Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To as you to teach your child how to act around dogs?

418 replies

ToBeOrNotToBee · 07/10/2023 19:58

I'm gobsmacked, truly, still around an hour or so after this event.
Dog and I have had a busy day travelling and exploring the countryside.
On our way home, coming off train 3 of 3 on the return leg, having been out for 12 hours, I walk to the lift (which is around a corner and obscured by a stairwell) at the end of the platform with dog to heel besides me.
We're waiting with a few others when this 5-6 year old child appears around the corner, running towards us, hands outstretched, literally beelining for the dog. I see what's about to happen and immediately put the dog behind my legs and put my hand out telling the child a stern 'No'.
The child then tries to go behind to reach my dog, who is cowering between my legs. I have no choice but to grab hold of the child's coat and physically stop them, letting go when the child stops trying to reach my dog.
After a moment or two, the Dad appears and then screams at me for touching his child. As he's midscream, the lift appears and I go into it with a few others and doors close as everyone else looks awkwardly at their feet.
The doors close, we go on our merry wall.
But I couldn't stop this feeling that the child will one day do that to the wrong dog and end up a dog bite statistic.
Say for example, I wasn't as switched on, and my dog as placid as he is, or in pain that day, and the child did poke him painfully causing him to snap and bite. Child would have been hurt, my dog potentially put down, and I get a conviction for having a Dangerous Dog Out of Control.
It's something I've noticed over recent years, people treating strange dogs as public property and not animals with sharp teeth and their own minds.
So please, teach your children not to run whilst on busy train platforms (or any train platform), to not approach unknown dogs, and if someone says no, to respect it.

Is that too much to ask???

OP posts:
Riverlee · 08/10/2023 22:11

Also, not all growling is a warning sign. My dog does a low growl when he wants to play.

nocoolnamesleft · 08/10/2023 22:11

I think the all dogs should have to wear muzzles is a great idea. It wouldn't stop them knocking people over, but it would avoid many of the maulings (not the ones that happen at home, but at least it would protect innocent bystanders).

Riverlee · 08/10/2023 22:10

@TrailingLoellia All people are asking is that parents parent their child.

Children are taught from a young age how to cross a road safely, and not to step into the road if a car is coming. When young, parents act as their advocates, and tell them when to cross the road. Obviously, if cars were to be removed from the road, then car accidents wouldn’t happen. Problem solved. However, that’s not going to happen, so car drivers learn to look out for people crossing the roads. Both parties take responsibility.

Similarly, parents should teach their kids not to touch a dog, and dog owners should be responsible with their dogs.

CashewGal · 08/10/2023 22:10

Men rape. Let's muzzle all men's penises.

MumOfTheNorth · 08/10/2023 22:09

TrailingLoellia · 08/10/2023 22:00

So to live in this “real world” of dog bites child, you think the best solution is to make nursery age children responsible for behaving in a way that puts dogs at ease instead of making adult dog owners responsible for keeping children safe by spending £10 on a muzzle and using it? Got it.

I'm finding the all dogs should wear muzzles argument really strange. Why do you think a dog with no history of aggression or biting should have to endure the discomfort of wearing a muzzle? And you might say all dogs have the potential to bite but lots of things we live with day to day have the potential to be dangerous - should we stop being allowed scissors and cars? I have the potential and physical ability to bite you but you wouldn't expect me to wear a muzzle (I hope).

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 22:08

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 22:04

Why would a dog growl?

What would that signify?

Why do you not understand that a dog’s reaction might be upsetting to a child and alarming to an adult, however raucous the child and negligent the parent?

Why should dogs not be muzzled?

SMS, TTFN, RNLI

I've already explained several times what a dog's growl signifies - it's that the dog is extremely uncomfortable and that it wants it to stop. It's nothing more than that - it's certainly not an indication of aggression under those circumstances.

If you think it is, then you know far less about dogs than you think you do, which is kind of the point of the thread.

I've already said that muzzling makes no difference in this circumstance - muzzled or not, a dog growling to get the incoming behaviour to stop still potentially results in its death, even though it's done nothing wrong.

Still heavily doubting your reading comprehension skills, because I've been over all of this twice in the comments you've replied to.

Answer me this: if a dog can't growl, and can't physically stop the child (and neither can the owner), how is it supposed to get the child to stop assaulting it?

