Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's an off lead dog one.

260 replies

Maluki · 07/10/2023 19:43

I walk my dog in the local park every day. There are sections where he is on lead and sections where I let him off. He is extremely used to people and dogs and generally very well behaved.

As we arrive at the park I always let him off lead and he does a poo. This is on a field area beside a path.

Today he did his poo in the field about 6 feet off the path as usual. I noticed a man in a suit approaching along the path. My dog then went back on to the path to wait for me and I leaned down to pick up the poo.

Very very unusually, my dog started to bark - he barked 4 or 5 times - and I saw he was now behind the man (who had walked past him). I was about to apologize, my dog almost never barks at people (he sometimes barks at really unusual things like a person wearing a sombrero or riding a tricycle, and this guy wasn't wearing anything unusual, except a slightly dishevelled suit on a Saturday morning). The man totally lost it at me. He started screaming that he had been bitten on the back of the leg by a dog, that my dog and dogs like him are aggressive and that it would bite my children and kill them (I didn't have my kids with me). He told me to get the dog away from him or he would kick it in the head. My dog is a bloody 10 lb cavapoo!

I appreciate that my dog should not have barked and that the man was triggered. If he had shouted to put it on a lead, before he walked past it, I would gladly have done so. My dog has excellent recall, and is completely reliable on the "wait" signal. He's actually a dream to get back on lead - but I hadn't called him over as there was no sign of what was about to happen. I do wonder if this man inadvertently spooked my dog or even kicked out at him in fear or something as it's so unusual for him to bark at people like that.

Aibu to think that the man, in his fear, may have inadvertently caused the dogs reaction? And that my dog behaved badly but it could have been avoided if the man had just called out for me to hold the dog?

OP posts:
MrsMorseEndeavour · 08/10/2023 15:23

Maluki · 07/10/2023 20:17

But it's not the end of story, as that isn't the law. If it were, then yes.

But it is the law if your dog is a threat to anyone. It doesn't need to be "the majority of people". Just that one person felt threatened and you pretty much said you would have done something if the man asked you to, implying because he didn't ask you were happy for your off lead dog to be a nuisance.

Cuttysark4321 · 08/10/2023 14:56

As many other posters have suggested I think the answer is further training OP and keeping the dog on the lead until you feel confident about that. The issue isn't whether you feel, or know you are safe around your dog it's whether others do and clearly in this situation the man did not. there is no question that the language used by the man and his response was disproportionate but here people are giving you solid suggestions as to how to avoid this situation in the future or more precisely, how to avoid causing fear or alarm while walking your dog. You might find that some people are more understanding than others but a lot of people are telling you they would find a barking dog intimidating and while you can't see that I'm afraid I think you need to take it on board.

ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 08/10/2023 14:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Maluki · 08/10/2023 14:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

What, objecting when you claimed for spurious tiny grammatical reasons that you could tell the OP prefers her dog to her disabled child? Is that the "kind of behaviour" that only dog owners show, that a non dog owner would accept?

What, in all honesty, did you expect my reaction - or any parents' reaction - to be?

I sincerely hope you have no idea of what it takes advocating for, supporting, nurturing, loving and caring for an autistic child. He is my fricking life.

I am taking the other people's comments on the chin or with a pinch of salt. They all have their reasons. But you, you crossed a line. You were cruel and vindictive. And why? Because my dog barked 4 or 5 times at someone who then went mad at me about it. Nobody was hurt. I have said I will put him back on lead in future when I pick up poo. I accept and always have throughout the thread that the person obviously felt threatened.

I did not deserve the unkind comment you made about my feelings towards my child. And that's the truth.

OP posts:
Nepmarthiturn · 08/10/2023 14:39

How could the man possibly have known whether the barking would escalate into an attack? Clearly the owner doesn't know either, otherwise she would not have said the whole clichéd "it's never happened before", "out of character" stuff. The problem is that it's too late by the time a dog actually attacks someone, to then say "oh yes, it wasn't under control".

