Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To as you to teach your child how to act around dogs?

418 replies

ToBeOrNotToBee · 07/10/2023 19:58

I'm gobsmacked, truly, still around an hour or so after this event.
Dog and I have had a busy day travelling and exploring the countryside.
On our way home, coming off train 3 of 3 on the return leg, having been out for 12 hours, I walk to the lift (which is around a corner and obscured by a stairwell) at the end of the platform with dog to heel besides me.
We're waiting with a few others when this 5-6 year old child appears around the corner, running towards us, hands outstretched, literally beelining for the dog. I see what's about to happen and immediately put the dog behind my legs and put my hand out telling the child a stern 'No'.
The child then tries to go behind to reach my dog, who is cowering between my legs. I have no choice but to grab hold of the child's coat and physically stop them, letting go when the child stops trying to reach my dog.
After a moment or two, the Dad appears and then screams at me for touching his child. As he's midscream, the lift appears and I go into it with a few others and doors close as everyone else looks awkwardly at their feet.
The doors close, we go on our merry wall.
But I couldn't stop this feeling that the child will one day do that to the wrong dog and end up a dog bite statistic.
Say for example, I wasn't as switched on, and my dog as placid as he is, or in pain that day, and the child did poke him painfully causing him to snap and bite. Child would have been hurt, my dog potentially put down, and I get a conviction for having a Dangerous Dog Out of Control.
It's something I've noticed over recent years, people treating strange dogs as public property and not animals with sharp teeth and their own minds.
So please, teach your children not to run whilst on busy train platforms (or any train platform), to not approach unknown dogs, and if someone says no, to respect it.

Is that too much to ask???

OP posts:
Esgaroth · 09/10/2023 02:40

I do wonder if the kind of parents who see no need to take responsibility for stopping their kids running up to dogs and grabbing them and getting in their faces would stop their child from chasing a sheep, throwing stones at a cat or pulling the legs off a spider. If a child isn't developmentally capable of being kind to animals an adult needs to keep a close watch on them in any place they might encounter them.

Yes, dogs need to be kept under control as well but two wrongs don't make a right.

It's also especially important that children know not to bother dogs in public spaces because sometimes the dog is actually working.

RomaniIteDomum · 09/10/2023 01:44

That suggests we should be prosecuting more dog owners. In any case I assume that if the police/wardens put dogs down for being out of control there isn’t a court case needed.

Police/wardens don't put dogs down. The prosecutors can apply for a destruction order in the event of conviction. Often the courts order the dog to be assessed by a professional and on the basis of that many are allowed to live - sometimes with conditions (yes, suck as your beloved muzzles) and sometimes the dog has been deemed to have been acting normally in the circumstances (ie defending itself from perceived attack)

Esgaroth · 09/10/2023 01:34

YANBU, the importance of being kind, calm and gentle with all animals is a lesson that all parents should teach their children. Nobody should frighten animals for the very simple reason that it's cruel. Even if it's not an animal that could hurt a human.

It's sad the number of children who treat animals like toys and have never been taught to empathise with their feelings.

UnNiddeRides · 08/10/2023 23:29

I thought that in a recent case the dog had been on a lead, but was too strong for the owner and had attacked anyway.

I think that the father was wrong. I’ve always taught my children that dogs can be unpredictable & you should never trust how they appear. It’s generally best to calmly avoid them & never approach them.

Bassetlover · 08/10/2023 23:16

I agree, I was in the park with my dog (on a lead) a few years ago and a child ran up and actually hit my dog. Luckily my dog is extremely tolerant but I did have words with the parents who didn't seem to give a shit to be honest. I do regularly get kids coming up and touching my dog without asking. I can't believe how stupid some people are.

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 23:03

TrailingLoellia · 08/10/2023 22:46

She is terrified of dogs, even tiny ones. She did nothing wrong, we were just taking a walk down the pavement to the park holding hands and as the dog ran over barking I scooped her up into my arms but then it jumped up latching on to her coat and pulled her out of my arms. I then dove after to try and get the dog off her, it released her only to bite and bite and shake its head while biting parts of her. I’m screaming “dog, dog, call off your dog” she’s screaming in pain and “mummy”. I still have nightmares from it.

If only dogs wore muzzles. Then it could have jumped all it wanted and I could have held on to her and kept her safe.

Or...if all dogs were required to be on leads in public (except in designated dog-friendly areas), the dog would never have had the opportunity to even scare your DD.

That's a properly terrible occurrence, and I'm truly sorry it happened to you. It should never have even gotten close to that happening.

I know it doesn't make me popular among fellow dog owners, but I'd be all for a ban on off-leash dogs in public (as well as one banning retractable leads). It would massively improve safety for both dogs and humans.

nocoolnamesleft · 08/10/2023 22:48

TrailingLoellia · 08/10/2023 22:46

She is terrified of dogs, even tiny ones. She did nothing wrong, we were just taking a walk down the pavement to the park holding hands and as the dog ran over barking I scooped her up into my arms but then it jumped up latching on to her coat and pulled her out of my arms. I then dove after to try and get the dog off her, it released her only to bite and bite and shake its head while biting parts of her. I’m screaming “dog, dog, call off your dog” she’s screaming in pain and “mummy”. I still have nightmares from it.