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 22:04

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 21:59

So...tell me this: if you didn't misunderstand, then why were you talking about biting, punching or kicking a child when that is absolutely nothing to do with what I was talking about?

Unless, of course, you think that a dog's warning vocalisation is the equivalent of maiming a child.

SMH

Why would a dog growl?

What would that signify?

Why do you not understand that a dog’s reaction might be upsetting to a child and alarming to an adult, however raucous the child and negligent the parent?

Why should dogs not be muzzled?

SMS, TTFN, RNLI

TrailingLoellia · 08/10/2023 22:00

RaeHitsEbSire · 08/10/2023 18:37

This is like banging my head against a brick wall!

We do not live in a perfect world. We live in a world where people are irresponsible and do wrong things.

We all have to learn to navigate that world - the real world, not an ideal world where every dog is perfectly trained (or muzzled, if that's what you'd like to see).

If you think "telling him/her that the dog owners will be prosecuted and heavily fined. And their dog destroyed" would make up for a serious injury, perhaps lifelong scarring, perhaps even death - you are naive.

You child needs to learn how to survive in the world we live in, not in your utopian vision of the world.

So to live in this “real world” of dog bites child, you think the best solution is to make nursery age children responsible for behaving in a way that puts dogs at ease instead of making adult dog owners responsible for keeping children safe by spending £10 on a muzzle and using it? Got it.

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 21:59

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 21:56

I don’t think anyone misunderstands. A growling, scary dog is a public nuisance and a potential hazard to children and others.

Any dog is a danger, growling or not, frankly. Which is why they should all have to wear a muzzle. (If your dog growls but has no teeth I might think differently.)

So...tell me this: if you didn't misunderstand, then why were you talking about biting, punching or kicking a child when that is absolutely nothing to do with what I was talking about?

Unless, of course, you think that a dog's warning vocalisation is the equivalent of maiming a child.

SMH

Rosebel · 08/10/2023 21:58

YANBU. The child shouldn't have approached your dog and should listen when you said no. Dad should have been more switched on and watching what his son was doing.
However you should not have grabbed the child at all because that will piss. off most parents. Also I'm a bit confused your dog goes on busy, noisy public transport but is freaked by one child. That doesn't really make sense.

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 21:58

MumOfTheNorth · 08/10/2023 21:55

Out of interest what would you expect a dog to do in this situation? E.g being attacked by a child and being caused a lot of pain. It sounds like you would only accept no reaction at all which seems a bit much to ask from any living creature.

I can accept that a dog would react. But it should be wearing a muzzle so that its reaction can’t be to bite.

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 21:56

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 21:51

Which part of my post didn't you understand? Because I'm talking about the situation where the dog has not bitten anyone, only growled, yet that poses a direct threat to the dog's life.

Seriously starting to doubt the reading comprehension capabilities of people on here.

I don’t think anyone misunderstands. A growling, scary dog is a public nuisance and a potential hazard to children and others.

Any dog is a danger, growling or not, frankly. Which is why they should all have to wear a muzzle. (If your dog growls but has no teeth I might think differently.)

MumOfTheNorth · 08/10/2023 21:55

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 21:49

If a child ran up to you and pissed you off, even hurt you, would you bite the child, or maybe punch him/her in the face, or maybe give the child a right kicking?

No? Because you’re sensible? And you know that assaulting a child would be a very serious criminal action?

Your dog doesn’t know that. But you are solely responsible for your dog. So you carry the can.

Out of interest what would you expect a dog to do in this situation? E.g being attacked by a child and being caused a lot of pain. It sounds like you would only accept no reaction at all which seems a bit much to ask from any living creature.

RaeHitsEbSire · 08/10/2023 21:55

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 21:13

I really don’t. But why don’t you tell me why your dog(s) shouldn’t be muzzled.

Edited

Well, he's dead now but he never bit or showed aggression to anyone, adult, child or animal (he lived with our two cats) in his lifetime. He was responsibly bred, well socialised and trained, and had all his needs met, so had no reason to mistrust humans.

HappiestSleeping · 08/10/2023 21:53

Maybe we are approaching this the wrong way. We should require a law that says all children should be on leads?

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 21:51

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 21:49

If a child ran up to you and pissed you off, even hurt you, would you bite the child, or maybe punch him/her in the face, or maybe give the child a right kicking?

