Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's an off lead dog one.

260 replies

Maluki · 07/10/2023 19:43

I walk my dog in the local park every day. There are sections where he is on lead and sections where I let him off. He is extremely used to people and dogs and generally very well behaved.

As we arrive at the park I always let him off lead and he does a poo. This is on a field area beside a path.

Today he did his poo in the field about 6 feet off the path as usual. I noticed a man in a suit approaching along the path. My dog then went back on to the path to wait for me and I leaned down to pick up the poo.

Very very unusually, my dog started to bark - he barked 4 or 5 times - and I saw he was now behind the man (who had walked past him). I was about to apologize, my dog almost never barks at people (he sometimes barks at really unusual things like a person wearing a sombrero or riding a tricycle, and this guy wasn't wearing anything unusual, except a slightly dishevelled suit on a Saturday morning). The man totally lost it at me. He started screaming that he had been bitten on the back of the leg by a dog, that my dog and dogs like him are aggressive and that it would bite my children and kill them (I didn't have my kids with me). He told me to get the dog away from him or he would kick it in the head. My dog is a bloody 10 lb cavapoo!

I appreciate that my dog should not have barked and that the man was triggered. If he had shouted to put it on a lead, before he walked past it, I would gladly have done so. My dog has excellent recall, and is completely reliable on the "wait" signal. He's actually a dream to get back on lead - but I hadn't called him over as there was no sign of what was about to happen. I do wonder if this man inadvertently spooked my dog or even kicked out at him in fear or something as it's so unusual for him to bark at people like that.

Aibu to think that the man, in his fear, may have inadvertently caused the dogs reaction? And that my dog behaved badly but it could have been avoided if the man had just called out for me to hold the dog?

OP posts:
explainthistomeplease · 08/10/2023 08:07

BlastedPimples · 08/10/2023 07:55

Dogs are allowed to bark there is no law against it.

Exactly.
Dogs bark and whimper and growl (it's a growl you probably need to worry about, not a bark)
Cats miaow and purr
Humans shout and talk and laugh and scream.

duchiebun · 08/10/2023 07:59

And toddlers are the same as dogs, do toddlers ever attack or kill people? I guess there's Chucky!

duchiebun · 08/10/2023 07:58

bit!

duchiebun · 08/10/2023 07:58

This thread is mental, the man is saying he was big but I'm not sure if he was or not because the man may have be carrying a knife 😆😆

BlastedPimples · 08/10/2023 07:55

Dogs are allowed to bark there is no law against it.

pickledandpuzzled · 08/10/2023 07:37

I can’t say about ’every time’, of course. In this case, if it had happened before OP wouldn’t have posted because it wouldn’t have surprised her. She’d know her dog takes against randoms.

in the case of your toddler, if it had happened before they wouldn’t have let the dog near your toddler.

Everything has a first time, and bad things don’t happen twice if it’s avoidable. Some things are predictable and you can avoid a first time. Some things are not.

Sehenswürdigkeiten · 08/10/2023 07:16

Some very interesting replies on here, several of which have reinforced my view that dogs really are better kept on leads in public places. OP, while you probably didn't intend to BU, I conclude that indeed YABU here. Learn for next time.

explainthistomeplease · 08/10/2023 06:58

I'm currently on Dartmoor doing a big walk. Yesterday I got barked at by two dogs. One was in his own farmyard and as we approached barked like crazy while still wagging his tail. We kept walking since the footpath went through the yard. My friend and I aren't particularly brave people but it was obvious the dog meant no harm. We continued walking and the dog and us were fine.
The second time a tiny dog rushed and barked at us when we crossed a stone bridge. Owners were picnicking by the river. Honestly it was no biggie as an event. I gave the dog some reassuring sing-song words and on we went. I don't even think my heart rate raised.
I think OP's man was probably the type of person to kick off in a variety of situations.

Now cows on a field we had to cross - that scared me!

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/10/2023 05:36

So if its not ok for a dog to make someone feel uncomfortable, how is it ok for a man to berate a stranger, and make them feel uncomfortable?

Dogs bark for lots of reasons - when playing and having fun, when spooked or feeling uncomfortable, when angry, truly frightened, defensive, trying to make something/someone go away, when calling out for a response if they're alone.

So a bark is not automatically unfriendly or aggressive, and aggression in any case is usually fear related - predatory behaviour, the desire to kill, dissect and consume is rarely accompanied by barking!

I think this guy was an arsehole, he was clearly NOT so terrified of the dog that he was reacting out of fear, he continued to approach and pass the OP's dog without calling out to ask her to recall the dog or put him on a lead. SO he wasn't frozen in fear, he wasn't unable to act... he chose to keep going and then have a go at teh OP, probably because she was an easy target and it made him feel good.

OP's only error is her dog being out of her direct eyeline, so she has no idea what the man did (if anything) as he approached or passed her dog. She and her dog have certainly not committed any dog related offence, barking is not illegal in this context.