If only dogs wore muzzles. Then it could have jumped all it wanted and I could have held on to her and kept her safe.

I am so sorry, that sounds awful. And yes, I'd happily muzzle every dog in the country to save that happening to one child.

TrailingLoellia · 08/10/2023 22:46

Riverlee · 08/10/2023 22:39

@TrailingLoellia Sorry to hear that.

She is terrified of dogs, even tiny ones. She did nothing wrong, we were just taking a walk down the pavement to the park holding hands and as the dog ran over barking I scooped her up into my arms but then it jumped up latching on to her coat and pulled her out of my arms. I then dove after to try and get the dog off her, it released her only to bite and bite and shake its head while biting parts of her. I’m screaming “dog, dog, call off your dog” she’s screaming in pain and “mummy”. I still have nightmares from it.

If only dogs wore muzzles. Then it could have jumped all it wanted and I could have held on to her and kept her safe.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 08/10/2023 22:45

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 22:17

It shouldn’t be able physically to ‘stop’ a child. A dog can’t talk to a child or hold a child, it can only scare them off or attack them.

Neither of which is acceptable to any sensible person.

How would a muzzle stop the growling?

Edited

So the child should be allowed to carry on hurting the dog, @WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps? The owner isn’t allowed to physically remove the child that is hurting the dog, and the dog isn’t allowed to do anything at all to stop the child hurting them - so what is the owner or the dog supposed to do?

And why is it not an option to say parents should teach their children not to hurt dogs - or indeed any animal - and should supervise their children so they don’t hurt animals?

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 22:42

TrailingLoellia · 08/10/2023 22:30

I’ve never heard of such a thing. Perhaps the owners were omitting history?

Nope, was a 9yr old dog rescued at 1yr, with zero problematic history and the owners were a middle-class family with no criminal records. They just had a local judge who handled both the CPN and the supposed breach. He denied the CPN appeal, and the dog was put down before the second appeal was heard after months of delay.

The family pushed for the appeal without knowing that, it was heard by a different judge, and both the original CPN and the order to destroy were quashed, which is when they admitted that the dog had been killed anyway.

All because of a drunk and a badly-behaved kid. No consequences for anyone involved, but a massive legal bill for the family and a dead family dog.

Riverlee · 08/10/2023 22:39

@TrailingLoellia Sorry to hear that.

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 22:38

RomaniIteDomum · 08/10/2023 22:33

What are the dog bite numbers? Hospitalisations because of dogs? Numbers of reports of out of control dogs?

I work in the courts. In my usual court I have seen fewer than 10 prosecutions for out of control dogs this year. (I'd need to check the stats for the exact number)
Fewer in the court on the other side of us but more in the one on the other side as that's in a big city.

Men with child abuse images are by far a bigger problem - most weeks see several coming through.

But sure, let's penalise the dogs. 🙄

That suggests we should be prosecuting more dog owners. In any case I assume that if the police/wardens put dogs down for being out of control there isn’t a court case needed.

TrailingLoellia · 08/10/2023 22:36

Riverlee · 08/10/2023 22:33

@TrailingLoellia why are you so hot on muzzles? Or are you a troll just winding people up?

Because my DD was attacked by a dog. A muzzle would have prevented so much of the harm. And don’t even think of victim blaming her or me. I fought that dog off after it jumped up and ripped her from my arms.

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 22:35

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 22:26

OK, you're absolutely trolling here, or you've completely lost touch with reality in your desire to be Right On The Internet. The very post you've quoted says that a muzzle wouldn't stop the warning growl.

🙄

By scaring children I was - obviously - thinking of a dog growling, barking and baring it’s teeth.

Sure, a growling dog could scare a child (growling dogs scare adults), as would a dog jumping about, but with a muzzle on it won’t scare nearly as much, and it certainly couldn’t bite.

It’s really not difficult.

RomaniIteDomum · 08/10/2023 22:33

What are the dog bite numbers? Hospitalisations because of dogs? Numbers of reports of out of control dogs?

I work in the courts. In my usual court I have seen fewer than 10 prosecutions for out of control dogs this year. (I'd need to check the stats for the exact number)
Fewer in the court on the other side of us but more in the one on the other side as that's in a big city.

Men with child abuse images are by far a bigger problem - most weeks see several coming through.

But sure, let's penalise the dogs. 🙄

Riverlee · 08/10/2023 22:33

@TrailingLoellia why are you so hot on muzzles? Or are you a troll just winding people up?

kitsuneghost · 08/10/2023 22:32

I don't even understand why in a 2 bed terrace someone really feels the need to own a dog
I get it if you are a farmer herding sheep but not in a suburban society.