No? Because you’re sensible? And you know that assaulting a child would be a very serious criminal action?

Your dog doesn’t know that. But you are solely responsible for your dog. So you carry the can.

Which part of my post didn't you understand? Because I'm talking about the situation where the dog has not bitten anyone, only growled, yet that poses a direct threat to the dog's life.

Seriously starting to doubt the reading comprehension capabilities of people on here.

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 21:49

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 21:40

Jesus....seriously?

None of my dogs ever scare people unless those people are posing a direct threat to the dog.

Do you really think a dog should just calmly put up with kids yanking on their ears or tails, causing them pain, and ignoring all instructions to stop? You're wilfully ignoring that part.

If a child ran up to you and pissed you off, even hurt you, would you bite the child, or maybe punch him/her in the face, or maybe give the child a right kicking?

No? Because you’re sensible? And you know that assaulting a child would be a very serious criminal action?

Your dog doesn’t know that. But you are solely responsible for your dog. So you carry the can.

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 21:49

Sigmama · 08/10/2023 21:44

Ntmfino, I've been growled at by big scary looking dogs with no provocation, I'm just curious why people want to own a breed that people feel threatened by

Then that is absolutely nothing to do with what I'm talking about, is it?

As to your "curiosity" - yes, I have an Akita, a Chihuahua and a medium-sized crossbreed. The breeds are irrelevant, they were dogs in need of a good home and we provided that to them. All of them can be scary to some people, and I keep my dogs away from those people to protect everybody concerned, because setting my dogs up to fail is a breach of their trust.

I cannot control other people's children, however, and that is what I'm talking about.

CashewGal · 08/10/2023 21:47

The owner did everything they could to prevent a child potentially endangering themself and yet the response is to blame the owner. Those saying it is the dog or owner's fault clearly see no scenario where it's the idiot humans' fault so why bother expecting a considered reply?

Sigmama · 08/10/2023 21:44

Ntmfino, I've been growled at by big scary looking dogs with no provocation, I'm just curious why people want to own a breed that people feel threatened by

HappiestSleeping · 08/10/2023 21:44

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 21:07

…until the law changes. Which it inevitably will.

Anyway, what is the problem with muzzling dogs? Given the deaths and misery caused to people, including children, by dogs, why would any dog owner object?

That is an easy one to answer. Theoretically, and dog can be taught to wear a muzzle if done correctly, and it shouldn't be uncomfortable for the dog. However, this relies on the owner knowing what to do, and doing it correctly. This is where it all goes wrong for me. If we take the view that a responsible owner would train their dog such that it wouldn't need a muzzle as it would be under control and of low risk (I agree that there is never zero risk, but it can be minimal), then we are really targeting irresponsible owners, of which there have been an increasing number in recent years.

What you then get is irresponsible owners not knowing how to train a dog to wear a muzzle which can, in turn, create a distressed dog which is more likely to be reactive. Before you say "yes, but it would be muzzled", there is much more risk that it would escape in a distressed state and potentially bite an innocent passer by, so the result would likely be the opposite of the intended result. At very least, the owners would be at higher risk of being bitten, which affects the statistics negatively as well.

I think your objective of a risk free society is admirable, I too would like to live in one, however it is unfeasible. Everything has risk, we just need to manage it to an acceptable level. Otherwise we wouldn't drive, fly, go parachuting, basically anything that involves leaving the house.

I don't think the law will change as it isn't a big enough issue, despite being very distressing and unfortunate for people who have been affected.

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 21:40

Sigmama · 08/10/2023 21:37

Ntmdino, so why walk around with something that scares people?

Jesus....seriously?

None of my dogs ever scare people unless those people are posing a direct threat to the dog.

Do you really think a dog should just calmly put up with kids yanking on their ears or tails, causing them pain, and ignoring all instructions to stop? You're wilfully ignoring that part.

Sigmama · 08/10/2023 21:38

Cashew, oh no I love dogs, just not big scary looking ones, do you often give orders to strangers?

CashewGal · 08/10/2023 21:38

@WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps We get it, you don't like dogs either. Move along please.

CashewGal · 08/10/2023 21:37

@sigmama We get it, you don't think dogs should exist. Move along please.

Swipe left for the next trending thread