Toenailz · 08/10/2023 01:42

As a dog owner, I wouldn't like an off lead dog standing near me and barking at me. Barking at people isn't a friendly behaviour is it? So I'd be a bit apprehensive of what it's next move was. I especially wouldn't like it from behind me. Ever had a dog chase you from behind, OP? It's fucking horrible. Had it with a rottie when I was younger. Also had it from a dalmatian when out jogging. Also had it from a yorkshire terrier that tried to bite my foot.

I'm a dog person - yet even I'd feel uncomfortable with that. It doesn't matter how small or cute you think your dog is. Ever been bitten by a small dog op?

He doesn't know your dog - so is judging from the behaviour presented infront of him. And your dog was barking at him.

I've mentioned elsewhere my dogs are rescues, don't like people (as in, they generally don't want anything to do with them until they've got a chance to know them a bit) and they certainly never, ever bark at a stranger whilst walking in public places, much less off lead. One was highly reactive when she arrived, and would bark just outside of our front door - I nipped it in the bud fucking rapidly. It's intimidating to people who don't know the dog.

You absolutely should train it out, or keep her leaded if she can have a go at people (barking) when she doesn't like what she sees, such as someone wearing a bloody hat or whatever. Then at least folk know your dog can't hurt them, and they won't feel threatened.

A lot of people will feel threatened by a dog barking at them when off lead, in a public place when they are simply going about their business. They have a right not to be made to feel this way.

If I thought a dog was going to go for me because it was barking at me, and near my feet or whatever, and I genuinely felt threatened, I'd absolutely kick it away. Keep your dog under control and don't let it get in that situation.

If you're responsible and have good recall (which you absolutely should have if you're letting her off lead in public) then it's not hard to call a dog close to you when you see people near, or are distracted. Both my dogs sit and won't move whilst I'm bent over picking up their poo - they know (because I trained them) that they have to wait, stay near me, and we can carry on once it's done. If I'm bent over I can't see folk, horses, other dogs, kids, or whatever else coming.

The guy told you he'd been bitten in the back of the leg by a dog - he was obviously worried, OP. Honestly, the amount of owners who don't get this into their head, give the rest a bad name. And even worse when they think it's fine because their dog is small.

Baaaaaa · 08/10/2023 00:08

Ragwort · 07/10/2023 21:15

Where can non dog lovers reasonably walk these days? I was walking to town yesterday - I saw a couple with a large dog (off lead), I stoped to allow them to pass but the dog came up to me and put his smelly, wet nose on my clean trousers, I appreciate that he didn't jump up at me but why should I have to accept a slobbery dogs messing up my clean clothes ?? The owner made a half hearted apology.

On another occasion a dog did jump up at my DH and when he remonstrated with the owner he was told 'this is a dog walking area ... you should expect to meet dogs here'. .. it wasn't a dog walking field ... just a general public assess beauty spot area Shock.

Oh no, that must have been almost intolerable for you. You poor, poor thing. Thoughts and prayers.

Baaaaaa · 08/10/2023 00:05

Chickenwing2 · 07/10/2023 20:16

Dogs should be on the lead in public. End of story.

Nonsense. Dogs have coexisted with humans for millenia. There is no law about leashing dogs, nor should there be and you certainly don't get to call it. A dog who is never off lead does not have quality of life.

Plenty of things you do probably annoy other people.

For example, making ridiculous judgements and finishing sentences with "end of story'

Wolfiefan · 08/10/2023 00:05

Many dogs need to run it freely sniff to ensure their well-being. Mine would never cope with on lead only. That’s why they are well trained and I ensure they don’t bother people.

Bigcoatweather · 07/10/2023 23:58

I lived abroad for a few years in a place where it was required by law to keep dogs on leads in public spaces. Dog parks were very popular and all the dogs I encountered were healthy and happy.
The idea that leads in public are unfair on dogs is ridiculous.

Emmalin · 07/10/2023 23:50

Well you can suspect what you like re the interaction between your dog and this guy obviously but you weren't in control of your dog or even watching it so you'll never know, will you? Suggest you don't leave it running around unsupervised in public in future.

surreygirl1987 · 07/10/2023 23:47

I wish everyone would keep their dogs on leads at all times.

Same.

My little boy was once attacked by an off-lead dog when he was 6 months old, sitting in his pram. The owner said 'oh he's never done anything like this before'. Moron. Any dog owner who thinks their dog is 100% under control is a complete idiot. Leads exist for a reason.

Lucinda7 · 07/10/2023 23:44

I highly doubt your lovely dog (liked the photo) could actually do much harm to anyone OP. Even if he wanted to. If he ran up to me I'd give him a fuss. I am scared of big dogs and would avoid them. I always had terriers and they definitely could bite hard if they wanted to.

MumOfTheNorth · 07/10/2023 23:42

OP you're not being unreasonable.

Being 2m away from your dog is not leaving it unattended as some have said. Your dog standing 2m from a guy and giving a few barks does not make it 'out of control' or 'dangerous'.

