Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Giving wine as a teacher gift?

217 replies

LoveRules · 07/10/2023 20:49

AIBU to think my DD (20) is right in her suggesting that to give wine or any alcohol as a thank you gift to someone you don't know very well eg teacher or colleague is irresponsible and inappropriate as they might be, unbeknownst to you, an alcoholic

My DP says this is ridiculous and any grown up including alcoholics would be able to cope with such a gift by passing it on etc. and should allowed to make their own decisions about their drinking as they manage to walk past booze in the supermarket every day if they are recovering alcoholics. So the odd gift of a bottle from one or several students or colleagues is acceptable.

AIBU in thinking he's not quite understood the challenges faced by recovering alcoholics

or

IAMBU he's right it's all totally fine?

OP posts:
Millybob · 08/10/2023 17:36

If I were a teacher, I would hate to think that anyone was giving a £10 gift to me this much headspace.
Just a thought - do the dads get this overwrought about teacher gifts?
Surely a card and 'Thanks for all you've done this term' is sufficient.

viques · 08/10/2023 17:01

My former colleague Cassim who was a beard wearing Muslim used to pass on the wine, and the aftershave! He laughed about it, but I thought it showed a lack of consideration.

ArtAndMusic · 08/10/2023 16:57

MumW · 08/10/2023 15:17

My daughters have always made cakes.
We did try and find out if there were any dietary requirements so they have had to learn to make both gluten free and vegan cakes along the way.

All the teachers I know feed homemade stuff to the birds/foxes. They've seen too many kids with poor hygiene. 😅

ArtAndMusic · 08/10/2023 16:46

It's a gesture. The person can pass it on or throw it away if they don't like it.

Lots of things could be contentious.

caringcarer · 08/10/2023 16:45

MasterBeth · 08/10/2023 16:41

Amazon is a pretty toxic business.

If they don't want the voucher they can pass it on. They have lots of choice and in schools I've taught in they have always been well received as they can be put towards a bigger gift.

MasterBeth · 08/10/2023 16:41

caringcarer · 08/10/2023 16:17

If your DC's teacher is Muslim they won't drink the wine. I always gift an Amazon voucher. Simply because they have so much choice. I was a teacher for almost 25 years and tbh I got gifted 3 or 4 bottles of wine every year. Most of it went in gravy but I did get a few decent to drink bottles. I just smiled and accepted them graciously especially because the students had often bought it themselves so Hardy's. I did get an amazing cheese platter once though.

Amazon is a pretty toxic business.

DIYandEatCake · 08/10/2023 16:41

I’m a teacher who can’t drink alcohol for health reasons and just politely thank people for bottles of wine which then get passed on to friends/relatives. As a result I’m very careful with gifts for my kids’ teachers - I never gift wine myself, or chocolate for that matter in case they’re dairy-free/dieting (except where my kids have told me their teachers love chocolate). A card with a thoughtful note of thanks is honestly the best gift, and apart from that ask my kids for suggestions of what they think their teacher would like (they’ve come up with some really thoughtful things).

Mamasharp97 · 08/10/2023 16:27

I feel so saddened by the amount of people talking about ‘they will NEED wine to cope with my child!’

alcoholism within teaching is an absolutely huge issue. I know so many teachers who can’t get through their evening marking without a bottle of wine, or the amount who say ‘once I’ve had a bottle of wine I’ll feel better!’ or are just living for the weekend/that Friday night. It’s so saddening that we feel that numbing out is a satisfying form of living. It is so normal to drink 10 units (bottle of wine) a night or more.

it also gives the message to our children that people who work hard drink more, or when we have had difficult times alcohol is a solution, or that our children are so challenging, difficult to deal with, so unenjoyable to be around that their adults need to drink to deal with them. Mummy wine culture really needs to change xx

DrCoconut · 08/10/2023 16:26

Costa is poor with allergies too. Almost everything is cross contaminated. That said, I don't drink wine so I'd just regift it if I got some. I've only ever received a gift from students once (it was wine and chocolate).

RabbitsRock · 08/10/2023 16:24

When DD was in primary school, she had a really great male teacher & I wanted to get him something extra nice to say thank you for being so supportive of all of us. I asked the TA if the teacher drank & she said he did so I got some locally brewed beer & he was chuffed to bits with it.

caringcarer · 08/10/2023 16:17

If your DC's teacher is Muslim they won't drink the wine. I always gift an Amazon voucher. Simply because they have so much choice. I was a teacher for almost 25 years and tbh I got gifted 3 or 4 bottles of wine every year. Most of it went in gravy but I did get a few decent to drink bottles. I just smiled and accepted them graciously especially because the students had often bought it themselves so Hardy's. I did get an amazing cheese platter once though.

ShowOfHands · 08/10/2023 16:17

I'm a teetotal teacher and find wine so disappointing. Luckily, my students tend to ask what I like before buying - very much appreciated - gifts.

I like a card/note best tbh.

Mamasharp97 · 08/10/2023 16:13

GiraffeLaSophie · 08/10/2023 08:47

I am talking about people I know. You seemed to be implying that we shouldn’t buy alcohol for anyone, regardless of whether or not they’re an alcoholic.

Well if you mean ignorant in the sense of not knowing much about alcoholism then yes, I suppose I am. None of my family members or close friends are alcoholics, and it’s not something I am required to have knowledge about for my job. I have made it quite clear in that post that this was my assumption though, it’s not like I’m claiming a fact.

You have missed out quite a large chunk of my post to make your point though. So maybe it wasn’t a great point.

Even for moderate drinkers, the safe amount to drink to not increase risk of cancer is half a pint / one small wine a year.
As well as that, alcohol is a grade 1 carcinogen and causes cancer at the same level as cigarettes, whether you are a social drinker (aka same amount as a social smoker) moderate drinker, or daily drinker.

I personally think that alone makes alcohol as a gift rubbish, whether the person is alcoholic or not.

And it’s up to you to assume whether you know how much someone drinks in the privacy of their own home, and if you want to encourage and promote drinking / having bottles of alcohol at home as a normality. I personally wouldn’t take the risk, because what I see and know about someone from a distance, especially an acquaintance like a teacher, may be completely different to their actual situation.

Mamasharp97 · 08/10/2023 16:04

We don’t have that at my school!

Mamasharp97 · 08/10/2023 16:03

As a sober alcoholic it totally depends on the person! Ive been gifted alcohol and passed it on without worry, but have also been gifted alcohol and been upset because it was expensive and they’d spent money on it and I felt guilty that I had to give it to someone else. Never been enough for me to relapse but still caused some emotional issues around it with guilt and shame.

It’s safer not to buy them alcohol if you’ve never spoken to them about if they drink etc. if they are an active alcoholic, and unaware they have a problem, then you buying them alcohol doesn’t make /much/ of a difference because they’ve made no decision to stop and would drink anyway. That said, since getting sober I’ve stopped buying all alcoholic gifts because it’s a poison and literally the worst thing to get some imo! You’re basically gifting them a headache and dehydration 😂

squashi · 08/10/2023 16:01

Alcohol's an odd gift if you don't know whether the person drinks or not. Bit of a waste of money, potentially.

ChamaChamaChamaChameleon · 08/10/2023 16:01

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2023 15:06

As I think this thread illustrates perfectly, no matter what you give, somebody, somewhere will be able to pick holes in it. So do what you want. You can't please all of the people all of the time.

Exactly. This attitude is why I just don't give things anymore...

MasterBeth · 08/10/2023 15:57

cardibach · 08/10/2023 15:23

It’s not being precious to dislike things. I do like coffee and cake, and I’m not fussy about my sarnies either. I only really go into Costa at service stations when travelling though. They just aren’t my favourite - and as I get coffee and cake out as a bit of a treat I’m inclined to go somewhere with a nice atmosphere and a bit of style. The fact the voucher made it a freebie would be a bit irrelevant.
Plus several posters have explained ethical objections they have to Costa (you not sharing those doesn’t make them less valid to those posters).

It's being precious to reject a Costa gift card because Costa coffee isn't your favourite coffee.

You've just said "I only really go into Costa at service stations when travelling". So why not use the card then?

crazyBadger · 08/10/2023 15:27

DD teacher makes things easier by saying to the boys she likes cards or drawings the best.... followed by pink wine :)

cardibach · 08/10/2023 15:25

MumW · 08/10/2023 15:17

My daughters have always made cakes.
We did try and find out if there were any dietary requirements so they have had to learn to make both gluten free and vegan cakes along the way.

Many teachers would be unlikely to eat a homemade gift as there’s no way of knowing the hygiene levels involved (I’m not one of them, I love a home made cake, but it’s still a factor).

cardibach · 08/10/2023 15:23

MasterBeth · 08/10/2023 14:59

Apologies. I forgot how precious Mumsnetters can be about perfectly normal things like sandwiches and drinks.

It’s not being precious to dislike things. I do like coffee and cake, and I’m not fussy about my sarnies either. I only really go into Costa at service stations when travelling though. They just aren’t my favourite - and as I get coffee and cake out as a bit of a treat I’m inclined to go somewhere with a nice atmosphere and a bit of style. The fact the voucher made it a freebie would be a bit irrelevant.
Plus several posters have explained ethical objections they have to Costa (you not sharing those doesn’t make them less valid to those posters).

cardibach · 08/10/2023 15:18

Wishihadanalgorithm · 08/10/2023 14:22

Where I work everyone drives in and I think this has been the case at my previous schools. Haven’t worked in an inner city school though - plants and flowers are no more difficult to transport than a breakable bottle of wine surely?

Of course they are. Wine bottles aren’t particularly fragile. Whatever back pack or other bag was used to get belongings to school will be fine - shove the bottle in. Not so with a plant that actually is fragile and which has soil that can spill, or delicate bunches of flowers: they have to be carefully carried in the hands.

MumW · 08/10/2023 15:17

My daughters have always made cakes.
We did try and find out if there were any dietary requirements so they have had to learn to make both gluten free and vegan cakes along the way.

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2023 15:06

As I think this thread illustrates perfectly, no matter what you give, somebody, somewhere will be able to pick holes in it. So do what you want. You can't please all of the people all of the time.

Username620 · 08/10/2023 15:06

PinkFizz1 · 07/10/2023 21:12

I’m an addict in recovery. Myself and DH talk about things like this all the time. I would say don’t do it. You have no idea if they are an addict or whatever the reason might be for them not drinking. Also, as an addict, if someone gave me a bottle of the substance I was addicted to and trying to stay away from, it would be extremely hard to just ‘pass it on’.

All that aside, even if they’re not an addict, it’s things like giving people bottles of alcohol as presents that totally normalises drinking in our society. Fascinating when you’re on the other side of it and can see how things like this aren’t given a second thought to by someone without alcohol issues, but could mean potentially someone’s sobriety being compromised, at worst. At best it’s completely normalising drinking, and giving alcohol as a ‘present’.

I too am an addict. My work gave everyone a bottle of champagne last Christmas. It’s still in my cupboard at work because I don’t want to bring it home to pass on. I’m scared I will drink it as it is a special one that I have always wanted to try.
I have been dry for 14 months now and I find it irresponsible just handing out alcohol to people. I’m not pious when it comes to drinking, most of my friends drink around me. Plus more and more people are making the lifestyle choice not to drink any more.