Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend misconstrued what I said and screamed at me in front of lots of people

171 replies

UnIucky · 07/10/2023 12:23

Apologies, I expect this is going to be long but I just need to get it all out. Not sure what I’m asking either.

I was attending a get together at a friends house last night. It was a mix of friends and people I also know professionally, including future colleagues at a new job I’m starting in a couple of weeks (small industry where everyone knows each other).

I was engaging in conversation with a group of them when the topic turned to celebrities and fashion which I have zero interest in. They started discussing plus size models and “cankles” (which I had never even heard of) at which point I decided to leave and get a drinks refill.

At the same time one of my long standing friends “Sarah” came up to the group and gave me a look that told me she wanted to join the conversation. Knowing she knew I hated all things celeb and fashion related I jokingly/slightly exasperatedly said “They’re talking about plus sized models and cankles. I think it’s my cue to get a refill”.

When I came out from refilling my drink Sarah stormed across the room towards me and started screaming at me. Everyone went completely silent and started watching us. I had no idea what was going on as she started yelling at me calling me all kinds of names under the sun.

Then it dawned on me she had misheard what I had said. She thought I said “talking of plus sized models and cankles” as she walked up to us. She assumed I was referring to her and that I had mockingly laughed at her as I left. She had then asked the other women to confirm what we had been talking about before confronting me (they say they didn’t hear our exchange at all).

I stayed very calm and tried to explain but she wouldn’t let me get a word in. She just kept screaming and telling me to shut my mouth. Eventually she broke down crying. Everyone rallied around her and started comforting her. I also was trying not to cry as nothing like this has ever happened to me before. I felt awful for her, upset she genuinely thought I’d say something like that and humiliated I’d been screamed at in front of so many people. I again tried to give my version of events but nobody really took notice. I tried to explain that:

  1. I never said what she thought I said and never would;
  2. I told them what I actually said;
  3. Even if I had said it, it wouldn’t make any sense as she is tiny and very skinny. I on the other hand had surgery on my thyroid a few months ago and have put on nearly 3 dress sizes since so I am very sensitive about my weight. I’d never mock someone for their weight, ever.

Shortly thereafter I apologised to the host and left. One of mine and Sarah’s mutual friends “Annie” gave me a call and said she believed me and understood my version of events. Annie said she’d talk with Sarah to try and explain. She messaged me again this morning and has been very kind. She is still talking things over with Sarah. I’ve also messaged the host apologising again and gave a brief explanation of what actually happened.

I’ve got no idea what to do now. I feel so humiliated especially that some of my colleagues and future colleagues were there. What if they now think I’m some kind of nasty, shallow backstabber?

Sarah does have a bit of a reputation for being a hot head so her yelling isn’t really out of character but this was proper screaming (I’ve seen her get into a yelling match with her boyfriend in public a couple of times). It’s like we are teenagers in some kind of school drama.

What on earth can I do to salvage this situation?

OP posts:
AtrociousCircumstance · 07/10/2023 13:16

@Thoughtful2355 The OP made it clear that she wasn’t plus size/didn’t have cankles.

Antst · 07/10/2023 13:15

Don't worry. You have explained. Word will get around. People who know you will ask about what happened and will be told. Don't do anything else. If anyone approaches you, repeat what you have already said.

The thing is, people as unstable as Sarah obviously is can't help themselves. She'll do something crazy to someone else.

People aren't dumb. Even now, when some of them might not have seen her behave this way, they'll understand how weird her behaviour was.

Thoughtful2355 · 07/10/2023 13:14

@AtrociousCircumstance talking of means like

Oh here she comes the one were talkin about, the model with the candles

" talking of the scientist with the big head" .. in comes the scientist with the big head, you get it? Yet it wouldnt make sense if someone said that and the scientist wasn't a scientist at all but a .. plumber... would it.

So why would it have related to her anyway unless she was a model with cankles.

Zoreos · 07/10/2023 13:14

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 07/10/2023 13:07

Do you have a very robotic monotone voice (like a recorded message from a machine)?
Because the intonation on
They're talking about lardarses (which is why I've left the conversation)
And
Talking of lardarses (up you pop) is very very different and it would be virtually impossible to misunderstand.

I'm going for a "did she aye" response.

People like Sarah will go out of their way to find a reason to “misunderstand” what’s been said purely for attention. Or perhaps she’s insecure and possessive and wants to make OP look bad in front of her colleagues because they can’t bear any self-perceived competition. Either way Sarah needs to have a quiet word with herself because she’s made a shit show of herself and spoiled people’s evenings for no good reason.

dogsinthesky · 07/10/2023 13:13

Even if you had said about plus size models and cankles, excusing yourself to leave would be fine??? I don't get her point.

Thoughtful2355 · 07/10/2023 13:12

@AtrociousCircumstance

"She thought I said “talking of plus sized models and cankles” as she walked up to us."

Now read what I said.

ballotspoiler · 07/10/2023 13:12

Yeah, you're the one deserving of an apology here. You've done nothing wrong and people will have seen (and rightly judged) Sarah's behaviour here, not yours.

AtrociousCircumstance · 07/10/2023 13:11

@Thoughtful2355 read the OP again. The reactive woman totally misconstrued what the OP said, which was along the lines of “those guys started talking about models and cankles which was my cue to leave!” I.e. the topic didn’t interest her/was awkward.

Lalallals248 · 07/10/2023 13:10

You don't need to do anything here except stop being friends with Sarah.
Even if she misunderstand what you said and was upset, she should have known to handle herself better given that she was part of a work-related party. She should have known that her behaviour could have ramifications for you later.
What she has done has gone past just shouting at you (which is abusive in itself); she's made you look a fool at work which is unacceptable from someone who is supposed to care for you.

PeggyPoggleshaw · 07/10/2023 13:08

In the words of Candace Owens, she needs to wear a helmet before she leaves her house if she's so sensitive. She sounds like a nightmare. You didn't do anything wrong at all, OP.

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 07/10/2023 13:07

Do you have a very robotic monotone voice (like a recorded message from a machine)?
Because the intonation on
They're talking about lardarses (which is why I've left the conversation)
And
Talking of lardarses (up you pop) is very very different and it would be virtually impossible to misunderstand.

I'm going for a "did she aye" response.

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 07/10/2023 13:05

Don’t message her, OP. You’re the one who should be angry.

PatchoulOilandRoses · 07/10/2023 13:04

Well she's made herself look like a complete idiot.
Why are you not fuming about how she treated you? Take back some power for yourself and stop simpering about it to people.
I wouldn't message her, I wouldn't give her the time of day at this point!
I think it is highly unlikely that people will believe a larger person had a go about a tiny person having 'cankles', anyone that hears about the whole charade will work out for themselves who the problem was.....spoiler it's not you OP.

therealcookiemonster · 07/10/2023 13:03

definitely don't msg her. just ignore

Miyagi99 · 07/10/2023 13:03

Screaming is not normal, if I’d misheard you I’d be offended and say ‘I’m sorry? What did you say?’ as I’d hope I misheard. Out of order behaviour from Sarah.

Mirabai · 07/10/2023 13:02

She sounds batshit. It’s not clear what set her off. You can’t reason with that kind of madness, so just avoid her in future.

WhichOfThePickwickTripletsDidIt · 07/10/2023 13:02

I agree with everyone saying really don’t message her. It doesn’t, in fact, matter at all how clear or reasonable your message might be — it would just be used as something else to feed into her narrative of you ‘upsetting her’.

Aquamarine1029 · 07/10/2023 13:02

You should be telling Sarah to go fuck herself.

Mirabai · 07/10/2023 13:01

Softsoftsleep · 07/10/2023 12:48

Not the popular opinion but I would message Sarah for the sake of closure. Then i would end the friendship.

