Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's an off lead dog one.

260 replies

Maluki · 07/10/2023 19:43

I walk my dog in the local park every day. There are sections where he is on lead and sections where I let him off. He is extremely used to people and dogs and generally very well behaved.

As we arrive at the park I always let him off lead and he does a poo. This is on a field area beside a path.

Today he did his poo in the field about 6 feet off the path as usual. I noticed a man in a suit approaching along the path. My dog then went back on to the path to wait for me and I leaned down to pick up the poo.

Very very unusually, my dog started to bark - he barked 4 or 5 times - and I saw he was now behind the man (who had walked past him). I was about to apologize, my dog almost never barks at people (he sometimes barks at really unusual things like a person wearing a sombrero or riding a tricycle, and this guy wasn't wearing anything unusual, except a slightly dishevelled suit on a Saturday morning). The man totally lost it at me. He started screaming that he had been bitten on the back of the leg by a dog, that my dog and dogs like him are aggressive and that it would bite my children and kill them (I didn't have my kids with me). He told me to get the dog away from him or he would kick it in the head. My dog is a bloody 10 lb cavapoo!

I appreciate that my dog should not have barked and that the man was triggered. If he had shouted to put it on a lead, before he walked past it, I would gladly have done so. My dog has excellent recall, and is completely reliable on the "wait" signal. He's actually a dream to get back on lead - but I hadn't called him over as there was no sign of what was about to happen. I do wonder if this man inadvertently spooked my dog or even kicked out at him in fear or something as it's so unusual for him to bark at people like that.

Aibu to think that the man, in his fear, may have inadvertently caused the dogs reaction? And that my dog behaved badly but it could have been avoided if the man had just called out for me to hold the dog?

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 07/10/2023 21:07

He over reacted and was a nobhead.

I suggest in future though, don't have your dog out of sight, so if you're bending to pick up poo, dog in front of you in a wait/sit stay etc...

I would put money on it that nobhead gave your dog a proper hard stare as he went past or even aimed a kick at him or hissed something nasty at him.. and that is why your dog behaved the way he did.

The onus is on the dog owner to keep their dog under control and unfortunately in situations like this that does mean that arseholes who stare at, bark at, kick out at dogs who are doing nothing offensive whatsoever are not legally in the wrong and the reacting but perfectly normal dog, is.

Sehenswürdigkeiten · 07/10/2023 21:05

ShirleyPhallus · 07/10/2023 21:01

your poor dogs

Why?

Sehenswürdigkeiten · 07/10/2023 21:04

Maluki · 07/10/2023 20:57

Here's my question though...let's say the man had had a knife and brandished it, and that made an off lead dog bark, is that dog out of control?

If the man is running away from an attack and an off lead dog barks at him, is that out of control?

How do we teach dogs what are "real" unusual events that spook them, where a dog might be heroic, and "just" a harmless person acting a bit weird? How do we enable one and suppress the other? Genuinely ?

A dog barking at a random person is already partly out of control imho, regardless of whatever these reasons are. It might be of benefit to you if it's something scary/suspicious that the dog is barking at, because it will alert you to potential danger - an on lead dog could also alert you however, and be seen as more under control (unless it was physically stronger than you, which your dog doesn't look to be).
Others may have other thoughts on this, that's just my 'off the top of my head' slant.

ShirleyPhallus · 07/10/2023 21:01

Neverwatchedgameofthrones · 07/10/2023 20:06

I wish everyone would keep their dogs on leads at all times. I've got 5 dogs, smaller than yours that are always walked on leads. It's safer for everyone, especially them and makes for a much more pleasant environment.

your poor dogs

Slipslidinginthefray · 07/10/2023 21:00

Maluki · 07/10/2023 20:57

Here's my question though...let's say the man had had a knife and brandished it, and that made an off lead dog bark, is that dog out of control?

If the man is running away from an attack and an off lead dog barks at him, is that out of control?

How do we teach dogs what are "real" unusual events that spook them, where a dog might be heroic, and "just" a harmless person acting a bit weird? How do we enable one and suppress the other? Genuinely ?

No one is telling you to stop your dog barking but they are saying if it does bark randomly (in fear or perceived threat or whatever) then it should always be on a lead so it won’t be seen as scary to the people it’s barking at.

Toansweraboutfees · 07/10/2023 20:59

He overreacted and was unreasonable - it was just a bark. Some people are unreasonable though, for lots of reasons, some of which are more understandable than others. A dog bite and a fear of dogs is fairly understandable.

Generally my experience of asking dog owners to call off or hold their dogs has been pretty negative - they often can’t recall them. Or they shout the ‘he’s friendly’ and do nothing.

