Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a Viennese Whirl a biscuit or a cake?

60 replies

Mysterian · 07/10/2023 18:26

I has a seaside Viannese whirl earlier. It was huge. Imagine circumnavigating a regular sized family hedgehog in ball formation. It was that diameter. Thick too, like a dog's paw or a book that makes you look intelligent. Probably the equivalent of 2 six packs of Mr Kipling's whirls.
But was it a cake or biscuit? It tastes like shortbread which is an obvious biscuit and it knows it, but then again it yields so easily to the squash of the tongue. Or is it a totally different category of foodtypes like a fungus is to plants and cats?

I say biscuit! - YANBU

Not biscuit - YABU

OP posts:
InMySpareTime · 07/10/2023 19:53

@Mysterian Eccles cake is a pastry

InMySpareTime · 07/10/2023 19:52

@70isaLimitNotaTarget there's plain flour, cornflour and Baking Powder in the BBC Good Food recipe. The baking powder is the difference between plain and raising flour, surely?
I always just use raising flour in recipes with plain flour and baking powder, and have never had an issue.

Mysterian · 07/10/2023 19:49

But I reckon an Eccles Cake would go soft so it must be a biscuit.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 07/10/2023 19:45

welovetv · 07/10/2023 18:30

I read somewhere recently that a cake goes hard when stale and a biscuit softens as it goes stale. On that basis, I assume a Viennese whirl would soften and would therefore be a biscuit?

(My source is likely either here or Facebook though, so I'm not sure how accurate it is!).

You're correct. This is how McVities won a tax case against HMRC.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 07/10/2023 19:42

InMySpareTime · 07/10/2023 18:51

Biscuit.
The reason it is softer than shortbread is that Viennese biscuits have self raising flour not plain flour.

Viennese Whirls you beat till they're fluffy , I just checked the BBC Good Food site , they use plain flour + cornflour )
Shortbread is rubbed in then kneaded to shape

I would go for shortbread all day long , especially if it;s a bit chewy in the middle .

TheYearOfSmallThings · 07/10/2023 19:30

The Viennese Whirl is a biscuit, but the one you are sounds very unorthodox to me.

evtheria · 07/10/2023 19:28

OnlyFannys · 07/10/2023 18:41

I can't get past your frame of reference for the size being regular sized family hedgehog in ball formation 😂😂😂
I haven't seen a hedgehog in real life for years so this doesn't help in the slightest but I love it nonetheless

This cracked me up too, I wondered if I was the only person who doesn't know how big/small this is!

Mysterian · 07/10/2023 19:12

gaggiagirl · 07/10/2023 18:52

Have you got any photos?
I've never seen a giant one before. Which seaside should I attend to acquire one?
Sounds beautiful.
And it's a biscuit 🍪

It was at Mudeford Quay on the South coast. I had a camera with me as I was about taking photos but it looked too gorgeous so I just followed my heart and ate it. Not it one go though. Too large for that, so took an uneaten third for a ride on a ferry before finishing it off.

Okay, it's confirmed as a biscuit. Feel weird about doubting myself but I felt it was safer to check. A lot could go wrong with careless food categorisation.

OP posts:
loverrr · 07/10/2023 19:07

Its sold in the cake aisle so...

MatthewsMumFromTikTok · 07/10/2023 19:01

With jam and cream....

Anniegetyourgun · 07/10/2023 18:53

Argh, you know what you've done now? There I was, picking at a bunch of grapes like a fairly virtuous person, and suddenly you talk about giant sized Viennese whirls. I would have voted YABU for that, except you've changed it to mean cake-voter. It's a biscuit obviously. Well, 2 biscuits in a sandwich. Mmmmmm.....

gaggiagirl · 07/10/2023 18:52

Have you got any photos?
I've never seen a giant one before. Which seaside should I attend to acquire one?
Sounds beautiful.
And it's a biscuit 🍪

InMySpareTime · 07/10/2023 18:51

Biscuit.
The reason it is softer than shortbread is that Viennese biscuits have self raising flour not plain flour.

RicherThanYews · 07/10/2023 18:50

Many biscuits and cookies contain egg yolks so that's a difficult one.

MatthewsMumFromTikTok · 07/10/2023 18:48

Cake has eggs in it.... biscuits don't ( do they?)

CorylusAgain · 07/10/2023 18:46

Biscuit

Y7jahbb33 · 07/10/2023 18:46

Definetly a biscuit

I absolutely love these.... but I'm ashamed to say i dont know how to say it so when in a bakery I just point and say 2 of them please 😂😂

Tessisme · 07/10/2023 18:44

Oh, definitely a biscuit. I had one in a coffee shop on Thursday and I didn't know whether to eat it or climb it. Definitely a biscuit though. Yum!

Ponoka7 · 07/10/2023 18:44

I did vote cake at first because they are in the cake isle and you treat them as a cake. They are a biscuit though. Mr Kipling describes his as biscuits.

thenightsky · 07/10/2023 18:43

Biscuit. My mum used to make lovely homemade ones from her BeRo cookbook.

mindthegap22 · 07/10/2023 18:42

Biscuit

The cakeateers are being quiet aren't they! Stealth voters 🤣

OnlyFannys · 07/10/2023 18:41

I can't get past your frame of reference for the size being regular sized family hedgehog in ball formation 😂😂😂
I haven't seen a hedgehog in real life for years so this doesn't help in the slightest but I love it nonetheless

theduchessofspork · 07/10/2023 18:41

A biscuit

always tastes like stale soft shortbread to me, but anyway.

funinthesun19 · 07/10/2023 18:40

On the Mr Kipling box in my cupboard it says it’s shortbread. So since shortbread is a biscuit, it’s a biscuit.

I want one of those seaside ones!

Offcom · 07/10/2023 18:40

welovetv · 07/10/2023 18:30

I read somewhere recently that a cake goes hard when stale and a biscuit softens as it goes stale. On that basis, I assume a Viennese whirl would soften and would therefore be a biscuit?

(My source is likely either here or Facebook though, so I'm not sure how accurate it is!).

Isn’t this the definition which meant Jaffa Cakes are VAT free (or were, wouldn’t be surprised if the Tories had closed that little loophole)