Hi Sarah,
I wanted to set the record straight because the way you spoke to me yesterday was absolutely unacceptable and unwarranted. When I spoke to you, I told you that the group were talking about celebrities. I in no way referenced anything about your appearance or mentioned anything to do with you at all. Had you addressed me calmly, I could have explained this but instead you screamed at me in the most humiliating and degrading way, simply for telling you what the others were talking about. Your behaviour was aggressive, juvenile and unnecessary. If in future you mishear someone, I suggest you calmly ask for clarity before creating a scene and embarrassing yourself as you did yesterday.

Send

Friendship over

Definitely don’t send one of these long winded MN texts.

Thoughtful2355 · 07/10/2023 13:01

I don't get it, is she a model that's overweight? If not why would you be referring to her in that anyway??

Autumnunmasks · 07/10/2023 13:00

No, don't message her. I had someone yell at me like that once, completely threw me and I was upset for ages. It still rankles years later tbh. I just look over her shoulder in a vague manner now if our paths cross, it's unforgivable when people act like that but you need to just rise above it if you can x

Peachy2005 · 07/10/2023 13:00

Don’t message her. That well-written message by @Softsoftsleep might be good for a rational person but she’s not rational is she? Hold your head high and if anyone asks about it, have something prepared but not a highly detailed explanation…more of a shrugging it off. Maybe a “think she must have had too much to drink…I’m staying far away from her from now on”

Maluki · 07/10/2023 12:57

I would also message Sarah, unlike everyone else here, but not as detailed as the poster above.

"Sarah, I was sorry to see you so upset last night over a complete misunderstanding. I want to reiterate that I said nothing about you that was derogatory or negative. I said nothing about you at all! To be honest, I am horrified that you think so little of me as to jump to conclusions over what you thought you heard. In any case I feel that your reaction was totally uncalled for. I was not allowed to clarify or explain. This is not how sensible adults behave, is it?

Take care and I hope you get the help you seem to need."

Softsoftsleep · 07/10/2023 12:56

supplycaptain · 07/10/2023 12:53

@Softsoftsleep The reason why this is unpopular is because people will find a way to paint themselves as the victim and discredit you. The situation will then turn into OP “sending a nasty message” which made “Sarah have a panic attack” or “Sarah cry and now Sarah feels she’s being bullied”. She will say anything to deflect blame - it’s a sink or swim moment for her to save face.

your problem is that you’re assuming Sarah is rational minded enough to understand what you’re saying at face value and realise she’s in the wrong…she won’t

You're probably right.
My period is due 😀

supplycaptain · 07/10/2023 12:53

Softsoftsleep · 07/10/2023 12:48

Not the popular opinion but I would message Sarah for the sake of closure. Then i would end the friendship.

Hi Sarah,
I wanted to set the record straight because the way you spoke to me yesterday was absolutely unacceptable and unwarranted. When I spoke to you, I told you that the group were talking about celebrities. I in no way referenced anything about your appearance or mentioned anything to do with you at all. Had you addressed me calmly, I could have explained this but instead you screamed at me in the most humiliating and degrading way, simply for telling you what the others were talking about. Your behaviour was aggressive, juvenile and unnecessary. If in future you mishear someone, I suggest you calmly ask for clarity before creating a scene and embarrassing yourself as you did yesterday.

Send

Friendship over

@Softsoftsleep The reason why this is unpopular is because people will find a way to paint themselves as the victim and discredit you. The situation will then turn into OP “sending a nasty message” which made “Sarah have a panic attack” or “Sarah cry and now Sarah feels she’s being bullied”. She will say anything to deflect blame - it’s a sink or swim moment for her to save face.

your problem is that you’re assuming Sarah is rational minded enough to understand what you’re saying at face value and realise she’s in the wrong…she won’t

Swipe left for the next trending thread