It only takes once, and then it is too late. Any dog that has already been approaching strangers/ barking at them has already exhibited the warning signs that it is not safe to be off-lead in a public area, so in this case there's even less excuse for continuing to walk it off-lead and subject others to the risk of it turning on them randomly. The fact the OP is defending what the dog did and trying to blame the person it intimidated shows exactly how irresponsible many dog owners are and why people are entirely justified to not want to have their dogs anywhere near them or their families.

Nepmarthiturn · 08/10/2023 14:30

CrazyHedgehogLover · 08/10/2023 14:21

@Nepmarthiturn i’m sorry that situation happened however your right that is a completely different situation to what OP described.

in your situation that WAS an out of control dog, in OPs situation her dog was not running up towards him.. her dog barked 4/5 times, dogs can sense If someone is dangerous aswell as scared, this man threatened violence.. there was a good chance this is why the dog barked because the dog knew what this man would be capable of..

under no circumstances is it ok to threaten violence towards an animal.

This is so disingenuous. There are multiple instances of dogs deciding they want to attack somebody who is not dangerous. My children were nowhere near the dog: it ran at us from 100 metres away entirely unprovoked. Dogs attacking and even killing random adults who posed no danger to them at all. Dogs killing children in their own homes even. All umprovoked. Dogs can turn on people for no reason, even their owners, even it they have "never done this before", as is always the claim. Hence the legal requirement that they must be undet control in public at all times: it is the owner's responsibility. If you want to take the chance with your family having one loose in your house/ garden that is your decision but in public spaces other people should not be subjected to the risk that your dog behaves "unpredictably". Barking at someone who was walking along a public footpath is aggressive behaviour so this dog should not be off-lead in any public area because it has now demonstrated that it cannot be trusted to behave calmly and leave other people alone.

CrazyHedgehogLover · 08/10/2023 14:21

@Nepmarthiturn i’m sorry that situation happened however your right that is a completely different situation to what OP described.

in your situation that WAS an out of control dog, in OPs situation her dog was not running up towards him.. her dog barked 4/5 times, dogs can sense If someone is dangerous aswell as scared, this man threatened violence.. there was a good chance this is why the dog barked because the dog knew what this man would be capable of..

under no circumstances is it ok to threaten violence towards an animal.

AppIe · 08/10/2023 14:20

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Nepmarthiturn · 08/10/2023 14:13

CrazyHedgehogLover · 08/10/2023 13:15

Wtf, this man threatened violence on your dog.. all these people on here saying “he was in fear” was he bollocks! If he was that fearful he wouldn’t be making threats to harm an animal.. he would want the dog on the lead to be able to walk past.

instead he ranted and raved at the OP and went on to shout abuse and threatened to kick an animal in the head..

no matter what anyone says! This is not a fearful man, this was a violent man, your dog probably picked up on this hence the barking!

he was being very unreasonable.

No. When an out of control dog attacked my small children, took the hat of one of their heads and knocked the other one to the floor when he tried to protect her, I reacted (despite being terrified) with anger and violence and kicked the dog as hard as I could. It's owner was still over 50 metres away at this point.

Obviously that is different to the situation the OP described, but the fight or flight response when threatened by a dog approaching you uninvited, barking or otherwise being aggressive or behaving inappropriately will often be that the fight or flight mechanism kicks in, especially if someone has been subjected to aggressive behaviour by dogs previously. With two small children, flight was not available to me. But often fear responses are instinctive, not a choice and it is the responsibility of the dog owner to prevent such situations occurring by controlling their dogs and keeping them away from anybody who hasn't specifically stated they wish to interact with the dog.

CurlewKate · 08/10/2023 13:36

"Your dog picked up on his wierdness/fear, hence the barking."

Bollocks.

CrazyHedgehogLover · 08/10/2023 13:15

Wtf, this man threatened violence on your dog.. all these people on here saying “he was in fear” was he bollocks! If he was that fearful he wouldn’t be making threats to harm an animal.. he would want the dog on the lead to be able to walk past.

instead he ranted and raved at the OP and went on to shout abuse and threatened to kick an animal in the head..

no matter what anyone says! This is not a fearful man, this was a violent man, your dog probably picked up on this hence the barking!

he was being very unreasonable.

Mrsttcno1 · 08/10/2023 13:07

Thank you @ToadOnTheHill ! It is a shame there are so many untrained dogs around at the moment because it really does make things very uncomfortable for everyone, my assumption is now always that someone I see on a walk will be nervous of my dog so we react appropriately and he walks to heel to pass anybody and only if someone asks if they can say hello to my dog do we give him permission to greet anybody! And even then he knows it’s calm, all paws on the floor, and no licking unless someone asks him for a kiss 🤣I wish more people realised how much good training improves your relationship with your dog! Hopefully over the next few years we do see more responsible dog owners taking over again and everyone will feel more comfortable! X

ToadOnTheHill · 08/10/2023 12:50

@Mrsttcno1 as someone who has had so many dogs jump up at me and run at me in the last 18 months, I actually felt myself relaxing as I read your post. I didnt realise I'd actually developed a nervousness of dogs until just this moment and he idea of dogs being trained as well as yours has actually made me feel warm. I wish all owners were like you, the world would be a better place for all people and dogs. X

ToadOnTheHill · 08/10/2023 12:46

Could have been avoided by you putting your dog on a lead while you dealt with the poo.

People are sick of dogs. And with all the press at the moment about dangerous dogs, people are more sensitive to them.

Not everybody likes dogs. A lot of people resent sharing public spaces with them so any bad behaviour escalates things if people are already anti dog

Mrsttcno1 · 08/10/2023 12:43

Honestly @Nepmarthiturn I don’t totally disagree with you. I love my dog, and I’m never going to agree with some who say all dogs should be on lead muzzled etc at all times, because that is just an extreme, however I absolutely agree there should be regulation on dog ownership and training.

It is a touch of madness that you can find a dog for sale online with a few clicks on your phone and a few hours later you can be bringing the dog home no questions asked.

The reality is there’s never going to be the rules you would like there to be, dogs and people as they have for decades do have to co-exist in public spaces and so training is really important, that’s all I was trying to express in my reply, OP wanted to know if that kind of training is possible and I was simply saying it is- and any responsible dog owner will have a well trained dog. If nothing else it makes your life as a dog owner much less stressful! X

Nepmarthiturn · 08/10/2023 12:39

Such tests need to include unfamiliar people, people being "loud" and behaving in unpredictable ways (e.g. people with mental impairments, who have a right to walk safely in public places), people "staring" (we can't all be expected to avert our eyes from a potentially aggressive dog!), people wearing "funny hats" or fancy dress or whatever. Small children. People eating picnics and the dog being capable of not approaching them, how they react when other dogs or other animals or small children who may be loud and crying or whatever are present. Etc.

Stress testing, and if they cannot cope with stressors and still obey commands they should not be in public places without a muzzle and a lead. This is basic common sense and it baffles me that any dog owner would argue against it, if they were responsible...

Nepmarthiturn · 08/10/2023 12:32

It’s a lot of training, time and patience but it is totally worth it. You can see the attitude some people have towards dogs from posts on this thread, and so from the day I brought my dog home I have literally put in crazy hours training him to make sure nobody will ever have reason to question my dog or me as his owner.

If all owners did as you describe them there would not be a (negative) attitude from other members of the public to dogs because all dogs would be under control and nobody would have had dogs run and jump at them, bark at them, knock them over, bite them etc so would not have any reason to be worried about it. Sadly, many people have had this experience because many owners are not responsible.

Until there are legal requirements in place that all dog owners must complete the training you've mentioned with their dogs in a formal setting and have an official document to prove that the dog has passed tests to show it can follow such commands and never bark or approach people without permission from the owner, and that the dog should never be off-lead in a public area until they have this document (and any dog found to be so will be confiscated) the public cannot have confidence that they are safe from random aggressive behaviour from dogs.

The fact this thread exists - that someone is continually attempting to justify an unsupervised dog she wasn't even watching barking at a random stranger and cannot even accept that this is her responsibility and she was breaking the law because the dog evidently was not under control - exemplifies the problem.