Just like I have to accept that dogs should be under control but often aren’t and adjust my behaviour accordingly (limiting where I go with my children, taking routes to avoid dogs etc).

Dog owners also have to accept that some people are not dog friendly and adjust accordingly, and some places are higher risk than others. Urban parks, particularly paths, are always going to be higher risk given the space is shared with lots of people without dogs.

Slipslidinginthefray · 07/10/2023 20:58

NoIcePlease · 07/10/2023 20:40

I wish everyone would keep their dogs on leads at all times. I've got 5 dogs, smaller than yours that are always walked on leads

You've got very small dogs, smaller than a cavapoo. Yes, a pootle around on a lead is probably great for them. Not all dogs are like yours though. I have a Springer Spaniel. Onlead doesn't cut it and she'd be miserable (and unhealthy).

I agree with the pp. Dogs exist and yes they should be under the control of the owner but people also need to react appropriately to them.

My dog doesn't pay any attention to people on a walk. None at all, totally ignores them. She'll politely sniff other dogs then wander away or occasionally play chase with a dog when invited to do so by them (yes, invited by the dog with clear 'run with me!' signs). Yet still, every couple of days we'll pass someone who'll dramatically yank their 10 year old close as she walks past them or jump and squeal or similar. It's ridiculous.

You are judging their reaction by the behaviour you know your own dog will display. Not all dogs are like yours.

I am a dog lover and a dog owner but I am also a runner and I have been bitten twice and jumped up at, barked at and even chased countless times and frankly been really scared on a good few occasions. I’ve had two pairs of running tights ripped and I still have a scar on the back of my thighs from being jumped up at by an apparently ‘super friendly’ dog with sharp nails.

A person walking through the park doesn’t know which dogs are off lead but disinterested in humans/under perfect owner control and which are likely to be potentially a threat or at the very least a PITA. So forgive them for behaving in fear.

It should also not be up to the human to tell you to put your dog on a lead OP not least because a lot of dog owners would react angrily or dismissively to this request.

Keep your dogs close when other humans are about and only have them off lead if they are under absolutely control and do not approach or jump up. Otherwise keep them on a lead or take them to an enclosed dog park.

Maluki · 07/10/2023 20:57

Sehenswürdigkeiten · 07/10/2023 20:46

If I didn't go in areas 'where people walk dogs' then I wouldn't be able to leave my front garden, walk to the shop, walk down the town, walk along a beach and so on. It's reasonable to expect dogs to be under control and if an off lead dog starts barking at someone then it's not under control. @Maluki your dog looks lovely, but if he suddenly started barking me for simply walking past him then I wouldn't be too pleased either tbh. Something perhaps spooked him about the person, but an off lead barking dog isn't great imho.

Here's my question though...let's say the man had had a knife and brandished it, and that made an off lead dog bark, is that dog out of control?

If the man is running away from an attack and an off lead dog barks at him, is that out of control?

How do we teach dogs what are "real" unusual events that spook them, where a dog might be heroic, and "just" a harmless person acting a bit weird? How do we enable one and suppress the other? Genuinely ?

OP posts:
Sehenswürdigkeiten · 07/10/2023 20:55

letstrythatagain · 07/10/2023 20:47

He was in a big field next to the path. You can't permanently keep a dog on a lead in public. They need to be able to run and sniff about. I get it on a high street etc but they have to be able to come off lead somewhere.

This isn't true. Lots of dogs don't get off lead and are perfectly happy. Also the minute the off lead dog starts causing a problem to other people then it's right to be 'off lead' is less certain! This might be a one off, but an off lead barking dog isn't great.

letstrythatagain · 07/10/2023 20:47

Chickenwing2 · 07/10/2023 20:16

Dogs should be on the lead in public. End of story.

He was in a big field next to the path. You can't permanently keep a dog on a lead in public. They need to be able to run and sniff about. I get it on a high street etc but they have to be able to come off lead somewhere.

Sehenswürdigkeiten · 07/10/2023 20:46

Loubelle70 · 07/10/2023 20:28

I have a fear of dogs off lead... however i always give them a wide birth if possible. Walk around away...he probably has real phobia but tbh if he has, why be in an area where people walk dogs

If I didn't go in areas 'where people walk dogs' then I wouldn't be able to leave my front garden, walk to the shop, walk down the town, walk along a beach and so on. It's reasonable to expect dogs to be under control and if an off lead dog starts barking at someone then it's not under control. @Maluki your dog looks lovely, but if he suddenly started barking me for simply walking past him then I wouldn't be too pleased either tbh. Something perhaps spooked him about the person, but an off lead barking dog isn't great imho.

Sehenswürdigkeiten · 07/10/2023 20:44

TheCupboardUnderTheStairsAtTheMojoDojoCasaHouse · 07/10/2023 20:37

Are you always incapable of differentiating between your personal opinion and the law?

Do you always dismiss others valid opinions, just because it's not 'the law'?
People are allowed to state a view and not feel like it's up for debate. I personally wish there were stricter rules regarding dogs being on leads in public places too, for the safety of humans and dogs, and I say this as someone who has owned dogs and appreciates their good points (as well as the not so good ones!).

NoIcePlease · 07/10/2023 20:40

I wish everyone would keep their dogs on leads at all times. I've got 5 dogs, smaller than yours that are always walked on leads

You've got very small dogs, smaller than a cavapoo. Yes, a pootle around on a lead is probably great for them. Not all dogs are like yours though. I have a Springer Spaniel. Onlead doesn't cut it and she'd be miserable (and unhealthy).

I agree with the pp. Dogs exist and yes they should be under the control of the owner but people also need to react appropriately to them.

My dog doesn't pay any attention to people on a walk. None at all, totally ignores them. She'll politely sniff other dogs then wander away or occasionally play chase with a dog when invited to do so by them (yes, invited by the dog with clear 'run with me!' signs). Yet still, every couple of days we'll pass someone who'll dramatically yank their 10 year old close as she walks past them or jump and squeal or similar. It's ridiculous.

TheCupboardUnderTheStairsAtTheMojoDojoCasaHouse · 07/10/2023 20:37

Chickenwing2 · 07/10/2023 20:16

Dogs should be on the lead in public. End of story.

Are you always incapable of differentiating between your personal opinion and the law?

smilesup · 07/10/2023 20:32

Chickenwing2 · 07/10/2023 20:16

Dogs should be on the lead in public. End of story.

No they shouldn't. End of.

Loubelle70 · 07/10/2023 20:28

I have a fear of dogs off lead... however i always give them a wide birth if possible. Walk around away...he probably has real phobia but tbh if he has, why be in an area where people walk dogs

Maluki · 07/10/2023 20:27

I mean I told him off, and he went back on lead for a considerable amount of time, but I feel a bit torn. He was acting on instinct, and I kind of don't want to make him think he can't alert to people he thinks may be up to no good....if we ever get burgled I would want him to bark at those guys.

It's an off lead dog one.
OP posts:
Undisclosedlocation · 07/10/2023 20:25

while the man totally overreacted, this is the reason I ALWAYS recall my dogs away from random members of the public and do nit allow them to approach or interact without my express permission
Humans are just as (if not more so)unpredictable as dogs imo. and I have no desire whatsoever to put my dogs in the firing line for the weird responses of random strangers.

rwalker · 07/10/2023 20:24

I can see your point of view and I can see his and tbh nether trumps the other one
I’d just draw a line under it

justaboutdonenow · 07/10/2023 20:19

pickledandpuzzled · 07/10/2023 20:17

It frustrates me that people have unreasonable expectations of dogs. They are not remote controlled.
They exist in our society and people need to learn how to behave around them, just as they learn how to behave around roads, wasps, and other hazards.

my young dog was passing a woman on a path in a country park. He looked at her, and she squealed and danced on the spot with her arms waving up in the air. It was guaranteed to attract his attention, and is in fact what I do when I’m calling him if he’s mislaid me. Not the right way to deal with a dog you don’t like.

This!

Newuser75 · 07/10/2023 20:18

The man totally over reacted and there is no excuse to speak to you so aggressively but he is right really.

I'm pretty sure (will stand to be corrected) that a dog is classed as dangerous if someone feels threatened by it which this man obviously did.

pickledandpuzzled · 07/10/2023 20:17

It frustrates me that people have unreasonable expectations of dogs. They are not remote controlled.
They exist in our society and people need to learn how to behave around them, just as they learn how to behave around roads, wasps, and other hazards.

my young dog was passing a woman on a path in a country park. He looked at her, and she squealed and danced on the spot with her arms waving up in the air. It was guaranteed to attract his attention, and is in fact what I do when I’m calling him if he’s mislaid me. Not the right way to deal with a dog you don’t like.

Maluki · 07/10/2023 20:17

Chickenwing2 · 07/10/2023 20:16

Dogs should be on the lead in public. End of story.

But it's not the end of story, as that isn't the law. If it were, then yes.

OP posts:
CoffeeChocolateandBooks · 07/10/2023 20:17

Your dog barked because he probably sensed something was off regarding the man.
Dogs are very protective.
I used to have a dog but all the joy has gone out of owning one now, so l would never get another one. My dog was a running dog, born to run, not to live a life tethered on a lead.

Chickenwing2 · 07/10/2023 20:16

Dogs should be on the lead in public. End of story.