oslo accords were a mistake and allowed hamas to flourish. Apparently Arafat was a politician of a small poor state yet died a billionaire. What does that tell you.