TrailingLoellia · 08/10/2023 22:30

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 22:24

It's very true, and it has happened locally - a dog was issued a CPN for growling at a drunk who threw something near it and they reported it as being threatening. Then the exact situation I described occurred - a child yanking the dog's tail - and the dog growled while moving away (while muzzled), and it was seized and put down because that was a breach of the CPN.

The DDA is not the only law in play here.

Edited

I’ve never heard of such a thing. Perhaps the owners were omitting history?

TrailingLoellia · 08/10/2023 22:28

MumOfTheNorth · 08/10/2023 22:09

I'm finding the all dogs should wear muzzles argument really strange. Why do you think a dog with no history of aggression or biting should have to endure the discomfort of wearing a muzzle? And you might say all dogs have the potential to bite but lots of things we live with day to day have the potential to be dangerous - should we stop being allowed scissors and cars? I have the potential and physical ability to bite you but you wouldn't expect me to wear a muzzle (I hope).

Muzzles aren’t that uncomfortable. Dogs are a species known for aggression and biting, much like other predators- wolf, cougar, bear- every dog is capable of both and no one should be put a risk because someone things their dog is a harmless fur baby.

Horses, donkeys and camels all wear bits for our convenience and those are uncomfortable so it’s not like we would be picking on dogs.

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 22:26

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 22:17

It shouldn’t be able physically to ‘stop’ a child. A dog can’t talk to a child or hold a child, it can only scare them off or attack them.

Neither of which is acceptable to any sensible person.

How would a muzzle stop the growling?

Edited

OK, you're absolutely trolling here, or you've completely lost touch with reality in your desire to be Right On The Internet. The very post you've quoted says that a muzzle wouldn't stop the warning growl.

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 22:24

TrailingLoellia · 08/10/2023 22:19

I've already said that muzzling makes no difference in this circumstance - muzzled or not, a dog growling to get the incoming behaviour to stop still potentially results in its death, even though it's done nothing wrong.

Sorry but this just isn’t true. Dogs can run amok, savage other dogs, kill cats and what not and will still not be put down because the dangerous dog act only requires the dog be put down if it has bitten a human. They certainly are not at any risk of death for merely growling with a muzzle on.

It's very true, and it has happened locally - a dog was issued a CPN for growling at a drunk who threw something near it and they reported it as being threatening. Then the exact situation I described occurred - a child yanking the dog's tail - and the dog growled while moving away (while muzzled), and it was seized and put down because that was a breach of the CPN.

The DDA is not the only law in play here.

TrailingLoellia · 08/10/2023 22:19

I've already said that muzzling makes no difference in this circumstance - muzzled or not, a dog growling to get the incoming behaviour to stop still potentially results in its death, even though it's done nothing wrong.

Sorry but this just isn’t true. Dogs can run amok, savage other dogs, kill cats and what not and will still not be put down because the dangerous dog act only requires the dog be put down if it has bitten a human. They certainly are not at any risk of death for merely growling with a muzzle on.

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2023 22:17

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 22:08

I've already explained several times what a dog's growl signifies - it's that the dog is extremely uncomfortable and that it wants it to stop. It's nothing more than that - it's certainly not an indication of aggression under those circumstances.

If you think it is, then you know far less about dogs than you think you do, which is kind of the point of the thread.

I've already said that muzzling makes no difference in this circumstance - muzzled or not, a dog growling to get the incoming behaviour to stop still potentially results in its death, even though it's done nothing wrong.

Still heavily doubting your reading comprehension skills, because I've been over all of this twice in the comments you've replied to.

Answer me this: if a dog can't growl, and can't physically stop the child (and neither can the owner), how is it supposed to get the child to stop assaulting it?

It shouldn’t be able physically to ‘stop’ a child. A dog can’t talk to a child or hold a child, it can only scare them off or attack them.

Neither of which is acceptable to any sensible person.

How would a muzzle stop the growling?

TrailingLoellia · 08/10/2023 22:17

Riverlee · 08/10/2023 22:10

@TrailingLoellia All people are asking is that parents parent their child.

Children are taught from a young age how to cross a road safely, and not to step into the road if a car is coming. When young, parents act as their advocates, and tell them when to cross the road. Obviously, if cars were to be removed from the road, then car accidents wouldn’t happen. Problem solved. However, that’s not going to happen, so car drivers learn to look out for people crossing the roads. Both parties take responsibility.

Similarly, parents should teach their kids not to touch a dog, and dog owners should be responsible with their dogs.

Sorry, but it is pie in the sky ideal world thinking to expect that nursery age children are all capable of learning how not to alarm any dog at any time. Most are still mastering potty training.

It is much more logical and realistic to expect adult dog owners to modify their behaviour and muzzle their dogs when out in public.

ntmdino · 08/10/2023 22:14

Riverlee · 08/10/2023 22:11

Also, not all growling is a warning sign. My dog does a low growl when he wants to play.

True enough; I was talking about this specific context, though. And if any of my dogs did the play-growl while a kid I didn't know was around, I'd remove them from the situation right away!

I definitely wouldn't expect a non-dog-owner to tell the difference between a play-growl and a threat-de-escalation growl, though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread