Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's an off lead dog one.

260 replies

Maluki · 07/10/2023 19:43

I walk my dog in the local park every day. There are sections where he is on lead and sections where I let him off. He is extremely used to people and dogs and generally very well behaved.

As we arrive at the park I always let him off lead and he does a poo. This is on a field area beside a path.

Today he did his poo in the field about 6 feet off the path as usual. I noticed a man in a suit approaching along the path. My dog then went back on to the path to wait for me and I leaned down to pick up the poo.

Very very unusually, my dog started to bark - he barked 4 or 5 times - and I saw he was now behind the man (who had walked past him). I was about to apologize, my dog almost never barks at people (he sometimes barks at really unusual things like a person wearing a sombrero or riding a tricycle, and this guy wasn't wearing anything unusual, except a slightly dishevelled suit on a Saturday morning). The man totally lost it at me. He started screaming that he had been bitten on the back of the leg by a dog, that my dog and dogs like him are aggressive and that it would bite my children and kill them (I didn't have my kids with me). He told me to get the dog away from him or he would kick it in the head. My dog is a bloody 10 lb cavapoo!

I appreciate that my dog should not have barked and that the man was triggered. If he had shouted to put it on a lead, before he walked past it, I would gladly have done so. My dog has excellent recall, and is completely reliable on the "wait" signal. He's actually a dream to get back on lead - but I hadn't called him over as there was no sign of what was about to happen. I do wonder if this man inadvertently spooked my dog or even kicked out at him in fear or something as it's so unusual for him to bark at people like that.

Aibu to think that the man, in his fear, may have inadvertently caused the dogs reaction? And that my dog behaved badly but it could have been avoided if the man had just called out for me to hold the dog?

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 09/10/2023 18:18

What 'off lead craze'...

Dogs have been off lead for a variety of reasons since... before dogs were even dogs.

The more modern 'craze' is believing dogs should tolerate without any reaction, anything humans do, up to and including causing them fear and pain.

Particularly odd given we have laws about animal welfare that includes their need to:

"exhibit normal behaviour patterns"

and

"to be protected from pain, suffering, injury and disease."

Baaaaaa · 09/10/2023 18:13

Maluki · 08/10/2023 10:54

I am absolutely not muzzling my 10 pound cavapoo who has never harmed, growled at or snapped at a single person. That is ridiculous.

It is ridiculous. Dog threads always bring out the fanatics though.

ShirleyPhallus · 09/10/2023 08:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Fucking hell what is actually wrong with you. What a load of nasty poison.

RantyAnty · 09/10/2023 00:49

Whomever started the off lead craze needs a kick up the back side.

So many have zero awareness or thought for others.

Even OP, you absolutely think you're in the right. You think it's the man's responsibility to ask you to recall your dog or put it on it's lead. That you'll do what you want until a law tells you different.

He's probably sick and tired of being bothered by "friendly" dogs every time he walks along the footpath. Barking, being followed or chased, sniffed, licked, snapped at.

Eventually there will be laws requiring all dogs to be on lead.

I know where I'm from quite a few parks have banned dogs on trails and some parks have banned them all together.

MumOfTheNorth · 09/10/2023 00:33

Maluki · 09/10/2023 00:25

Lay off, @Apple. You have said enough.

I cannot believe not a single other poster on this thread has said you were in the wrong, and there are posters here saying the same thing that has been rehashed over and over in repeated posts from a single poster 10, 15 times.

I have been on mumsnet for 15 years and I am leaving now. Eviscerating other mothers for sport is not for me.

I agree, I think suggesting anything about your parenting because of the use of a d is ridiculous. OP I think you should leave Mumsnet - I've only been on 2 days and it seems super toxic. I think I'll leave too. I don't think any good will come of you continuing reading this thread OP. Just leave and know that you didn't deserve that man being aggressive to you in real life and you don't deserve the hate on this thread particularly relating to your child. Good luck x

Maluki · 09/10/2023 00:25

Lay off, @Apple. You have said enough.

I cannot believe not a single other poster on this thread has said you were in the wrong, and there are posters here saying the same thing that has been rehashed over and over in repeated posts from a single poster 10, 15 times.

I have been on mumsnet for 15 years and I am leaving now. Eviscerating other mothers for sport is not for me.

OP posts:
AppIe · 09/10/2023 00:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

surreygirl1987 · 09/10/2023 00:03

Your dog was not under proper control, caused fear in a human being, and your response is to victim blame by saying that the scared man must have been giving off weird vibes

Yes, definitely some victim blaming going on here.

surreygirl1987 · 09/10/2023 00:02

Sorry OP, your dog looks sweet, but I'm with the man on this one.
After being bitten several times by neighbourhood dogs as a child, then being badly bitten by my own dog as a teenager, I was terrified of dogs for years. When walking, I'd look round the corner before I turned in case there was an off lead dog and would make a detour if I saw one from afar. I was constantly on edge. I would have absolutely shit myself if a dog barked at me like yours did.
I'm much better now and have a dog that I love. He's the second I've had and loved as an adult. I had to get over the fear before I passed it onto my children, because I didn't want them constantly scanning for dogs when out. It's an awful feeling.
My case might sounds extreme but it's more common than you'd think. Nobody would have guessed I had this fear, I'm not a nervous person. But for all the many thousands of dog bites that happen every year, there is a victim of them that has been impacted.
It's not fair on these people who are just trying to live their lives, to be barked out or approached by an off lead dog. So, his reaction seems OTT to you, but when you are terrified any reaction is

A good, sensible response. I fully agree.

surreygirl1987 · 08/10/2023 23:54

Surreygirl, you do realize this is the poster who said the terrible thing to me, and is referring here to the fact that I swore at her in response, in my now deleted post?

Oh OP, for goodness sake. Yes I realise that. But I'm referring to her views about your dog, in relation to the post you made. Regardless of her comments on your child, I do agree with the point of hers I quoted. Her comments about your son doesn't mean that any of her other points are automatically void 🙄

nocoolnamesleft · 08/10/2023 23:52

Your dog was not under proper control, caused fear in a human being, and your response is to victim blame by saying that the scared man must have been giving off weird vibes.

Fionaville · 08/10/2023 23:50

Sorry OP, your dog looks sweet, but I'm with the man on this one.
After being bitten several times by neighbourhood dogs as a child, then being badly bitten by my own dog as a teenager, I was terrified of dogs for years. When walking, I'd look round the corner before I turned in case there was an off lead dog and would make a detour if I saw one from afar. I was constantly on edge. I would have absolutely shit myself if a dog barked at me like yours did.
I'm much better now and have a dog that I love. He's the second I've had and loved as an adult. I had to get over the fear before I passed it onto my children, because I didn't want them constantly scanning for dogs when out. It's an awful feeling.
My case might sounds extreme but it's more common than you'd think. Nobody would have guessed I had this fear, I'm not a nervous person. But for all the many thousands of dog bites that happen every year, there is a victim of them that has been impacted.
It's not fair on these people who are just trying to live their lives, to be barked out or approached by an off lead dog. So, his reaction seems OTT to you, but when you are terrified any reaction is possible.

Maluki · 08/10/2023 23:36

Who have I mocked? Nobody.
I just disagree that my dog needs muzzling.

You are absolutely fundamentally wrong in what you said to me.

I can't believe I have to say this, but, I used "ddog" because he was the focus of the post. I mentioned my child in passing in this post. Apart from anything else it would have been grammatically clunky to write "I have an autistic dchild ddog is good with".

Yes you touched a nerve because, like many parents of disabled children, I have had to cope with my son's agony and distress in education, watch him battle depression, reduce my work hours to support him, nurse him at the brink of suicide, watch all my hopes and dreams for him be distilled into just hoping he will keep on living, and then a wazzock comes along and dismissively says something so ridiculously cruel that it takes your breath away.

That's why.

OP posts:
AppIe · 08/10/2023 23:27

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Maluki · 08/10/2023 23:08

surreygirl1987 · 08/10/2023 22:53

Your attitude in your further posts, op, is exactly the kind of behaviour we who don't want to be bothered by dogs see on a regular basis from dog owners. In light of your further comments, I feel all the more you were being very unreasonable in the incident in the op

I agree - I don't think the OP is wiling to see things from the other point of view.

Surreygirl, you do realize this is the poster who said the terrible thing to me, and is referring here to the fact that I swore at her in response, in my now deleted post?

You might want to rethink your response unless you agree that what she said about my disabled child was reasonable, proportionate, and merited.

If you read my posts you will see I have
A) agreed the person was scared
B) agreed what I can do to avoid this next time, ie keep him on lead when picking up poo

What more do you want? Blood?

OP posts:
MumOfTheNorth · 08/10/2023 22:59

I'm with you OP ❤️

surreygirl1987 · 08/10/2023 22:53

Your attitude in your further posts, op, is exactly the kind of behaviour we who don't want to be bothered by dogs see on a regular basis from dog owners. In light of your further comments, I feel all the more you were being very unreasonable in the incident in the op

I agree - I don't think the OP is wiling to see things from the other point of view.

surreygirl1987 · 08/10/2023 22:52

there was a good chance this is why the dog barked because the dog knew what this man would be capable of

You can not actually be serious.

surreygirl1987 · 08/10/2023 22:51

No. When an out of control dog attacked my small children, took the hat of one of their heads and knocked the other one to the floor when he tried to protect her, I reacted (despite being terrified) with anger and violence and kicked the dog as hard as I could. It's owner was still over 50 metres away at this point.

Jeez how awful. I'm so sorry that happened. A dog attacked my child too and I had to physically wrestle it off him with my bear hands while screaming at it. I will never ever forget that, or what dogs are capable of. The idiot owner said 'it's the first time he's ever done anything like that.' Yep, there's always a first time.

surreygirl1987 · 08/10/2023 22:49

It seems perfectly reasonable that a person would have a fear of injury if they walk along a public footpath and are accosted by an off-lead dog barking at them, when said dog is not next to its owner and the owner isn't even watching the dog let alone calling them back. That is not a dog "under control".

Precisely.

surreygirl1987 · 08/10/2023 22:48

Your dog did nothing wrong. The man almost certainly did something that provoked the reaction and made your dog uncomfortable.

Eh? So because the dog wasn't behaving, you assume the issue is with a person? Not to mention the fact that the owner wasn't even paying attention and didn't see..?! I've heard it all! 🤦‍♀️

When a dog raced up to my 6 month old baby's pram and dived onto him, snarling at him, did my 6 month old baby provoke that reaction too? Get real.

Maluki · 08/10/2023 22:38

I am delurking again to repost a response to what @Apple wrote, since my earlier one was deleted.

I have been on Mumsnet for many years.

I have seen very few messages as spurious, cruel and vindictive as the one @Apple wrote earlier. I wrote in an earlier post in this thread, "I have an autistic child ddog is very good with". This person saw fit to extrapolate from the fact that I wrote "child" but "ddog" that I obviously care more for my dog than my disabled child.

I assume you had my response taken down because I swore at you. I would swear at you again.

Look, I get that you don't like dogs. You probably have good reasons. You might think I am the worst dog owner in the world. But when you snidely suggest about the mother of a disabled child that they love their child less than their dog, based on the evidence of one letter in a post, do you honestly not pause and think "Am I being a bit shitty here? Is this a proportionate response to the issue being presented, or am I going a bit over the top?"

The post you made reflects terribly upon you and I hope you feel the shame that you should.

OP posts:
CashewGal · 08/10/2023 21:02

Your dog did nothing wrong. The man almost certainly did something that provoked the reaction and made your dog uncomfortable. Mumsnet is full of absurd dog haters, so there is no point seeking a rational response on these pages.

Nepmarthiturn · 08/10/2023 19:35

It seems perfectly reasonable that a person would have a fear of injury if they walk along a public footpath and are accosted by an off-lead dog barking at them, when said dog is not next to its owner and the owner isn't even watching the dog let alone calling them back. That is not a dog "under control".

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/10/2023 15:46

MrsMorseEndeavour · 08/10/2023 15:23

But it is the law if your dog is a threat to anyone. It doesn't need to be "the majority of people". Just that one person felt threatened and you pretty much said you would have done something if the man asked you to, implying because he didn't ask you were happy for your off lead dog to be a nuisance.

No, that isn't the law.

A person needs to have 'reasonable apprehension of injury'.

A court will look at what is reasonable, which means looking at the specific details and context.

A small fluffy dog, at a distance, not approaching, barking a couple of times at a reasonably healthy, mobile adult, is not a reasonable cause to fear injury. Add in that the dog is well trained, recalls swiftly, doesn't wander far etc - no case to answer.

A bigger dog, on a lead but towing the owner around, outweighing the owner, lunging at people and not listening to the owner, not complying with cues... that could give people reasonable cause to fear injury, and might well be an offence a court would take action over.

Courts look at what is 'reasonable', its called the 'reasonable person rule' - what would the average reasonable person do/expect/understand... in a particular situation.