Far, far tighter controls on this are needed with confiscation for non-compliance with training standards (which should be as you set out for any dog off lead in a public area, although in many public areas it would still be inappropriate to be off-lead), and also significant financial penalities for any non-compliance, properly enforced, funded by dog owners through an annual licence fee.

Mrsttcno1 · 08/10/2023 12:13

Maluki · 08/10/2023 11:33

Right, got the frothers piling on now.

I know how to handle this situation in future.
I don't yet know how to stop a dog barking when it's inappropriate, but keep the option of barking when there is a real danger, but obviously not going to get the answer to that particular question on here.

I'm out now, thanks.

If you do ever return to this thread, some advice on this (which I got from our time with a dog trainer for my Labrador) is you have to teach the dog to bark on command, so that you can then teach them not to bark on command. It takes a lot of time and patience in training, but it really is a hugely important skill to teach both for yours and their safety.

For us this means that when out and about on walks etc, our dog knows he is not allowed to bark, this doesn’t mean he can’t feel nervous/worried of things in public, but means we have taught him that if he is worried/scared/unsure of something, he comes to us and goes into a “middle” position, so he goes between our legs. He trusts that by doing that we will keep him safe and so there is no need for him to “react” to ward off danger or anything himself, he knows that as his owner that’s my job. HOWEVER, because he knows the “speak” command, if we were to be on a walk and someone was behaving towards me in a threatening way or something, I can just give the command “speak” and he will then bark, it’s up to me as the human to tell him when there’s danger, he just has to trust my direction.

In the house he receives the “relax” command so can switch off, and if I’m unaware of somebody at the door he will bark to let me know, but again as soon as I ask him to stop he does as he knows the command.

It’s a lot of training, time and patience but it is totally worth it. You can see the attitude some people have towards dogs from posts on this thread, and so from the day I brought my dog home I have literally put in crazy hours training him to make sure nobody will ever have reason to question my dog or me as his owner. It protects both your dog and yourself from situations like the one you have encountered x

Maluki · 08/10/2023 12:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

AppIe · 08/10/2023 12:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

wildlifeWalker · 08/10/2023 11:57

StSwithinsDay · 07/10/2023 22:13

I have a dog and am used to dogs. I was walking in a park the other day and an off lead dog - a biggish one - came up towards me and started barking and growling. I was very nervous. I took a step forward and the barking and growling escalated. About 30 seconds later the very apologetic owner came running up and put him on a lead. I don't give a flying fuck that according to her he was a teenage dog who was just being friendly - that was not the impression I got.

Yes it is pretty terrifying. I've had this once with an off lead Rottweiler, another time with a very bouncy Labrador and several times with small terrier type dogs.
I do love dogs but wary of them.

Barking directly at someone is a warning and the dog needs to be on a lead.

Nepmarthiturn · 08/10/2023 11:54

Lol

Why is it funny?

Maluki · 08/10/2023 11:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Sorry, just having to come back to laugh at this one. Really? Really?

Jesus Christ.

OP posts:
M5ybelle · 08/10/2023 11:49

People can only react from personal experience, to a strange dog on its own. It can be frightening and terrifying for some people. Calling to someone to put the dog on a lead usually ends up with the comment “oh it’s okay they are very gentle it’s just being friendly whilst jumping up at a 4 year old. A adult can’t do that to a child so why is it thought acceptable a dog is allowed to do that.
A dog off lead in an area where under 5s prace around, or elderly frail people take a walk, can never be a sensible safe option, doesn’t matter if it’s legal, it’s about how much do you really care for your dog. If it knocked a person over who hit their head and died what might happen then.
There are lots of dogs where owners do have control over them, they recall them easily and leads go back on. Im not commenting on your personal behaviour as you have been concerned about this, imagine his behaviour was frightening for you too.
So many people got dogs during lockdown, and whilst working from home but how many went to obedience classes. How many are regarded as precious babies.

AppIe · 08/10/2023 11:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.