A few people have said 'all dogs should never be off lead' which I don't agree with but at least it's consistent. What I really don't get is the people that say your dog should be on lead except if it's 100% under control - how can you ever control another living thing 100%? It just seems like a really simplistic statement to me.

At the moment a lot of people seem to think all dog encounters are equal - from being barked at from a stationery dog to being attacked and mauled and that any subsequent reaction is justified. When it comes to dogs any reaction seems acceptable as the person was having a fear response. I find it frightening when men walk close behind me at night but if I started screaming at them and being aggressive everyone would find that unacceptable and rightly so. It only seems to be dogs that allow people to behave however they want from fear.

The other day I was out with my baby and dog and a huge XL bully type dog started lunging, snapping and snarling at us. It was on a lead and the owner was really struggling to hold it back. In the end the owner was lying on the floor to try and hold it back and told me 'i better get out of here quickly'. This is what I would consider a dangerous, out of control dog.

OP I think from reading this thread and other similar ones there are a few dangerous people out there who think any level of force is acceptable to use against a dog at the slightest provocation so I would be more cautious. Not because you or your dog have done anything wrong but there just seems to be a really anti dog vibe out there at the moment.

Becomingolder · 07/10/2023 23:27

Maluki · 07/10/2023 22:49

Ok I get the wider points people are making but:

He didn't run up to anyone. He was stood in the path waiting for me and the man walked past him.

He most certainly didn't bite (or growl or snarl). The man referred to a previous bite.

He wasn't out of my control, or dangerous - though I understand the man may have felt endangered.

In terms of whether people are safe near my dog @LightSpeeds yes, it's my responsibility to ensure they are actually safe. This man was not in danger. I accept he obviously felt he was. Does he, as the sentient human (he was at least in his 40s) in the interaction, have no responsibility to help his own feelings of safety? As I said earlier, if he would have said "I am not a dog fan, can you keep your dog near you?" I'd have done so no question. If he doesn't say anything until he's yelling at me that my dog needs it's head kicking in, how can I nip that in the bud?

Yes he does have some responsibility to help his feelings of safety but it's getting harder and harder. I avoid places where I know I'll see dogs off lead, means that I am now limited to just walking in places where there is a quiet enough road that I can cross if needs be, green spaces are entirely out, even those that are signposted as lead only because so many dog owners ignore it.

I've tried CBT and gradual exposure therapy (though that wasn't with a professional). The CBT didn't work and any time spent with a dog makes things worse. I try but it sometimes feels like we're not that far off my only safe space being my house and family and friends houses.

Wolfiefan · 07/10/2023 23:24

You probably would have spotted it if you’d had eyes on him. Plus he has barked at people before so you should be extra aware.

Maluki · 07/10/2023 23:17

Wolfiefan · 07/10/2023 23:13

Dog issues cause much frothing on here. The behaviour of your dog made this man extremely uncomfortable.
It isn’t up to us as dog owners to decide how others should be happy to have our dogs behave around them. It’s up to us to ensure our dogs don’t upset people. That can mean anything from letting people make a fuss of your dogs to putting them on a lead or recalling them to prevent them upsetting people who aren’t happy to have dogs extremely close to them.

I agree wolfiefan - and likewise, something about the behaviour of this man made my dog very uncomfortable!

As I said, if he had made any indication of discomfort prior to going nuclear I could have sorted it.

OP posts:
ivybx · 07/10/2023 23:15

@TheCupboardUnderTheStairsAtTheMojoDojoCasaHouse I get they understand words etc but they 100% do not act the same as any human being. They are animals

Maluki · 07/10/2023 23:14

@hollywally54
Not sure why I posted either really. Bit taken aback I suppose at being told my dog would kill my children and would have its head kicked in if it went near this man. Wanted reflections on why dogs sometimes bark at people unexpectedly. Is this something we should train out of them, this instinct that someone is atypical (I don't mean neurodivergent, have an autistic child ddog is fab with)? Would it be ok if he barked at people giving off bad vibes, but only if he's on lead? Should I train him not to bark even when spooked by someone? Could I even do that?

He's such a good boy in general. He isn't even much fussed by fireworks.

OP posts:
HalliwellManor · 07/10/2023 23:14

Maluki · 07/10/2023 20:27

I mean I told him off, and he went back on lead for a considerable amount of time, but I feel a bit torn. He was acting on instinct, and I kind of don't want to make him think he can't alert to people he thinks may be up to no good....if we ever get burgled I would want him to bark at those guys.

He is gorgeous!🥰🥰

Wolfiefan · 07/10/2023 23:13

Dog issues cause much frothing on here. The behaviour of your dog made this man extremely uncomfortable.
It isn’t up to us as dog owners to decide how others should be happy to have our dogs behave around them. It’s up to us to ensure our dogs don’t upset people. That can mean anything from letting people make a fuss of your dogs to putting them on a lead or recalling them to prevent them upsetting people who aren’t happy to have dogs extremely close to them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread