Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or could he take my children from me

32 replies

Brabraboo · 07/10/2023 16:28

Looking to ask any people of a legal background (in scotland specifically as I know there’s vast differences within the U.K.)

My other half (important to note, we are not married. This was and is my choice and it’s quite important to me. I do not want to be married but I believe in scotland this means I am entitled to nothing if I leave, and I’m ok with that) is the main breadwinner in our house. He also owns our house. And our car. Everything is in his name. I have always worked, but I contribute the daily things. I do all the grocery shopping, buy everyone’s clothes , all the toys and the fun stuff. I also am the primary childcare for three children who are not yet of school age so I do have to juggle working and I don’t earn anything like what he does. My earnings are a decent contribution we can’t do without, but they aren’t substantial enough to actually provide any stability.

my question is part curiosity and part feeling a bit vulnerable I suppose. I’m sure people will think I’m naive and silly to have allowed everything in his name but to be honest, I had a very rough upbringing, was a care kid and trashed my credit record years ago. His is immaculate (far nicer childhood) he has a better job, he earns a good salary and I don’t feel entitled to anything that is his. Although I appreciate that he couldn’t have done this without me raising his children, we have never had to pay childcare because I’ve provided all of it.

I suppose what I want to know. Is IF we were to split at any point. Could he take my children from me, legally, because he is the one with the solid circumstance . I’m the mother, but he has the house, car, income, all the stability. I would have absolutely nothing. What would happen in this hypothetical situation? His family are wealthy and he has a lot of stability to fall back on. I have nothing but the fact I am their mother.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CheshireDing · 09/11/2023 07:25

I would check re the mortgage situation because for England and Wales if you can be on the deeds but not on the mortgage, there are only certain lenders who do this though, HSBC is one. I can’t remember the others off the top of my head.

I cannot see why in regards to this particular point it would be any different in Scotland because it’s the mortgage company’s decision in the end , newamaterdam is incorrect in terms of England and Wales.

Don’t automatically believe what your DP tells you though about not being allowed on the deeds either. You need to both go to a mortgage broker together to see what they say.

Do pm me if you like OP, I am not a mortgage broker but am a Conveyancer in England so can probably help with some questions re the house.

Jomasell · 09/11/2023 07:16

Just regarding legal status, defo check scotland, as in England if you set up home as a family then the other partner can have a claim. My x who had no kids with me, lied about his contributions financially to my house, owned another property, lived with me "officially" for 7 months, took me to court and got a good chunk of the equity in my house. He claimed he had done d.i.y on improving it- very little bits and bobs. And I had 4 kids to house. The reason I was given that he could do this was we bought the house (totally in my name) with the "intention" to live there as a family! We were not married, he had no bills coming to the house before 7 months before we split but that was enough to get the cash. We were talking 25k out of about 90k equity. This was in 2006.

kikisparks · 09/10/2023 11:05

https://legal.acandco.com/news/review-of-cohabitants-rights-in-scotland in Scotland it seems you will have some rights but you will need to get legal advice and raise your case within 1 year of any separation. But really the gold standard for an economically disadvantaged partner saving their other half money on childcare is marriage (or civil partnership, amounts to the same thing) plus being a joint owner of the home.

Cohabitants Rights in Scotland: A Review

The number of cohabiting couples has significantly increased in Scotland, with more and more people opting out of entering into marriage and civil partnerships in favour of cohabitation.

https://legal.acandco.com/news/review-of-cohabitants-rights-in-scotland

Mrsttcno1 · 09/10/2023 10:55

It is possible to be on the deeds without being on the mortgage, it basically means that you are an owner but are not liable for the repayments sometimes called a “non borrower”, but this doesn’t change the fact that if the mortgage payments are defaulted then the provider can still reclaim your home.

It’s worth knowing though that most mortgage lenders won’t agree to this set up of being on the deeds but not the mortgage, although it is technically possible, in reality it’s quite rare.

And of course it relies on your partner putting you on the deeds, you couldn’t do it alone

newamsterdam · 09/10/2023 09:55

Brabraboo · 09/10/2023 09:36

@newamsterdam oh I see. Someone on a different thread told me that in scotland I can be on the deeds without being part of the mortgage.

I don't know how about Scotland, but logically I can't see how. Why would the bank allow that?

Brabraboo · 09/10/2023 09:36

@newamsterdam oh I see. Someone on a different thread told me that in scotland I can be on the deeds without being part of the mortgage.

OP posts:
newamsterdam · 09/10/2023 09:35

Brabraboo · 07/10/2023 22:38

What is the process for this? I don’t even really know. Can I be put down on the house deeds without becoming a part of the mortgage borrowing? My credit rating isn’t like his. I feel like I would drag us down by being on it.

No. If the house is mortgaged, the bank won't allow you to be added to the deeds and not be responsible for the mortgage, it would halve the collateral value of the house. As it stands, he is the only one liable for the debt, so he's the only one that can be on the deeds.

Brabraboo · 07/10/2023 22:38

What is the process for this? I don’t even really know. Can I be put down on the house deeds without becoming a part of the mortgage borrowing? My credit rating isn’t like his. I feel like I would drag us down by being on it.

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 07/10/2023 17:52

I'd say you have two choices;

1-increase your earnings to the point where you could afford adequate housing for yourself and your DC. Only you know if and how you can do this.

2-marry the man and 'stick with it' long enough to have legal rights to a 50% share of joint assets. Where I live (US), that's generally a 10 year marriage, it's 5 in some states. But also where I live, assets acquired prior to a marriage and held as separate property are NOT considered joint assets.

Your best bet is to quietly see a solicitor, lay out your circumstances and get proper advice. Then act accordingly to protect yourself.

AnotherNameNow · 07/10/2023 17:44

Why don't you feel entitled to the house that you've worked hard to pay for? It's 'his' but you pay for groceries etc. Why not spin it around: if you didn't pay for groceries and provide all the childcare, would his income still be enough for the mortgage?

I think you have left yourself and your children extremely vulnerable. Do you feel you deserve stability? You have earned it, you have paid into it, your name should be on the deeds.

I think you have a lot to unpick

Cowlover89 · 07/10/2023 17:36

You don't need to get married

Butterfly898 · 07/10/2023 17:34

I understand you have chosen not to be married, I have chosen the same at the moment but am a significantly higher earner than my partner. You have given so much to this partnership and saved him thousands on childcare whilst enabling him to grow his career (a fact that is not true in my situation as I’m paying for it all) - I truly think you should marry to protect yourself here.

newamsterdam · 07/10/2023 17:23

ditalini · 07/10/2023 17:20

To be clear though, adequately house and care for the children is a fairly low bar - no one is going to rule that the children have to live with him full time because he has the bigger/nicer house and a car and a rich family. Op would be entitled to maintenance from him and UC.

If he had the family home and plenty of money, and all she could afford was a one bed on UC, it would likely be ruled that they live with him. And then she would not be entitled to any maintenance at all.

ditalini · 07/10/2023 17:20

newamsterdam · 07/10/2023 17:10

yes, if you left him and had no house, no car, no money, and could not adequately house and care for your children, he absolutely could get residency of them.

To be clear though, adequately house and care for the children is a fairly low bar - no one is going to rule that the children have to live with him full time because he has the bigger/nicer house and a car and a rich family. Op would be entitled to maintenance from him and UC.

newamsterdam · 07/10/2023 17:10

yes, if you left him and had no house, no car, no money, and could not adequately house and care for your children, he absolutely could get residency of them.

jolaylasofia · 07/10/2023 17:08

GET MARRIED! Protect yourself and all your hard work.

ditalini · 07/10/2023 17:04

You don't need to get married. Hetrosexual couples can have a civil partnership now. Registrar's office, sign the form, job done.

However, I don't think this is really the issue is it? You don't feel "entitled" - this sounds far more like it's down to your upbringing, that you don't think you're "as good", or "deserving" which is all bollocks but not something that can be resolved by a certificate.

Is it likely that you'll split do you think? Is the relationship abusive?

WillowCraft · 07/10/2023 17:00

This situation isn't fair. If you're doing all the childcare he should give you some money to compensate for that, which you can save for yourself. If you're not married you need to be really careful things are financially fair and that you don't compromise your earning potential.
If you split you ca. probably claim benefits and get a council house though, I don't think they will remove children from their primary carer unless there really isn't anyway you can care for them, dad having more money isn't relevant.

OliveWah · 07/10/2023 17:00

If you split he would need to pay child maintenance and you would probably be entitled to some Universal Credit - there are online calculators you can use to find out how much.

HowIsItOctoberAlready · 07/10/2023 16:58

My earnings are a decent contribution we can’t do without

OP please read this again, and then ask yourself how is it fair that you don't own any part of your home or other big purchases?

In your "partnership" why is your cash shared but your assets are not?

You need to get married ASAP to protect yourself and your children.

CoffeeBean5 · 07/10/2023 16:57

It's fine not to be married but it's risky not being named on the mortgage. He's getting a good deal. He pays for the house and car but you have to fund everything else and have zero claim on the house.

I don’t feel entitled to anything that is his you gave him 3 children. Why don't you feel entitled to anything?

Coyoacan · 07/10/2023 16:56

Well you'd be entitled to child maintenance and the fact that you are their primary carer is a major point in your favour.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 07/10/2023 16:53

So he sinks his cash into investments for him. And you sink your cash into consumables for the family. This is not a fair set up. I don't know about the kids (I would like to think there was support to keep children with their primary caregiver however). I do think you need to be married or come up with a different financial arrangement that is fair to everyone

Wibblywobblylikejelly · 07/10/2023 16:51

Unless he has safeguarding concerns he is unlikely to stop any access. So no you wouldn't lose custody.
But many courts now are favouring 50/50 and shared lived with.

LeavesOnTrees · 07/10/2023 16:46

No legal advice but you need to look after yourself financially.
If you don't feel you deserve it do it for your children..