Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To as you to teach your child how to act around dogs?

418 replies

ToBeOrNotToBee · 07/10/2023 19:58

I'm gobsmacked, truly, still around an hour or so after this event.
Dog and I have had a busy day travelling and exploring the countryside.
On our way home, coming off train 3 of 3 on the return leg, having been out for 12 hours, I walk to the lift (which is around a corner and obscured by a stairwell) at the end of the platform with dog to heel besides me.
We're waiting with a few others when this 5-6 year old child appears around the corner, running towards us, hands outstretched, literally beelining for the dog. I see what's about to happen and immediately put the dog behind my legs and put my hand out telling the child a stern 'No'.
The child then tries to go behind to reach my dog, who is cowering between my legs. I have no choice but to grab hold of the child's coat and physically stop them, letting go when the child stops trying to reach my dog.
After a moment or two, the Dad appears and then screams at me for touching his child. As he's midscream, the lift appears and I go into it with a few others and doors close as everyone else looks awkwardly at their feet.
The doors close, we go on our merry wall.
But I couldn't stop this feeling that the child will one day do that to the wrong dog and end up a dog bite statistic.
Say for example, I wasn't as switched on, and my dog as placid as he is, or in pain that day, and the child did poke him painfully causing him to snap and bite. Child would have been hurt, my dog potentially put down, and I get a conviction for having a Dangerous Dog Out of Control.
It's something I've noticed over recent years, people treating strange dogs as public property and not animals with sharp teeth and their own minds.
So please, teach your children not to run whilst on busy train platforms (or any train platform), to not approach unknown dogs, and if someone says no, to respect it.

Is that too much to ask???

OP posts:
Sigmama · 08/10/2023 21:37

Ntmdino, so why walk around with something that scares people?

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 21:36

CashewGal · 08/10/2023 21:27

The onus is on parents to teach their children how to behave around a dog, just like we teach them to deal with any other potential danger, like strangers. I've had many children run toward my dog, hands waving in the dog's face, absolutely desperate to make contact with the dog, and I have also had to step forward and say no it's not OK to touch my dog. It's only common sense to teach all children to "stand like a tree," arms down at their sides if a dog approaches, and not to ever run at at dog or stick a hand in front of its teeth or otherwise startle it. Yet the dog hate on Mumsnet continues!!

Um, it’s not dog hate. It’s a reasonable belief that everyone should be able to go about life without having to put up with dogs - just like not having to put up with any other public nuisance.

The OP asked about an uncontrolled child. Some posters, me included, think it’s a bad thing not to supervise a child and not be in a position to intervene if necessary.

But any dog that reacts to a child, whatever the child does, is responsible - or strictly speaking the dog’s owner is responsible.

If you don’t want that responsibility, don’t have a dog. Or at least muzzle it so it can do no real harm.

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 21:35

Sigmama · 08/10/2023 21:32

Ntmdino, a large growling dog is scary

It's supposed to be! Do you expect the dog to hold a finger up and say, "Excuse me, young sir, would you mind not pulling my ear please? It's getting rather painful, and I don't think it's fair"?

I mean, I guess you could try to explain the finer points of the DDA to it, but it probably won't get you as far as telling a kid not to grab dogs they don't know.

Sigmama · 08/10/2023 21:32

Ntmdino, a large growling dog is scary

Sigmama · 08/10/2023 21:30

Cashewgirl, why walk around with 'a potential danger' in the first place, that's a lifestyle choice

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 21:29

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 18:34

The dog - or rather the dog’s owner, legally speaking - is always in the wrong.

You cannot displace blame for harm caused by your dog to someone else, whatever the circumstances.

Unless, I suppose, you have a guard dog that injures a burglar. Children on railway platforms, in parks, on the streets or elsewhere in public are not burglars or any other sort of wrongdoer.

And I'll say it again, because you don't seem to have quite understood. A dog can be seized and put down without ever even touching another human being - all that's required for that to happen is for somebody to feel threatened, which can be as simple as the dog growling.

For a simple scenario where this happens regularly to dog owners (thankfully not to its complete conclusion): child runs up to dog and starts grabbing at it despite being told not to by the owner. Dog growls purely to communicate that it's not happy and the child needs to stop - which is exactly what a dog is supposed to do, warn extensively before getting physical. Child gets scared - which it should do, because it's misbehaving - and then the parent calls the police. Dog seized, owner prosecuted for having a dangerous dog, dog put down.

No injury to humans, just an inattentive parent and a child that got scared as a direct result of ignoring instructions from both the dog and its owner. The child indirectly killed the dog with its poor behaviour.

Growling is not aggression; it's direct communication. In fact, in a lot of circumstances, a dog being punished for growling is responsible for bite incidents because its owners have effectively trained it not to use any of its available communication strategies (stepping away, growling, baring teeth) that would normally be a step on the warning escalation ladder, so it has no other option than to snap or bite in order to remove the threat. Discouraging those behaviours is utter stupidity.

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/10/2023 21:28

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 17:00

Sure. But if your dog was muzzled there’d be no realistic likelihood of damage to an (improperly) unsupervised child would there?

Eh... no.

A dog can knock someone over, scratch them, muzzle-punch (exactly as it sounds, unmuzzled dogs can do this too where they go as if to bite but don't open the mouth. Muzzled dogs often do it attempting to bite), which if the dog has a metal wire muzzle on, can do some damage.

A big dog wearing a muzzle could still do a small child some significant harm.

Big, secure muzzles limit a dogs ability to give out and read body language, so if all dogs were muzzled you'd see an increase in dog to dog aggression (important as many dog attacks resulting in human injury started as dog to dog).

It makes it harder to meet a dogs needs - play, training, all harder if your dog can't use their mouth.

So increases in aggression and decreases in training/socialisation... generally not a great idea for society.

On a personal level, if my dog is on a lead and muzzled and a child comes barrelling over to hit/kick/sit on/grab my dog, your child is still at risk because I am going to grab/stop/do whatever is necessary to protect my now completely vulnerable and defenseless dog and it might well result in your child having an unpleasant experience.

Riverlee · 08/10/2023 21:28

Mischance · 08/10/2023 21:10

Someone has suggested that children should be taught canine communication in school. I honestly do not think that pupils should have to receive lessons to pander to others' choices in life. The onus is fair and square on the dog owners.

Children are a choice in life also.

The onus is on both parties. Dog owners should be responsible with their dogs.eg. Don’t let them jump up etc. However, parents should also be responsible and not allow their children to pat, stroke etc strange dogs. They’re not toys.

CashewGal · 08/10/2023 21:27

The onus is on parents to teach their children how to behave around a dog, just like we teach them to deal with any other potential danger, like strangers. I've had many children run toward my dog, hands waving in the dog's face, absolutely desperate to make contact with the dog, and I have also had to step forward and say no it's not OK to touch my dog. It's only common sense to teach all children to "stand like a tree," arms down at their sides if a dog approaches, and not to ever run at at dog or stick a hand in front of its teeth or otherwise startle it. Yet the dog hate on Mumsnet continues!!

IMarchToADifferentDrummer · 08/10/2023 21:18

What is wrong with people these days? Of course you are NOT being unreasonable, that parent should have known better than to let his child run up to a dog like that, or any animal!!
Would he, on the other hand, have been so calm if an unknown dog had run up to his child for hugs, I think not!
Children should be taught that you ask the person with the dog if they are friendly, can they stroke/pet them?
If someone I didn't know was to run up to me, I'd be on the defense!!

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 21:13

RaeHitsEbSire · 08/10/2023 21:09

You have one of the most one-track-minds I have ever encountered.

I really don’t. But why don’t you tell me why your dog(s) shouldn’t be muzzled.

Mischance · 08/10/2023 21:10

Someone has suggested that children should be taught canine communication in school. I honestly do not think that pupils should have to receive lessons to pander to others' choices in life. The onus is fair and square on the dog owners.

RaeHitsEbSire · 08/10/2023 21:09

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 21:07

…until the law changes. Which it inevitably will.

Anyway, what is the problem with muzzling dogs? Given the deaths and misery caused to people, including children, by dogs, why would any dog owner object?

You have one of the most one-track-minds I have ever encountered.

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 21:07

HappiestSleeping · 08/10/2023 21:03

No, the office of national statistics. It is the actual number of admissions, not a percentage.

I agree that there will be occurrences of bites that didn't result in hospital admissions, however if it were that much of a problem, it would already be being discussed more broadly than a few disgruntled mumsnetters on a couple of threads here and there. You are very much entitled to your opinion, as I am to mine, so we will have to agree to differ. My dog will remain unmuzzled.

…until the law changes. Which it inevitably will.

Anyway, what is the problem with muzzling dogs? Given the deaths and misery caused to people, including children, by dogs, why would any dog owner object?

Mischance · 08/10/2023 21:07

Dentilly89 · 08/10/2023 14:11

Kid and parent will learn one day when they meet the wrong dog. Cant say I would have much pity for them.

Oh dear - there is the dog obsession writ large. You would see a child hurt and have no pity? Really?

HappiestSleeping · 08/10/2023 21:03

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 20:23

Assuming you got those figures from the BMJ paper online, dog bites are recorded as 18.7 per 1000. So, on a low population figure of 60m, that would make well over a million dog bites annually - and the online figure of the UK population is 67m.

I suspect that this is a severe under-reporting of the prevalence of dog bites. But I’ll go with the - already shocking - published figures.

However many are bites to owners (or their children)…muzzle your dog.

No, the office of national statistics. It is the actual number of admissions, not a percentage.

I agree that there will be occurrences of bites that didn't result in hospital admissions, however if it were that much of a problem, it would already be being discussed more broadly than a few disgruntled mumsnetters on a couple of threads here and there. You are very much entitled to your opinion, as I am to mine, so we will have to agree to differ. My dog will remain unmuzzled.

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 20:23

HappiestSleeping · 08/10/2023 19:50

7987 hospital admissions, children making up about 20% of that. Not insignificant, however a good many of them will be the owner of the dog concerned.

Edited

Assuming you got those figures from the BMJ paper online, dog bites are recorded as 18.7 per 1000. So, on a low population figure of 60m, that would make well over a million dog bites annually - and the online figure of the UK population is 67m.

I suspect that this is a severe under-reporting of the prevalence of dog bites. But I’ll go with the - already shocking - published figures.

However many are bites to owners (or their children)…muzzle your dog.

HumanBurrito · 08/10/2023 20:12

Some kids have crap parents who don't teach them anything. Some kids have hidden disabilities and cannot learn simple life lessons. And some dog owners muddy the message by letting their dogs run up to people uninvited. Which is why the onus is on dog owners should expect the unexpected.

HappiestSleeping · 08/10/2023 19:50

7987 hospital admissions, children making up about 20% of that. Not insignificant, however a good many of them will be the owner of the dog concerned.

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 19:45

HappiestSleeping · 08/10/2023 19:40

Unfortunately the statistics do not agree with you. Dog bites and attacks are not a massive issue. They are an issue that get massive publicity. Pre 2022, the average was 3 fatalities per year. Compare that to over 70,000 reported cases of rape. Or 46,000 reported cases of knife crime, etc etc etc. Of course there are other dog related incidents that don't end in fatality, but it is infinitesimal in comparison. I would much rather see those dealt with.

And yes, the statistics are skewed by an increase in the last year. This is already linked to covid, and the increase in dog ownership by stupid people who didn't know what they were doing as can be evidenced by them turfing their dogs back to kennels as they didn't know how to look after them.

What are the dog bite numbers? Hospitalisations because of dogs? Numbers of reports of out of control dogs?

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 19:42

Riverlee · 08/10/2023 19:36

Yes, let’s muzzle the kids, or have them on reins so they can’t get to the dog. That should solve the problem! (Light-hearted).

Sure. Everyone should restrict their own and their kids’ behaviour for your dog’s peace of mind. (Light hearted)

HappiestSleeping · 08/10/2023 19:40

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 19:29

I think dog bites and attacks are a massive issue. The news seems to back me up.

We don’t need lots more police. Just a new and simple law and some enforcement. New laws are enacted every day. A requirement to muzzle all dogs, with a penalty for the owner and confiscation of the dog would be one of the most straightforward, easiest and cheapest to enforce.

Unfortunately the statistics do not agree with you. Dog bites and attacks are not a massive issue. They are an issue that get massive publicity. Pre 2022, the average was 3 fatalities per year. Compare that to over 70,000 reported cases of rape. Or 46,000 reported cases of knife crime, etc etc etc. Of course there are other dog related incidents that don't end in fatality, but it is infinitesimal in comparison. I would much rather see those dealt with.

And yes, the statistics are skewed by an increase in the last year. This is already linked to covid, and the increase in dog ownership by stupid people who didn't know what they were doing as can be evidenced by them turfing their dogs back to kennels as they didn't know how to look after them.

Riverlee · 08/10/2023 19:36

Yes, let’s muzzle the kids, or have them on reins so they can’t get to the dog. That should solve the problem! (Light-hearted).

RaeHitsEbSire · 08/10/2023 19:36

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 19:34

Why would a copper or dog warden have to be nearby? If they could identify you - which wouldn’t be very difficult, especially if the photos were publicised, like with other criminals - they’d just come to your house, arrest you and take your dog away.

Would they bollocks be arsed to do that! Half the time, they even won't come out for crimes where people have been harmed.

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 19:34

RaeHitsEbSire · 08/10/2023 19:30

Well, it's worth a try, but unlikely to go anywhere.

If a muzzling law was brought in, an unmuzzled dog that hadn't harmed anyone would be right at the bottom of the priority list. If there happened to be a nearby officer they'd doubtless do something (probably just a warning while the owner made some excuse about how the muzzle fell off or broke), but otherwise, the police wouldn't be trawling through photographs to identify the owner.

If the dog bit someone it might be different, but then so would it if a dog bit someone with no muzzling law in place.

Why would a copper or dog warden have to be nearby? If they could identify you - which wouldn’t be very difficult, especially if the photos were publicised, like with other criminals - they’d just come to your house, arrest you and take your dog away.

Swipe left for the next trending thread